Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this doctors note is ridiculous

283 replies

Bluesjies · 06/06/2023 13:00

Okay this employer has always been a bit lazy but we’ve just had to put up with it.
She does around half the work of other colleagues but we’ve never been able to do anything about it as she does just enough to avoid her being sacked.

Anyway we allocated her a few tasks to do which include several in person meetings (can’t be virtual on this occasion for various reasons).
We knew she didn’t like attending meetings as she prefers just working from home so wondered if she’d say she was sick on the day or say she was not well enough to not work from home.
We can’t avoid attending meetings forever. She’s more than competent when she is in them. I think it’s just she lives an hour from the meeting place and she doesn’t like the commute, getting up early etc.
We do try to have teams meetings where we can but it’s not always possible.

Anyway the meeting on Monday has been arranged and she informed me she could not attend as she was having pain and struggling to walk 🙄”. I replied the meeting isn’t for four days. Will the pain be better then? She didn’t reply but then a couple days later submitted a doctors note saying she needs to work from home until her maternity leave (in 4 months) due to pelvic pain.
There’s not much we can do here really if there’s a doctors note. Or so I thought.

I happened to see her walking perfectly well down a road near her home today so I do have evidence she’s more than able to mobilise.

AIBU to think her note is just nonesense and challenge her on her perfect walking ability? I don’t know why these GP’s write these notes out when it’s not the truth.

Or am I best to silently seeth and get on with it.

OP posts:
FuckoffeeBeforeCoffee · 06/06/2023 14:31

The doctor isn't t lying for her, OP.

I had really bad PGP during both pregnancies. Some days it wasn't too bad - I could walk and it was uncomfortable but not excruciating. Other days I could barely move. It also got progressively worse the further along I was. I couldn't even turn over in bed without crying in pain.

On a good day I risked a quick trip to IKEA. I was in tears by the time I got ti the tills.

I imagine the doctor has written her a note because they know it's just going to get worse and they're trying to manage it as best they can. Rest and not over exerting yourself is the only thing that helps - but really there isn't anything you can do to stop it.

NoraBattysCurlers · 06/06/2023 14:29

Based on what @Bluesjies has written above, I wouldn't be at all surprisied if Bluejies found herself in front on a disciplinary committee in the coming months. She certainly seems determined to skate on thin ice!

MolkosTeenageAngst · 06/06/2023 14:29

Bluesjies · 06/06/2023 13:19

It’s an issue though as employees shouldn’t be able to get sick notes if they’re not true. Some proper assessment should be needed.

If somebody says they’re in pain how would you expect the doctor to assess whether that’s true? Pain isn’t usually outwardly visible, there’s no blood test or examination which can prove or disprove whether somebody is in pain. Pelvic pain when walking is very common in pregnancy and it can fluctuate so just because you saw your colleague walking near her home doesn’t mean she doesn’t have pain when walking some or most of the time.

If a pregnant woman attends an appointment saying she has pelvic pain when walking, a common/ known problem for some women in pregnancy, what would you have expected from the doctor prior to writing the fit note? How do you know this was not carried out?

riverlodge90 · 06/06/2023 14:28

Pretty sure posting a employees personal medical and HR terms on the internet is against policy in the public sector. Do you need to go on a performance plan?

She could very well read this as could your other employees.

Shocking management.

xogossipgirlxo · 06/06/2023 14:26

You are stepping on thin ice, I would leave it.

Achwheesht · 06/06/2023 14:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

BellatrixLestrangesHeatedCurlers · 06/06/2023 14:23

leave her alone

LuvSmallDogs · 06/06/2023 14:23

Weird how you're just "management team", surely there are more specific titles/roles? Idk why you're being so cagey, with the way you've been getting into the nitty gritty with the employee's business.

Anyway, careful being the type to "just be passing" sick people's houses or spotting that they've been on FB. It'll make you no friends.

