Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this doctors note is ridiculous

283 replies

Bluesjies · 06/06/2023 13:00

Okay this employer has always been a bit lazy but we’ve just had to put up with it.
She does around half the work of other colleagues but we’ve never been able to do anything about it as she does just enough to avoid her being sacked.

Anyway we allocated her a few tasks to do which include several in person meetings (can’t be virtual on this occasion for various reasons).
We knew she didn’t like attending meetings as she prefers just working from home so wondered if she’d say she was sick on the day or say she was not well enough to not work from home.
We can’t avoid attending meetings forever. She’s more than competent when she is in them. I think it’s just she lives an hour from the meeting place and she doesn’t like the commute, getting up early etc.
We do try to have teams meetings where we can but it’s not always possible.

Anyway the meeting on Monday has been arranged and she informed me she could not attend as she was having pain and struggling to walk 🙄”. I replied the meeting isn’t for four days. Will the pain be better then? She didn’t reply but then a couple days later submitted a doctors note saying she needs to work from home until her maternity leave (in 4 months) due to pelvic pain.
There’s not much we can do here really if there’s a doctors note. Or so I thought.

I happened to see her walking perfectly well down a road near her home today so I do have evidence she’s more than able to mobilise.

AIBU to think her note is just nonesense and challenge her on her perfect walking ability? I don’t know why these GP’s write these notes out when it’s not the truth.

Or am I best to silently seeth and get on with it.

OP posts:
Youthinkyoureuniqueyourejustastatistic · 06/06/2023 17:23

I had pelvic pain in pregnancy, sometimes it was ok others I couldn’t walk.
It still flares up now and I’m 3 yrs post partum.

Also, I wouldn’t want to put a pregnant person at risk of catching infectious disease at an in person meeting when it can be done on teams.
Are the meetings masked and or in well ventilated rooms? When pregnant you are immunosuppressed.
There has been a rise in maternal and foetal death since covid…causation or correlation I don’t know…but I wouldn’t risk it as a manager responsible for people if not necessary.

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 06/06/2023 17:22

Bluesjies · 06/06/2023 13:12

Yeah we probably won’t do anything to be honest. Just letting off steam on here 😂

@Bluesjies - totally the wrong forum to vent about employees who may be swinging the lead. You could witness and video said employee cartwheeling and undertaking a trapeze act whilst signed off for mobility issues and still have your arse handed to you

nidgey · 06/06/2023 17:16

Bluesjies · 06/06/2023 13:16

We all think she needs to be on a performance management plan.
She’s been on a few previously but it’s SO difficult to actually end someone’s employment in public sector that they’re really not worth your time and effort.
So now she kind of does just enough to not be sacked.
Prior to pregnancy there was no doctors notes or sick leave though..to be fair.

Would you not join the dots if she didn't have medical leave before she was pregnant? She could easily have symphysis pubis dysfunction (SPD) which is not uncommon in pregnancy, and can make walking extremely painful.

A good manager would wind their neck in, go with what the doctor says and support her, not come onto a website and bitch about an employee.

SchoolShenanigans · 06/06/2023 17:16

Unfortunately, whilst it's probably obvious she's making it up, you won't be able to prove it and you'll be opening yourself and the firm up to all sorts of issues if you so much as raise it.

I would talk to HR about what you can do when she returns from maternity. Ie, change contracts to stipulate how many in person meetings she needs to attend per month.

lieselotte · 06/06/2023 17:13

Also, if most meetings can be hybrid, so can this one.

I attended a face to face meeting yesterday. We were asked to go in for it, but it could have been done remotely. It was just better face to face.

momonpurpose · 06/06/2023 17:12

I hope you realize by law you are putting YOURSELF in a position to be fired and your company sued. As a manager you should have the training to know this. I say this as a member of management for 26 years. This is totally going to be picked up by the daily mail so if o were you I would start hunting for a job asap

lieselotte · 06/06/2023 17:12

I know people have little faith in GPs these days but it's not right to cast aspersions on their integrity and professionality OP.

I've had SPD when I was pregnant and it wasn't funny, although it didn't stop me working as it was mild, and I only had a 10 minute drive to work.

Also being able to walk down the road has no bearing on whether you can manage a one hour commute. As an example, I pulled a muscle in my bottom a few months ago. I could still run, walk and swim, but I struggled to sit in the car. If you google it, you will find it is a common problem. I could manage 10 minutes here and there, but an hour in the car (and then back at the end of the day) would have been very painful and I wasn't even pregnant to add to the mix.

I also agree that if someone is rubbish at their job, you can get rid of them, even in the public sector. The law is no different, you just need the evidence. So draw it together. But you have missed the boat now as she is pregnant and it will seem just a little too convenient.

Poor managers get poor employees...

....and lose the good ones.

Whapples · 06/06/2023 17:12

I’m disabled. Diagnosed, get some benefits based on it, have letters/medications etc. I use a walking stick most of the time. Sometimes… I don’t! When I walk across the classroom to grab something, when I walk to the loo at work, if I need to carry things to my car… it doesn’t mean it’s not painful but I can manage it to make something else quicker or easy. Some really ableist assumptions on this thread. Seeing someone walk normally doesn’t mean they aren’t in pain.

