Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this doctors note is ridiculous

283 replies

Bluesjies · 06/06/2023 13:00

Okay this employer has always been a bit lazy but we’ve just had to put up with it.
She does around half the work of other colleagues but we’ve never been able to do anything about it as she does just enough to avoid her being sacked.

Anyway we allocated her a few tasks to do which include several in person meetings (can’t be virtual on this occasion for various reasons).
We knew she didn’t like attending meetings as she prefers just working from home so wondered if she’d say she was sick on the day or say she was not well enough to not work from home.
We can’t avoid attending meetings forever. She’s more than competent when she is in them. I think it’s just she lives an hour from the meeting place and she doesn’t like the commute, getting up early etc.
We do try to have teams meetings where we can but it’s not always possible.

Anyway the meeting on Monday has been arranged and she informed me she could not attend as she was having pain and struggling to walk 🙄”. I replied the meeting isn’t for four days. Will the pain be better then? She didn’t reply but then a couple days later submitted a doctors note saying she needs to work from home until her maternity leave (in 4 months) due to pelvic pain.
There’s not much we can do here really if there’s a doctors note. Or so I thought.

I happened to see her walking perfectly well down a road near her home today so I do have evidence she’s more than able to mobilise.

AIBU to think her note is just nonesense and challenge her on her perfect walking ability? I don’t know why these GP’s write these notes out when it’s not the truth.

Or am I best to silently seeth and get on with it.

OP posts:
Reality25 · 06/06/2023 13:43

It's obviously bollocks but the justice system is too unreliable now to count on it defending you without some solid evidence against her, such as multiple time-stamped videos of her doing gymnastics and marathons.

Just remember it and deal later once she's been back from leave for a few months.

Conkersinautumn · 06/06/2023 13:42

To be Frank she was near home and will have been advised to try to keep mobile for her strength and her stamina with labour looming. Whether you believe it or not this is a genuine condition of pregnancy.
The wider issue of you thinking she is lazy, looking to get rid etc seems curious that you are setting her up to fail during pregnancy, surely this complicates the situation. Why on earth has her lack of productivity not been brought up before?

dancinginthesky · 06/06/2023 13:41

"Will the pain be better then?"

WTAF. How can anyone know if pain will be better in 4 days time? No wonder she didn't reply.

She has enough to report you though thankfully and hopefully sees this post

payaklw · 06/06/2023 13:40

YABVU

I'm WFH currently due to PGP. It's horrific and you sound like a dickwad by complaining about your struggling employee to be honest. Get over yourself and have some compassion FFS

SleepingStandingUp · 06/06/2023 13:40

Bluesjies · 06/06/2023 13:19

It’s an issue though as employees shouldn’t be able to get sick notes if they’re not true. Some proper assessment should be needed.

How exactly would you like a doctor to test a pregnant woman to see if she actually has pain when she walks? Perhaps make her do a run on a treadmill and assess at which point she collapses or cries? Have you ever been to the GP for back pain or similar? I remember being 16 and the doctor heaving my legs all over the place to see which positions hurt, i left in more pain than i went in with, barely upright and sobbing in agony. But yes, that's clearly how we should treat people. Assume they're lying and force them to prove the pain is real.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 06/06/2023 13:40

Don’t challenge it now as that’s just going to be sleepwalking into a discrimination claim. Her doctor has said she needs to wfh and unless you have medical evidence to counter it that’s that.

She should have been managed better when she was being lazy and underperforming before her pregnancy. She’s either doing her job properly or she isn’t, and in the latter she should have been performance managed. Unfortunately having put up with it and not managed her properly until now, now is not the right time to start. Wait until she’s back and settled after her leave/

viques · 06/06/2023 13:40

Bluesjies · 06/06/2023 13:16

We all think she needs to be on a performance management plan.
She’s been on a few previously but it’s SO difficult to actually end someone’s employment in public sector that they’re really not worth your time and effort.
So now she kind of does just enough to not be sacked.
Prior to pregnancy there was no doctors notes or sick leave though..to be fair.

No it’s not that difficult. You stick like glue to your company or organisations policies. You make sure everything is documented. You set achievable targets, then challenge when they aren’t met. You are scrupulous with performance management meetings, 121 meetings, absence records etc. It takes time, you have to bite your tongue, but eventually either the evidence is there and you initiate capability actions, or the employee gets tired of the monitoring and leaves of their own accord. If you go about it half heartedly then , yes, your employee will take the piss if they are that way inclined. You have now been backed into a corner by her pregnancy, you best hope is that she decides not to return to work.

OfficerPastiche · 06/06/2023 13:39

labcoats · 06/06/2023 13:35

OP do you really think doctors just write whatever a patient wants them to write?

The OP is being ignorant in this instance but actually many do!
It's so hard to even get a GP appointment they don't even check, just write a sick note and job done.

