Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Using gender when studying Biology! What are they teaching.

161 replies

Confusedmumannoyedson · 06/06/2023 17:03

So was talking about getting a pet and my son said what gender. I said not gender just boy or girl and he said we aren't 'allowed' to say that anymore we have to use gender. I explained that gender is something you can pick and there are lots people use including them/they which is fine for how someone identifies but not for animals or when talking biology. I am thinking he is confused because he said they use gender in biology now and don't use sex. I checked with a friend who said he is right.

AIBU? Surely sex should be used for a science subject like biology, and gender should be kept for personal use for how someone thinks they are.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 07/06/2023 11:06

That's sequential hermaphrodites. Like the famous clownfish.

Irrelevant to mammals, and there are still only 2 sexes that they are changing between.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 07/06/2023 10:23

I have read of some animals that are able to change biological sex, IIRC certain snails are among them, but I’ve never heard of any other animal, inc. fish, amphibians or reptiles, let alone mammals, with this ability.

If anyone else has, do please enlighten me.

Kucinghitam · 07/06/2023 10:18

Also, further reading recommendation: look up the Univariate Fallacy.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 07/06/2023 10:11

Gina Rippon's The Gendered Brain is a really good dissection of the evidence on differences in brain structures.

[Summary: there are no pink or blue brains; what there is is an awful lot of cherry picked data, bad research questions, tiny sample sizes, poor methods, confirmatian bias, and skewed reporting of results.]

Verv · 07/06/2023 10:10

Tinysoxx · 07/06/2023 09:50

And I disagreed with you. I have done my research. The neurosurgeon worked on my child.

Gina Rippon debunked the gendered brain as neurosexism nonsense a few years back and wrote a book about it. She's a neuroscientist.
There was another study here which concluded - "Sex differences are sexy, but this false impression that there is such a thing as a 'male brain' and a 'female brain' has had wide impact on how we treat boys and girls, men and women," Dr. Eliot said."
https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2021/03/210325115316.htm

Massive study reveals few differences between men's and women's brains: Neuroscientists conduct meta-synthesis of three decades of research

How different are men's and women's brains? The question has been explored for decades, but a new study coalesces this wide-ranging research into a single mega-synthesis. And the answer is: hardly at all.

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2021/03/210325115316.htm

BohrMagneton · 07/06/2023 10:08

I just thank God that my children have grown up before all this bollocks became normalised, world has gone stark staring fucking mad

Tinysoxx · 07/06/2023 09:50

ChatWTF · 07/06/2023 09:46

@Tinysoxx

The study I quoted is from a peer reviewed journal, one of the top rated globally, which if you know anything about science you’ll understand. This is not a hack or anything to do with a gender dysmorphia discussion.

you have quoted from a random editorial and your friend who is a neuro surgeon, yet the fact they didn’t even mention the size difference is worrying.

There are some people on this thread who seem determined to read something into a post that isn’t there to meet their own agenda. I AM NOT talking about gender dysmorphia, I am talking about physiological differences. Do your own actual research.

And I disagreed with you. I have done my research. The neurosurgeon worked on my child.

ChatWTF · 07/06/2023 09:46

@Tinysoxx

The study I quoted is from a peer reviewed journal, one of the top rated globally, which if you know anything about science you’ll understand. This is not a hack or anything to do with a gender dysmorphia discussion.

you have quoted from a random editorial and your friend who is a neuro surgeon, yet the fact they didn’t even mention the size difference is worrying.

There are some people on this thread who seem determined to read something into a post that isn’t there to meet their own agenda. I AM NOT talking about gender dysmorphia, I am talking about physiological differences. Do your own actual research.

Confusedmumannoyedson · 07/06/2023 09:41

scienceteacher101 · 07/06/2023 08:02

Science teacher here. Biology is not my specialism but I've had to teach more of it over the past few years. I've been astonished at how many resources conflate gender and sex in a context where it can only be referring to biological sex. I always change where possible and or reword in my explanation. I've been teaching science for decades and it's only the past couple of years I've had this need to preface the word sex with "biological" constantly to keep myself right lest the students complain. (And if you teach science and are embarrassed to use the word sex in front of a class then it might be time for a career change.) Some exam board specs still confuse this (eg 2023 CIE IGCSE) but I note it's been removed in the 2025 onwards edition.
They currently name gender as a factor in human nutritional requirements and a risk factor in developing coronary heart disease! Inheritance topic is at least usually clear as most specs still teach XX/XY chromosomes and explain it defines (biological) sex not gender.

Indeed.

