Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I am probably being mean but......

233 replies

razz · 05/06/2023 19:04

Its a long one so I can try not to dripfeed. When my DH and I met I had a great job, good money, own (but mortgaged!!!) house and he earnt very little but was following a passion. We had our first child, I was still the main breadwinner but have always loved working (I am not really cut out to be a SAHM!) so have never minded that. Fast forward to DC2 DH had a much better job so I gave up work (happily) to look at DC2 and then DC3 when they arrived. Went back to work after 3 years working about 30 hours a week. Over the last 7 years I have retrained (whilst working full time) and got a great job with fab prospects. I have been approached by my boss about a promotion that will be even more challenging than my current role, more travel and lots more money (likely just below 100k). DH has a good job, decent money, still a bit of a passion but not as 'fun' as he once thought it was. So to cut a long story short...if I get the new job DH says he wants to give up work. DC are now late teens, DH does very little around the house (we have never had a cleaner), doesn't decorate, repair stuff or anything like that - I have always done 90% of everything. The issue is that I don't want him to. Mainly because I don't see why he should get to do what he wants all day (he wants to spend more time on his hobby....long days out in the country with his mates) and not contribute. I dont want to give up work so it isnt jealousy. I just know he won't keep up with the household choirs like I do so I will still need to do all that and the kids dont need full time care like they did when I wasn't working. I also accept that I am probably being mean. Am I? What would you do?

OP posts:
Harry12345 · 06/06/2023 11:30

Definitely no, this situation is so different to when you have young children. I’d be resentful and find it really unattractive tbh and I’d say the same about a woman

BMW6 · 06/06/2023 10:56

Well he won't be childminding as a SAHD so unless he can contribute 50% of the household expenses (including holidays, savings) it'd be be a firm NO from me!.

Tootootoot · 06/06/2023 10:51

I earn about £100k and encouraged DH to go part time which he is about to do. But he's in his late 50s and his health isn't great, plus he's always pulled his weight. It took a lot of convincing as he wanted to feel he was doing his part. In your situation I wouldn't be happy that your DH seems to be leaping at the chance to live off you.

happinessischocolate · 06/06/2023 08:10

You need to pay off the mortgage and get some savings before he gets to stay at home doing nothing all day.

Saz12 · 05/06/2023 22:45

I work part-time (4 days 9-4). dh earns way more than me. I do the lions share of the domestic yuck, because Ive more time to do it.

I guess I could just go on endless bike rides, abd leave him to do it all... but I quite like being an adult and behaving like one.

OP, tell your DH this is unfair. Suggest he works shorter hours and gets all the cleaning/washing/cooking/admin/elderly care done, leavhbg you BOTH time to enjoy chore-free weekends.

AnneElliott · 05/06/2023 22:40

I agree that you shouldn't do this. Especially if you still have a mortgage! What happens if you get made redundant or get I'll?

H would love to do this but I've made it clear he needs to always bring in half the bills at least. Once the mortgage is paid off then that's £2k less than the bills now so would make it potentially viable for him to work for himself or part time. He was quite surprised that I'd put my foot down as I love my job and I think he thought I'd be happy if he sat at home doing sweet FA!

But after he did nothing while on gardening leave for 6 weeks I know I'd still be doing everything at home so I won't hear of it. I've always paid my way (only had 6 months Mat leave which was full pay) so why should he live off me?

Say no op. Plus it doesn't put him at a disadvantage if you were to divorce and also as pp have said in relation to NI credits.

jackstini · 05/06/2023 22:27

He doesn't get to give up work completely and do no chores!! Just, no.

Also need to consider retirement plans/pension contributions

My dh has been a SAHD since his 3rd redundancy about 6 years ago

But - he does the vast majority of housework (cleaning, laundry, ironing, gardening etc.) plus all the DIY & car stuff

Knowing he is there for childcare enabled me to have a job with more travel and better salary

Your dh needs to contribute to life in some way - financially or housework/admin etc. How is up to you both, but not doing anything will lead to massive resentment!

Maplelady · 05/06/2023 22:12

I’ve been in this situation and I ended up feeling really resentful. The deal was that I earned the money and they dealt with restoring our new house. He got bored with the project and ended up doing very little. I made an ultimatum that they go back to work and we paid for cleaners, painters etc. because he lost all enthusiasm. I ended up project managing the house plus being the laundry woman, cleaner, Money earner etc and I felt really taken for granted. I wouldn’t have minded if he’d got a low paid job In something he was passionate about. The relationship fell apart because it felt like I was living with a lazy teenage boy.

Comeonbarbiebrianharvey · 05/06/2023 22:03

Yanbu. You were a sahp for presumably pregnancy childcare and housework. I bet you were run ragged. This is not comparable as he'll be doing none of those things. It's completely different.

Heronwatcher · 05/06/2023 21:45

No I don’t think you are being U. I think there’s a huge difference between taking time off to look after tiny babies and giving up work to be supported when your kids are teenagers. Of course they still need parents at that age but they do not need full time care.

