Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Using gender when studying Biology! What are they teaching.

161 replies

Confusedmumannoyedson · 06/06/2023 17:03

So was talking about getting a pet and my son said what gender. I said not gender just boy or girl and he said we aren't 'allowed' to say that anymore we have to use gender. I explained that gender is something you can pick and there are lots people use including them/they which is fine for how someone identifies but not for animals or when talking biology. I am thinking he is confused because he said they use gender in biology now and don't use sex. I checked with a friend who said he is right.

AIBU? Surely sex should be used for a science subject like biology, and gender should be kept for personal use for how someone thinks they are.

OP posts:
Studyoflife · 07/06/2023 00:51

Studyoflife · 07/06/2023 00:45

I really enjoyed reading this article, thank you. On the whole I think it’s great and does a better job than I have at articulating the importance of not viewing all species from a purely human standpoint when trying to understand biology as a whole. I think it is missing a little nuance but I cannot blame them when trying to hit a word count!

Personally I’m not as concerned as them, because from what I’ve seen, the general biologists are sticking to our clear distinction of sex- but I agree that I think the distinction is essential in that gender cannot apply to non-humans. Perhaps I’ll let the human biologists squabble amongst themselves!

There are multiple species for which more than two genders is the norm (not an exception), though sadly the article brushes over this (I suspect for focus and word count). Physarum slime moulds (hundreds) and schizophyllum mushrooms (thousands) are a couple of extreme examples. Nothing I’ve mentioned about non-humans has been about disorders, because if we were to delve into that, literally anything is possible- just as humans can have disorders, so can all other species!

Oh god, apologies I’ve just noticed I said two genders, not two sexes in my last paragraph- absolutely not what I meant, just far too tired now! 🤦‍♀️ Wish there was an edit option.

TheShellBeach · 07/06/2023 00:47

Studyoflife · 07/06/2023 00:45

I really enjoyed reading this article, thank you. On the whole I think it’s great and does a better job than I have at articulating the importance of not viewing all species from a purely human standpoint when trying to understand biology as a whole. I think it is missing a little nuance but I cannot blame them when trying to hit a word count!

Personally I’m not as concerned as them, because from what I’ve seen, the general biologists are sticking to our clear distinction of sex- but I agree that I think the distinction is essential in that gender cannot apply to non-humans. Perhaps I’ll let the human biologists squabble amongst themselves!

There are multiple species for which more than two genders is the norm (not an exception), though sadly the article brushes over this (I suspect for focus and word count). Physarum slime moulds (hundreds) and schizophyllum mushrooms (thousands) are a couple of extreme examples. Nothing I’ve mentioned about non-humans has been about disorders, because if we were to delve into that, literally anything is possible- just as humans can have disorders, so can all other species!

Very possibly, but humans only have two sexes.

Studyoflife · 07/06/2023 00:45

onlytherain · 07/06/2023 00:09

@Studyoflife Are those additional sexes in other species also disorders or are there animal species in which more than 2 sexes are the norm?

Thanks for sharing your views on the graphic. Very interesting! As I said, I am not a biologist and I don't follow the debates amongst biologists, but the mixing of biological fact and ideology seem to be becoming more common. For instance, I have come across it in science videos that suddenly turned into political lectures. This was written by a biologist who seems concerned: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/bies.202200173

I really enjoyed reading this article, thank you. On the whole I think it’s great and does a better job than I have at articulating the importance of not viewing all species from a purely human standpoint when trying to understand biology as a whole. I think it is missing a little nuance but I cannot blame them when trying to hit a word count!

Personally I’m not as concerned as them, because from what I’ve seen, the general biologists are sticking to our clear distinction of sex- but I agree that I think the distinction is essential in that gender cannot apply to non-humans. Perhaps I’ll let the human biologists squabble amongst themselves!

There are multiple species for which more than two genders is the norm (not an exception), though sadly the article brushes over this (I suspect for focus and word count). Physarum slime moulds (hundreds) and schizophyllum mushrooms (thousands) are a couple of extreme examples. Nothing I’ve mentioned about non-humans has been about disorders, because if we were to delve into that, literally anything is possible- just as humans can have disorders, so can all other species!

