Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Deliberate Damage to sofa-wwyd

194 replies

Dailywalk · 06/06/2023 09:11

Over the weekend my dd (6) had a friend over. They had scissors out as they were doing some craft project. I noticed today the sofa has been damaged . It’s been snipped in a couple of places. Tiny cuts but still they are there.
My daughter didn’t know anything about the cuts and I believe her. She’s the kind of kid that would cry and guilt would make her confess if it was her.
I don’t want to confront anyone but I suspect the friend has done this deliberately when she’s been on her own in the room. I’m fully expecting backlash that they shouldn’t have been left alone with scissors but they often get on with craft projects or games when I’m in another room. Wwyd?

OP posts:
NotQuiteHere · 06/06/2023 11:27

What do you want to do? To approach the parents of the girl and demand the refund for the damage? Ridiculous even if it was her who did that.

Forshameandyegads · 06/06/2023 11:26

Icanbringmyselfflowers · 06/06/2023 09:20

Oh op, you know you can’t say I left two 6 year olds alone with scissors sharp enough to cut my sofa and think your kid did it deliberately as I believe mine, cmon now.

Yeah this

SkankingWombat · 06/06/2023 11:23

Chimneypotblues · 06/06/2023 09:56

I'd be very careful in allocating blame. I lost a friend when I was around that age. We were playing at her house, she destroyed her mum's expensive makeup playing a game I refused to join in with, but I got the blame because she didn't believe her daughter would do such a thing!

I agree. My DD returned from a playdate recently and immediately burst into tears after coming through the door. Whilst there, her Golden Child 'best friend' had jumped on the sofa, knocked over a vase, and it had smashed. When the mum had asked what had happened, her 'friend' pointed straight at DD and said she had done it. DD was upset that she got the blame for something she hadn't done, but moreso that her supposed friend had been so brazen and quick to lie and save their own skin at her expense. DD is now much more cautious of them as a friend.

Twonewcats · 06/06/2023 11:23

Go to the other parent and say, "I left your child and my child alone with very sharp scissors. And, although I saw nothing at all, I believe that YOUR child DELIBERATELY cut my sofa, and I'd like you to reimburse me for repairs and/or a new sofa. My child doesn't lie, so I totally believe her when she says it wasn't her - and there is no way that this was an accident."
Good luck.

Bemyclementine · 06/06/2023 11:21

Aged 6 , did you know they had scissors on the living room? I'd have had them sitting at a table for crafting. I think you have to chalk this up to experience

Madamecastafiore · 06/06/2023 11:21

I wouldn't be so sure that's it's not both of them, little kids get very snip happy and it almost is a sort of compulsion, hair, clothes etc.

There have been numerous times in my very long parenting journey where I'd have sworn blind my child wouldn't do something, would fess up or I'd know immediacy whilst being completely shocked when it turned out it was one of my little buggers after all.

Just chalk it up to experience and get them to do craft at the kitchen table.

AuntieJune · 06/06/2023 11:19

Dailywalk · 06/06/2023 11:16

Get over yourself. Seriously? You’ve never left the room while your kid had a friend over?

Yeah I don't get the outrage about scissors!

I have a 6yo and a 4yo. If 6yo has a friend over, do I supervise them at all times and let 4yo off to wander unsupervised? Do I make him stay in the same place as 6yo and friend and annoy them? What if one of them asks for a drink, do I make them accompany me to the kitchen?

6 years old is old enough to know what to do and what not to do with scissors.

Viviennemary · 06/06/2023 11:17

I wouldn't ask the child back into my home if I thought it was deliberate. But otherwise I wouldnt do anything else.like speak to the paretnt.

AuntieJune · 06/06/2023 11:17

Jeepers, they're six - they can be left alone with children's scissors. Sharp pointy adult scissors are a different matter.

If they're tiny snips, a few stitches should be able to hold them together and stop the cuts from ripping further.

I would call the friend's parent and in a non-confrontational way, say there were cuts and your daughter says it was her friend, you don't know what happened and maybe on balance should have been watching them - not to ask for compensation or anything but so friend can learn that doing something like that doesn't just go away, her parent can see if her story is the same and tell her off.

This is why I get secondhand sofas!

budgiegirl · 06/06/2023 11:16

Wwyd?

Claim on insurance if you have it

Don't leave small children alone again with scissors sharp enough to cut sofa material

Chalk the incident up to experience.

Don't necessarily believe your DD when she says she knows nothing about it. ALL children will lie at times, it's incredibly naive to believe that yours won't. I never once caught my eldest son in a lie, but when I asked him when he was a teenager if he'd ever lied to me in the past, he said of course he had. He must have just been very good at it!

Dailywalk · 06/06/2023 11:16

SittingNextToIt · 06/06/2023 10:43

Oh the faux naivete.

What should I do if my sofa got ruined when I left two unsupervised 6 year olds on it with scissors, doing crafting?

Obviously, the only answer OP wanted to learn (That she had NO idea of) is: do not leave unsupervised 6 year olds with scissors doing crafting.

Surely OP wouldn't have understood this blatant fact herself.

That's the only reason she posted. Poor innocent OP. Just needed someone to tell her - don't leave kids with scissors on your sofa.

Get over yourself. Seriously? You’ve never left the room while your kid had a friend over?

OP posts:
Fandabedodgy · 06/06/2023 11:14

I would start a claim with insurance to get the sofa replaced.

Not let children of that age play with scissors unsupervised.

Not blame the other child. They were both in there with the scissors. Of course your child is going to deny it.

Zarataralara · 06/06/2023 11:13

Are the cuts suitable for invisible mending? Might save the sofa.

Dancingroses · 06/06/2023 11:10

Possibly they were using the sofa as a board to lean on and didn't know it was snipped. If it's on the arm or the seat it's highly possible.

WonderingWanda · 06/06/2023 11:07

A 6 yo with scissors did not maliciously damage your sofa. I recall cutting my own hair and hiding it behind a cushion at that age with no thought about why I was doing it or what would happen when my Mum found out.

Ring your home insurance and see if it's covered is the best you can do.

LadyLapsang · 06/06/2023 11:06

Have you got accidental cover on your home insurance?

lostinfusion · 06/06/2023 11:06

your probably quite lucky they both still had hair

RedToothBrush · 06/06/2023 11:03

I think your biggest problem here is the fact you don't actually know what happened because you weren't there.

It doesn't matter what happened because of that.

It leaves you in a position where if you say anything, you have to admit you left a couple of six year olds with scissors knowingly, without supervision, when you don't know whether the other child can be trusted with them.

You might be fine leaving your daughter with them, but add another child into the mix and you need to know them (and their parents) well enough before you do things like that.

If you confront the other parent, you are accusing their child of something you can't prove and is a significant attack on their child's personality. How do you think thats going to go down? Will the parents accept it or defend their child? How do you think thats going to play out for you and your daughter?

They could easily accuse you of not looking after their child properly.

The reality is its tough shit and you are going to have to suck it up or you are going to cause a major drama and probably not get anywhere with it.

Anaemiafog · 06/06/2023 11:00

Glad you took advice on board. You took on responsibility of the friend and let them have access to such a dangerous object. If I was the other parent I'd feel no responsibility even if it was my child because it was on your watch. In fact, I'd be angry you left them unattended with the scissors.

lostinfusion · 06/06/2023 11:00

I remember doing this with a rug when I was small - it wasn't deliberate at all it was me cutting on the floor & not realising I was also cutting into the rug

2bazookas · 06/06/2023 10:58

It’s a robust sofa not with flimsy fabric. There are three definite cuts and a fourth where the scissors haven’t got straight through. These are not accidental.

If either child laid paper or other material on the sofa so they could cut it out with pointy scissors they could easily have cut right through it into the sofa fabric without knowing or noticing.

That's almost certainly what happened.

EasternEcho · 06/06/2023 10:57

What I would do is thank my lucky stars that nothing far more serious happened while I left two young kids alone with scissors sharp enough to puncture a robust sofa. Like ending up in the A&E. Then I'd make sure I don't do it again.

CurlewKate · 06/06/2023 10:57

Why on earth do you think the other child did it deliberately??

MolkosTeenageAngst · 06/06/2023 10:56

As a child of a similar age I purposefully caused damage to a piece of furniture in my family home when I had a couple of friend around. When my parents confronted me I convincingly lied and said I didn’t know anything about it. To this day my parents believe it was caused by one of my friends.

You don’t know how this was caused. It may have been your daughter. It may have been her friend. It may have been purposeful. It may have been an accident.

This is a lesson to you. Children are careless. Children are impulsive. Children can be sneaky. Children can be liars. Children won’t always respect furniture. Children don’t think through the consequences of their actions. Six is still very young. Young children shouldn’t be left unsupervised with sharp scissors. Be thankful it was only a sofa they cut and not their hair!

Moving forward the only real course of action to take is no more crafting on the sofa, crafting should take place sat at a table where damage is less likely to occur accidentally or purposefully. Crafting which involves anything that could cause damage or standing such as scissors, glue, paint etc should only take place under adult supervision.

LateAF · 06/06/2023 10:54

SeulementUneFois · 06/06/2023 10:49

This OP.

Don't have that friend over again.

You can even explain it to your DD if she asks, that it's because when they were together the sofa got damaged.
Children learn best through natural consequences.

You're seriously suggesting punishing two unsupervised six year olds for behaving like two unsupervised 6 year olds?

I agree that people learn best through natural consequences - OP will learn that the natural consequence of leaving two 6 year olds unsupervised with scissors sharp enough to cut robust sofa fabric is that her sofa got damaged and she will need to repair it. And hopefully OP will learn to supervise playdates after experiencing this consequence.

OP should just be grateful that none of the kids gouged their eyes out or cut their fingers or skin - and that she was able to get her daughter's friend back home in one piece.