Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Poll) If a new disease with a similar fatality rate to pre-vaccination COVID appeared again…

433 replies

user1477391263 · 06/06/2023 12:58

And the government started to issue instructions about rules, hand washing, masks, social distancing, not meeting up with people, and the like, similarly to what happened in 2020-21….

What would your response be?

A: I would follow the rules more strictly than I did last time (because WFH has made it easier OR because the deaths from COVID make me feel we should have been stricter last time).

B: I would follow the rules about as strictly as I did last time, for the most part.

C: I would follow some rules or follow most rules to an extent, but would be significantly less “strict” about this than I was during COVID.

D: I would be much, much less strict or would completely ignore most rules/instructions, insofaras I was able to disregard them.

I’m just trying to work out whether the COVID experience and aftermath has shifted the Overton window and made people more open to the idea of following rules etc. to contain infectious diseases, OR alternatively whether people have grown a bit more blasé about diseases, disillusioned about governments or concerned about negative aftermaths of pandemic control measures.

For what it’s worth, I’d be a C (although I was never very strict first time round either to be honest).

And MNHQ, can we please get a proper poll selection option that goes beyond YABU/YANBU options?

OP posts:
Hobert · 06/06/2023 17:09

C/D

I followed them quite strictly for covid and now feel like a complete idiot. I can't believe I let DS go weeks without seeing other children. I would not be so stupid if it happened again.

HalfasleepChrisintheMorning · 06/06/2023 17:09

C
I am happy to do masks but would never support school closures again and wouldn’t keep away from my family again either.
life is too short

StormShadow · 06/06/2023 17:09

IComeLastInAllTheRaces · 06/06/2023 16:59

Well, if you prefer a direct quote we can use that instead.

You can't @StormShadow

I never said that things would all be fine with positive thinking or selflessness.

You haven't read my posts accurately.

OK, well I'll have another go.

You said, in a couple of posts:

Yes, after a while if children's hospitals collapsed. But before that there would be a period of society trying to reduce transmission, and trying to work together to muddle along. Civil unrest wouldn't happen immediately, imo. There would be panic but also hope and attempts to keep the essential plates spinning.

However, I am optimistic that society would try to organise and collate and at least attempt something cohesive and not just going straight to civil unrest . Humans are resourceful and quite tough even when facing adversity.

I think this is unrealistic, skirts over the problem of parents refusing to work on a wide scale and doesn't explain how any of the problems would actually be managed.

I agree with your point about people putting their families first though.

WhatTheHeckyPeck · 06/06/2023 17:07

D

I followed the rules in Lockdown 1....my mum still died
I followed the rules in lockdown 2....my dad still died.

So if it should ever happen again, I won't follow any rules unless I've no choice.

megletthesecond · 06/06/2023 17:06

A. I didn't sacrifice anything in covid. I'm a lone parent and had no one years before covid kicked off. My priority has always been to keep healthy, parent and work. No social life at all, ever, and no back up.

If anyone fancies dealing with my dc's every day (including the one with MH issues who might smash up the house) and paying my bills then maybe I'll be more chilled next time......

StormShadow · 06/06/2023 17:05

awimbawaaay · 06/06/2023 16:57

@StormShadow yeah I get you. I think what I'm saying though is that we all probably subconsciously knew covid wasn't a big deal because if it WAS, you wouldn't be getting a paddling pool delivered by Amazon and a Chinese from Just Eat. You'd probably be hoping that you'd be getting rations from the army + volunteers at the end of your street who'd be calling you out one-by-one over a tannoy? While you, the former Tesco delivery driver, stayed home with your kids, your brothers kids, the downstairs neighbours kids or whatever because they had seriously critical jobs like ICU nurses and Army etc. Or it would be the oldest person on the street doing the Costco run (if it were indeed kids at risk). I know that's what one of my neighbours did for all the elderly in our street in the early days when everything felt very serious and delivery slots were like hens teeth.

I accept I may be totally naive but I do think if "the big one" happened and it was a subset of society at risk, people tend to rally. Especially if the difference in risk amongst different demographics was as apparent as it was during covid with some virtually no risk at all.

I'm not sure people tend to 'rally' if that means not seeing their children for a potentially open ended period of time. It's an order of magnitude different from people doing errands for their more vulnerable neighbours.

