Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Using gender when studying Biology! What are they teaching.

161 replies

Confusedmumannoyedson · 06/06/2023 17:03

So was talking about getting a pet and my son said what gender. I said not gender just boy or girl and he said we aren't 'allowed' to say that anymore we have to use gender. I explained that gender is something you can pick and there are lots people use including them/they which is fine for how someone identifies but not for animals or when talking biology. I am thinking he is confused because he said they use gender in biology now and don't use sex. I checked with a friend who said he is right.

AIBU? Surely sex should be used for a science subject like biology, and gender should be kept for personal use for how someone thinks they are.

OP posts:
AndTheSurveySays · 06/06/2023 21:44

For what it’s worth, there are many, many species with more than two sexes- some slime moulds with thousands

You're talking of mating types, not sexes.

TheShellBeach · 06/06/2023 21:41

Studyoflife · 06/06/2023 21:29

I’m saddened by how this has become fairly unpleasant towards someone making an interesting and valid scientific point. As a now biology teacher, formerly behavioural evolution researcher with a specialism in the evolution of sexual reproduction (not as kinky as it sounds), this really is my favourite area and I love that people are taking an interest.

I’ve written a long and detailed response to this three times but my phone keeps refreshing and losing it, so I’ve got fed up and am using this from someone else (cannot find who to give credit to):

First of all, in a sexual species, you can have females be XX and males be X (insects), you can have females be ZW and males be ZZ (birds), you can have females be females because they developed in a warm environment and males be males because they developed in a cool in a cool environment (reptiles), you can have females be females because they lost a penis sword fighting context (some flatworms), you can have males be males because they were born female, but changed sexes because the only male in their group died (parrotfish and clownfish), you can have males look and act like females because they are trying to get close enough to actual females to mate with them (cuttlefish, bluegills, others), or you can be one of thousands of sexes (slime mold, some mushrooms.) Oh, did you mean humans? Oh ok then. You can be male because you were born female, but you have 5-alphareductase deficiency and so you grew a penis at age 12. You can be female because you have an X and a Y chromosome but you are insensitive to androgens, and so you have a female body. You can be male because you have two X chromosomes, but one of your X's HAS an SRY gene, and so you have a male body. You can be male because you have two X chromosomes, but also a Y. You can be female because you have only one X chromosome at all. And you can be male because you have two X chromosomes, but your heart and brain are male.

For what it’s worth, there are many, many species with more than two sexes- some slime moulds with thousands :)

Nothing you've described there is mammalian.

TheKeatingFive · 06/06/2023 21:39

For what it’s worth, there are many, many species with more than two sexes

I don't think anything you are describing is actually an additional sex. If it is, what is the gamete and what is its role in reproduction?

Studyoflife · 06/06/2023 21:31

And back to the focus of the OP- yes, XX and XY as they learn in GCSE biology should be referred to as sex, not gender. I and all other biology teachers I know are very careful to ensure that we clarify the distinction- but as a previous reply stated, there are a lot of older exam questions still in circulation that get it wrong. It’s possible that the teacher or your son got muddled.

Studyoflife · 06/06/2023 21:29

I’m saddened by how this has become fairly unpleasant towards someone making an interesting and valid scientific point. As a now biology teacher, formerly behavioural evolution researcher with a specialism in the evolution of sexual reproduction (not as kinky as it sounds), this really is my favourite area and I love that people are taking an interest.

I’ve written a long and detailed response to this three times but my phone keeps refreshing and losing it, so I’ve got fed up and am using this from someone else (cannot find who to give credit to):

First of all, in a sexual species, you can have females be XX and males be X (insects), you can have females be ZW and males be ZZ (birds), you can have females be females because they developed in a warm environment and males be males because they developed in a cool in a cool environment (reptiles), you can have females be females because they lost a penis sword fighting context (some flatworms), you can have males be males because they were born female, but changed sexes because the only male in their group died (parrotfish and clownfish), you can have males look and act like females because they are trying to get close enough to actual females to mate with them (cuttlefish, bluegills, others), or you can be one of thousands of sexes (slime mold, some mushrooms.) Oh, did you mean humans? Oh ok then. You can be male because you were born female, but you have 5-alphareductase deficiency and so you grew a penis at age 12. You can be female because you have an X and a Y chromosome but you are insensitive to androgens, and so you have a female body. You can be male because you have two X chromosomes, but one of your X's HAS an SRY gene, and so you have a male body. You can be male because you have two X chromosomes, but also a Y. You can be female because you have only one X chromosome at all. And you can be male because you have two X chromosomes, but your heart and brain are male.

For what it’s worth, there are many, many species with more than two sexes- some slime moulds with thousands :)

VestaTilley · 06/06/2023 21:15

YANBU. Pets and humans are male or female (boy and girl or man or women if grown up) and sex cannot be changed.

People treat gender as though it’s a synonym for sex, when it’s no such thing.

8state · 06/06/2023 21:12

Any sniggering during sex education in my day was met by either 'don't be so silly', or 'would you like to explain to the rest of the class what is so funny?' My Biology teacher was truly terrifying, though, I must say😀

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 06/06/2023 21:05

BTW I couldn't be further from a biologist, but any half-baked fool like me knows that there are two sexes: male and female. Anything else is a load of cobblers.

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 06/06/2023 21:04

Confusedmumannoyedson · 06/06/2023 21:02

Yep the deluded one is called @Conkersinautumn who thinks that there are animals out there with other sexes other than male and female. 🙄

I suspect that Conker has gone off hunting for an elusive sex other than male or female. Might need a big bowl of popcorn and a very long wait for the return though.

We'll all be long dead by the time Conkers finds one.

SconesCreamJam · 06/06/2023 21:03

MendedDrum · 06/06/2023 17:30

(another biologist here just waiting to hear about all those animals with more than two sexes, by the way)

🤣

Confusedmumannoyedson · 06/06/2023 21:02

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 06/06/2023 18:02

There's a special type of animal called a deluded fool.

Yep the deluded one is called @Conkersinautumn who thinks that there are animals out there with other sexes other than male and female. 🙄

I suspect that Conker has gone off hunting for an elusive sex other than male or female. Might need a big bowl of popcorn and a very long wait for the return though.

OP posts:
Confusedmumannoyedson · 06/06/2023 20:58

Well @Conkersinautumn your statement "There are more than 2 sexes in a lot of other animals though, or were you too incensed to actually teach your child something? Or was your education limited by some notion of Adam and eve, 2 by two?"

Lots of us are still waiting to hear about the mysterious other sexes that you have discovered.... Or were you too incensed to actually read what I said and race down what you thought was clever with the Adam and Eve bit (but wasn't clever at all)?

Still waiting for all the other sexes you speak of. Enlighten us all?

OP posts:
Confusedmumannoyedson · 06/06/2023 20:51

Tinysoxx · 06/06/2023 18:09

YANBU
I would always use sex instead of gender in biology unless I was talking about social stereotypes. When I was a biology teacher the word ‘sex’ always generated sniggers and red faces in the class.

Worth a few red faces and sniggers to teach facts though. I'm glad you did it and no idea when it became a thing to change it.

OP posts:
Confusedmumannoyedson · 06/06/2023 20:50

Saschka · 06/06/2023 20:07

Lots of science teachers in secondary school will say gender when they mean sex, because a teacher saying the word “sex” repeatedly in front of a group of teenage boys will result in a lot of sniggering, IME.

Not a new thing, and definitely not a trans thing.

Seriously, WOW! Science teachers say it and yet teach science. You say to avoid sniggers from boys. Surely they aren't that bothered by sniggers. No wonder kids are confused.

OP posts:
Saschka · 06/06/2023 20:07

Lots of science teachers in secondary school will say gender when they mean sex, because a teacher saying the word “sex” repeatedly in front of a group of teenage boys will result in a lot of sniggering, IME.

Not a new thing, and definitely not a trans thing.

TheOrigRights · 06/06/2023 20:04

Confusedmumannoyedson · 06/06/2023 17:17

He is 15 and usually pretty bright, I guess he isn't as bright as his school report suggests. However, he said that his teacher said they should use gender and it's all they use. I did chat to him about ideologies around gender and beliefs and that science and biology is based around chromosomes and sex.

I think I need to suggest he questions a bit more rather than relies on what school says. My mistake.

My son is 14. I'll keep an ear out for this nonsense.
I am a molecular biologist so he's got a pretty good understanding of DNA from me.

8state · 06/06/2023 18:32

@Sinoatrialnode That's a relief to hear!

titchy · 06/06/2023 18:18

Sperg

Tinysoxx · 06/06/2023 18:10

PurpleChrayne · 06/06/2023 18:06

The animals went in two by two. Except for the species that have more than two sexes. They went in three by three.

😖😆

What is this mysterious third gamete then, and what is its function? Sperm, egg, and what?

Spegg

Tinysoxx · 06/06/2023 18:09

YANBU
I would always use sex instead of gender in biology unless I was talking about social stereotypes. When I was a biology teacher the word ‘sex’ always generated sniggers and red faces in the class.

PurpleChrayne · 06/06/2023 18:06

The animals went in two by two. Except for the species that have more than two sexes. They went in three by three.

😖😆

What is this mysterious third gamete then, and what is its function? Sperm, egg, and what?

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 06/06/2023 18:02

Confusedmumannoyedson · 06/06/2023 17:13

Not at all. Mammals are male and female. Could you let me know which animals have different genders then?

There's a special type of animal called a deluded fool.

TheShellBeach · 06/06/2023 17:53

willingtolearn · 06/06/2023 17:52

@TheShellBeach

I'd get a comfy chair for that wait - could be while

I've already got in a large stock of popcorn.
Grin

willingtolearn · 06/06/2023 17:52

@TheShellBeach

I'd get a comfy chair for that wait - could be while

TheShellBeach · 06/06/2023 17:51

I'm still interested in being told about all the animals which have more than two sexes.