TheShellBeach · 07/06/2023 00:12

ChatWTF · 07/06/2023 00:05

You have entirely misinterpreted my post and what makes you think I either don’t know that or think it?

I was replying to the comment/question about the differences between male and female brains inferring there isn’t any - when there clearly physiologically is.

Ah okay. Sorry. I misunderstood.

onlytherain · 07/06/2023 00:09

@Studyoflife Are those additional sexes in other species also disorders or are there animal species in which more than 2 sexes are the norm?

Thanks for sharing your views on the graphic. Very interesting! As I said, I am not a biologist and I don't follow the debates amongst biologists, but the mixing of biological fact and ideology seem to be becoming more common. For instance, I have come across it in science videos that suddenly turned into political lectures. This was written by a biologist who seems concerned: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/bies.202200173

ChatWTF · 07/06/2023 00:05

TheShellBeach · 07/06/2023 00:02

There's no need to observe people's brains in order to tell which sex they are.

You have entirely misinterpreted my post and what makes you think I either don’t know that or think it?

I was replying to the comment/question about the differences between male and female brains inferring there isn’t any - when there clearly physiologically is.

8state · 07/06/2023 00:03

Many thanks @Studyoflife , it was kind of you to post answers. I too accept people feel that way, I just struggle to understand how one can feel like something one physically is not, or that the brain is nothing to do with the body and can have a different identity. Don't worry, every now and then I try to think this through and come to the same conclusion, I just don't get it.

TheShellBeach · 07/06/2023 00:02

ChatWTF · 07/06/2023 00:00

there are observed differences:

How our brains differ
The neuroscience literature shows that the human brain is a sex-typed organ with distinct anatomical differences in neural structures and accompanying physiological differences in function, says UC-Irvine professor of neurobiology and behavior Larry Cahill, PhD. Cahill edited the 70-article January/February 2017 issue of the Journal of Neuroscience Research — the first-ever issue of any neuroscience journal devoted entirely to the influence of sex differences on nervous-system function.
Brain-imaging studies indicate that these differences extend well beyond the strictly reproductive domain, Cahill says. Adjusted for total brain size (men’s are bigger), a woman’s hippo­campus, critical to learning and memorization, is larger than a man’s and works differently. Conversely, a man’s amygdala, associated with the experiencing of emotions and the recollection of such experiences, is bigger than a woman’s. It, too, works differently, as Cahill’s research has demonstrated.

There's no need to observe people's brains in order to tell which sex they are.

Studyoflife · 07/06/2023 00:01

ItsFunToBeAVampire · 06/06/2023 23:10

I missed that part.
A female with XX chromosomes but has a male brain and heart? Are they blue instead of pink or something?
No, that's not right at all and makes me doubt that poster has anything to do with biology.

Apologies I missed this.

As stated in my original reply, what I wrote kept disappearing so I gave up and copy pasted. I could argue male female chimerism but equally, someone can “feel” male with two XX chromosomes and vice versa.

My thesis was on the evolution of sexual reproduction, albeit written a decade ago- I’m no longer an academic and have moved into teaching, but still very happy to answer genuine questions about biology especially when they’re about my favourite topic.

I don’t have the energy for the bizarre and unpleasant undertones of a lot of these comments though.

Argue what you like about how you feel, but arguing about the biological facts of different species is just a bit silly.

ChatWTF · 07/06/2023 00:00

TheShellBeach · 06/06/2023 23:48

How do we define what a woman is?

there are observed differences:

How our brains differ
The neuroscience literature shows that the human brain is a sex-typed organ with distinct anatomical differences in neural structures and accompanying physiological differences in function, says UC-Irvine professor of neurobiology and behavior Larry Cahill, PhD. Cahill edited the 70-article January/February 2017 issue of the Journal of Neuroscience Research — the first-ever issue of any neuroscience journal devoted entirely to the influence of sex differences on nervous-system function.
Brain-imaging studies indicate that these differences extend well beyond the strictly reproductive domain, Cahill says. Adjusted for total brain size (men’s are bigger), a woman’s hippo­campus, critical to learning and memorization, is larger than a man’s and works differently. Conversely, a man’s amygdala, associated with the experiencing of emotions and the recollection of such experiences, is bigger than a woman’s. It, too, works differently, as Cahill’s research has demonstrated.

