Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Poll) If a new disease with a similar fatality rate to pre-vaccination COVID appeared again…

433 replies

user1477391263 · 06/06/2023 12:58

And the government started to issue instructions about rules, hand washing, masks, social distancing, not meeting up with people, and the like, similarly to what happened in 2020-21….

What would your response be?

A: I would follow the rules more strictly than I did last time (because WFH has made it easier OR because the deaths from COVID make me feel we should have been stricter last time).

B: I would follow the rules about as strictly as I did last time, for the most part.

C: I would follow some rules or follow most rules to an extent, but would be significantly less “strict” about this than I was during COVID.

D: I would be much, much less strict or would completely ignore most rules/instructions, insofaras I was able to disregard them.

I’m just trying to work out whether the COVID experience and aftermath has shifted the Overton window and made people more open to the idea of following rules etc. to contain infectious diseases, OR alternatively whether people have grown a bit more blasé about diseases, disillusioned about governments or concerned about negative aftermaths of pandemic control measures.

For what it’s worth, I’d be a C (although I was never very strict first time round either to be honest).

And MNHQ, can we please get a proper poll selection option that goes beyond YABU/YANBU options?

OP posts:
Greentree1 · 07/06/2023 15:33

B. I followed the sensible rules, handwashing and sanitising, keeping a sensible distance from people, wearing a mask in confined spaces. We are lucky and have a large garden so lock down didn't effect us too much, but I could hear people out chatting on the common land behind us (obviously disobeying the rules but to my mind not doing anything dangerous), I think some of the rules on going out weren't necessary if you were following the common sense stuff. I don't know what I would have done if I couldn't visit someone dying in hospital.

It also depends if you were/would be at high risk or if members of your family were/would be at high risk. We were at moderately high risk from Covid for age and health issues. Another disease might be more dangerous for young children, which would change things a lot.

Brideintheheadlights · 07/06/2023 15:21

D without doubt.

Crobbyhaft · 07/06/2023 15:21

D

thing47 · 07/06/2023 15:19

There were changes though but always with accusation of ‘u turn’ from media and public. This was seen to be a failing.

You're right. What the politicians should have said early on is something along the lines of 'we still don't know exactly what we're dealing with here, so the scientific advice is constantly changing and evolving and our policies may have to change along with it'. But when has a politician ever said something like that?!!

brieislife · 07/06/2023 15:06

B assuming the rules & risks were similar to last time.

edenhills · 07/06/2023 15:06

B

SunnyEgg · 07/06/2023 15:04

thing47 · 07/06/2023 15:01

Part of the problem is that politicians and governments don't deal in nuance, they want attention-grabbing headlines and media soundbites. Science doesn't work in this way. Leaving aside some of the outrageous forecasting that went on, in general scientists gave the best possible advice based on the evidence available at the time; when the evidence evolved or shifted, so the advice changed. Politicians like to adopt a stance and then double-down on it when questioned, which is the exact opposite of how scientific discovery works.

So I would still be listening to scientific advice in the event of another pandemic, I would just try to get it straight from the horse's mouth rather than filtered through politicians who I do not trust and may – as we have since seen – have an agenda of their own.

There were changes though but always with accusation of ‘u turn’ from media and public. This was seen to be a failing.

I agree science evolves etc though

Also as even Whitty said his contribution was within remit but the decisions made were outside of it and political

Although the omicron line wasn’t great and cost a fair whack in the end

thing47 · 07/06/2023 15:01

Part of the problem is that politicians and governments don't deal in nuance, they want attention-grabbing headlines and media soundbites. Science doesn't work in this way. Leaving aside some of the outrageous forecasting that went on, in general scientists gave the best possible advice based on the evidence available at the time; when the evidence evolved or shifted, so the advice changed. Politicians like to adopt a stance and then double-down on it when questioned, which is the exact opposite of how scientific discovery works.

So I would still be listening to scientific advice in the event of another pandemic, I would just try to get it straight from the horse's mouth rather than filtered through politicians who I do not trust and may – as we have since seen – have an agenda of their own.

StormShadow · 07/06/2023 14:57

PortUmber · 07/06/2023 14:10

@StormShadow

I agree, it is about trust. But no organisation or government is ever going to be 100% honest, truthful and right 100% of the time.

It’s about likelihood. So if most governments, organisations, bodies across the world think this will probably be the best course of action then I would follow that.

The bodies that advocated no lockdown, no masks, no vaccines at the time of the pandemic : what guarantee was there that these bodies were ‘better’, more trustworthy, less biased, better researched, better scrutinised?

I believe you if you say you would, but you're going a step further when you say other people are in the wrong for disagreeing and seeing no reason to have the level of trust you do.

