Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a self catering holiday still a holiday?

166 replies

bagpuss90 · 06/06/2023 13:40

Very light hearted thread. I’m just curious as to opinions on this. So I was chatting to a friend last nite and I mentioned I was off on holiday next week to a self catering cottage . She said she would rather not go on holiday than go self catering because it’s not a holiday . Personally I think that’s nuts . I love the flexibility it gives. We will eat out a good bit . I’m not at work , I’m in a beautiful place away with my family . How is that not a holiday ?

OP posts:
yoshiblue · 06/06/2023 15:26

Currently on a self catering holiday in France. Like a pp I have a child with SEN/food issues so it's so much easier and less stressful to organise our own food.

Meals can be so simple; we've had croissants/cereal for breakfast, bread/cheese for lunch, tonight we're having sausages, chips from the campsite takeaway and salad.

You also get much more space, two bedrooms, a living room and a large outside deck to enjoy.

Call me a saddo I'm also looking forward to doing a wash and putting it out to dry tomorrow!

CountryParsonPetal · 06/06/2023 15:22

I much prefer self catering as I can suit myself, avoid too much social contact and eat out every day at the best local restaurants.

My absolute nightmare would be fully-inclusive, I'd feel very miserable and confined if I had to do that.

mogtheexcellent · 06/06/2023 15:21

My Dh cant cook at all so i loathe self catering holidays. Its not much of a holiday for me and DH refuses to eat out most nights due to cost.

BiddyPop · 06/06/2023 15:20

I should add we also eat out a lot - generally at least once a day and often more. So the SC part is not that onerous.

BiddyPop · 06/06/2023 15:19

We do self catering in various guises more than any other type of holiday.

The beds are made with clean sheets on arrival (and sometimes Sheets/towels replaced while we are there), to a clean house (again sometimes cleaned while there).

I have a box of essentials to make it easier on me - things that we've missed in previous holidays and bought while away or I've picked up knowing I've often bemoaned the absence. Like a couple of sharp knives (in covers), a corkscrew, small chopping board, handful of pegs etc.

We buy lots of naice foods to enjoy, treats and snacks, easy dinners or a few special meals we don't get time to make normally.

We enjoy slowing down and doing things at our pace. Finding a local bakery for morning pastries, or bringing a bag of frozen croissants for morning baking. Proper ground coffee for the cafetière. Easy dinners that require minimal prep and lots of sitting with G&T while things cook etc. We also enjoy long walks, swimming, going to local tourist or historical places, etc. And usually a chance to do some shopping at a relaxed pace.

Some places have needed us to do some cleaning at the end. But normally the materials are provided and as we have packed our things in the car, it is much easier and quicker around a clutter free cottage compared to home.

An AI hotel in a very hot country surrounded by hundreds of others all the time is not my idea of a holiday. I can manage Centre Parcs as the cottage is quiet and we have space to unwind, but a small hotel room doesn't give that space.

cocksstrideintheevening · 06/06/2023 15:18

We go self catering and eat out.

We go AI and eat out. AI is great for pool/ beach days for breakfast / lunch / snacks / ice creams and drinks.

Self catering and cooking is not my idea of a holiday.

tiggergoesbounce · 06/06/2023 15:17

I much prefer SC, you get so much more space and you i find it a lot more relaxing.
I just can't relax in a hotel suite.

We don't cook on holiday, we may whip up.a sandwhich for our DS or a bit of snacky something but we mostly do brekkie, lunch and tea out. I dont like the option of the same 3 or 4 resteraunts for 10 days. We just go where we want.

I do understand people saying its much cheaper if you have kids to go All inclusive as they get endless drinks and ice creams so you are not buying them while you are out and about, but I prefer it.

And washing....no i dont do washing on holiday as a rule.

SpareHeirOverThere · 06/06/2023 15:13

I really hate all-inclusive holidays; being trapped in a place and expected to eat what they offer, 3 meals a day... that's my nightmare holiday.

I like self catering. But I'm not the maid/cook in my family, and there is no expectation that I will cook most days, or at all. I'd feel very different if that was my assumed role!

I like having the option of eating in - great for breakfast, for cooking up what you find in local markets, if you just fancy a salad and some fresh bread and local cheese, etc.

I like independent travel, that's my preference. But I can understand why people might prefer the opposite. Everyone's different.

WonderingWanda · 06/06/2023 15:10

@bagpuss90 🤣 if course it's still a holiday. I even consider camping a holiday where it's bring your own accommodation too, I can imagine your friend doesn't do camping.

That said if I'm going abroad I do often quite like a decent AI holiday because it's a treat for me not to have to worry about what fussy kids and food intolerant dh will eat.

StarmanBobby · 06/06/2023 15:03

‘Personally I don't really consider it "self-catering" if you eat out for most meals’

Self catering just means meals not included! And access to a kitchen. Like staying in a cottage versus a hotel with no cooking facilities or proper fridge.

StarmanBobby · 06/06/2023 15:02

Family of 4 here. Self catering saves us a fortune as we have breakfast at the place, can take picnic bits and snacks out for the day. Save money on coffees/drinks.

doesn’t mean you have to cook every meal- we eat out loads still. Plus it’s not like being at home where you still do housework or clean or do laundry. Or DIY or whatever like you would with a week off work at homeZ

DanceMonster · 06/06/2023 15:01

bingoitsadingo · 06/06/2023 14:58

Personally I don't really consider it "self-catering" if you eat out for most meals. If someone described a holiday as self-catering I would assume they were planning to prepare at least several meals themselves. Which wouldn't really appeal to me, but obviously there are good reasons to

Self catering just means you have kitchen facilities and no meals provided/cooked for you at the accommodation.

snowlady4 · 06/06/2023 15:01

Of course it is!
Holiday is what you make it.
I don't personally choose sc because I like hotels and going down for breakfast/having others do all the cooking and cleaning/ going to the bar etc, but can see why it suits people!
It's cheaper, it's very flexible, you can eat what you want when you want. I'd say it suits alot of people!
We don't all like the same things!

DanceMonster · 06/06/2023 15:00

There would never be a situation where I was cooking all the meals every day for the whole family though, because my DH isn’t a dick.

BarbaraofSeville · 06/06/2023 14:59

@mellicauli

to add: you don't come back from your day out to find that the cleaner has hidden away all your toiletries, wrapped your bed up so tightly it's a hell of a job getting back into it, and piled up all the unnecessary cushions, blankets and throws back on the bed that you shoved down the side of the wardrobe, to avoid having to piss around with them every night.

You don't find that, even if you spend 90% of your waking hours out and about, every time you pop back to the room to get changed or pick something up, the cleaner is trying to service the room.

You don't have to dodge a load of people faffing at the buffet, as if they've never seen a coffee machine or had to choose between apple and orange juice before.

bingoitsadingo · 06/06/2023 14:58

Personally I don't really consider it "self-catering" if you eat out for most meals. If someone described a holiday as self-catering I would assume they were planning to prepare at least several meals themselves. Which wouldn't really appeal to me, but obviously there are good reasons to

cushioncovers · 06/06/2023 14:56

At long as I have the budget to eat out most days then I don't mind self catering. No way I'm cooking everyday when I'm on holiday.

DanceMonster · 06/06/2023 14:54

Actually even without our autistic child we always preferred a private pool and our own space to sharing with hundreds of others!

mellicauli · 06/06/2023 14:53

Advantages of self catering over hotels:

  1. You are not paying for an executive business centre, a wellness room, a laundry, a receptionist, an inhouse beautician and room service options that you will never ever need
  2. You are never crowded out of the pool. It's all yours. You can play really noisy games that take up the entire pool and blare out your tunes if you are far enough from others.
  3. You don't have to listen to: other people arguing, other people having sex, other people slamming doors and laughing down corridors, other people having sex or other people's boring conversations.
  4. You don't have to sit in the dark or get bitten by mozzies on the balcony while the little ones sleep. You can read your book on a sofa.
  5. No portion control on the booze
  6. No queue for the pingpong table
  7. If you get food poisoning it's all your own fault
  8. You get to mooch around local supermarkets WITH PURPOSE and try out random stuff
  9. No need to hide from a rep or swerve past the welcome drinks
  10. You can stay 2 weeks in self catering for price of 1 in a hotel
  11. You never miss breakfast in self catering
  12. No need to go on a tedious tours to dull tourist attractions with a bunch of morons. (Or if you do, at least they are your morons)
Definitelynotme2022 · 06/06/2023 14:52

I like both!

I preferred self catering when the kids were younger, a particular highlight was several years in a beach hut on the sandspit at Mudeford - just stunning. Best holidays ever!

Now they're older (16 and 11) we prefer AI. We book two adjacent rooms and they share. The catering wherever we've has been flexible enough that you can breakfast at 8.00am or 11.00am, and the kids are old and sensible enough to almost do their own thing in a more enclosed environment. We went for some sunshine in October half term last year, and it worked just brilliantly.

fizzyfood · 06/06/2023 14:50

Not for me. Would rather save a bit longer and go in a hotel.

DanceMonster · 06/06/2023 14:45

My autistic child wouldn’t cope with a hotel either. And the other guests wouldn’t cope with his 3 hour meltdowns in the middle of the night. So self catering is the best we’re going to get for the foreseeable future! Luckily we enjoy it.

Crunchymum · 06/06/2023 14:44

Of course it is a holiday but I do kind of get what she means. We had booked our first ever AI for May 2020 (and we all know how that went down) as I wanted a "proper" break. I know from experience that SC means I end up doing the lions share.

We never did make the AI but we've been on about 8 UK Self catering holidays since. I love them, value them and enjoy them as holidays but I still hanker after holiday where I don't have to cook or make a packed lunch

** I do have a DP but I have fallen into that horrible default parent role and the one thing he doesn't "do" is cook

Wishawisha · 06/06/2023 14:42

I know it’s not the point really, but I hate that it’s up to debate what a holiday is. Like the whole idea that staying in the UK is just a staycation and not actually a holiday as if there is a price threshold or distance from
home threshold that the holiday needs to meet.

Staying in a tent and cooking on a tiny, parafin fire might not be an enjoyable holiday for some, but it’s a holiday just as much as staying in an all inclusive in the Bahamas.

I don’t really love self catered, but it is easier sometimes with children. But, I don’t think it needs to be SC vs all inclusive resort. You can stay in a hotel and eat out for different meals. This was my preferred way to holiday before children - I’d mainly visit different cities and travel around and eat out wherever I fancied. You can do it with children but it’s harder.

Conkersinautumn · 06/06/2023 14:41

I couldn't get with a catered holiday, set choices and mealtimes, being around groups of strangers like that. I definitely want my own space and being able to come and go, to have people round if we want but essentially be able to be able to relax away from other people on holiday or staff etc.