We were watching a programme at breakfast this morning. It is a series that follows Columbus Zoo in the US. A very rare fox was pregnant and the keeper said 'let's find out what genders they are' and scanned then! I mean no wonder some children/adults are confused the silly keeper thought that she was checking a gender but was really checking for sex. A teacher upthread said that a child would lose marks if using gender when referring to sex in a biology exam - that is my concern so I have had a chat and said that many adults are confused. That gender is a social construct and like another poster said a bit like a religion with an ideological belief system. Sex is fact and to use the word sex during any and every science lessons unless they are talking about feelings and social constructs.

OP posts:
Tinysoxx · 07/06/2023 09:11

ChatWTF · 07/06/2023 00:00

there are observed differences:

How our brains differ
The neuroscience literature shows that the human brain is a sex-typed organ with distinct anatomical differences in neural structures and accompanying physiological differences in function, says UC-Irvine professor of neurobiology and behavior Larry Cahill, PhD. Cahill edited the 70-article January/February 2017 issue of the Journal of Neuroscience Research — the first-ever issue of any neuroscience journal devoted entirely to the influence of sex differences on nervous-system function.
Brain-imaging studies indicate that these differences extend well beyond the strictly reproductive domain, Cahill says. Adjusted for total brain size (men’s are bigger), a woman’s hippo­campus, critical to learning and memorization, is larger than a man’s and works differently. Conversely, a man’s amygdala, associated with the experiencing of emotions and the recollection of such experiences, is bigger than a woman’s. It, too, works differently, as Cahill’s research has demonstrated.

https://theconversation.com/amp/you-dont-have-a-male-or-female-brain-the-more-brains-scientists-study-the-weaker-the-evidence-for-sex-differences-158005

You can’t tell the difference between a male and female brain. I have also asked a neurosurgeon and he said no too. It doesn’t really matter one way or another (unless people with gender dysphoria think somehow their brains are of the wrong sex) but that study you quoted does not change what most medical people think.

You don't have a male or female brain – the more brains scientists study, the weaker the evidence for sex differences

https://theconversation.com/amp/you-dont-have-a-male-or-female-brain-the-more-brains-scientists-study-the-weaker-the-evidence-for-sex-differences-158005

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 07/06/2023 08:46

Ah good, that saves me tagging you into the thread @Kucinghitam. I do hope you have that saved on your clipboard rather than having to retype it every time.

CandidaAlbicans2 · 07/06/2023 08:29

So was talking about getting a pet and my son said what gender. I said not gender just boy or girl

@Confusedmumannoyedson YANBU, but as language matters I have to point out that unless the pet you're discussing is a juvenile human, then it's not going to be a "boy" or a "girl", it will be a male or a female. Or if talking about dogs, it would be dog or bitch. If discussing horses, it would be stallion, gelding, or mare. Et cetera. Seeing puppies advertised as "boys and girls available" is a peeve of mine.

scienceteacher101 · 07/06/2023 08:02

Science teacher here. Biology is not my specialism but I've had to teach more of it over the past few years. I've been astonished at how many resources conflate gender and sex in a context where it can only be referring to biological sex. I always change where possible and or reword in my explanation. I've been teaching science for decades and it's only the past couple of years I've had this need to preface the word sex with "biological" constantly to keep myself right lest the students complain. (And if you teach science and are embarrassed to use the word sex in front of a class then it might be time for a career change.) Some exam board specs still confuse this (eg 2023 CIE IGCSE) but I note it's been removed in the 2025 onwards edition.
They currently name gender as a factor in human nutritional requirements and a risk factor in developing coronary heart disease! Inheritance topic is at least usually clear as most specs still teach XX/XY chromosomes and explain it defines (biological) sex not gender.

flutterby1 · 07/06/2023 07:38

"This is becoming a nightmare, I teach my children that gender ideology is similar to religious ideology. It is something that people choose to believe rather than something that can be quantified like biological sex and science."

This

jeaux90 · 07/06/2023 07:03

OP this is batshit...I went to meet the headteacher at the school to get clarification on this and she agreed.

Go and meet the head and ask that the actual hell that teacher is telling your son. Sex is science and biology so you'd hope he was learning facts rather than ideology.

TheTellTaleHeart · 07/06/2023 06:34

Studyoflife · 06/06/2023 22:59

Have you read my comments? If not, it sounds like you’d find them interesting as I’ve addressed your questions- though I’m puzzled at why you slathered them in sarcasm.

I hadn’t. I have now. There’s lots of words there, but still only two sexes.

TheHandbag · 07/06/2023 05:57

Kucinghitam · 07/06/2023 05:38

OK, are we sitting comfortably?

Once upon a time, possibly around a billion years ago, some very simple life-forms hit upon the idea of exchanging little bits of genetic material, which gave them the advantage of variation in changing environments. Amazingly, this is still how the majority of life-forms have “sex” - you may have heard of the worrying phenomenon of antibiotic resistance spreading through populations of bacteria.

