Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I just don’t seem to fit in?

67 replies

Tigerintheundergrowth · 06/06/2023 10:55

I think I’m probably going to get flamed for this post as it’ll no doubt come across as judgy, it’s not how I mean it to be but i’m trying to be as pragmatic as possible and sometimes that involves saying it as you see it.

I’ll preface this by saying I am lucky in that I do have about 7 friends that I consider pretty close friends and see regularly (though they’re all separate) so I do have friends, but I struggle to make new ones nowadays.

I find where I live women seem to be two types (generalisation I know but genuinely they really do seem to be)

Type A have lived here their whole lives, (no judgement, so have I apart from a 5 year stint at uni and away for a job, I moved back in my early 20’s) all the family lives within 0.5 mile radius and they all have huge families that have all lived here for generations (my family do live quite close but only my nuclear family, all my extended family live in different parts of the country) they didn’t go to uni etc so all their friends are from high school and they still hang around in the huge groups that they hung around in in high school. (All of my high school friends have moved away, I’m genuinely really sad about this, but it is what it is) Some of them I guess could be considered a bit ‘rough’ around the edges, I know a few were the school bullies for example. They’re married to typically ‘blokey blokes’ that love football, gettin’ on the beers etc.

These people already have their ‘tribe’ and I can just tell they see me as a bit too well spoken as I don’t have a strong local accent (I grew up here too but don’t have the accent, well, not as strong as theirs anyway. I’m absolutely not posh at all, just don’t have a strong, local accent) I’m married to a slightly serious, bookish professional (although he does really enjoy socialising and loves a night out too!) who I know probably wouldn’t gel with their DH’s.

These women are quite glam, love getting dressed up and going on nights out, holidays together etc and I’m definitely in THAT category, I love doing the above.

Type B bake, do crafts, won’t have more than 1 glass of wine because they’re a ‘mum’ now and definitely give you a side eye if you do, don’t really talk about much other than their children. Have no time for any talk of hair or make up etc. I’ve known some of these for ages and they were always like the above, even when we were 18, they never went on nights out or anything like that. They were born ‘old’ for want of a better expression 😳 Or they’re all of the above and also really academic and a bit snooty with it I guess. They’re okay with me because I’m married to a professional 🙄but they’re just not my type.

I just don’t quite ‘fit’ because I’m considered either too ‘posh’ and ‘bookish’ or whatever by one type and not ‘posh’ (for want of a better word) enough for another type.

Sometimes I wonder where all the women like me are? I like to talk about hair and make up, celebrities and trashy tv, but also, sometimes like to talk about what’s going on in the world, politics etc. I love going for lunch or a walk with friends, but equally love getting dolled up and having a wine or 5. I love my DC but they’re not my whole life, I don’t want to sit and talk endlessly about them.

I’m the most unremarkable person ever, so why can’t I find anyone else on a similar wavelength? Whenever I meet new people I always take them at face value and don’t try and pigeon hole them, but inevitably, around here they do seem to just fall into these two types.

Has anyone else experienced similar? 😳

OP posts:
Dontlikeveg · 06/06/2023 15:30

@ComtesseDeSpairbeautiful post full of wisdom, thank you

I too, enjoyed that post....

heartsinvisiblefury · 06/06/2023 13:57

I'm the same as you OP!

amluuui · 06/06/2023 13:49

@ComtesseDeSpair beautiful post full of wisdom, thank you

lllllllllll · 06/06/2023 13:49

And this is why I'm glad I live in London. This sort of situation simply isn't an issue here.

OriginalUsername2 · 06/06/2023 13:35

It’s confusing reading this because you do have friends! How many do you need / want? Not being snarky at all, I just don’t know how people navigate so many and fit them in to daily life.

originalglazedsingle · 06/06/2023 13:20

Settin · 06/06/2023 13:15

Wonder what an average man might think reading this thread - Type A, Type B, queen bee, etc 😂

Blokes just chat to other blokes. Job done. I have an adult son (NT and sporty, to be fair) and was gobsmacked seeing how easy it was for him to make friends growing up. Literally zero drama, no "groups" or "types", the boys all just got on. Now they're all easy-going mates as adults. Such a contrast to my own experience. Why is it so different for girls and women?!

I do understand OP. I'd just talk to anyone and everyone and take up new hobbies, and see how you get on. It's great that you have some fab existing friends. Maybe focus on quality, not quantity?

And watch Motherland for a laugh!

very true.

Also true that the ones complaining about "drama" and the bitchy school mums ARE the drama. Most people just get on with their lives 😂

Settin · 06/06/2023 13:15

Wonder what an average man might think reading this thread - Type A, Type B, queen bee, etc 😂

Blokes just chat to other blokes. Job done. I have an adult son (NT and sporty, to be fair) and was gobsmacked seeing how easy it was for him to make friends growing up. Literally zero drama, no "groups" or "types", the boys all just got on. Now they're all easy-going mates as adults. Such a contrast to my own experience. Why is it so different for girls and women?!

I do understand OP. I'd just talk to anyone and everyone and take up new hobbies, and see how you get on. It's great that you have some fab existing friends. Maybe focus on quality, not quantity?

And watch Motherland for a laugh!

Vinvertebrate · 06/06/2023 13:04

You sound like me OP. Seven friends is impressive! I caused a diplomatic incident at DS' school by suggesting on Whatsapp that a fellow mum "drop and run" on a playdate at mine. (I even did a winky face!) She spluttered a lot and a couple of other mums "had a word" because I'd embarrassed her. She'd have a coronary if she heard how my bestie and I speak to each other...

crazeekat · 06/06/2023 12:59

Tigerintheundergrowth · 06/06/2023 12:45

And to the posters saying I’m judgy and I should just have different friends for different things and not pigeon hole people, I get it, I totally agree and therefore am ‘acquaintances’ with these two different types of women.

The type A I would like to be ‘friends’ with but they just don’t take to me, I don’t know why. It quite probably is me let’s face it but they’ll only keep me as an acquaintance; I think it’s mostly because they already have large friendships groups and families and they just don’t need to add me into that.

The type B- I’m happy to just keep them as acquaintances as I just don’t enjoy their company or conversation enough to have them as friends. But I do meet up with them (mainly due to the DC) occasionally for lunch/ a coffee, so it’s not like I shun them, it’s just after years of having them as acquaintances, it’s never moved to friendships as we just don’t gel and tbh, I know they do judge me because I wear a bit of make up and like nights out.

i have not picked you up as being bitchy or judgy at all, u have explained the situation you are in.
as i said before dont fake anything. if people don't take to you that's totally fine. but don't waste your time also doing things with groups you see are just acquaintances now. and as for the judgy make up friend. please wear more make up next time you see her and give her something more to talk about. just be u and enjoy life.

Kanaloa · 06/06/2023 12:56

It kind of sounds like you judge other people by sight and then assume that they do the same to you. I try to reserve judgement and it’s a huge priority of mine not to put my preconceptions onto other people. So unless somebody said to me ‘I don’t like you because you went to uni and you’re so posh and have a bookish husband’ it would never occur to me to think that they thought that. I try not to decide what other people think.

Because from your op it comes across more like you’ve cast them in the role of the ‘rough’ working class girl who didn’t go to uni and married a working class man, then you’ve viewed them through that lens and decided they must be intimidated by you and your well educated husband. When in fact it could be that they’ve picked up on your judgement of them and that’s why they’re more reserved.

What are the chances that everyone else is either ‘rough’ or boring, and you’re just the main character and are much more special and interesting? Isn’t it much more likely that if you spoke to and made the effort with all these people, at least a few of them would be richly interesting and multi layered people just like you?

originalglazedsingle · 06/06/2023 12:54

Tigerintheundergrowth · 06/06/2023 12:47

I actually really don’t care whether people wear make up or not, it’s certainly not a criteria needed for me to be ‘friends’ with someone. I’d say 2 of 7 women that are my closest friends never wear a jot of make up. The fact is they don’t judge me for doing so and I have been judged for it. (And for context I only ever wear light make up, conceal or under my eyes, slick or mascara and a bit of bronzer so I’m hardly trowling it on to go on the nursery run)

Don't kid yourself, I guarantee you that most people don't even notice if you wear genuinely "light make-up" and a bit of mascara.

If it's true a group is judging you and bitching about you, it's not about a touch of tinted vaseline. I have no idea if they do bitch and why they would, but I am sure it's not just about light make-up, because again, most people can't see it!

Tigerintheundergrowth · 06/06/2023 12:47

originalglazedsingle · 06/06/2023 12:40

I think the issue is when you start being bitchy about the ones who don't 😂
Do you feel so insecure you need to put other people down?

I do have a make-up addiction as it happens, but who has time to think about what others put on their face or not? Unless someone puts their make-up in public transport, then it's ok to judge.

I actually really don’t care whether people wear make up or not, it’s certainly not a criteria needed for me to be ‘friends’ with someone. I’d say 2 of 7 women that are my closest friends never wear a jot of make up. The fact is they don’t judge me for doing so and I have been judged for it. (And for context I only ever wear light make up, conceal or under my eyes, slick or mascara and a bit of bronzer so I’m hardly trowling it on to go on the nursery run)

OP posts:
Tigerintheundergrowth · 06/06/2023 12:45

And to the posters saying I’m judgy and I should just have different friends for different things and not pigeon hole people, I get it, I totally agree and therefore am ‘acquaintances’ with these two different types of women.

The type A I would like to be ‘friends’ with but they just don’t take to me, I don’t know why. It quite probably is me let’s face it but they’ll only keep me as an acquaintance; I think it’s mostly because they already have large friendships groups and families and they just don’t need to add me into that.

The type B- I’m happy to just keep them as acquaintances as I just don’t enjoy their company or conversation enough to have them as friends. But I do meet up with them (mainly due to the DC) occasionally for lunch/ a coffee, so it’s not like I shun them, it’s just after years of having them as acquaintances, it’s never moved to friendships as we just don’t gel and tbh, I know they do judge me because I wear a bit of make up and like nights out.

OP posts:
weirdas · 06/06/2023 12:45

You sound like me. I have my old friends who I grew up with but I don't have much in common with them anymore. I have my mum group who are lovely but are more coffee than cocktail

originalglazedsingle · 06/06/2023 12:40

Tigerintheundergrowth · 06/06/2023 12:36

Oh the irony when your bitchy, judgy post was meant to do exactly that.

There is nothing wrong with putting on a bit of make up in the mornings, unless you trowl it on, a bit of light make up literally takes a few minutes and if it makes you feel better about yourself and gives you more confidence to go about your day then great, I don’t see the issue.

I think the issue is when you start being bitchy about the ones who don't 😂
Do you feel so insecure you need to put other people down?

I do have a make-up addiction as it happens, but who has time to think about what others put on their face or not? Unless someone puts their make-up in public transport, then it's ok to judge.

Tigerintheundergrowth · 06/06/2023 12:39

MaryJean87 · 06/06/2023 11:23

I think people are all different once you get to know them and it's not good to generalise people. I kind of get it though, I feel like a lot of my " mum" acquaintances at the school are very different to me. One of them told me she's far too busy to put make up on for the school run and doesn't see the point in it, when I know she only said ir

I get what you mean.

I go to a baby and toddler group most weeks and about a month ago I walked in and the ‘queen bee’ of the group shouted ‘oh here’s Tiger coming in looking all glamorous AGAIN and making us all feel like shit AGAIN’ with a tinkly laugh. There was definitely an edge to it.

For context I was wearing a jumper, slim fit mom jeans and trainers. I’d brushed my hair and had put on some mascara and tinted Vaseline on my lips as they were dry. Presentable yes, glamorous? No.

OP posts:
Tigerintheundergrowth · 06/06/2023 12:36

SunnySaturdayMorning · 06/06/2023 11:51

I very much doubt they’re saying it expressly to make you feel bad.

That sounds like you’re projecting because of how you feel about the amount of time you waste putting on your war paint.

Oh the irony when your bitchy, judgy post was meant to do exactly that.

There is nothing wrong with putting on a bit of make up in the mornings, unless you trowl it on, a bit of light make up literally takes a few minutes and if it makes you feel better about yourself and gives you more confidence to go about your day then great, I don’t see the issue.

OP posts:
Tigerintheundergrowth · 06/06/2023 12:34

Thanks for the responses, I’m so relieved to realise I’m not alone in feeling like this! Since having DC I’ve made two ‘mum friends’ and they’re so like me, we have the best time, I could literally talk to them all day, we’re just so similar, making friends with them was relatively easy, there wasn’t months and months of polite small talk, we just kind of ‘got each other’ from a few meets. It helps that I have a hobby in common with one of them, but even without that, we’re just similar people.

So yeh, it’s made me realise that I just don’t meet similar people all that often, which is ridiculous as like I said, I’m the most ‘normal’ vanilla person really, average intelligence etc. I just like to have FUN and I like fun people that are up for a laugh and don’t take themselves too seriously. Unfortunately, round here that often means druggy ‘rough’ types. Whereas I just want some likeminded women who like a gossip and a laugh and enjoy a few cocktails!

Maybe we should all meet up 😂 I’m from the east of England.

OP posts:
YinYogi · 06/06/2023 12:33

Why do you have to be friends with people exactly like you? I find this strange and unrealistic.

originalglazedsingle · 06/06/2023 12:29

OP, you do sound extremely judgey to be honest, making it sound like no one is good enough for you.

You know it's ok to have different "friends": mum friends, with the focus on the children, "party friends" to get dolled up and go drinking with, "work friends" to have deep discussions about the world.