Worth noting that most NHS clinical staff and carers with DC did not choose to live away from their families during covid, despite the fact that they'd clearly pose less risk to their patients if they did. That's a very substantial sacrifice and it's not one we can assume most parents would make, especially not if they could reduce the risk to their DC in exactly the same way by not working.

JenniferBooth · 06/06/2023 17:01

@KrisAkabusi They were relaxed for Christmas were they? No You are gaslighting. But you now wont be able to say anything about me going to my parents at Christmas 2020.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/06/2023 17:00

Are we all assuming that we wouldn't be the ones who would die this time, then?

IComeLastInAllTheRaces · 06/06/2023 16:59

Well, if you prefer a direct quote we can use that instead.

You can't @StormShadow

I never said that things would all be fine with positive thinking or selflessness.

You haven't read my posts accurately.

Aishah231 · 06/06/2023 16:59

D - never ever again!

awimbawaaay · 06/06/2023 16:57

@StormShadow yeah I get you. I think what I'm saying though is that we all probably subconsciously knew covid wasn't a big deal because if it WAS, you wouldn't be getting a paddling pool delivered by Amazon and a Chinese from Just Eat. You'd probably be hoping that you'd be getting rations from the army + volunteers at the end of your street who'd be calling you out one-by-one over a tannoy? While you, the former Tesco delivery driver, stayed home with your kids, your brothers kids, the downstairs neighbours kids or whatever because they had seriously critical jobs like ICU nurses and Army etc. Or it would be the oldest person on the street doing the Costco run (if it were indeed kids at risk). I know that's what one of my neighbours did for all the elderly in our street in the early days when everything felt very serious and delivery slots were like hens teeth.

I accept I may be totally naive but I do think if "the big one" happened and it was a subset of society at risk, people tend to rally. Especially if the difference in risk amongst different demographics was as apparent as it was during covid with some virtually no risk at all.

user1469559754 · 06/06/2023 16:54

B. I love outside UK and we had very strict rules and I followed them to the letter. I'm glad I did and would do it again for the common good.

WhenImSixtyFour · 06/06/2023 16:54

B
as my spouse hasn’t magically changed from being CEV

StormShadow · 06/06/2023 16:52

IComeLastInAllTheRaces · 06/06/2023 16:43

But a virus that's really dangerous for children means a huge number of adults are going to refuse to work. We'd need a lot more than positive vibes and a bit of selflessness to be able to get through that without real societal problems. And the hypothetical situation you mentioned is a lot more widespread than the small, quite localised ebola outbreaks you refer to here.

With any hypothetical situation, there are a range of elements to consider. It's not automatic that it is airborne.

The localised ebola outbreaks are an interesting example of how communities did work together during a really dangerous time for those communities - diverse public figures such as religious leaders, musicians and beloved activists like Leymah Gbowee all influenced behaviours which helped to stop transmission.

Who said we'd get through it with positive vibes and a bit of selflessness? Because it certainly wasn't me.

Well, if you prefer a direct quote we can use that instead. I don't think any of the exact things you've described would be nearly enough to deal with the inevitable refusal of a lot if not most parents to work outside the home. People would try, yes, it wouldn't just be a fuck this, but the idea that we'd be working together until the children's hospitals collapsed is far too optimistic. Massive problems would kick in way before that!

Jagoda · 06/06/2023 16:50

B

MereDintofPandiculation · 06/06/2023 16:49

HoldingTheDoor · 06/06/2023 15:55

They feel justified because they were ok and most reasonably healthy people were ok (not forgetting those who died, of course, but most younger and healthyish people did recover) and now assume that it will be the same going forwards. That 'only' old or medically fragile people will be at risk.

Or some of us have faced various other adverse life events, losses and health issues and accept that living comes with risks, that we face multiple risks every day so I'm not going to flap over one more.

We were told last time that the risk of death for the elderly was 4%, ie 1 in 25, that it was high for those with co-morbidities, and that hospital beds would be assigned on the basis of "frailty" - in effect, those who were elderly and at highest risk would be on their own.

Yes, we face all sorts of risk in life, but most are not that high, and most that are not immediately fatal come with some expectation of medical help.

I remember attending a small concert in mid March 2020. Many of the audience had not turned up, and those of us who had were going purple in the face trying not to cough in case anyone thought we had Covid! If lockdown had not been ordered by the government, I believe there would have been a very high non-participation rate, certainly in voluntary activities.

Of course in 2020 many of use believed the government were giving factual information. That belief may not be so widespread now.

