Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect HMRC not to pursue tax credit overpayments from 18 years ago

64 replies

saveforthat · 05/06/2023 20:06

My friend ( whose youngest child is 28) has received a letter from HMRC today saying she owes them £2000 from 2005. She actually remembers this and has kept some paperwork, they made a mistake and she has an apology letter from them from 2006 but who else keeps records so long? Has anyone else had to deal with something like this?

OP posts:
ThreeFeetTall · 05/06/2023 23:07

The six year thing doesn't apply.

I've never worked for HMRC but my assumption would be that it was some automated letter based on an old database of debtors. I would write back with a photocopy of the apology for mistake letter and say politely oh sorry it appears there is an error on your system and actually I don't owe any money, goodbye.

I know UC isn't great but tax credits were just crap for this sort of thing.

CombatBarbie · 05/06/2023 23:05

Moosethroat · 05/06/2023 22:09

I work for HMRC and yes they would expect it to be paid back. Tell your friend to call and set up a payment plan called Time To Pay if she cannot afford to clear in one go.

Why, they said it was an error.

humblemeep · 05/06/2023 22:52

I've had a letter from a debt collection agency about an alleged overpayment of tax credits. I know I've only claimed correctly, so I've written to HMRC requesting a breakdown of dates and amounts. No reply yet, in three weeks. If it dates back that far I doubt I'll still have the paperwork. The link above seems to say that if they don't chase it within six years, they can't ask for it, is that right?

Womencanlift · 05/06/2023 22:39

A very similar thing happened to a friend of mine a few months back. Wasn’t as long ago as 18 years but they did have the paperwork that confirmed that they didn’t owe anything. When they provided that this time round they got a “sorry our records are not updated, sorry for the inconvenience”

In their case they were told that records got so messed up during lockdown that they are revisiting old cases. Who knows if that’s true

Chchchchchangesss · 05/06/2023 22:39

HadalyEve · 05/06/2023 21:25

She knew since 2006 she owed HMRC £2k and did nothing?
Of course they are going to want to be paid back.

Imagine advertising so clearly that you didn't read the op. Embarrassing.

TheThinkingGoblin · 05/06/2023 22:33

Sounds to me like someone at HMRC is trying to go after some low hanging fruit.

Itisyourturntowashthebath · 05/06/2023 22:31

Tax credits did some major fuck ups at this time (18 years ago).

I spent a few years quite borderline and decided not to claim.

I have friend who's correspondence has been, we over paid you, no we didn't, you owe us £5,000, oh hang on maybe we owe you £500. Most then got told a moratorium was in place and it was a truce.

I'd be very pissed off if someone came at me asking for a repayment on a debt that hadn't been mentioned for 18 years.

Have these debts been passed on from HMRC to a debt collector?

GwinCoch · 05/06/2023 22:28

CaroleSinger · 05/06/2023 21:49

There's no time limit on government debt unfortunately.

This is true, as gross as it maybe. Same with student loans, I overpaid £2,300 because they couldn’t get their act together - I took out as student loan for my Masters this year and they said: “Oh actually we owe you!” 15 years and not a peep from them, even when I questioned back then if I should still be paying. My email address is the same, so is my mobile number. No excuse for not being able to contact me at any point subsequent. Government is Teflon in either direction. But if she has the original letter excusing her then she should be able to fight it with some help - even if the debt isn’t excused she could work out a reasonable repayment schedule, not a lump sum. Best to talk to Citizens Advice.

AuroraForever · 05/06/2023 22:25

Can she ask for a ‘mandatory reconsideration’ and provide the letter they sent her as proof they said they made a mistake?

Hannahsbananas · 05/06/2023 22:25

saveforthat · 05/06/2023 21:43

Yes this is correct. I wasn't clear enough. I can see now this could have been read more than one way. I'm just amazed they are looking at it now. Maybe they have taken on more staff to pursue old cases.

Your posts are very unclear.
Why would they try to pursue a non existent debt twice?

ItsJustNotHappening · 05/06/2023 22:23

And your friend should definitely submit a SAR as PP suggested to obtain copies of the original letters.

ItsJustNotHappening · 05/06/2023 22:21

Does that link help?

mopeymoo · 05/06/2023 22:16

No I'm not clear again. I thought HMRC are now saying their apology was wrong and she does owe them!!!

saveforthat · 05/06/2023 22:12

Moosethroat · 05/06/2023 22:09

I work for HMRC and yes they would expect it to be paid back. Tell your friend to call and set up a payment plan called Time To Pay if she cannot afford to clear in one go.

OK I know my original post was not clear but please read my updates. She wasn't overpaid. She owes nothing.

OP posts:
mopeymoo · 05/06/2023 22:11

saveforthat · 05/06/2023 21:38

Yes I have nothing from 18 years ago except birth certificates and the like. She kept it because there were so many errors made with her payments, she went through her MP in the end.

Yeah see I'd keep something like that too

Moosethroat · 05/06/2023 22:09

I work for HMRC and yes they would expect it to be paid back. Tell your friend to call and set up a payment plan called Time To Pay if she cannot afford to clear in one go.

Newyeardietstartstomorrow · 05/06/2023 21:50

Its a long time, but a tactic used sometimes is to wait until you are likely to be able to afford to pay it back. I used to work in debt advice, and we saw this sort of thing reasonably regularly, particularly with mortgage companies.

CaroleSinger · 05/06/2023 21:49

There's no time limit on government debt unfortunately.

EliflurtleTripanInfinite · 05/06/2023 21:47

I don't know if there's any statute of limitation on tax, I've certainly kept all mine from when I started working, so circa 25 years ago. Suggest to her she makes a SARS request to see the reason they think she's underpaid and if they previously informed her she didn't owe it you might be able to rely on that. Though from experience if it's your fault or theirs you still end up paying any overpayment/tax owed back.

HadalyEve · 05/06/2023 21:45

saveforthat · 05/06/2023 21:43

Yes this is correct. I wasn't clear enough. I can see now this could have been read more than one way. I'm just amazed they are looking at it now. Maybe they have taken on more staff to pursue old cases.

Thank you because it wasn’t clear, as I said when they overpay due to an error on their part they do apologise but they still want the money back. 😅

saveforthat · 05/06/2023 21:43

Saschka · 05/06/2023 21:33

I think she doesn’t actually owe the money? They said she did in 2005, then apologised and said she didn’t in 2006, and now have decided she does again.

Yes this is correct. I wasn't clear enough. I can see now this could have been read more than one way. I'm just amazed they are looking at it now. Maybe they have taken on more staff to pursue old cases.

OP posts:
HadalyEve · 05/06/2023 21:43

Whatisithatido · 05/06/2023 21:28

You did not even read the OP.

I did. I’ve had such a letter that says, sorry due to an error we have overpaid you and you owe a debt of ££££.

Apology letter doesn’t mean they don’t want their money back.

LIZS · 05/06/2023 21:39

They made a mistake in telling her she needed to repay them or the mistake was in overpaying her but she still owed it.

stealthninjamum · 05/06/2023 21:39

I keep all letters from hmrc and p45s and the end of year pay slips specifically because hmrc and the pensions people have been known to make mistakes and its very hard to make your case if you don’t have the paperwork. Wasn’t there a scandal where loads of women weren’t given the correct pensions? It all goes in one binder.