For a stay at home arrangement I think that both parties have to want it, and there has to be an understanding of what the SAHP needs to do- and then they need to do it. But if you’re not happy with the arrangement then don’t feel pressured to agree to it, it will just breed resentment.

GnomeDePlume · 05/06/2023 21:40

SleeplessinScarbourough · 05/06/2023 19:59

Why can’t a DH be a SAHD? My uncle was for a long time. Teenagers still need parents around. It sounds like you won’t be short of money. I don’t get why DH are discouraged from giving up work in exchange for happiness and the mere suggestion labels them a CF cocklodger

No reason at all. If anything it makes more sense, housework, DIY, chasing kids around can be hard physical work. My DH was SAHP for a significant part of our DCs' childhood. It was difficult for DH to get back into the labour market. He now has a supermarket job working 24h per week.

The big difference between our situation OP's is that my DH still does 90% of home care duties. I have a good salary and work very long hours for it.

Sierra26 · 05/06/2023 21:36

Why not suggest he starts putting as much salary as his employer will allow in to his pension? If you don’t need it now, save it for the future and in short term he’s not lazing round at home. A few years of that and then he could drop to part time?

If you’re not sure how to just say “hell no” I’d lead with that one! And smart too.

You should also put as much as you can in to pension once your salary increases

PaigeMatthews · 05/06/2023 21:11

If we had plenty of money with my earning and i loved my job, id be happy for dh to be at home… BUT he would do everything at home as he is an equal adult in the house already. Ive no doubt he would completely take over all chores.

in your case I would not be happy. I would most likely be resentful very quickly. And be looking to leave.

make it clear this is nit ok with you and if he chose to leave work you would seek a divorce, as you know he would also expect you to do everything at home and that level of freeloading is unacceptable.

lamaze1 · 05/06/2023 21:03

You're not mean at all. I'd find that deeply unattractive if he was my DH especially as you have kids. If you had paid off your mortgage, had good pensions and savings perhaps a different matter, but no. He is a grown up with bloody responsibilities! You don't just opt out of work for a hobby. [Note: I say this as someone that doesn't particularly like their job but get on with it for the good of my family, so I do understand but I'd feel way to guilty leaving my husband to provide for us all].

MysteryBelle · 05/06/2023 20:57

fewer hours

MysteryBelle · 05/06/2023 20:57

Can you both work less hours? Best of both worlds? I know that’s probably not possible with your new job. Maybe with his?

MysteryBelle · 05/06/2023 20:55

Whatonearth07957 · 05/06/2023 19:14

You'll resent him. Tell him to respect him you would expect him to contribute

Agree with this.

HerMammy · 05/06/2023 20:53

Your new salary is hardly a boost if your then lose his income, he needs to work, there's no reason for him not to be contributing.

ChampagneCommunist · 05/06/2023 20:51

@GCalltheway @Blabberbox @AntiSocial6DaysAWeek I don't want to derail, but it didn't happen all at once. It was quite a long time before i realised what had happened.

We aren't married (my choice) and - most ridiculously - I am a shit hot lawyer. Not a divorce lawyer, obvs

AMuser · 05/06/2023 20:39

razz · 05/06/2023 19:40

Yes I guess so, but part of it is that have worked hard to get this chance and I suppose I had envisaged another 10 years of both of us saving, paying off the mortgage and getting some kind of pension. We aren't rich, no real savings but of course the new salary is huge so would make a massive difference to achieving all these goals but not without him earning some kind of salary. Maybe I compromise with part time and he does the decorating and we get a cleaner then we both get more time lol!

With respect a potential promotion to say £90k a year when you have no savings or pension (from what I gather) to date … is not “huge”. By the time you pay tax and NI etc how much better off will you be than currently? I’d have thought hardly enough for your DH to become a man of leisure.

Id have thought it’s a chance to use the excess ti max out your pension and ISAs and enjoy a fun retirement together.

Oh but do get a cleaner twice a week either way if he’s a lazy sod. So you don’t have to come home from a work trip to a dirty house.

WhatADrabCarpet · 05/06/2023 20:36

No. He wants an easy life on your back.

HeckinBamboozled · 05/06/2023 20:33

YANBU and you aren't mean. Resentment is going to fester if he quits with and does sweet FA.

Blabberbox · 05/06/2023 20:32

What if you become ill and can’t work? Or do household chores? He is fit enough to work and contribute to what needs to be done in your house and should do so. How can you live with someone like that?

StemStem · 05/06/2023 20:32

Could you just leave him?

GCalltheway · 05/06/2023 20:31

ChampagneCommunist · 05/06/2023 20:01

Don't. I'm in this situation & am resentful.

He's retired and pays for 3/4 of food. I pay for everything else, including an absolutely massive mortgage on a house I don't want to live in but he won't agree to move.

I work 11 hours a day. Often one day a weekend too, do all the laundry and pay for a cleaner because he refuses to do it. He does do some gardening.

Don't be me.

I think you are being abused actually.