Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a self catering holiday still a holiday?

166 replies

bagpuss90 · 06/06/2023 13:40

Very light hearted thread. I’m just curious as to opinions on this. So I was chatting to a friend last nite and I mentioned I was off on holiday next week to a self catering cottage . She said she would rather not go on holiday than go self catering because it’s not a holiday . Personally I think that’s nuts . I love the flexibility it gives. We will eat out a good bit . I’m not at work , I’m in a beautiful place away with my family . How is that not a holiday ?

OP posts:
ManateeFair · 06/06/2023 18:27

For me, a self-catering holiday is absolutely still a holiday. If we self-cater, we stay somewhere with lovely surroundings, we go out somewhere every day and we do barely any cooking - we mostly eat out but if we eat in, it's usually something super easy and holiday-ish, like a nice cheese/charcuterie platter and nice bread from a bakery or something like that.

Admittedly, we don't have kids. But I was actually reminiscing with my mum and dad about childhood holidays a couple of weeks ago, and they were both waxing lyrical about how much they enjoyed them and how it felt like just leaving normal life behind for a week, so despite the fact that we were always in a static caravan or a holiday chalet or something, they must have felt like it was still very much a holiday. I certainly don't think much cooking was done, and certainly no laundry or anything, and there were no strict bedtimes for us kids. I think a lot of the time we'd have been staying in places that didn't provide a telly (we're talking late 70s/early 80s) because I remember playing a lot of family card games/board games/guessing games and so on in the evenings and going out every day to the beach or a local attraction or something.

I expect it might depend on people's different family dynamics and how they self-cater, though. If someone is doing the same food shopping, cooking and laundry on a self-catering holiday that they do when they're at home, and trying to occupy kids in the same way they would at home too, then I suppose they might feel like it wasn't really a holiday for them. But my argument would then be that they are doing self-catering all wrong. It's a holiday if you make it a holiday.

Notreallyhappy · 06/06/2023 18:21

It's a no from me.. cooking cleaning and tidying up, whats for snacks,, blah blah blah.. its like being at home... hotel for me please..

EllaPaella · 06/06/2023 18:19

Depends on the holiday. If staying in a holiday cottage/apartment then of course it's still a holiday - you don't have to cook, you can eat out as much as you like. It's also actually great to have a washing machine so you don't have to pack as many clothes!
I also love an AI when abroad with the kids, you always get a good choice of food and for fussy kids it's a godsend. I don't go AI when away with DH or friends as we like to explore local restaurants etc but it is very useful for skiing or kid's holidays.

rookiemere · 06/06/2023 18:18

We mostly did SC with DS as we hate sharing a bedroom, and now that we have started holidaying without him we've realised that I like to go to bed earlier than DH so it's convenient to have the TV in another room.

At the minute we're self catering in Tuscany. We have eaten every breakfast in, but eaten out for every meal bar a couple of lunches where we bought some cold cuts and cheese from the local coop. It's half the price of staying in a hotel and we even have a somewhat freezing pool.

ToeJammed · 06/06/2023 18:16

I'm one of those commoners who always goes all inclusive.
To me, a holiday means no looking at the time and doing absolutely bugger all domestic wise, not so much as washing a teaspoon, especially when holidaying with the kids.
To be fair, since the kids grew up and stopped going on holidays with us, we only go to adult only all inclusive hotels.
Sometimes we even venture outside the hotel to go sightseeing, have a meal or a few drinks in a decent bar.

Onthegrid · 06/06/2023 18:11

There is nothing wrong with Self Catering, if you are not the one expected to shop, pack, cook and clean for everyone.
DH and I have always shared the 'housekeeping' when at home and also on holiday, plus our 2 DC were not messy and lent a hand.
My favourite family holiday is a villa somewhere near a beach with other activities and sightseeing nearby. Bedrooms for everyone, lazy breakfast at 'home' with coffee on tap. Make a packed lunch for the beach or whatever, then back for showers and afternoon tea. Then either take out, dine out or a simple home cooked meal.
Hotels all in one room and having to eat every meal at a set time (at a high cost) is not great.
UK holidays tend to be multi generation mixed households and that works too.

We do hotels too, but mainly no that it is just the 2 of us and even then I prefer a condo or room with a kitchen.

DancedByTheLightOfTheMoon · 06/06/2023 18:08

You need to ask.yourself what is driving this so called friend to put a dampner on your holiday. She sounds very mean spirited.
I would love to stay in a little cottage somewhere, and l have lovely memories of previous cottage holidays, much better than being stuck in a hotel surrounded by annoying bores in my opinion, (not that l would say this outloud to someone who was staying in a hotel.)

BlowDryRat · 06/06/2023 18:08

We went self-catering last week, like we do most times we go on holiday. I like having separate bedrooms but a shared living area with the DC, having a fridge and being able to eat somewhere different every day, according to what suits our plans or what we stumble across. We booked the cleaning package so we just stripped the beds and emptied the bins when we left, which wasn't a hardship.

I never cook on holiday though. It's usually cereal or pastries for breakfast, bread, cheese and fruit for lunch and eating out for dinner. Cutlery and crockery goes in the dishwasher. Sorted.

Wishawisha · 06/06/2023 18:06

UndercoverCop · 06/06/2023 16:30

Two things here, we used to always go SC or b&b before DC and have some things in for breakfast, yogurt fruit etc and then just eat out. So no not like being at home, deficient no laundry etc.

Having said that lots of people saying I'd rather SC than being cramped in one room with my family and not being able to choose where we eat.
Our most recent holiday was AI, two bedroom two bathroom suite, two balconies overlooking the sea. Lovely. AI buffet was great, 7 ala carte restaurants and we still good a car, went out did things and ate out if it suited.

No one is wedded to anything. If you don't want to cook and do a tesco big shop on holiday, don't. If you don't want to stay glued to the poolside drinking cocktails on your AI, don't.

Yes I think it’s funny how people are somehow suggesting that the alternative to SC is some kind of terrible Spanish resort with “reps”, a whole family in one room and one dining hall where everyone has to eat en masse.

There are so many different varieties of holiday (and they are ALL holidays!). Just pick based on what you enjoy, what suits your family and what you can afford.

IMO all holidays are harder with young children anyway. We have picked SC for quite a few years and (never pre-DC) this year are trying something else. They’re all holidays.

lavenderlou · 06/06/2023 18:04

I only do self catering - can't stand hotels. It's what works best for your family set up. We have DH with terrible insomnia, DD awaiting autism assessment who doesn't like crowds and is very fussy about food. Self catering is much better for us as we are more in control of eating and sleeping arrangements. We rarely eat out either due to the aforementioned eating issues. I am quite happy in the kitchen with a glass of wine though I can see why some people don't enjoy it.

Also, I have found even factoring in money spent on food and drink, self-catering in a French gite always seems to come in cheaper than any AI holidays.

TiredArse · 06/06/2023 18:03

This is why I like an apart hotel. Separate bedrooms and a kitchen/sitting room, but hotel facilities on-site.

LlynTegid · 06/06/2023 18:01

It's a holiday, but I understand why it is not for everyone.

mogtheexcellent · 06/06/2023 17:55

Relax everyone! We only ever camp with DH for a week each year very close to his parents holiday location so get meals or eat out there. Hes a farmer so not much time off during the summer and a genuinely dreadful cook.

Dd and i enjoy some lovely hotel breaks while he is working Wink. But i flat out refuse to do self catering as i do all the cooking at home.

MarnieCres · 06/06/2023 17:39

Last time we did we called at a farm shop close to the cottage and stocked up on loads of local, no cook/easy cook delights. Loved it.

CocoPrivileges · 06/06/2023 17:35

Have really tried to love SC but can't. People say, just make simple meals, soup, salad, stick a pizza in the oven...well yes, but I do that every day at home in the comfort of my own better equipped kitchen, so it's not much of a treat on holiday!

I especially dislike the murky kitchen cupboards in SC cottages full of what I suspect are the owner's cast off pans and utensils.

When I'm on holiday, I want to start the day with a fabulous breakfast cooked by someone else, not the same depressing cereal or croissants I would have at home!

Of course you can eat out, but having to cook and clean up after yourself in an unfamiliar place for the rest of the time is just not a holiday.

Would much rather stay in a hotel for a few days and actually feel like I've had a proper break!

Appleofmyeye2023 · 06/06/2023 17:14

Grumpyfroghats · 06/06/2023 14:26

@Appleofmyeye2023 when we do self catering, we usually get a three bed so that the kids have their own rooms. They sleep a lot better, mess about less and we get more time to ourselves too.