Eventually though, some slightly less simple life-forms partially formalised the genetic-stuff-swapping arrangements by requiring different “mating types” - in some species of fungi, there can be a hundred or so mating types. These, therefore, are the only group of living things known to have anything remotely resembling a “spectrum” of sexes.

However, in pretty much all other known life-forms, the number of mating types settled to just two. In higher eukaryotes (this includes humans) there are no additional gametes. (There is extensive debate as to why, because on the face of it mathematically it means that only 50% of other members of your species are suitable mates; I have read various mathematical-modelling scenarios involving distribution of mitochondria etc.)

The reproductive cells, known as gametes, can be isogamous (similar in morphology/size) or anisogamous (different in morphology/size). In anisogamous species, the difference boils down to:

  • Male gametes: Small, motile
  • Female gametes: Large, immotile
(Sometimes with isogamous species, we don’t call them male and female, but + and -.)

Some species produce both male and female gametes in the same individual, these are monoecious species (or in animals can be called hermaphrodites). Some species produce male and female gametes on separate individuals, these are dioecious species (in animals called gonochoric). The primary sexual characteristics of the individual refer to the systems for production of the gametes.

Typically, gonochoric species are sexually dimorphic (they have differences in their bodies as well as the gametes they make) - this is because of the unavoidable differences in necessary adaptions required for successful reproduction; the secondary sexual characteristics are connected with these adaptations.

The manner in which the sexual role of an individual of a gonochoric species is established is variable. Some animals have sex determined by temperature during development (e.g. crocodilians), some can indeed change sex in the truest sense by producing the other gamete (e.g. some species of fish), some have gone for a hardwired chromosomal method (e.g. birds and mammals).

Humans, like other mammals, are a gonochoric anisogamous species whose sex is determined chromosomally, or specifically by the presence of the SRY gene on the Y-chromosome. Your complement of chromosomes is determined the moment your male parent’s small motile gamete fertilised your female parent’s large immotile gamete, and is passed into every cell of your body (except red blood cells, but they are descended from nucleated precursors), where this chromosomal make-up determines how your body develops all those secondary sexual characteristics that evolution has determined are needed for the continuation of the species.

Errors in chromosome segregation, problems with hormone production or receptor function, variations in anatomical growth during embryo development - these are not a spectrum of multiple rainbow sexes, but are DSDs.

There is no known way for human sex, nor any of the true underlying architecture associated with our sexed bodies, to be re-written. We can make superficial modifications to appearance and circulating levels of sex hormones, but that’s it.

The TLDR take home message is that in Homo sapiens sex is binary, is determined at conception and is immutable. We are not Mr/Mrs Potato Head.

No other species has “gender” and most humans do not either.

Thank you

Kucinghitam · 07/06/2023 05:38

OK, are we sitting comfortably?

Once upon a time, possibly around a billion years ago, some very simple life-forms hit upon the idea of exchanging little bits of genetic material, which gave them the advantage of variation in changing environments. Amazingly, this is still how the majority of life-forms have “sex” - you may have heard of the worrying phenomenon of antibiotic resistance spreading through populations of bacteria.

Eventually though, some slightly less simple life-forms partially formalised the genetic-stuff-swapping arrangements by requiring different “mating types” - in some species of fungi, there can be a hundred or so mating types. These, therefore, are the only group of living things known to have anything remotely resembling a “spectrum” of sexes.

However, in pretty much all other known life-forms, the number of mating types settled to just two. In higher eukaryotes (this includes humans) there are no additional gametes. (There is extensive debate as to why, because on the face of it mathematically it means that only 50% of other members of your species are suitable mates; I have read various mathematical-modelling scenarios involving distribution of mitochondria etc.)

The reproductive cells, known as gametes, can be isogamous (similar in morphology/size) or anisogamous (different in morphology/size). In anisogamous species, the difference boils down to:

  • Male gametes: Small, motile
  • Female gametes: Large, immotile
(Sometimes with isogamous species, we don’t call them male and female, but + and -.)

Some species produce both male and female gametes in the same individual, these are monoecious species (or in animals can be called hermaphrodites). Some species produce male and female gametes on separate individuals, these are dioecious species (in animals called gonochoric). The primary sexual characteristics of the individual refer to the systems for production of the gametes.

Typically, gonochoric species are sexually dimorphic (they have differences in their bodies as well as the gametes they make) - this is because of the unavoidable differences in necessary adaptions required for successful reproduction; the secondary sexual characteristics are connected with these adaptations.

The manner in which the sexual role of an individual of a gonochoric species is established is variable. Some animals have sex determined by temperature during development (e.g. crocodilians), some can indeed change sex in the truest sense by producing the other gamete (e.g. some species of fish), some have gone for a hardwired chromosomal method (e.g. birds and mammals).