TheShellBeach · 06/06/2023 23:58

8state · 06/06/2023 23:54

@TheShellBeach Maybe a woman now is what society has agreed to call a set of socially constructed roles and stereotypes? I think it used to be linked to things like menstruation, pregnancy, menopause, but now I wonder if the definition changed when I wasn't looking.

I do not think so.
The definition is the same as it always was.

8state · 06/06/2023 23:54

@TheShellBeach Maybe a woman now is what society has agreed to call a set of socially constructed roles and stereotypes? I think it used to be linked to things like menstruation, pregnancy, menopause, but now I wonder if the definition changed when I wasn't looking.

Studyoflife · 06/06/2023 23:54

8state · 06/06/2023 23:25

@Studyoflife I'm thinking hard about it. The explanation isn't new to me, but thank you for breaking it down. It's gender that confuses me. I am really sorry, but don't we interpret ourselves by observation of our bodies and by confirmation from others? That's how I came to the conclusion I am female. Identity comes partly from that interpretation. How we interact in the world is just a result of personality, life experience and social conditioning, I thought. I don't understand how people can have a separate man or woman feeling that's nothing to do with the observable reality. I do understand someone might have a strong desire to be the opposite sex, but that's a bit different. You sound very informed and well meaning, but I can not comprehend this set of ideas at all.

I entered this as a biologist intending to clarify sex in different species as people were asking- I’m afraid I’m not a gender expert and am shattered at this point in the evening so don’t think I’m the person to be answering this!

From my understanding of human development, you’re right that we base a lot of how we feel on social conditioning etc. There’s actually very little difference in male and female bodies and brains before puberty, so the gender stereotypes we see developing in children are almost entirely down to social conditioning, but with a normal distribution (bell curve) so there will always be extremes and overlaps. Hormones kick in mostly in puberty. Someone’s psychological gender development and interpretation of their gender is separate to this, and I don’t know enough about the current evidence on what drives this so I won’t try to explain it. Similar to you, I don’t entirely understand it because it’s not my experience, but I am absolutely confident that if those people, and medical experts, tell me they feel different, I believe them. It would be ludicrous for me to deny someone else’s experience. In the same way that there are exceptions and limitless variation when it comes to everything in our bodies and psychology (whether that be genetic or environmental variation, or disorders), it makes perfect sense to me that there would be exceptions and variation in terms of people’s gender. It’s just that I have a better understanding of what drives physiological variation than my understanding of psychological variation, and I think that is the case still within the medical evidence base.

TheShellBeach · 06/06/2023 23:48

TheKeatingFive · 06/06/2023 23:13

What characterises a male brain or heart? 🤔

How do we define what a woman is?

Robinni · 06/06/2023 23:47

Conkersinautumn · 06/06/2023 17:09

There are more than 2 sexes in a lot of other animals though, or were you too incensed to actually teach your child something? Or was your education limited by some notion of Adam and eve, 2 by two?

Mammals not amongst them.

TheShellBeach · 06/06/2023 23:46

Studyoflife · 06/06/2023 22:59

Have you read my comments? If not, it sounds like you’d find them interesting as I’ve addressed your questions- though I’m puzzled at why you slathered them in sarcasm.

Your comments weren't sarcastic?
Refusing to define what a woman is?

MajesticWhine · 06/06/2023 23:45

@Studyoflife - thank you for trying to define gender -
I am puzzled by this : "For most people, their gender tends to align with their sex"
Given that gender and sex are different concepts then what does it mean that they are aligned? How would I know if my gender is aligned with my sex, apart from through sexist stereotypes?

Catabogus · 06/06/2023 23:44

Could you please explain about the male heart? How could that be possible in a female body?

Studyoflife · 06/06/2023 23:35

onlytherain · 06/06/2023 23:13

@Studyoflife Thanks a lot for taking the time to explain. I am still slightly confused. The poster above said "There are more than 2 sexes in a lot of other animals though". Lots of posters picked this up (some in not particularly kind ways). You then said that the poster was correct. However, it still seems to me that there are only two sexes. Would you say it is correct to say that there are two sexes in animals, but they are physically expressed in more ways than just XX and XY chromosomes or the size of gametes?

