Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Using gender when studying Biology! What are they teaching.

161 replies

Confusedmumannoyedson · 06/06/2023 17:03

So was talking about getting a pet and my son said what gender. I said not gender just boy or girl and he said we aren't 'allowed' to say that anymore we have to use gender. I explained that gender is something you can pick and there are lots people use including them/they which is fine for how someone identifies but not for animals or when talking biology. I am thinking he is confused because he said they use gender in biology now and don't use sex. I checked with a friend who said he is right.

AIBU? Surely sex should be used for a science subject like biology, and gender should be kept for personal use for how someone thinks they are.

OP posts:
Cherryblossoms85 · 06/06/2023 23:14

"but the beautiful thing about biology is that there are no perfect definitions and there are always exceptions to the rule."

The thing is, the exception does not in any way negate the rule. My son is a human child. Human children have 10 toes. My son does not. Nobody believes this makes him a dinosaur.

onlytherain · 06/06/2023 23:13

@Studyoflife Thanks a lot for taking the time to explain. I am still slightly confused. The poster above said "There are more than 2 sexes in a lot of other animals though". Lots of posters picked this up (some in not particularly kind ways). You then said that the poster was correct. However, it still seems to me that there are only two sexes. Would you say it is correct to say that there are two sexes in animals, but they are physically expressed in more ways than just XX and XY chromosomes or the size of gametes?

I am aware of different meanings of sex and gender, but I have come across the phrase "sex as a spectrum", eg. https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/sa-visual/visualizing-sex-as-a-spectrum/ . This graphic mixes biology and ideology and claims people with DSDs are less female or masculine than people without DSDs, which of course is problematic.

TheKeatingFive · 06/06/2023 23:13

What characterises a male brain or heart? 🤔

Studyoflife · 06/06/2023 23:10

8state · 06/06/2023 22:52

I really don't understand what gender is (apart from in the grammatical sense.) I don't understand in what way it reflects how someone feels. I really wish it wasn't being used so much, it's really confusing. Can anyone explain what it is?

I’m maybe not the best person to explain, but:

  • Sex is used in a scientific sense to describe someone’s chromosomes (XX for female, XY for male). This is their DNA and what determines the genitals they are born with and the hormones they release, for example (with some medical exceptions).
  • Gender is used in a social sense to mean how someone interprets themselves, how they feel and identify, and how they interact with the world. For most people, their gender tends to align with their sex, but for some people how they feel does not match up with their DNA so they may be of a different gender to what would be anticipated based on their chromosomes.
  • Sexuality is separate again; I know you didn’t ask, but just for clarity’s sake sexuality is who you are sexually attracted to and is entirely separate to both sex and gender.
ItsFunToBeAVampire · 06/06/2023 23:10

Catabogus · 06/06/2023 23:05

And you can be male because you have two X chromosomes, but your heart and brain are male

I am baffled by this! Can you really have a “male brain” or a “male heart”?

I missed that part.
A female with XX chromosomes but has a male brain and heart? Are they blue instead of pink or something?
No, that's not right at all and makes me doubt that poster has anything to do with biology.

Catabogus · 06/06/2023 23:09

Catabogus · 06/06/2023 23:05

And you can be male because you have two X chromosomes, but your heart and brain are male

I am baffled by this! Can you really have a “male brain” or a “male heart”?

Sorry, this quote was from Studyoflife

ItsFunToBeAVampire · 06/06/2023 23:07

You can be male because you were born female, but you have 5-alpha-reductase deficiency and so you grew a penis at age 12.

That's not right though, is it?
They aren't born female and miraculously change to male.
They may have been misidentified as female at birth but they were never actually female.
They were born male and remain male. (See Caster Semenya who has 5-ARD).