Humans, like other mammals, are a gonochoric anisogamous species whose sex is determined chromosomally, or specifically by the presence of the SRY gene on the Y-chromosome. Your complement of chromosomes is determined the moment your male parent’s small motile gamete fertilised your female parent’s large immotile gamete, and is passed into every cell of your body (except red blood cells, but they are descended from nucleated precursors), where this chromosomal make-up determines how your body develops all those secondary sexual characteristics that evolution has determined are needed for the continuation of the species.

Errors in chromosome segregation, problems with hormone production or receptor function, variations in anatomical growth during embryo development - these are not a spectrum of multiple rainbow sexes, but are DSDs.

There is no known way for human sex, nor any of the true underlying architecture associated with our sexed bodies, to be re-written. We can make superficial modifications to appearance and circulating levels of sex hormones, but that’s it.

The TLDR take home message is that in Homo sapiens sex is binary, is determined at conception and is immutable. We are not Mr/Mrs Potato Head.

No other species has “gender” and most humans do not either.

Muddays · 07/06/2023 05:06

@Conkersinautumn @Studyoflife
The basic platform for all life is two sexes. Whether mixed or not. The third sex is a mind f&ck, for the bored/distracted.

Muddays · 07/06/2023 05:00

@Studyoflife
You clearly haven't the faintest clue about science. Plenty of rational thought here except for yours. What exactly are your scientific credentials?

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 07/06/2023 01:36

How can a female know what it's like to feel male and vice versa? They can't. You can't know what it's like to be something you're not.

Feelings don't change reality.

This. Some people may feel how they think it feels to be the opposite sex, but that's not to say they are correct in their interpretation. And even if they were, that still wouldn't change their sex.

TheShellBeach · 07/06/2023 01:32

OneLongSmorgasbord · 07/06/2023 01:27

So when you say a female can have a male brain and heart, you don't mean the physical organ, you mean something akin to a soul?

Why does that have any part in a discussion on biology?

You said you don't fully understand gender, but have you thought it might be because it doesn't make any sense?

How can a female know what it's like to feel male and vice versa? They can't. You can't know what it's like to be something you're not.

Feelings don't change reality.

I agree with this.
Men cannot know what it's like to be female.
They still have XY chromosomes.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 07/06/2023 01:32

@Studyoflife While that was an interesting list of assorted mechanisms of sex determination and disorders of sexual development, none of those things constitute additional sexes in animals.

A bird may be male or female depending on whether it has a Z chromosome. A bee may be male or female depending on whether it comes from a fertilised egg with 2 sex chromosomes or an unfertilised egg with 1. But they're still either male or female. In sequential hermaphrodite species individuals change from one sex to the other - but there are still just 2 sexes. The nearest thing to a third sex would be a hermaphrodite species, where an individual produces both male and female gametes - but they still have only 2 types of gametes, it isn't actually a third sex.

Slime moulds, I grant you, are weird. But not animals.

OneLongSmorgasbord · 07/06/2023 01:27

Studyoflife · 07/06/2023 00:01

Apologies I missed this.

As stated in my original reply, what I wrote kept disappearing so I gave up and copy pasted. I could argue male female chimerism but equally, someone can “feel” male with two XX chromosomes and vice versa.

My thesis was on the evolution of sexual reproduction, albeit written a decade ago- I’m no longer an academic and have moved into teaching, but still very happy to answer genuine questions about biology especially when they’re about my favourite topic.

I don’t have the energy for the bizarre and unpleasant undertones of a lot of these comments though.

Argue what you like about how you feel, but arguing about the biological facts of different species is just a bit silly.

So when you say a female can have a male brain and heart, you don't mean the physical organ, you mean something akin to a soul?

Why does that have any part in a discussion on biology?

You said you don't fully understand gender, but have you thought it might be because it doesn't make any sense?

How can a female know what it's like to feel male and vice versa? They can't. You can't know what it's like to be something you're not.

Feelings don't change reality.

Boredwitholdname · 07/06/2023 01:01

mathdoc · 06/06/2023 22:17

I think it is useful to separate out the concepts of "sex" and "gender" however I do think that sometimes people are too confident that their understanding of the meanings are the only correct ones. My understanding (which might be incorrect) is that until the mid 20th century these two words were synonymous. Then a group of sociologists decided that it was useful to assign different meanings to the two terms. I'm not comfortable in imposing this change in terminology on everyone, or telling someone they are wrong just because they are not in the group who use these words in the new way.

My understanding too. In ‘my day’ gender referred to the descriptive words: male, female, neuter. I recognise that this has now changed but it would be wrong to assume that the word ‘gender’ has always held its current meaning.