Createausername1970 · 06/06/2023 14:23

Well, she is pregnant so she probably has good reason, and if she wasn't providing dubious medical notes prior to pregnancy, then there is really no basis for thinking it is anything other than genuine.

However, as someone who worked in the public sector with a colleague who seemed to be off more than she was in with some very dubious reasons, I can understand your concerns. On reason she gave for being unable to come in totally contradicted the reason she had given a couple of months previously.

The final straw was her asking for AL for a particular date and it being declined as someone else was off at the same time. A few days before the time she wanted to take off, she very conveniently broken her wrist and appeared briefly in work towards the end of the week with a plaster cast on and to say the hospital had advised her to rest her wrist for the next two weeks as it was a bad break. But when she was asked for a hospital note, apparently the hospital "forgot" to give her a discharge note. Guess what, she came back to work after two weeks - and those two weeks were the two weeks she had originally wanted off, all tanned. It might have been coincidence. And then she had the plaster cast removed after the 4th week following "the bad break" there was no sign of injury, she was using her arm and hand with no noticeable difficulty and her arm was TANNED the same as the rest of her!! So she wasn't wearing a plaster cast on holiday!!! We had no clue how she managed to get two plaster casts onto an arm that didn't need it, but somehow she did. She left of her own choice not long after that.

TheShellBeach · 06/06/2023 14:23

I am horrified that a manager sees fit to write a post about a pregnant employee, which she may well see.

How dare you, OP. This is the equivalent of the DWP telling disabled people that they can walk, even when they can't.

I've had subluxation of the symphysis pubis three times. It was agony. But sometimes it just went away for an hour or two. It was unpredictable but incredibly painful when it kicked in..
YABVVU.

BreviloquentBastard · 06/06/2023 14:22

Are you implying that you've been able to do a better and more thorough assessment of her pelvic pain than her own doctor has? By merely seeing her walking down the street one day?

Are you Dr House?

You've got the unprofessionalism and total lack of empathy down at least.

Whatyoutalkingabouteh · 06/06/2023 14:19

It’s not virtually impossible to dismiss for poor performance if you follow a fair process. Get them on a performance action plan and collate evidence.
however for the time being with her being pregnant I would not be touching her at all. If she was a poor performer before pregnancy it’s a shame it wasn’t dealt with then but you’ll be risking a lot to do it to a pregnant woman.
when and if she returns, monitor her performance, ensure you have supported her, if she still has pains then send her to occ health for an assessment. I’d be asking her what treatment is she seeking if it’s an ongoing issue?
if poor performer continues you action it in line with your policy.
But for now I’m afraid you’ll have to bite your tongue

everydaybatperson · 06/06/2023 14:18

Challenge her OP, and then we can all follow the thread where she successfully sues you.

Soakitup37 · 06/06/2023 14:15

Ops never had / heard of or can appreciate the agony of pgp clearly. I had it and couldn’t commute in both pregnancies. My manager was very sympathetic and understanding.

With managers like op who wants to work harder!

OfficerPastiche · 06/06/2023 14:14

Also @labcoats if there was an issue with the baby yes but the discomfort of the mother nobody cares.
Again this isn't for this woman but in tue context of you saying that a sick note is hard to get... It's really not.

UnionRep · 06/06/2023 14:14

Bluesjies · 06/06/2023 13:21

It’s virtually impossible even with really good evidence unless it’s gross misconduct or a job with very specific expectations.

No it isn't 'virtually impossible'. I've been a Union Rep for over 35 years in the Public Sector. It is usually because management go down the path of misconducts and capabilities without getting the correct information or building the case properly and try and wing it. You really cannot do that when someone's job is at stake.
In this case - forget it. Maternity is on her side. In any case if you had brought this to a hearing I would be asking if I could see your medical degree as you clearly think she can fool her GP but not you.

OfficerPastiche · 06/06/2023 14:13

labcoats · 06/06/2023 13:51

Really?! I don't live in the UK anymore, but when I was in the UK and pregnant, the doctors and midwives would be wanting to check out the position not just writing a sick note. You are saying this would happen now even if someone were pregnant?

