Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this doctors note is ridiculous

283 replies

Bluesjies · 06/06/2023 13:00

Okay this employer has always been a bit lazy but we’ve just had to put up with it.
She does around half the work of other colleagues but we’ve never been able to do anything about it as she does just enough to avoid her being sacked.

Anyway we allocated her a few tasks to do which include several in person meetings (can’t be virtual on this occasion for various reasons).
We knew she didn’t like attending meetings as she prefers just working from home so wondered if she’d say she was sick on the day or say she was not well enough to not work from home.
We can’t avoid attending meetings forever. She’s more than competent when she is in them. I think it’s just she lives an hour from the meeting place and she doesn’t like the commute, getting up early etc.
We do try to have teams meetings where we can but it’s not always possible.

Anyway the meeting on Monday has been arranged and she informed me she could not attend as she was having pain and struggling to walk 🙄”. I replied the meeting isn’t for four days. Will the pain be better then? She didn’t reply but then a couple days later submitted a doctors note saying she needs to work from home until her maternity leave (in 4 months) due to pelvic pain.
There’s not much we can do here really if there’s a doctors note. Or so I thought.

I happened to see her walking perfectly well down a road near her home today so I do have evidence she’s more than able to mobilise.

AIBU to think her note is just nonesense and challenge her on her perfect walking ability? I don’t know why these GP’s write these notes out when it’s not the truth.

Or am I best to silently seeth and get on with it.

OP posts:
mycoffeecup · 06/06/2023 15:01

Could I just point out that not all GPs do this. I would have flatly refused to make such a specific recommendation and would have signposted to occupational health. GPs who basically give out sick notes on demand give us all a bad name.

WonderingWanda · 06/06/2023 15:01

If she has a sick note from the Dr then you need to accept that regardless of whether you believe it to be real or not. As others have said pelvic pain can be very bad in pregnancy and can come and go. It might be that the hour in the car is the bit she can't do and this may be genuine.

I think you are muddling up this current sick note with previous conduct which does seem to really be angling toward working from home and not ever attending meetings. All you can do as an employer here is continue to be professional and when this pregnancy and maternity leave is over you can go back to her and deal with the not attending meetings again.

MrsLilaAmes · 06/06/2023 15:00

@Bluesjies I think I've been where you're coming from.

Re PGP, it's horrific and the employee has the doctor's note so that's really the end of the matter. You could ask her to see OH to discuss appropriate support etc but they will be governed by the limits the GP has set out for the duration of the note.

Re chronic underperformance and/or bare minimum performance, strategic sick leave etc I understand your frustration. It is true that someone who is determined to work things to their advantage, in the public sector, can do what's necessary during performance review and then slip back into really annoying underperformance very quickly. It's also true that historic mismanagement or overly indulgent management can mean you inherit a really impossible situation. The amount of extra work it requires from you, as a manager, to actually deal with such an employee, on top of likely also picking up the pieces the employee habitually drops, can make it feel like it's not worth the effort or your sanity.

I'm sending you my sympathy because I totally believe it's possible to be a rubbish employee and one suffering debilitating pregnancy symptoms at the same time. If she returns from maternity leave, plan ahead to tackle things robustly then.

Nell09 · 06/06/2023 14:59

God forbid somebody has a difficult pregnancy and tries to keep on working by asking for adjustment such a wfh.

A Doctor/physio would encourage her to keep active (as mine did) by going for short walks etc, so seeing her walking by her home really isn’t evidence of anything. I hope you didn’t film the poor woman.

You don’t sound professional at all, I imagine she has a very different take on what you’ve posted!

Curtains70 · 06/06/2023 14:57

I am cringing at your post. You are most definitely not cut out for management.

DPotter · 06/06/2023 14:53

Having tried to manage people out from public service employment - you have my sympathy. I too had a situation where someone signed off sick for back pain / mobility issues was seen walking around and this was reported to me by several other employees. This person was also in a management role. I did eventually persuade this person that leaving was an easier option than staying, with me on their case full time. however this was a man, and he was not pregnant.

At least now you know this employee is off for 1 year plus and can plan accordingly.

I also know of a case, which went to tribunal, where someone signed off long term sick was seen working somewhere else. Employee sacked, went to tribunal. Would have been cheaper to pay them off, rather than take the hit on the legal fees. But it's at times like these where you do have to think about the impact of that on the remaining staff.

LaffTaff · 06/06/2023 14:52

You sound an absolute nightmare, a proper jobsworth 🙄😬
The woman in question may be suffering anxiety around group meetings, you don't sound remotely approachable (if indeed there was such an issue).

Greenpin · 06/06/2023 14:52

It's awful working with lazy people who expect their collegues to cover for them.
Most of us have come across people like that.
She may or perhaps does not have pelvic pain so you can't do anything about it.
However if I was one of her put upon collegues I would want management to deal with it properly when she returns from maternity leave.

Stanandlarry · 06/06/2023 14:52

From just reading this brief summary you come across as very unpleasant. You have obviously been spending time bitching about an employee with other managers without following appropriate procedures. I worked in the public sector and you can terminate someone's contract for not meeting the required standard in attendance or capabilities - you just have to follow procedures - which admittedly can be less fun than bitching about someone! Finally please remember there is a human at the centre of this - someone's daughter, mother ... and treat her like you would like one of your own treated.