StormShadow · 06/06/2023 16:48

awimbawaaay · 06/06/2023 16:38

general societal agreement that households with children should be financially supported, there'd still be a huge gap in the essential workforce to fill.

But wouldn't there be more of a "war effort" type scenario if the threat was actually great enough to justify it. I mean if we have an ebola level virus affecting children, and my partner is a firefighter and my brother is a shunter and his wife is a nurse, the logical thing to do is isolate me with the four kids in one house while they drop stuff off at me. Send kids out to farms in the country ala WW2. Move them in with granny. It would be living hell but people would grin and bear it in the same way carers physically left their families and moved in with their patients to protect them when the risk seemed great enough to justify it.

The problem with covid is that the risk did not feel great enough to the vast majority of people who were being forced to go through hell. At the start when we didn't know what we were dealing with, perhaps. But not when we saw the numbers and started catching it ourselves.

The thing is that even if this 'war effort' scenario happens, that still leaves the practicalities. If we lose, say, 10% of NHS clinical staff because they have DC at home, grinning and bearing it is only going to get us so far. More workers with specific skills can't be magicked up. As we're learning now!

I also don't think for a second that people are going to be willing to send their kids out to the countryside with someone they don't know, or even someone they do know, so they can carry on being a Tesco delivery driver. I fucking wouldn't. Most carers didn't move in with their charges during covid either, so there's no reason to think they'd be willing to in the future.

And help to family might just as easily look like financial assistance. If this happens in a generation, I'd be more inclined to spare my DGC the trauma of separation from their parents and give them money instead. This all sounds extremely naive.

ThroughThickAndThin01 · 06/06/2023 16:47

D

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/06/2023 16:44

the logical thing to do is isolate me with the four kids in one house while they drop stuff off at me

Thats exactly what my SIL, who works in ICU, did. Her kids came to us for the lockdown. Two of her colleagues did the same and basically isolated themselves from their families.

IComeLastInAllTheRaces · 06/06/2023 16:43

But a virus that's really dangerous for children means a huge number of adults are going to refuse to work. We'd need a lot more than positive vibes and a bit of selflessness to be able to get through that without real societal problems. And the hypothetical situation you mentioned is a lot more widespread than the small, quite localised ebola outbreaks you refer to here.

With any hypothetical situation, there are a range of elements to consider. It's not automatic that it is airborne.

The localised ebola outbreaks are an interesting example of how communities did work together during a really dangerous time for those communities - diverse public figures such as religious leaders, musicians and beloved activists like Leymah Gbowee all influenced behaviours which helped to stop transmission.

Who said we'd get through it with positive vibes and a bit of selflessness? Because it certainly wasn't me.

awimbawaaay · 06/06/2023 16:38

general societal agreement that households with children should be financially supported, there'd still be a huge gap in the essential workforce to fill.

But wouldn't there be more of a "war effort" type scenario if the threat was actually great enough to justify it. I mean if we have an ebola level virus affecting children, and my partner is a firefighter and my brother is a shunter and his wife is a nurse, the logical thing to do is isolate me with the four kids in one house while they drop stuff off at me. Send kids out to farms in the country ala WW2. Move them in with granny. It would be living hell but people would grin and bear it in the same way carers physically left their families and moved in with their patients to protect them when the risk seemed great enough to justify it.

The problem with covid is that the risk did not feel great enough to the vast majority of people who were being forced to go through hell. At the start when we didn't know what we were dealing with, perhaps. But not when we saw the numbers and started catching it ourselves.

Littleroundsponge · 06/06/2023 16:34

C

IComeLastInAllTheRaces · 06/06/2023 16:31

TheKeatingFive · 06/06/2023 16:07

However, I am optimistic that society would try to organise and collate and at least attempt something cohesive and not just going straight to civil unrest

This debate has come up before on here. I would not be too sanguine about the likelihood of society supporting those who have families to stay at home with them, while everyone else runs around keeping the show on the road. From what I've read. Let's just hope it never happens.

Agree I hope it never happens.

I'm not sanguine about it at all. I don't think everything would all be grand. It's almost certain that unrest would arrive, in those sets of circumstances.

But I do think people would ATTEMPT stuff to cooperate and help and improve the situation.

I think we are hardwired to want to help each other - especially when the dangers are starkly obvious - but of course will put our own family first.

Hollyppp · 06/06/2023 16:30

d

Queeniewag · 06/06/2023 16:30

D