Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Poll) If a new disease with a similar fatality rate to pre-vaccination COVID appeared again…

433 replies

user1477391263 · 06/06/2023 12:58

And the government started to issue instructions about rules, hand washing, masks, social distancing, not meeting up with people, and the like, similarly to what happened in 2020-21….

What would your response be?

A: I would follow the rules more strictly than I did last time (because WFH has made it easier OR because the deaths from COVID make me feel we should have been stricter last time).

B: I would follow the rules about as strictly as I did last time, for the most part.

C: I would follow some rules or follow most rules to an extent, but would be significantly less “strict” about this than I was during COVID.

D: I would be much, much less strict or would completely ignore most rules/instructions, insofaras I was able to disregard them.

I’m just trying to work out whether the COVID experience and aftermath has shifted the Overton window and made people more open to the idea of following rules etc. to contain infectious diseases, OR alternatively whether people have grown a bit more blasé about diseases, disillusioned about governments or concerned about negative aftermaths of pandemic control measures.

For what it’s worth, I’d be a C (although I was never very strict first time round either to be honest).

And MNHQ, can we please get a proper poll selection option that goes beyond YABU/YANBU options?

OP posts:
StormShadow · 07/06/2023 07:10

PortUmber · 07/06/2023 06:08

I don’t think it’s right to think : well I hate our government, they’ve been wrong on so many counts, they haven’t followed the rules themselves, therefore I’m not doing what they say. A pandemic should be thought of more as a global response. If our government are handling it badly, what are the rest of the world doing? If the majority of the world think a certain course of action is most likely to have the best outcome, then I would go with that.

I think a lot of it is about trust. There aren't a lot of institutions or bodies whose trust levels have emerged unscathed from the past 3 years. The WHO, the most obvious rest of world body, have hardly covered themselves in glory.

Additionally, doing what the rest of the world, did, or the rich world anyway, got us a lockdown that our pandemic planning had advised against and that was essentially a punt. It should be obvious why a lot of people wouldn't want that again, either because of views on the lockdown itself or on not following our existing pandemic plans. Even if you don't feel that way yourself.

DollyParkin · 07/06/2023 06:37

A or B

I know of too many unnecessary deaths or long-term after effects.

BarbaraofSeville · 07/06/2023 06:31

Yes, this thread does seem to be dominated by 'our government are shits so I'll deliberately break the law' and the 'cool rebels'.

I find it hard to believe that if we were back in a position where we had a new disease that was easily transmissible, couldn't be vaccinated against and was causing serious illness and death that the majority would do nothing to protect themselves or their loved ones.

PortUmber · 07/06/2023 06:08

I don’t think it’s right to think : well I hate our government, they’ve been wrong on so many counts, they haven’t followed the rules themselves, therefore I’m not doing what they say. A pandemic should be thought of more as a global response. If our government are handling it badly, what are the rest of the world doing? If the majority of the world think a certain course of action is most likely to have the best outcome, then I would go with that.

PortUmber · 07/06/2023 05:56

@user1477391263

I don’t think I’d think of it in terms of ‘the government’ or ‘our government’. I’d see what was happening on global level, look at the reasoning behind the safety precautions, evaluate the risk to my family/others - and decide from that whether I need to take more precautions than advised.

Our Tory government is more about economy, allowing the rich to thrive while the less fortunate are left to flounder. In particular I think Sunak would go economy over safety.

Across Europe, I think Finland possibly had the best Covid response, and lessons and better strategies could be learnt from that.

Purplepeaches123 · 06/06/2023 21:30

D

MissWired · 06/06/2023 21:29

D.

PurpleAirGuitar · 06/06/2023 21:28

B, but how strictly I followed them last time was pretty strictly.

Cuckoosheep · 06/06/2023 20:44

B, we followed quite strictly the first time round

I have a child with complex needs although not strictly medical, severe autism. Many families were correctly reporting that dnr's had been placed on their relatives medical files. I was scared to death of him not getting the help he would need if he becae ill. Knowing that dnr's were put in place, I'd never risk them making those same decisions again znd putting him at risk whether reported or not.

Gardendad · 06/06/2023 20:25

D

KisstheTeapot14 · 06/06/2023 20:20

B

Panteranoir · 06/06/2023 20:19

B

mrsrobin · 06/06/2023 20:16

D

Daffodil92 · 06/06/2023 20:13

cakewitch · 06/06/2023 20:10

I'd weigh up the risks myself and take measures accordingly. Like myself, and all my friends and family did. Sensible and measured. Unlike the absurd lengths the media and government lead us to believe we had to go to.