Have a look at the various threads on here about how hard it is to even get a GP appt - people wake up at 8 a.m. to ring, takes hours to get through and the next available slot is ages away.
Sometimes all you get is a telephone appointment.

So it's easier for them to give a sick note. It doesn't affect them anyway.

Besides people can also choose to be signed off with things like stress or depression which nobody can verify, so what's the point?

AuntieJune · 06/06/2023 14:11

Do you know what happens with pelvic gidle pain? Your hip bones become unstable and grind against each other as you walk. It's agony, but it's worse on some days than others.

I agree that it sounds like you just don't like her because she's not licking arse all the time. Maybe your meetings are an unproductive waste of time? Most meetings are.

Putting someone on a performance plan in late pregnancy would be horrible. I bet she's looking forward to mat leave and hoping there'll be a change of management while she's away.

Namechanginggiraffe · 06/06/2023 14:08

Sometimes I can't WALK* at all (not work)

bloodywhitecat · 06/06/2023 14:08

So many armchair experts on here who seem to know that this employee is "swinging the lead". I wonder if they are the same people who declare "He doesn't look blind" when I ask them not to bump into my little one's buggy as he is blind and it scares him when his buggy moves without warning.

You are out of order OP.

Rosesarered222 · 06/06/2023 14:07

i was in this exact scenario I was the pregnant person and my manager kept hounding me to attend uneccessary face to face meetings. In the end I left that job because of the discrimination and lack of care for my health. You don’t know what she going though just leave it OP.

Namechanginggiraffe · 06/06/2023 14:07

And this is why I left my previous company. I have MS and they made me feel like I "wasn't allowed" to go for a walk or do anything much really. I was FB friends with a colleague who would show management my weekend activities and if it was "too fun" then I'd go in on a Monday and was treated like a liar. (Once I realised it was her, I deleted her immediately!)

If I wasn't in a wheelchair - they were rude and dismissive!

Sometimes I can run 5k, sometimes I can cycle 10km and sometimes I can't work at all.

blalala34 · 06/06/2023 14:06

You're been EXTREMELY unreasonable.

I developed SPD on both my pregnancies and although I could walk and even drive if needed, it was very very painful. I was also signed off to go to the office until the baby was born. Some ppl end up on wheelchair even because of the pain. It's so so hard, you've got no idea, clearly.

I'm glad her GP stepped in.
You sound a nightmare of a manager and completely lacking empathy!

The poor lady.

MorningMoaner · 06/06/2023 14:04

It really isn't hugely difficult to dismiss someone in the public sector if there are genuine grounds and you are a good manager with the support of a decent HR department and occupational health team. I've been on both sides as I was in a public sector management role previously and I eventually had to leave due to long term ill health. So I have both been involved in managing people out and been managed out myself. It's a myth that it's impossible to lose a public sector job.
If this employee genuinely under performs to the degree that you're suggesting and it hasn't been dealt with, that's the fault of the management team/wider organisation but it is a separate issue to her current sickness. Leaping to the conclusion that either she, her GP or both are lying because you saw her walking down the street once is ridiculous. As many people have pointed out her symptoms are likely to be intermittent and by definition you're only going to see her out and about in a good phase. For all you know she might have gone home and been bedbound for the rest of the day. You don't have to be incapable of doing anything to be unfit for work. She may well have been advised to keep as active as she can, but that could be a world away from being able to work as normal.
I'd ask your HR department for an update on your organisation's policies on sickness absence and maternity rights if I were you. You might want to look over their employee social media use policy too as it could be you that's facing disciplinary action if the employee in question recognises herself from this thread.

SophieinParis · 06/06/2023 14:04

Firstly you should just leave her alone. She had a doctors note and she’s pregnant. Suck it up.

Secodly, public sector is always like this. It’s why people prefer working in the private sector..more money and more freedom. Less box ticking. Probably less ‘management team’ jobs though..