Catabogus · 06/06/2023 23:05

And you can be male because you have two X chromosomes, but your heart and brain are male

I am baffled by this! Can you really have a “male brain” or a “male heart”?

papayabread · 06/06/2023 23:05

@Studyoflife

"We don’t usually call biological sex a spectrum, although I suppose you could consider those exceptions as being at some point between XX and XY- it’s not something I’d ever considered to be honest.

I think though you’re thinking of the gender spectrum? Sociologically and psychologically we use the term gender to distinguish from XX and XY sexes- gender is how the person experiences life (how they feel, for example), rather than what chromosomes they have. That is referred to as a spectrum as there are many variations that someone may identify with."

I think what you're missing is that's there are, in fact, a lot of people trying to claim biological sex in humans is a spectrum based on the disorders/exceptions you listed up thread.

Studyoflife · 06/06/2023 22:59

TheTellTaleHeart · 06/06/2023 22:57

Just coming in at the end here to find out what the other sexes are. Has @Conkersinautumn provided the list? Or explained what the hell that’s got to do with Noah’s Ark? Other than it being a thinly veiled inference that anyone who believes that there are two immutable sexes is a right wing religious zealot?

Have you read my comments? If not, it sounds like you’d find them interesting as I’ve addressed your questions- though I’m puzzled at why you slathered them in sarcasm.

8state · 06/06/2023 22:59

@LulooLemon Thank you, I remain confused when people use the word. I don't actually know what they are talking about! I understand when it's paired with words like roles or stereotypes, but as a word on it's own I don't.

TheTellTaleHeart · 06/06/2023 22:57

Just coming in at the end here to find out what the other sexes are. Has @Conkersinautumn provided the list? Or explained what the hell that’s got to do with Noah’s Ark? Other than it being a thinly veiled inference that anyone who believes that there are two immutable sexes is a right wing religious zealot?

Tinysoxx · 06/06/2023 22:55

@Studyoflife there are clearly people who want to conform to stereotypes associated with modern day versions of the opposite sex so in that way gender is a useful word to describe feminine and masculine. As a biologist and a woman, ‘woman’ is off-limits for a change of definition. A woman is an adult female human. To change such a fundamental word is unscientific and dangerous medically.

LulooLemon · 06/06/2023 22:54

Gender is vague and therefore meaningless.

It does not help that the law is unclear on the definitions and use of sex and gender.

We need 'male' and 'female' and the term 'sex' to be clarified in law.

8state · 06/06/2023 22:52

I really don't understand what gender is (apart from in the grammatical sense.) I don't understand in what way it reflects how someone feels. I really wish it wasn't being used so much, it's really confusing. Can anyone explain what it is?

Studyoflife · 06/06/2023 22:51

DarkSideOfTheCheese · 06/06/2023 22:36

I tried to dig up the information but I can't actually find anything about any animal (let alone cuttlefish) switching sex alternately with their partner. Looks like I either misunderstood or the lecturer made it up :-(

I did find a lot of really fascinating information though about animals that do switch sex:

https://www.newsweek.com/animals-change-sex-hermaphrodite-evolution-1793036

This is a really nicely explained article, great find! 😍

If you’re interested and want a book/audiobook, ‘Dr Tatiana’s Sex Advice To All Creation’ by Olivia Judson is great for interesting examples, or for a deeper dive into the theory then I’d recommend Matt Ridley’s ‘The Red Queen’.

Tinysoxx · 06/06/2023 22:45

Confusedmumannoyedson · 06/06/2023 20:51

Worth a few red faces and sniggers to teach facts though. I'm glad you did it and no idea when it became a thing to change it.

Yep
When the boys realised I was very unembarrassed to say vulva, penis and vagina etc quite matter-of-factly it usually became a lesson where they would shut up and listen. I had strict rules about no personal stories etc and that I would answer any questions biologically - if they were too embarrassed they could write it down anonymously. 99% of the time they were some very sweet and innocent questions eg. can you get pregnant standing up?

I was taught to remember some children may be pregnant/ have had abortions so be careful how you phrase things too.