Of course, in an ideal world, you would have a group mixing all of YOUR interests. Think about it: many people might think you are too narrow minded yourself, and would write the same OP as you do, but about YOU. In real life, it's ok to have different priorities, different support network and freedom, and be at different stage of your life.

It also helps to be in a bigger city, with a wider range of people around you, and mix work with hobbies, school volunteering and studying. It's the best way to meet the most people and find the ones you click with the most, but it's also ok to have different people for different things, .When you are an adult, it's not all about having BFF and be clickey😂

NancyJoan · 06/06/2023 12:26

You sound very much like me, and most of my friends and colleagues. We are out there!

originalglazedsingle · 06/06/2023 12:24

ZacharinaQuack · 06/06/2023 11:29

@MaryJean87 that mum might be a total bitch, but it's also possible she said it to try and excuse the fact that she hadn't bothered, i.e. she was feeling like she might be judged for not making an effort. Obvs came out a bit wrong though if so!

exactly that.

ComtesseDeSpair · 06/06/2023 12:21

Generally, regardless of their background, their interests, and what they do for a living, people want to be friends with people who make them laugh, make them feel happy, make them feel good about themselves, who appear interested and who they can share nice experiences with. If you always keep that in mind and work on that basis, you’ll find socialising and making friends much easier. Join some local groups based around shared interests. Change the initial questions you ask the people you meet there away from the things you seem to be very focussed on, like class and professions and university education and local accents, and ask them the sorts of questions which help you actually get to know somebody’s personality and passions and what makes them tick. Why do they do this hobby, how did they get into it, what’s their biggest achievement in it, what else do they do for fun, can you have the details of that group because you like that too. Forget about all the superficial socially-constructed waffle which you think makes you too different to others. It just gets in the way of who you actually are.

I met a lot of my oldest and closest friends through Burning Man and the Burner community. At Burning Man, nobody gives a shit what you do for a living, what your parents did for a living, what you studied at university, whether you went to school at all, and there are so many different accents from so many different countries on playa that nobody has a clue whether you’re well-spoken or what social class you designate yourself as even if they cared, which they don’t. People care about what excites you, what makes you laugh, whether you’re a team player, how you treat others around you, that you’re a reliable friend and there for a hand or a hug. Because the whole concept is so ridiculous, and because when you’re riding a shonky dune bicycle through the desert whilst wearing a tutu to watch 500 adults dressed in rabbit ears be chased by 500 other adults dressed as carrots having had no sleep because you spent the night talking to strangers at a moving diner art car which somebody made back home in their garage in Ann Arbor, it really does strip you back to relating to people in the same open and as-you-are way you did when you were a kid.

If you’re always all inside your own head and thinking that you’re too different and that people view you as too clever, too well spoken, too posh and that this is why they don’t like you, and feeling that you don’t belong, then ultimately you’re going to be giving off this reserved, self-conscious vibe and it’s this vibe which doesn’t appeal to others. I very much doubt many people you meet actually think any of those things about you; but they probably do think that you’re probably going to be quite difficult to get friendly with, and that tends to make people not bother trying.

Something like trying an improvisational theatre or comedy course might bonkers at first, but the purpose is to work in a fun and supportive atmosphere with other people who also feel they struggle socially to learn and practice techniques and skills for building bravery, spontaneity and creativity for conversation and communication. It gives you really good groundwork to get out there and actually relate to people without being so damn self conscious about what you think they might be thinking about you.

crazeekat · 06/06/2023 12:17

wow u have just described me!!
the friends i am close to these days all have said when they first met me i was scary, had a resting bitch face and thot i was huffy and judgy. now they see me as the still the same hahaha but understand me and that im none of the sort really,
but i find it really hard
to make
friends and i guess im happy with the few close ones i really have.
i like having a drink or whatever, watch reality tv, but with converse about politics, animal rights , the nhs. etc etc, what some of my pals will say oh here's (me) on my high horse again and laugh.
so i find this, school mums......just not my cup of tea but i will talk if i have to. managed to get my oldest
child to p7 without making a single school friend, and my wee one is in p7 and not
spoke to anyone at all at school apart from last week had a party to go to and spoke to one mum, it's not that i'm unfriendly i just have that look that prob looks to others as unapproachable.
so my advise to u op is....just be u. don't fake it for anyone. talk to the snob pals about crap tv, and talk to ur old pals in ur snobbiest accent. if they are judgy, then really are they real pals to start with. i hope u find ur peopleSmile

ThimbleForWotsits · 06/06/2023 12:13

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at OP's request