All of what you said is 10x worse in a hotel room in my experience, horrible to be all in one room

Yep, but as she was told my option would be no holiday (staycation with 2 weeks off of work and loads o f fun days out ) is better than holiday with kids 😱🤣🤣🤣🤣

UndercoverCop · 06/06/2023 16:30

Two things here, we used to always go SC or b&b before DC and have some things in for breakfast, yogurt fruit etc and then just eat out. So no not like being at home, deficient no laundry etc.

Having said that lots of people saying I'd rather SC than being cramped in one room with my family and not being able to choose where we eat.
Our most recent holiday was AI, two bedroom two bathroom suite, two balconies overlooking the sea. Lovely. AI buffet was great, 7 ala carte restaurants and we still good a car, went out did things and ate out if it suited.

No one is wedded to anything. If you don't want to cook and do a tesco big shop on holiday, don't. If you don't want to stay glued to the poolside drinking cocktails on your AI, don't.

Loopyloo159 · 06/06/2023 16:30

Always do self catering. So much more space when the children were younger not being cooped up in hotel rooms ! Still prefer it now they are adults!
Sun terrace and always larger balconies,can eat in if we want to which never happens ! More choices food wise at different restaurants,breakfast at apartment with French bread croissants from local bakeries . I genuinely would hate staying in a hotel with less flexibility.

caringcarer · 06/06/2023 16:25

I prefer self catering as we can get up and breakfast what time we like. I like to do a cooked breakfast on holiday so bacon, sausages, an egg, baked beans, hash browns and a half tomato with toast and butter cut into soldiers. DH likes mushrooms too. We are not restricted to one hotel but can eat out at different restaurants each night. I quite like a packed lunch picnic on the beach at lunch time. As long as it's nice accommodation what's not to like? We do one shop on the day we arrive and just go one other day if on a 10 day holiday to top up picnic foods. Some of my best holidays have been self catering.

drpet49 · 06/06/2023 16:19

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 06/06/2023 13:52

Nope sorry not in my world- if I have to cook and clean it’s not a holiday, it’s a stressful way of looking after children, as it’s usually a smaller unfamiliar space. I would rather not holiday, and spend money on a week of meals out at home.

This.

Sweetsweetlike · 06/06/2023 16:19

bagpuss90 · 06/06/2023 13:40

Very light hearted thread. I’m just curious as to opinions on this. So I was chatting to a friend last nite and I mentioned I was off on holiday next week to a self catering cottage . She said she would rather not go on holiday than go self catering because it’s not a holiday . Personally I think that’s nuts . I love the flexibility it gives. We will eat out a good bit . I’m not at work , I’m in a beautiful place away with my family . How is that not a holiday ?

My kids are fussy eaters so when we've been to all inclusive they only want to eat chips and pizza (no matter what country or location) and would have that for the whole holiday if they could get away with it, so self catering has been good at times to make sure their meals are more balanced or in line with what they are open to

Turfwars · 06/06/2023 16:18

We always book self catering, I'll make coffee and pour cereal and drinks and if I'm feeling really magnanimous, I may stretch to making rolls for a picnic. But that's it. For everything else we eat out.

If everyone else gets a holiday away from their daily chores, so should I.

StaringAtTheWater · 06/06/2023 16:17

I just cannot get my head round how families cope in a small hotel room for 2 weeks straight.

I agree with this! Hell is sharing a room with one's children. (tho I might be biased as my eldest has night terrors and yells loudly while he's asleep. Somehow younger DC sleeps through it!)

StillWantingADog · 06/06/2023 16:14

Oh and critically by going “self catering” this means we can get a 2/3 bedroom apartment or house with separate living area.

I just cannot get my head round how families cope in a small hotel room for 2 weeks straight.

BonjourCrisette · 06/06/2023 16:13

We do self catering with another family that we get on really well with. The children get on, we have other adults to talk to, there are four people to share the cooking and shopping and we get a place with a pool so that we can have fun without other people in our space.

We eat out a few times in the fortnight and do really easy bread/cheese/salad type lunches so nobody feels like they've spent their entire holiday in the kitchen.

It is brilliant.

Swipe left for the next trending thread