Studyoflife · 06/06/2023 22:42

onlytherain · 06/06/2023 22:31

@Studyoflife It's great that you are here and you seem very knowledgeable. Can you explain to me how, if we say sex is a spectrum in humans (for all the examples you have given above), we could still keep the current taxonomy? I am not a biologist by the way and might be completely wrong.

All the examples you have given about human chromosomes and hormones are outside the norm and medically speaking they are disorders, correct? So, if we said, based on this, sex is a spectrum, we would have to apply this to the entire human taxonomy. Following that, humans would have a spectrum of 0-20 fingers that can be attached to the shoulder, elbow, wrist, hand or anywhere in between. Humans would have a spectrum of 0-2 arms, 0-2 legs, 0-10 nipples etc. Pretty much everything would be a spectrum then. Since we are talking science, the same would have to apply to every specie. Wouldn't that render the whole taxonomy useless? Or how do you get around this problem?

You’re right that those examples are exceptions, so for humans we would say that there are two sexes. In biology we’re used to there always being exceptions so we don’t worry about hard and fast rules- we have so many definitions for different things but there’s always at least one example that doesn’t fit, and we love it!

We don’t usually call biological sex a spectrum, although I suppose you could consider those exceptions as being at some point between XX and XY- it’s not something I’d ever considered to be honest.

I think though you’re thinking of the gender spectrum? Sociologically and psychologically we use the term gender to distinguish from XX and XY sexes- gender is how the person experiences life (how they feel, for example), rather than what chromosomes they have. That is referred to as a spectrum as there are many variations that someone may identify with.

Zebedee999 · 06/06/2023 22:39

TheHandbag · 06/06/2023 17:09

This is becoming a nightmare, I teach my children that gender ideology is similar to religious ideology. It is something that people choose to believe rather than something that can be quantified like biological sex and science.

Good parenting well done.

ChatWTF · 06/06/2023 22:39

PurpleChrayne · 06/06/2023 18:06

The animals went in two by two. Except for the species that have more than two sexes. They went in three by three.

😖😆

What is this mysterious third gamete then, and what is its function? Sperm, egg, and what?

I think it’s chips, or could be beans? Expect its function is a fuel source for the foetus.

😂

PickAChew · 06/06/2023 22:39

Studyoflife · 06/06/2023 22:28

I’m not the person you’re quoting, but I have already answered this 😊

Cheers. I finally got to this. Not the gotcha the PP was intending but fascinating all the same.

Damnloginpopup · 06/06/2023 22:38

Wrasse change sex.

I reckon the platypus would be a contender for having more than two sexes or genders or whatevers. They're a bit rebellious.

DarkSideOfTheCheese · 06/06/2023 22:36

Studyoflife · 06/06/2023 22:18

I’m not familiar with them actually switching sex (I will have to investigate!), but I know giant cuttlefish have really sneaky tactics where smaller males will disguise themselves as females when larger males are around to ‘sneak past’ and mate with the actual females. There’s also another species where the males display male colouration on the side of their body facing females, and female colouration on the side facing males- again to maximise their mating chances. Both lovely examples of game theory!

I tried to dig up the information but I can't actually find anything about any animal (let alone cuttlefish) switching sex alternately with their partner. Looks like I either misunderstood or the lecturer made it up :-(

I did find a lot of really fascinating information though about animals that do switch sex:

https://www.newsweek.com/animals-change-sex-hermaphrodite-evolution-1793036

clownfish sex change

The species that change sex

A surprisingly large number of species can swap from male to female or female to male at some point during their lives based on their environment.

https://www.newsweek.com/animals-change-sex-hermaphrodite-evolution-1793036

mathdoc · 06/06/2023 22:36

Fairyliz · 06/06/2023 22:33

But presumably his teacher who is teaching a 15 year old GCSE science will have some scientific background and know the difference?

I think the issue is that this distinction comes from Social Science rather than Science.

Swipe left for the next trending thread