Inmydreams88 · 06/06/2023 14:49

I'd "silently seeth and get on with it" if I was you. Otherwise you're going to be the one getting sacked. Whatever made you think this was a good idea to post? Completely unprofessional, cruel, unnecessary and probably grounds for discrimination.

Wildlyboring · 06/06/2023 14:49

This very much reads like you know as a manager what will make your pregnant employee's life easier and have gone out of your way to do things that make life harder for her. I suggest you make an Occ Health referral so that appropriate measures can be implemented by you (as her senior manager).

Soubriquet · 06/06/2023 14:49

I’m assuming she’s pregnant in which case it sounds like SPD which I had during pregnancy. I couldn’t walk for months. It’s agonising.

pollykitty · 06/06/2023 14:47

Three weeks ago I drove myself to the ER, parked nearby and walked in because I had a terrible stomachache and right-sided pain. Three hours later I was in surgery for appendicitis. Anyone who spotted me would have thought, 'oh there's pollykitty' not 'pollykitty looks like she's in terrible pain'. You cannot really tell anything by seeing someone walk down the road. People are capable of doing things in terrible pain and discomfort.
Having said that, I think this issue (her potential lie regarding pain) and her work are separate. So she's a crap lazy employee - what have you done about it, really? I was a manager years ago and had two employees who were not doing their jobs very well at different times. One was put on a performance plan, and then decided to quit rather than do the plan, the other was also put on a plan, did not do any of it, and was fired. Both processes took months and were incredibly annoying but the only 'fair' way to sort it out. We (management) made the employee aware of their performance as under par, and gave them tools to improve. Neither person improved -- their choice.
This whole 'she does enough to avoid getting fired' is BS. If you want her out, put the work into the proper procedure and get her out. Don't use her maternity condition and trying to say her doctor's note is fraudulent as some way around it. It comes off as creepy and lazy yourself.

TheUnsettling · 06/06/2023 14:47

Thisnis like when employers see an employee who has been signed off for mental health issues out for a walk or reading a book in the park and decide they’re not unwell.

I had pelvic issues in pregnancy OP, it was awful. I had lots of issues in pregnancy to be honest, but that didn’t mean I constantly waddled everywhere, sometimes I had to stop walking, other times I walked okay.

There is nothing you can do, nor should you do anything. Leave her be.

Redlarge · 06/06/2023 14:44

toddlermom99 · 06/06/2023 13:08

I had severe pelvic pain (PGP) from half way through my pregnancy and at times was left completely bed bound. Equally, at times I felt absolutely fine and pain killers would kick in and you wouldn't even know I had it. So it's still entirely possible that she's telling the truth.

Me too, on my second pregnancy, i ended up wearing a brace and the pain could be agonising.

Cam22 · 06/06/2023 14:44

And yes, I do hope also that this conduct has repercussions for you.

MumblesParty · 06/06/2023 14:43

I'm a GP.
We get pressured into giving sick notes. And pain is very subjective - if someone says they have pain we have to take their word for it.

Cam22 · 06/06/2023 14:42

I find it I incredible that you are discussing a colleague’s business on a forum. YABU and unprofessional.

RosesAndHellebores · 06/06/2023 14:42

As a senior manager may I respectfully suggest that you and your senior manager colleagues seek legal advice in relation to adjustments for a pregnant woman. If performance issues remain on her return from maternity then manage them with smart objectives, support and regular documented monitoring.

NaNaNaNaNaNaBaNaNa · 06/06/2023 14:38

I hope the employee finds this thread, there's some excellent ammunition for a bullying and harassment case here.

Managers all talking about a staff member and micromanaging her without informing her of the concerns or putting her on a formal PMP, accusing her of lying, spying on her outside of work, no attempts to make reasonable adjustments when she has additional health needs. Lots to unpack here.

thecatsthecats · 06/06/2023 14:38

I'm in a very different situation in that I've just been told by my employer that I can't attend the office after 20 weeks - I'm at 19.5.

Thing is though, after being dragged out to a meeting that was cancelled, I did kind of lose my shit. Because yes, pregnancy doesn't make me an invalid, but it was a horrendous use of my energy.

My back hurts more, I got even worse indigestion from the travel, I slept badly for the night before in the hotel and the night after due to back pain.

All unnecessary - the cancelled meeting could have been arranged on Teams.

Pregnancy places limits on my health and energy, and I don't see why work should get first dibs on both at all times when reasonable accommodations can be made.

Nothingisblackandwhite · 06/06/2023 14:37

Thread very carefully, she is pregnant it’s the uppermost protection you can have in the work place .
She can have SPD and it comes and goes and yes it makes traveling really difficult. Maybe try and adjust work to her needs , that’s all you can do

CreepingJenny · 06/06/2023 14:36

I remember having to literally carry my bump with my hand to stop the terrible pulling pain as I walked, ligaments get stretched it was horrible.

Then again an easy thing to fake to a Dr.. so you’ll never know really I guess.

jays · 06/06/2023 14:36

I think the fact you’ve used the term ‘you have proof she’s able to ‘mobilise’ is just truly awful.

Efacsen · 06/06/2023 14:33

OfficerPastiche · 06/06/2023 13:39

The OP is being ignorant in this instance but actually many do!
It's so hard to even get a GP appointment they don't even check, just write a sick note and job done.

Are you a GP? If not

How do you have this intimate knowledge of what goes on in a GP consultation?

Or is it maybe what you've done yourself to mislead a GP?

Swipe left for the next trending thread