Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this doctors note is ridiculous

283 replies

Bluesjies · 06/06/2023 13:00

Okay this employer has always been a bit lazy but we’ve just had to put up with it.
She does around half the work of other colleagues but we’ve never been able to do anything about it as she does just enough to avoid her being sacked.

Anyway we allocated her a few tasks to do which include several in person meetings (can’t be virtual on this occasion for various reasons).
We knew she didn’t like attending meetings as she prefers just working from home so wondered if she’d say she was sick on the day or say she was not well enough to not work from home.
We can’t avoid attending meetings forever. She’s more than competent when she is in them. I think it’s just she lives an hour from the meeting place and she doesn’t like the commute, getting up early etc.
We do try to have teams meetings where we can but it’s not always possible.

Anyway the meeting on Monday has been arranged and she informed me she could not attend as she was having pain and struggling to walk 🙄”. I replied the meeting isn’t for four days. Will the pain be better then? She didn’t reply but then a couple days later submitted a doctors note saying she needs to work from home until her maternity leave (in 4 months) due to pelvic pain.
There’s not much we can do here really if there’s a doctors note. Or so I thought.

I happened to see her walking perfectly well down a road near her home today so I do have evidence she’s more than able to mobilise.

AIBU to think her note is just nonesense and challenge her on her perfect walking ability? I don’t know why these GP’s write these notes out when it’s not the truth.

Or am I best to silently seeth and get on with it.

OP posts:
AuntieJune · 06/06/2023 16:18

Claricethecat45 · 06/06/2023 16:06

Please refer this employee to an Occupational Health Advisor, via an official Referral Form, setting out the job role/hours/demands etc - with an account of the recent and current history. Ask for a report to help you understand what the barriers are and what, if any, reasonable adjustments could be suggested to allow the employee to remain working, safely and productively. A GP generally has no interest in the Employers position and wont suggest anything other than that which the employee tells them. Obviously you need Consent from the Employee to attend this OH review, but it is the sensible thing to do. Most importantly, it demonstrates that you are fulfilling your 'duty of care' as an Employer. This is important in regards to establishing your expectations going forwards. An Occupational Health Advisor can offer work focussed advice independent of the GP opinion, and it does give you the benefit of a possible alternative view with suggestions. A GP note is not a legal document and it is ONLY for Guidance....it is not your obligation to adhere to the GP advice. ( It is possible the OH Advisor will suggest same of course but at least you have an independent advisor, supporting both you, and the employee)HTH

This sounds like an expensive way to find out someone has pelvic girdle pain and it hurts to high heaven. What's an oh going to do, you can't determine it from an examination? The company could fork out for girdles etc but that's an expensive way to buy a £10 girdle

Ffs

StemStem · 06/06/2023 16:16

uonika · 06/06/2023 15:47

I'm self employed (in HR) and I cannot tell you the amount of times clients have come to me whinging that one of their employees is either pregnant or on sick leave with a condition that may qualify them as disabled but that they are lazy, don't pull their weight, are underperforming, and that these problems pre-date the sickness/pregnancy so what can they do? My question is always why the fuck haven't you already dealt with it? Underperformance needs to be dealt with immediately, not left to fester while you and the rest of the team silently resents this poor person but are too cowardly to actually do anything about it.

Fed up of people being promoted into line management when it's patently obvious they haven't got the first clue how to actually manage.

This with bells on 👆

AuntieJune · 06/06/2023 16:15

DPotter · 06/06/2023 14:53

Having tried to manage people out from public service employment - you have my sympathy. I too had a situation where someone signed off sick for back pain / mobility issues was seen walking around and this was reported to me by several other employees. This person was also in a management role. I did eventually persuade this person that leaving was an easier option than staying, with me on their case full time. however this was a man, and he was not pregnant.

At least now you know this employee is off for 1 year plus and can plan accordingly.

I also know of a case, which went to tribunal, where someone signed off long term sick was seen working somewhere else. Employee sacked, went to tribunal. Would have been cheaper to pay them off, rather than take the hit on the legal fees. But it's at times like these where you do have to think about the impact of that on the remaining staff.

@DPotter this reads a lot like 'I constructively dismissed a person with back pain/mobility issues because they were seen walking once and I advise you to constructively dismiss someone you don't like when she returns from mat leave'

Middle management out in full glory today

ghostyslovesheets · 06/06/2023 16:12

SchoolTripDrama · 06/06/2023 15:54

How on earth is this the same thing as what your manager did? That's completely different. Yea let's put OP in the same category as every negative thing that's ever been done by any manager

Because she's angry and wanting to 'manage' aggressively a woman with a debilitating pregnancy condition

dancinginthesky · 06/06/2023 16:11

I mean my heart bleeds for those who have had the misfortune to work with lazy colleagues

But the whole attitude of "I know they're malingering even if they provide a medical note" towards people by those who make a split second judgement based off of their own ignorance from people "looking fine" really does make the world a whole damn sight harder to navigate for those of us who are actually disabled

I put on a brave face and smile - god forbid anyone sees me carrying a bag of shopping from my car one day when I'm feeling well enough to have gone out and reports me for "looking fine" to the benefit fraud investigators

Thankfully I have endless amounts of hospital appointments, reports and medication and the rest that I'd be able to prove I am genuinely disabled but not being able to afford the absolute necessities while it'd be suspended and investigated would really fuck up my entire life

JenWillsiam · 06/06/2023 16:10

Have you experienced pelvic pain in pregnancy? Being able to walk up the road doesn’t mean you’re fine.