Nahimjustaworm · 06/06/2023 13:39

Doctors don't follow their patients around with a gopro all day you know. They get 10 minutes with that patient so mostly have to go by what the patient reports. Tbh with the state of the NHS they have a lot better things to worry about than whether a grown adult is being entirely honest about their symptoms or whether issuing a sicknote is going to upset some Karen manager. The doctor's note is a temporary legal notice of sickness but it isn't by any means a comprehensive assessment of emplyment ability. A GP isn't a medical lawyer or an employment expert and this is beyond their responsibility. You're blaming them for what you essentially view as a lazy employee which is ridiculous. You will have to figure out yourself how you can ethically and legally challenge this if it upsets you but I would tread carefully

GrandTheftWalrus · 06/06/2023 13:39

dancinginthesky · 06/06/2023 13:32

One of my friends was signed off for depression, he was spotted out doing an activity by a colleague- I think him and his wife and kids had gone to the cinema or something. He looked happy in that he was smiling and it was the first time he'd left his home that fortnight.

He wasn't okay and wasn't ready to be back at the type of job he has.

"Looking fine" means absolutely zero.

After my dh came out of hospital we went on holiday a month later, he was still using a stick and dosed up on painkillers. Someone may have thought he was fine but even his manager said go, relax and recover and 10 days round a pool relaxing helped lots before his return to work.

People are just twats.

RagingWoke · 06/06/2023 13:37

Fine to address performance issues, performance management plan or whatever you need to do. You should have a process for dealing with underperformance.

But it's incredibly unprofessional to question her medical issues. She may be able to walk short distances and look fine, but it isn't your place to tell her she's lying based on passing her on the street.

Have you ever had pelvic pain in pregnancy? Even if you haven't surely you have a small amount of compassion.

Thatladdo · 06/06/2023 13:36

If shes doing enough not to get fired, it sounds like shes doing the job that she has signed a contract to do, shes just not giving you extra ( for nothing ), perfectly reasonable and quite right!

If shes not performing as she should then management are to blame for not managing her performance and providing "assistance" / guidance discipline as required.

She might well be swinging the lead and convinced the Doctor that she has something that she either doesnt or that its worse than it actualy is, but thats between the GP and herself - You have the fitnote and thats all you get.

However, this does sound personal and more like a management issue that could very easily turn into a tribunal if anything careless was said or done.

You should have managed her out if her performance is not up to spec before now - you will now have to deal with maternity, further flexi working and working from home demands now.

labcoats · 06/06/2023 13:35

OP do you really think doctors just write whatever a patient wants them to write?

YouAndMeAndThem · 06/06/2023 13:35

'you' as a group of senior management, should know better than to share this information online and be unprofessional and discriminatory to boot. If she is signed off, she is signed off. You haven't got a leg to stand on. I hope you get identified and disciplined.

WeAreTheHeroes · 06/06/2023 13:34

I'm glad this employee has the note from the GP because your OP reads as though you and your "management" colleagues have deliberately set out to make work difficult for her, i.e. you are victimising her. Given your management skills seem dubious from what you've posted here I'm not the least bit surprised you've been unable improve the woman's performance, if it is indeed lacking.

Desperatetime · 06/06/2023 13:34

Have some compassion fgs op

Seasonofthewitch83 · 06/06/2023 13:34

Good luck with your impending employment tribunal LOL.

Itallbalancesout · 06/06/2023 13:33

You are massively in the wrong. You have no idea how much pain she was in whilst waking. She may ‘look ok’ but have been far from it.
Start acting professionally.

takealettermsjones · 06/06/2023 13:33

That's a lot of words for "I'm a terrible manager," OP. Get a grip, and then some training.

DeflatedAgain · 06/06/2023 13:32

You can't do anything. I was signed off for pelvic pain during pregnancy and was advised by my GP to go out walking as much as I felt able to!

She's not bedridden. Some days you feel better than other days.

dancinginthesky · 06/06/2023 13:32

One of my friends was signed off for depression, he was spotted out doing an activity by a colleague- I think him and his wife and kids had gone to the cinema or something. He looked happy in that he was smiling and it was the first time he'd left his home that fortnight.

He wasn't okay and wasn't ready to be back at the type of job he has.

"Looking fine" means absolutely zero.

IAmAlreadyRegrettingMyGreyColourScheme · 06/06/2023 13:32

It's actually pretty creepy that you're spying on her walking down the road like that, and then presumably reporting back on her physical capabilities to the rest of the "we" in your department.
I can see why she isn't in a rush to spend much time with you!

WetBandits · 06/06/2023 13:32

It’s so wildly unprofessional of you to post this here that I can’t actually believe what I’m reading! It’s very outing.

sahm9 · 06/06/2023 13:32

I rarely comment on any of these threads.
YABVU, I’m very very glad I don’t work for you.

Peppermint81 · 06/06/2023 13:32

We all know her type.

Let it go whilst she pregnant, if she comes back then her manager/hr hone down on her performance management.