After all, there was no proper contemporary scrutiny of the actions much of the world took in early 2020, and in some cases (like ours) it went against our existing pandemic planning. What guarantee would the ordinary person have that, say, the WHO wouldn't be subjected to significant political pressure as they were from China again? Pandemic management is innately political.

And the bit about other bodies is sort of the other half of my point. I agree there aren't any such guarantees for them either, so wouldn't expect them to be accorded any more legitimacy by the general public than, say, the WHO. There's a vacuum in that space. For completely valid and understandable reasons. And it's not immediately obvious at this point if and how it's going to be filled.

foodledoff · 07/06/2023 14:38

D

PortUmber · 07/06/2023 14:34

@Hbh17

Far less sentimental about death? When it’s yourself or a loved one who is in pain and dire need of hospital treatment and can’t access basic humane care because their hospital is too overwhelmed and short staffed…

Hbh17 · 07/06/2023 14:14

D.
We knew from early on last time that the rules were unnecessary, ridiculous and damaging.
We also need to be far less sentimental about death, coz it happens to all of us and we just have to take our chances and accept it when it happens.

LifeExperience · 07/06/2023 14:11

D

PortUmber · 07/06/2023 14:10

@StormShadow

I agree, it is about trust. But no organisation or government is ever going to be 100% honest, truthful and right 100% of the time.

It’s about likelihood. So if most governments, organisations, bodies across the world think this will probably be the best course of action then I would follow that.

The bodies that advocated no lockdown, no masks, no vaccines at the time of the pandemic : what guarantee was there that these bodies were ‘better’, more trustworthy, less biased, better researched, better scrutinised?

KeyWorker · 07/06/2023 09:51

A mixture of C & D.

StormShadow · 07/06/2023 09:49

DisquietintheRanks · 07/06/2023 09:34

Ime, whatever people say now, people's behaviour will depend very much on who's dying and how visible the disease is in their communities.

If we get a disease like Spanish flu where suddenly all the young are dying I can't see the population at large being that chill.

All it took was the death of one pregnant school mum in my community during the swine flu epidemic and suddenly the queues for vaccination were round the block.

People definitely wouldn't be chill in that situation, no. But if anything, that potentially makes it less likely that there'd be sufficient trust in the authorities for people to adhere to restrictions. Fear doesn't necessarily translate into trust. I know it did last time, but it isn't a given.

I'd also distinguish willingness to be vaccinated from willingness to adhere to lockdowns. Given that most people during covid were vaccinated and a significant number will have broken the rules at least sometimes, ticking both boxes will be common enough.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 07/06/2023 09:41

D.
DH and I are both in ‘vulnerable’ groups. We utterly repudiated the idea that the young and fit should have their lives ruined for some notional benefit for us. We could predict the financial and emotional ruin that masking, lockdown and all the rest of the no…..sense would inevitably entail .

not in my name.

MrsArchchancellorRidcully · 07/06/2023 09:36

D 100%

No way would I waste my time again like that.

DisquietintheRanks · 07/06/2023 09:34

Ime, whatever people say now, people's behaviour will depend very much on who's dying and how visible the disease is in their communities.

If we get a disease like Spanish flu where suddenly all the young are dying I can't see the population at large being that chill.

All it took was the death of one pregnant school mum in my community during the swine flu epidemic and suddenly the queues for vaccination were round the block.

Beveren · 07/06/2023 09:24

B. It would be ridiculous not to.

StormShadow · 07/06/2023 08:34

bluetongue · 07/06/2023 07:49

Somewhere between C and D. I started ignoring many of the mandates before they were removed but I did get some pretty dirty looks for going maskless.

Obviously it would also depend how strictly it was all policed. Here in Australia we had some people arrested for refusing to wear a mask outside when asked or for attending protests. I’m not willing to get a criminal record.

Yeah, I'd assume most people are talking about going about their business quietly rather than trying to draw attention to it or protesting. I may be wrong, but that's how it worked for me and the people around me last time. None of us went near a protest and I think we all did masks when that was the law too. I expect the Ds would look like reciprocal childcare for friends and family, kids birthday parties in houses, having your mum or your mate round for a brew, playdates etc.

bluetongue · 07/06/2023 07:49

Somewhere between C and D. I started ignoring many of the mandates before they were removed but I did get some pretty dirty looks for going maskless.

Obviously it would also depend how strictly it was all policed. Here in Australia we had some people arrested for refusing to wear a mask outside when asked or for attending protests. I’m not willing to get a criminal record.

Harebrain · 07/06/2023 07:42

It’s a D for me!

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 07/06/2023 07:35

E - I would follow the advice of the actual scientists / medical experts. As I did in 2020.

montysma1 · 07/06/2023 07:30

B

Swipe left for the next trending thread