Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

(Poll) If a new disease with a similar fatality rate to pre-vaccination COVID appeared again…

433 replies

user1477391263 · 06/06/2023 12:58

And the government started to issue instructions about rules, hand washing, masks, social distancing, not meeting up with people, and the like, similarly to what happened in 2020-21….

What would your response be?

A: I would follow the rules more strictly than I did last time (because WFH has made it easier OR because the deaths from COVID make me feel we should have been stricter last time).

B: I would follow the rules about as strictly as I did last time, for the most part.

C: I would follow some rules or follow most rules to an extent, but would be significantly less “strict” about this than I was during COVID.

D: I would be much, much less strict or would completely ignore most rules/instructions, insofaras I was able to disregard them.

I’m just trying to work out whether the COVID experience and aftermath has shifted the Overton window and made people more open to the idea of following rules etc. to contain infectious diseases, OR alternatively whether people have grown a bit more blasé about diseases, disillusioned about governments or concerned about negative aftermaths of pandemic control measures.

For what it’s worth, I’d be a C (although I was never very strict first time round either to be honest).

And MNHQ, can we please get a proper poll selection option that goes beyond YABU/YANBU options?

OP posts:
Vellincharm · 06/06/2023 15:21

B

Alittlenonsensenowandthen · 06/06/2023 15:20

D. My feelings are that Boris would've voted d as well which is why he did such a bad job sticking t rules (not excusing his behaviour but I think it was revealing).
The long term impact financially, emotionally and mentally on this country, not to mention other health issues ignored doesn't justify the decision.

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/06/2023 15:18

LongTermLurker · 06/06/2023 14:51

We obeyed the rules at the time and the consequences for my family were awful. I'm particular, one of my kids' mental health plummeted. It was terrifying, and entirely a result of lockdowns.

If I had to relive the ordeal, I'd ignore as many of the rules as possible in an attempt to keep some sort of normality for my DC. I don't see it as selfish, but as self-protective. I see my previous behaviour as unhealthily self-sacrificing.

My post very specifically talks about people deliberately being in contact with my very vulnerable child knowing they/their child has CP/covid/d&v.

That is selfish.

Some parents will justify that as protecting their child (one parent who concealed that 3 of their 4 children had chicken pox because their DD “really really wanted” to spend time with one of mine on her birthday - that’s the type of selfishness I’m referencing dealing with now) - which in some ways is understandable, but my annoyance that people around us no longer have basic manners with a heads up on illness is also understandable.

Some contact with ill people is inevitable. I had to take the gamble of my older children returning to school for their sakes for example.

but people are more selfish specifically now and that has made the world more dangerous for vulnerable people.

TheKeatingFive · 06/06/2023 15:17

But let’s say it was a virus like Ebola where the death rate is almost 100% and the spread is high, I think it’s likely that people would think differently.

Yes, but the whole situation would be different then. Would essential workers be happy to put themselves at considerable risk to keep the show on the road for others?

Violasaremyfavourite · 06/06/2023 15:15

B but not UK and had a far stricter lock down.

FigTreeInEurope · 06/06/2023 15:14

A - But only if people were turning into actual brain eating zombies, other wise D, and I might have a party or two in my office/free personal residence, conduct an affair, and drive to a castle for a day out.

JenniferBooth · 06/06/2023 15:12

D.

And my DH is disabled with COPD But neither he (nor I) liked him being used as emotional blackmail to get others to comply with restrictions when ppl dont give a fuck about him the rest of the time. How others couldnt see this stuns me It really does. And for those who ask what would we do if a new virus targeted children go back and read @TheKeatingFive post.

I suspect they would try and force the child free by choice to keep the country running but i think this would be met with an outcry because they already do much to accomodate other peoples kids. Read any thread about bank holiday/Christmas working.

And the fact that we became a nation of scruffs while celebs were allowed to get their hair done AND get glammed up on Strictly and elsewhere .......the hypocrisy was off the charts. So they can fuck right off were this to happen again.

Cockawoes · 06/06/2023 15:11

D i wasn't strict last time but the damage to my teens was tough. No way would I follow a single rule. Absolutely not.

MayThe4th · 06/06/2023 15:10

This is assuming though that the virus was exactly the same as COVID. Because it would be easy to say what you would do when you have an idea of what the outcome might be.

But let’s say it was a virus like Ebola where the death rate is almost 100% and the spread is high, I think it’s likely that people would think differently.

Lidlpopdrinker · 06/06/2023 15:08

Seasonofthewitch83 · 06/06/2023 14:56

Would your answer change if a new virus targeted children?

Yes of course, because children haven’t already had their lives, but they wouldn’t do the same for kids because kids can’t vote.

AlyssumandHelianthus · 06/06/2023 15:06

C/D
Depending on who it most highly impacted, I'd be more likely to be strict if it disproportionately affected kids. If it was COVID exactly, I'd not be happy to follow the same rules again and would actively protest about schools and unis shutting.

