Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is a self catering holiday still a holiday?

166 replies

bagpuss90 · 06/06/2023 13:40

Very light hearted thread. I’m just curious as to opinions on this. So I was chatting to a friend last nite and I mentioned I was off on holiday next week to a self catering cottage . She said she would rather not go on holiday than go self catering because it’s not a holiday . Personally I think that’s nuts . I love the flexibility it gives. We will eat out a good bit . I’m not at work , I’m in a beautiful place away with my family . How is that not a holiday ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
shellyleppard · 07/06/2023 18:16

Omg this made me laugh so hard!!! Thank you, thank you, thank you!! 😂😂

kitchenassistance · 07/06/2023 17:44

bellac11 · 07/06/2023 09:07

Also what are people doing cooking all the time (if they dont want to), surely you go out and eat.

I guess if you're doing SC to save money, then you might not be able to afford to eat out all the time. Tbh we've spent a small fortune on meals out recently when we've been on city breaks. Two teenage kids who love adventurous/high quality food and are always hungry, eating out every night in a European capital, costs a LOT. Even if you're SC in the British countryside, a meal out in the local pub can be pricey. I'm perfectly happy doing a bit of cooking on holiday, as is DH, and I actively enjoy it when we're overseas, so in a SC week we'd typically eat out (well) three nights and cook for ourselves the rest. I don't ever clean on holiday though (beyond the bare minimum). We don't have a dishwasher at home, so having one on holiday feels like a bit of a luxury!

thecatsthecats · 07/06/2023 14:14

I find being forced "out" every evening a bit tedious after a while. I love good food, but in some countries and cultures, it can dominate in a way that takes over sodding hours every day, and leaves you full up for carrying on the adventure. So self catering is especially good for packed lunches, snacks etc.

I really like a mixture of being able to chill and read one evening on a sofa, then out in a bar the next.

Turfwars · 07/06/2023 13:53

bellac11 · 07/06/2023 09:07

Also what are people doing cooking all the time (if they dont want to), surely you go out and eat.

Years ago on holiday there was a german family in the ground floor apartment. Looked like two families with maybe 5 children. The men lounged out all day long, but the two whole weeks were were there, we never saw their wives unless they were bringing out snacks and drinks or clearing dishes. Then the kids would run past their dads to get their mother to fix their goggles, put on suncream, dry them off, change them, get them a drink or a snack or soothe ouchies. The men just lay there with their hands out for the women to swap in full beers for empties.

Then on that same holiday, we met a couple from an AI resort on a boat trip. They paid quite a bit for AI so even though the food was shit, they didn't have much money to eat elsewhere.

That put me right off self catering+cooking and AI .

So while we opt for self catering for the flexibility and space, lunches and dinners are eaten out all the time. Best of both worlds really. A big part of what we enjoy on our holiday is going to different restaraunts and trying different things so we budget for it..

randomsabreuse · 07/06/2023 12:09

I think a lot of my problem is budget, I'd like to spend more money on less frequent holidays and push the boat out properly. So spend a week skiing in the Alps in a HB hotel or catered chalet and skip the UK holiday in the mid/low range holiday cottage with the saggy, tired mattresses and just enough plates for 1 meal so you have to wash up or run the dishwasher every meal, barely enough "soft" seats for the number of beds.

We've only had 1 "cottage" holiday where the mattresses didn't have a nest and I went home early from a cottage holiday because I was 6 months pregnant and had a baby wedged in my diaphragm meaning I could barely waddle let alone enjoy fun walks. Couldn't hang out in the cottage as neither the bed nor any of the sofas/armchairs were comfortable for more than 15 minutes...

DH wants to go away to get "away" from work while I'd like to just do the fun bits of a holiday (eat out, museums, beach, walks) with my own comfortable bed and sitting room furniture and do a big holiday less frequently. I'm happy to camp in the interim but don't find anything other than a very high end cottage any more comfortable than camping.

Nordicrain · 07/06/2023 09:09

I like self catering holidays, very flexible. But I am veyr relaxed, and still take things very easy. Eat out loads, minimal cleaning. Minimal food prep.

bellac11 · 07/06/2023 09:07

Also what are people doing cooking all the time (if they dont want to), surely you go out and eat.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 07/06/2023 09:06

Of course it is, it’s my favourite plan as it’s so flexible. Abroad I might butter a croissant and eat out other meals, it’s hardly taxing. In the UK I might cater more but just simple pasta dishes etc. I personally can’t stand AI (and I’ve done several ultra all inclusive sun Caribbean, Indian Ocean etc). I definitely wouldn’t choose a one in Europe. On the whole they are repetitive, unhygienic, uninspiring and the dining areas resemble school canteens. I’d much rather go out, choose a restaurant with service, a nice view and an interesting menu.

bellac11 · 07/06/2023 09:05

We always self cater, both home and abroad. Living in a hotel room for a week would drive me insane.

rookiemere · 07/06/2023 09:03

Oh and I'm not cooking- we have eaten in local restaurants and one memorable evening had pizza and anti pasti at the football club run outdoors pizzeria.

rookiemere · 07/06/2023 09:01

To me it's about space, not about cooking.

We are in the heart of Tuscany, I paid 630 euros for a one bed apartment with a separate lounge and enclosed garden and a swimming pool. A basic hotel was coming out at about 1100 euros for the same duration.

But when we go to Canaries in October with DS17 and friend, we will pay for hotel because the premium for entertainment, food and drink on tap and a heated pool is worthwhile for that particular holiday.

Grumpyfroghats · 07/06/2023 08:34

I think probably a lot of this comes down to how much you like restaurant food Vs how much you like cooking.

I don't especially like restaurants - as a family we have a few dietary requirements and it can be a pain to communicate them. A lot of the time, I find the food disappointing. I like eating out occasionally but a whole week of it isn't really an treat for me.

Whereas I do enjoy cooking and trying out new ingredients, especially when there is less time pressure.

I also - like a lot of women - am watching my weight and I find it stressful not being in control of my food. (As I have dietary requirements, I can't just pick anything off the menu)

TheaBrandt · 07/06/2023 08:03

Dh hates being round other people on holiday so massively prefers SC. I could go either way but to be fair he takes on the lions share of food and cooking as it’s a novelty for him he goes to local markets etc so that suits me fine. I also prefer the space and peace of our own property.

knittingaddict · 07/06/2023 07:45

Of course its a holiday. All our holidays are self catering. I rarely cook on any of them and I'm sure that's true of lots of people who book holiday cottages and the like.

Having said that I think a sc holiday where I had to cook just like I would at home would make me a bit resentful. That's just a personal opinion.

Obviously I am very lucky that we can afford to eat out on holiday. Not everyone has that luxury and they can still have a great time and it would still be a holiday. I would hope that all the adults would share the load and it's not just left to the default cook. That would be grossly unfair.

kitchenassistance · 07/06/2023 07:37

When the kids were little we mainly self catered - now we do both. We've got more money now, so happy to pay for two rooms at a hotel (hate hate hate family rooms), and the kids are old enough to entertain themselves with phones/TV after dinner, so less need for space to play. I love SC though -and I have no problem cooking (quite enjoy the ubiquitous challenge of finding the cheese grater!). Some of my very happiest childhood memories are of helping cook on holiday and then long lazy dinners outside while my parents drank too much cheap local red wine.

Generally now we do hotels in cities (where there are loads of places to eat and the days are packed with sightseeing) or for a one ir two night stopover, and SC in the countryside where there might be fewer restaurants and I want the space to spread out, make noise, feel alone. I can't imagine ever wanting to do AI, half the fun of holidays is eating out in different places.

Withnailandeye · 07/06/2023 07:37

FatCatBum · 07/06/2023 07:15

Do you think that once you enter a hotel they hold you hostage until it's time to leave? You aren't forced to eat in the hotel, just go out!

I hate self catering because if I'm going to do cooking and chores I'd rather it be at home where I have everything I need. The only thing I think would be worse is camping (shudder) so it's good that there is choice for everyone

Yes, I am well aware of how a hotel operates, I travel a lot for work. The vast majority of hotels operate a “breakfast between X & Y hours” which I would dislike on holiday as I like to be up and out.

I don’t tend to cook much in self catering, we have young children so will usually have big lunch out and easy supper at accommodation or vice versa, sometimes fish and chips etc. not having the option to cater for the children and having to eat out wouldnt work for me.

rookiemere · 07/06/2023 07:17

Withnailandeye · 07/06/2023 06:57

I couldn’t think of anything worse than staying in a hotel, eating at specified times from the same restaurant most of the week - it seems utterly bizarre that people are so limited that they find organising their own food options to be a chore.

When we did the HB with DS16 and his pal it was so much easier eating at the hotel.
No having to make sure they were ready for a certain time, no worrying about how much they were going to eat and how much that would cost and also if they didn't like something , they could just get another dish.
I do enjoy eating out but am finding that for a week long holiday it does become a bit of a chore.

BooksAndHooks · 07/06/2023 07:16

We only ever go self catering, it’s still very much a holiday. We eat the main meal out most days anyway so it’s only breakfast eaten there and we make picnics to take out.

FatCatBum · 07/06/2023 07:15

Withnailandeye · 07/06/2023 06:57

I couldn’t think of anything worse than staying in a hotel, eating at specified times from the same restaurant most of the week - it seems utterly bizarre that people are so limited that they find organising their own food options to be a chore.

Do you think that once you enter a hotel they hold you hostage until it's time to leave? You aren't forced to eat in the hotel, just go out!

I hate self catering because if I'm going to do cooking and chores I'd rather it be at home where I have everything I need. The only thing I think would be worse is camping (shudder) so it's good that there is choice for everyone

rookiemere · 07/06/2023 07:13

It's nice to do a mixture.

I know when we did all self catering when DS was younger, I craved having someone to make my breakfast, but then recently in October we were HB in the hotel and at teen DS insistence we changed to AI for the last few days. I found the amount of food overwhelming and felt an internal pressure to drink more than normal to get my money's worth - not an experience I particularly want to recreate.

Fizbosshoes · 07/06/2023 07:01

We normally camp or s/c. I know camping isn't everyone's cup of tea - and as a teen DD didn't want to go - but I felt like (for me) it was just as much of a holiday. Usually in a nice location. When DC were little they always slept better than at home. DH did most of the cooking or we ate out. There is limited cleaning to be done in a tent! 😀

But I completely get that other people prefer hotels. There is no right or wrong answer

Withnailandeye · 07/06/2023 06:57

I couldn’t think of anything worse than staying in a hotel, eating at specified times from the same restaurant most of the week - it seems utterly bizarre that people are so limited that they find organising their own food options to be a chore.

PeloMom · 07/06/2023 06:54

I prefer self catering as it gives us flexibility — we don’t waste lots of time looking for places to eat and waiting for food (especially breakfast, snacks). We sometimes order in for lunch/ dinner or eat out. In short, we do whatever we want to. Recently we went to a resort (for a wedding) where we had to eat out every meal and was a bit of nightmare. My child loves certain fruits at this time of the year (usually sold in every store) and I couldn’t find them anywhere at the resort (there was only one store) and the restaurants didn’t have them. And other little annoying things like this.

Vanillazebra · 07/06/2023 06:46

It’s not a holiday, it’s a business trip

Quisquam · 07/06/2023 06:38

*@CocoPrivileges

DH enjoys cooking! It’s the only creative thing he does, after working on a computer all week. I don’t care who does it, so long as it’s not me!

Anyway, we have our 2 week hotel holiday in Greece; and we take disabled adult DD on a self catering holiday in the UK, because going abroad with her is too stressful. Its better to have an automatic washing machine for her; than have do it by hand in a hotel!

Swipe left for the next trending thread