Claricethecat45 · 06/06/2023 17:08

AuntieJune · 06/06/2023 16:18

This sounds like an expensive way to find out someone has pelvic girdle pain and it hurts to high heaven. What's an oh going to do, you can't determine it from an examination? The company could fork out for girdles etc but that's an expensive way to buy a £10 girdle

Ffs

AuntieJune
I suggest that it is a lot less expensive than the employer being taken to a tribunal and being found to have lacked a duty of care, or have been discriminatory. It may be that the employee isn't deemed fit to work in any capacity - or - she may be fit to work in the office/attend meetings with a flexible hours arrangement and ergonomic support. And you clearly don't understand what OH is - it is a lot more detailed than suggesting to 'fork out for a girdle'. It is a very reasoned, evidence based assessment process with professionally qualified advice provided, that seeks to protect the employee, and support the employer also.

Ffs

Abouttoblow · 06/06/2023 17:05

Ellatella · 06/06/2023 16:46

Sounds like you really have it in for her. You say she likes to work from home so you decided to schedule her in for in person meetings an hour away from where she lives.
And you can't be sure she is lying about her pain. Also why were you driving near where she lives? I hope not trying to check up on her?

How did you come to that conclusion after reading the OP?

Anyway we allocated her a few tasks to do which include several in person meetings (can’t be virtual on this occasion for various reasons).

TheRowdy3 · 06/06/2023 17:04

Being able to undertake a short walk and standing on a packed train are two very different situations.

Public sector organisations have worked virtually for a number of years now. It may not be your preferred way of working, meetings should have a Teams or Zoom capability. Logistically it can work.

CountryCob · 06/06/2023 17:01

I would say pelvic pain in pregnancy can be very sore and just because she has walked doesn't mean she is fine.....

TheRowdy3 · 06/06/2023 16:55

Is this a reverse?

This situation has been managed poorly up until now. Pregnancy is not the time to start to proactively manage a return to the office.

Take the doctor's note at face value and support your employee's wellbeing.

Rosesbloomingnow · 06/06/2023 16:53

SPD is very painful but I doubt you would always be able to tell that someone has it by watching them walk.

AuntieJune · 06/06/2023 16:53

FloweryName · 06/06/2023 16:34

She wouldn’t have been able to get away with this before working at home became so common and it’s situations like this that give pregnant women a bad name in the workplace and why employers will avoid employing a women that are likely to have babies when they can.

If her pregnancy means she can’t do her job properly she should go on maternity leave.

@FloweryName before people were able to work from home she'd have been signed off work presumably. But she's somehow a scrounger for continuing to work?

And people who refuse to hire women of childbearing age are small-minded, discriminatory bigots who are crap at business

BittenontheBum · 06/06/2023 16:53

@Bluesjies I am very happy nobody I know works for you.
@Nahimjustaworm we will never get away from the derogatory use of 'Karen' being used against women if people are still using it to berate women on here!

roomadvice · 06/06/2023 16:49

I hope this poor lady isn't on Mumsnet and works out who you are.

Zone2NorthLondon · 06/06/2023 16:48

Pg with a doctor note,and a protected category.Can you managers spell Tribunal?

Ellatella · 06/06/2023 16:46

Sounds like you really have it in for her. You say she likes to work from home so you decided to schedule her in for in person meetings an hour away from where she lives.
And you can't be sure she is lying about her pain. Also why were you driving near where she lives? I hope not trying to check up on her?

Abouttoblow · 06/06/2023 16:42

Whatyoutalkingabouteh · 06/06/2023 16:38

Im confused why people are saying you can't get rid of people in the public sector?! Follow the policy and manage them. it feels like those moaning haven't managed properly

Have you ever dealt with unions in the public sector?

Grumpy67i8 · 06/06/2023 16:41

Walking for brief periods of time near her home is VERY different to commuting. YABU.

Whatyoutalkingabouteh · 06/06/2023 16:38

Im confused why people are saying you can't get rid of people in the public sector?! Follow the policy and manage them. it feels like those moaning haven't managed properly

FloweryName · 06/06/2023 16:34

She wouldn’t have been able to get away with this before working at home became so common and it’s situations like this that give pregnant women a bad name in the workplace and why employers will avoid employing a women that are likely to have babies when they can.

If her pregnancy means she can’t do her job properly she should go on maternity leave.

Fruitjellies · 06/06/2023 16:22

You need to speak to HR and get advice. An OH referral can and will override a GP note in certain circumstances - I've had to refer to them in a similar event (not pregnancy related)

MorningMoaner · 06/06/2023 16:20

SchoolTripDrama · 06/06/2023 15:54

How on earth is this the same thing as what your manager did? That's completely different. Yea let's put OP in the same category as every negative thing that's ever been done by any manager

There are plenty of people happily putting the woman that the OP is complaining about into the same category of every poor colleague they have ever known though. There are loads of posts talking about recurrent episodes of sickness or long sick leave and even the OP has said perfectly clearly that this is not the case here and that the employee did not have any sickness prior to the pregnancy.
She's been described as "a bit lazy" by the OP who also recognises that when she has been on a performance management plan she has met the requirements, so that may or may not be true. But even if it is, that doesn't mean she is lying about her sickness. Even lazy people have been known to be ill once in a while. And she has been seen walking down the road, not running the London Marathon or taking part in a tap dance competition for heaven's sake. She's stated to be unfit for work, not unfit to leave the house, and she has a condition that is recognised to fluctuate in its severity so. She could be malingering of course, who knows, but the OP seemingly has no evidence of this and she should be very careful about making baseless accusations.

Swipe left for the next trending thread