Spendonsend · 06/06/2023 15:03

I dont know.

In the last round i worked in an infant school, which was open and was in fact a hub bringing in other children from other schools so it was basically the same as before lockdown. I was with my colleagues and loads of kids plus I saw lots of parents too. I didnt wear a mask and didnt get a vaccine until it was my turn as it were.

Id have seen more of family, but they were all old/vulnerable so its not just my decision. They might still choose not to meet me whatever i thought.

If the impact on children was same as covid i would definitely expect parks to be open and full of children playing.

peachypudding · 06/06/2023 14:59

D

HelpMeGetThrough · 06/06/2023 14:57

E. Tell them to fuck off.

Useruser1 · 06/06/2023 14:57

D!

Seasonofthewitch83 · 06/06/2023 14:56

Lidlpopdrinker · 06/06/2023 14:49

D, and I didn’t exactly observe the rules last time. There’s no way I’m sacrificing any more of my life for the sake of people who have already had theirs.

Would your answer change if a new virus targeted children?

EddieVeddersfoxymop · 06/06/2023 14:55

Another D here. I followed the rules more or less to the letter and wouldn't again. The damage to my mental health still hasn't healed and I'm not sure it will. Not for me, sorry.

Seasonofthewitch83 · 06/06/2023 14:55

awimbawaaay · 06/06/2023 14:36

I think my answer would apply the same. Protect the vulnerable at all costs and "the rest" go above and beyond to do so. So if that meant appealing to those who'd retired to go back out on a volunteer basis and keep the country running so the young could be safer etc, then yes.

What we had in the summer-autumn of 2020 (in Scotland anyway) was playparks chained up and kids who hadn't set foot in schools since early March, WHILE THE BINGO HALLS WERE OPEN AND FULL OF PENSIONERS.

It was just absolute madness and I will never forgive or forget what they did to children.

I think one of the largest drivers was how nonsensical the rules actually were, its no wonder people just gave up as it was hard to find the fairness or common sense. It was easier during lockdown 1 as it was a largely blanket effect. It was the subsequent lockdowns that made the whole thing seem like a farce.

I like to think I would still obey rules that made sense - and I say that as someone who gave birth during lockdown 1 and have some horrible PTSD because of it. Ultimately I felt I had a duty to protect the vulnerable as well as ease the burden on the NHS.

When people say that future lockdowns we should just protect the vulnerable but the healthy carry on living, no one ever explains what that entails - locking them away.

Porkandbeans1 · 06/06/2023 14:55

I followed the rules to a certain extent during covid. I think that a lockdown was the correct response until we gathered more data. After that I feel it was over the top for the majority. I do like that masks are more acceptable now. I like to wear one when I have a cold and this has always been acceptable and almost expected in Asia, but when we are in the UK people found it strange.

I would probably follow the rules again. The only thing we really missed was travelling and that's not an easy rule to break.

PinkiOcelot · 06/06/2023 14:54

D
The government didn’t follow their own rules so why should I?

thing47 · 06/06/2023 14:53

I'm a C like you @user1477391263, broadly speaking, but I do have the advantage of living with an expert in infectious diseases.

So I know, for example, that it's almost impossible to catch Covid outside – if your hypothetical new pandemic had the same profile I wouldn't be restricting myself from going outside at all. I also think there is considerable evidence to suggest that locking down schools and care homes was disproportionate and I wouldn't be in favour of that recurring.

Dymaxion · 06/06/2023 14:51

B whilst at work, basically would do what I was told.

C at home.

LongTermLurker · 06/06/2023 14:51

YetMoreNewBeginnings · 06/06/2023 14:15

Most people will be D.

Many people now don’t even give families like mine (my DD is extremely vulnerable and we’ve had to avoid illnesses as much as possible since before covid) as much consideration with bugs, coughs and colds as they did pre-covid because “life must go on”.

There’s a selfishness (I tried to find a different word) now that there wasn’t before. People’s lives were interrupted and now they’ll do whatever.

Folks have knowingly allowed their child to be around my child (even though we’re the one that always misses the event if someone flags up - we don’t expect others to stay away other than from our home) with chicken pox, d&v and colds multiple times since people got angry about covid. They never, ever did that before.

The lockdown resentments have actually made life more dangerous for vulnerable people now imo.

We obeyed the rules at the time and the consequences for my family were awful. I'm particular, one of my kids' mental health plummeted. It was terrifying, and entirely a result of lockdowns.

If I had to relive the ordeal, I'd ignore as many of the rules as possible in an attempt to keep some sort of normality for my DC. I don't see it as selfish, but as self-protective. I see my previous behaviour as unhealthily self-sacrificing.

Lidlpopdrinker · 06/06/2023 14:49

D, and I didn’t exactly observe the rules last time. There’s no way I’m sacrificing any more of my life for the sake of people who have already had theirs.

Forshameandyegads · 06/06/2023 14:48

B