Justwishtherewasmoreeffort · 06/06/2023 16:08

How unprofessional of you!

As a mother I actually sympathise with the pregnant lady here - I worked in the NHS when I was pregnant and we had ‘flexi’ working hours, as in if we came in slightly late we could work slightly later in the day. Think admin rather than patient facing. Heavily pregnant (around 6-7months) I had to park on the total opposite side of the hospital site on the staff car park. I arrived in 10 minutes after my ‘start’ time as I literally struggled to walk and arrived in to my manager stood by my desk tapping her watch.

Id imagine your management style to be this

Claricethecat45 · 06/06/2023 16:06

Please refer this employee to an Occupational Health Advisor, via an official Referral Form, setting out the job role/hours/demands etc - with an account of the recent and current history. Ask for a report to help you understand what the barriers are and what, if any, reasonable adjustments could be suggested to allow the employee to remain working, safely and productively. A GP generally has no interest in the Employers position and wont suggest anything other than that which the employee tells them. Obviously you need Consent from the Employee to attend this OH review, but it is the sensible thing to do. Most importantly, it demonstrates that you are fulfilling your 'duty of care' as an Employer. This is important in regards to establishing your expectations going forwards. An Occupational Health Advisor can offer work focussed advice independent of the GP opinion, and it does give you the benefit of a possible alternative view with suggestions. A GP note is not a legal document and it is ONLY for Guidance....it is not your obligation to adhere to the GP advice. ( It is possible the OH Advisor will suggest same of course but at least you have an independent advisor, supporting both you, and the employee)HTH

Soontobe60 · 06/06/2023 16:04

BreehyHinnyBrinnyHoohyHah · 06/06/2023 15:56

You have my sympathy OP. You'll get pounced on here because she's pregnant but I have one of these in my team and it's utterly draining.

Does just enough on performance management plans to avoid getting sacked. Goes off on "sick" for long periods of time with vague symptoms etc etc. Causes other team members' stress as they have to pick up the slack, which then leads to resentment and the loss of good hard working people.

I have every sympathy with people who have long term illnesses etc, but there are a small minority of people who are just lazy and will find any excuse. If you've ever had to work with one you would understand how frustrating it is.

If someone is doing enough work to meet targets on their PM, then they're doing the job well. What youre saying is that you expect employees to do MORE work for the same pay because thats what others in your organisation do. Just because theyre stupid enough to push themselves for free, doesn’t mean everyone in the workforce does.

sunflowerdaisyrose · 06/06/2023 16:03

My husband was unwell for around 9 weeks and was totally off work for 2 and then couldn't drive so had a certificate from the dr. The dr saw him on day 1 of the illness and that's it. All other certificates were provided when he filled in a form online for the GP. He genuinely needed it but made us realise quite how easy it was to get one as they didn't even speak to him, never mind assess him.

ForeverFailing · 06/06/2023 16:02

@Bluesjies WTF? You work for a public sector organisation and you’re on MN how you can sack a pregnant employee!!!
with ‘leaders’ like you it’s no wonder public organisations are so shit.
Read your company guidance, phone HR. Or better still, find a non management job.

Soontobe60 · 06/06/2023 16:01

Bluesjies · 06/06/2023 13:12

Yeah we probably won’t do anything to be honest. Just letting off steam on here 😂

It’s not funny. You have admitted to setting up someone whom you think is lazy despite her doing her job, knowing that she hates face to face meetings, then you question what her GP has written on her sick note. You’re a really good example of a really bad manager.

shivawn · 06/06/2023 16:01

I happened to see her walking perfectly well down a road near her home today

You happened to? That was convenient.
Are you maybe a bit too invested in this?

Newnamenewname109870 · 06/06/2023 15:59

Walking down the street one time is very different to commuting into work and working. It can come and go and for all you know it was unbearable.

BreehyHinnyBrinnyHoohyHah · 06/06/2023 15:56

You have my sympathy OP. You'll get pounced on here because she's pregnant but I have one of these in my team and it's utterly draining.

Does just enough on performance management plans to avoid getting sacked. Goes off on "sick" for long periods of time with vague symptoms etc etc. Causes other team members' stress as they have to pick up the slack, which then leads to resentment and the loss of good hard working people.

I have every sympathy with people who have long term illnesses etc, but there are a small minority of people who are just lazy and will find any excuse. If you've ever had to work with one you would understand how frustrating it is.

SchoolTripDrama · 06/06/2023 15:54

ghostyslovesheets · 06/06/2023 15:50

Are you my old manager? Who referred me to OH for 'period problems' after 3 miscarriages ? I was pregnant at the apt and management got a massive dressing down - she was moved to another office.

YABU - and unprofessional - I hope she reads this or the DM picks it up because you are sharing her confidential information all over the web

also in the public sector it's very easy to put people on a plan for sickness - I had 6 weeks off - 2 different times, due to covid and long covid - I was put on a plan by my manager because that was procedure - it's standard practice - she was required to do it - so this smells bullshitty to me

How on earth is this the same thing as what your manager did? That's completely different. Yea let's put OP in the same category as every negative thing that's ever been done by any manager

uncomfortablydumb53 · 06/06/2023 15:53

YABU and you know it
You are not a Dr and don't know her medical history
You are extremely unprofessional posting on a public forum, a question which has an obvious answer

HadalyEve · 06/06/2023 15:50

I hope you get sued for maternity discrimination.

It is obvious she is having a difficult pregnancy and no her pelvic pain isn’t going to get better while she is still pregnant FFS!

ghostyslovesheets · 06/06/2023 15:50

Are you my old manager? Who referred me to OH for 'period problems' after 3 miscarriages ? I was pregnant at the apt and management got a massive dressing down - she was moved to another office.

YABU - and unprofessional - I hope she reads this or the DM picks it up because you are sharing her confidential information all over the web

also in the public sector it's very easy to put people on a plan for sickness - I had 6 weeks off - 2 different times, due to covid and long covid - I was put on a plan by my manager because that was procedure - it's standard practice - she was required to do it - so this smells bullshitty to me

AlfietheSchnauzer · 06/06/2023 15:49

IAmAlreadyRegrettingMyGreyColourScheme · 06/06/2023 13:32

It's actually pretty creepy that you're spying on her walking down the road like that, and then presumably reporting back on her physical capabilities to the rest of the "we" in your department.
I can see why she isn't in a rush to spend much time with you!

Sorry but this is hilarious! Only on MN can spotting someone you know walking down a street when you happen to drive past, be considered "spying"
^
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣^

uonika · 06/06/2023 15:48

Yep, I used to be an NHS manager, on every training course we were always told if someone calls in sick even if you see them happily doing their shopping in the supermarket you can't do anything about it. It's not 'evidence'. Because they might be well enough to do urgent things like get food or even be going to the pharmacy to get a prescription for their illness, picking kids up from school that can't be avoided etc and still not be well enough to be at work. Not really difficult to understand tbh.

Once had a client who had an employee signed off sick with depression and one of their colleagues saw her at a restaurant on a friday night. They asked if she could be sacked for gross misconduct. My eyes rolled so far I'm surprised they didn't disappear.

Dangeliss · 06/06/2023 15:47

Even if she IS a serial scammer, this thread is totally off-base and unprofessional, and I hope for your sake that it doesn't get traced back to your workplace like a lot of these things do.

uonika · 06/06/2023 15:47

I'm self employed (in HR) and I cannot tell you the amount of times clients have come to me whinging that one of their employees is either pregnant or on sick leave with a condition that may qualify them as disabled but that they are lazy, don't pull their weight, are underperforming, and that these problems pre-date the sickness/pregnancy so what can they do? My question is always why the fuck haven't you already dealt with it? Underperformance needs to be dealt with immediately, not left to fester while you and the rest of the team silently resents this poor person but are too cowardly to actually do anything about it.

Fed up of people being promoted into line management when it's patently obvious they haven't got the first clue how to actually manage.

TiredandHungry19 · 06/06/2023 15:46

in terms of having seen her I do t think you can use that as evidence. My old org had a similar case where a staff member was too anxious to be in the office due to covid (after restrictions where lifted) but had a second job working as a singer in packed pubs/clubs. He posted a lot of photos on Facebook of this. We where advised by hr lawyers that we couldn’t use this as evidence his anxiety was exaggerated 🤷‍♀️.

Yep, I used to be an NHS manager, on every training course we were always told if someone calls in sick even if you see them happily doing their shopping in the supermarket you can't do anything about it. It's not 'evidence'. Because they might be well enough to do urgent things like get food or even be going to the pharmacy to get a prescription for their illness, picking kids up from school that can't be avoided etc and still not be well enough to be at work. Not really difficult to understand tbh.

dishyrishi · 06/06/2023 15:46

You sound like an arse

You have no idea about her medical
Condition, if a doctor has signed her off or advised light duties, you follow that advice

Swipe left for the next trending thread