Quite.
My dad is elderly and vulnerable, his letter from the government said he shouldn’t go in his own garden or take the bins out!

cakewitch · 06/06/2023 20:10

I'd weigh up the risks myself and take measures accordingly. Like myself, and all my friends and family did. Sensible and measured. Unlike the absurd lengths the media and government lead us to believe we had to go to.

BlowDryRat · 06/06/2023 19:52

C/D. I followed everything to the letter last time (never snitched on anyone though!) but I'm completely disillusioned and would never put myself or my family through that again. I wrote and told my MP that too when all the party stuff came out.

StormShadow · 06/06/2023 19:43

It is also likely that if it hadn't been for the timing, ie it would have fucked Christmas at short notice for the second year in a row, we would have had a 2 week lockdown or at least strengthening of restrictions when the Omicron variant emerged late in 2021 but it wasn't known straight away how it would spread and affect people.

I doubt we'd have had another lockdown after the 2021 one ended at any time, because they have to be paid for and there needs to be a reason that persuades the public.

It's true that the general public were particularly unwilling to adhere to restrictions due to it being Christmas, which made them functionally impossible. You're not wrong there. But I can't see how the government would've been willing to fund one if it had all happened a month later and the decision was being made in January 2022. The downsides of restrictions were also being discussed much more by then, and the Overton window had moved. The ICO forcing the government to publish the equality impact information in December 2021 was a big reason for that, I think. And the start of the Partygate revelations. But there's just a limit to how long people can be expected to buy into restrictions.

funnelfan · 06/06/2023 19:39

Somewhere between B and C depending who was in government, how credible they were and what we were being asked to do. DH and I would find some way of being able to visit our respective elderly mums, we wouldn’t leave them without visits again.

it is quite depressing though how many people have regressed on things like hand washing. It’s really simple basic stuff like that that improves everyone’s health.

ladyofshertonabbas · 06/06/2023 19:31

D

ContinuousProcrastination · 06/06/2023 19:30

If the profile of the illness was like covid (where the majority of deaths affected the elderly) then C. I'd have continued to take extra precautions around my older parents like mask wearing, testing etc to reduce their risk, and would respect if there were social measures put in place to protect them such as a special shopping period eg 10 -12 where masks & distancing were required.

I'd happily be vaccinated.

I would not:

  • keep well children at home or out of school
  • stay off work unless ill myself
  • test constantly unless symptomatic
  • distance from healthy friends/family
BarbaraofSeville · 06/06/2023 19:30

Firstly I’d think about it in terms of public health not government (yes they were a bunch of lying selfish devious bastards but that doesn’t change the fact that advice and direction should come from health experts first - so SAGE should be independent like the BoE or something)

Advice and direction is given from the health experts. As well as being published by the NHS and public health bodies, the advice is given to the Government, who have the final say on policy.

It is quite likely when there were the long delays while the entire country was on the edge of their seats waiting for a 5/6/7 pm announcement that eventually came at 8 pm (I remember a couple of occasions like this) that there were arguments going on behind the scenes because BJ and senior cabinet ministers weren't implementing policy as advised by Chris Whitty etc.

It is also likely that if it hadn't been for the timing, ie it would have fucked Christmas at short notice for the second year in a row, we would have had a 2 week lockdown or at least strengthening of restrictions when the Omicron variant emerged late in 2021 but it wasn't known straight away how it would spread and affect people.

DemBonesDemBones · 06/06/2023 19:21

Covid legit almost killed me...so I should say A but honestly, my 6 year old is still non verbal and the waiting time for S&L was and remains so long and intervention during lockdown was non existent. Teenagers at my Daughter's school have zero social skills and there are massive problems with violence that friends in other parts of the UK say is the same at their schools. Kids gave up way too much, it would be difficult to agree to it again.

StormShadow · 06/06/2023 19:20

Firstly I’d think about it in terms of public health not government (yes they were a bunch of lying selfish devious bastards but that doesn’t change the fact that advice and direction should come from health experts first - so SAGE should be independent like the BoE or something).

@MotherOfCatBoy I thought your post was generally well stated and useful, but thought this bit needed more discussion. Because the process of choosing which expertise we want on bodies like SAGE is political, so is what they advise on and so is the question of what we do with their direction. Someone has to decide how to weigh up the views of the epidemiologist against those of the child psychologist, the obesity experts etc. I can't see how that could be anything other than the business of government, either directly or indirectly.

Nextlevelnonsense · 06/06/2023 19:20

D

MsJuniper · 06/06/2023 19:17

B (I followed quite strictly)