I am aware of different meanings of sex and gender, but I have come across the phrase "sex as a spectrum", eg. https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/sa-visual/visualizing-sex-as-a-spectrum/ . This graphic mixes biology and ideology and claims people with DSDs are less female or masculine than people without DSDs, which of course is problematic.

I think it’s important to distinguish between all living organisms, animals, and humans. We tend to think about humans (because we are human!) but most biologists think more about the variety of species as a whole- I know I do. So when we’re describing billions of species, we don’t bother to include all the anomalies and exceptions in those species, except when it’s relevant. So there are many more than two sexes in lots of species, but if we’re describing the human species, we’d say XX and XY, but with exceptions (like you’d find in other species too). We just don’t bother to caveat all the time by referring to those exceptions.

That article is interesting, but I suspect different people may interpret it differently. My interpretation is that it focuses on those exceptions- the genetic disorders- and attempts to map them alongside the norm. I don’t feel that it’s claiming we should entirely redefine sex, and it does distinguish between sex and gender. I think it is aiming to consider the exceptions and present them as evidence for not assuming sex and gender must always align perfectly with ‘XX means girl and XY means boy’- because as they’ve shown, there are exceptions. I think it’s more of a thought exercise than an attempt at redefining sex, and is showing that actually sex and gender are not as black and white as some people like to imagine.

8state · 06/06/2023 23:25

@Studyoflife I'm thinking hard about it. The explanation isn't new to me, but thank you for breaking it down. It's gender that confuses me. I am really sorry, but don't we interpret ourselves by observation of our bodies and by confirmation from others? That's how I came to the conclusion I am female. Identity comes partly from that interpretation. How we interact in the world is just a result of personality, life experience and social conditioning, I thought. I don't understand how people can have a separate man or woman feeling that's nothing to do with the observable reality. I do understand someone might have a strong desire to be the opposite sex, but that's a bit different. You sound very informed and well meaning, but I can not comprehend this set of ideas at all.

TrashyPanda · 06/06/2023 23:25

Gender is used in a social sense to mean how someone interprets themselves, how they feel and identify, and how they interact with the world. For most people, their gender tends to align with their sex, but for some people how they feel does not match up with their DNA so they may be of a different gender to what would be anticipated based on their chromosomes

IMO most people don’t ever consider if they do or do not have a gender.

i don’t identify as a female - I am a female. I don’t feel like a woman - I am just me.

teadi · 06/06/2023 23:21

@ItsFunToBeAVampire made me chuckle anyway!!

TrashyPanda · 06/06/2023 23:21

Sex is biological fact

gender is a concept

for a long time, the two terms were used to mean the same thing, as some people were too prudish to say “sex”, as if it was a dirty word. But now people acknowledge the two are not interchangeable and that sex matters and denying this leads to unfair treatment and oppression.

ItsFunToBeAVampire · 06/06/2023 23:20

teadi · 06/06/2023 23:14

So should "gender reveal parties" be re-named "sex reveal parties" - serous question??!

I'd love to see the reactions of some elderly family members when they first receive an invite to a "sex reveal" and get the wrong end of the stick 😂😂😂😂

In theory, it should be a sex-reveal party but I can understand why people use gender in the old-fashioned way, which was as a polite synonym for sex.
At some point, gender has come to mean something completely different and a lot of people haven't caught up yet.

teadi · 06/06/2023 23:14

mindutopia · 06/06/2023 17:19

I'm a scientist. I suspect he is just confused.

That said, all the people on Mumsnet having 'gender reveal parties' are clearly no more enlightened than a teenager. I think you are assuming this is part of some trans conspiracy to take over the world. Unfortunately, speaking here as a scientist, it's just because many people don't actually understand the difference between the two terms and are using them interchangeable. Just like they have for like 30 years...

So should "gender reveal parties" be re-named "sex reveal parties" - serous question??!

I'd love to see the reactions of some elderly family members when they first receive an invite to a "sex reveal" and get the wrong end of the stick 😂😂😂😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread