Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I am probably being mean but......

233 replies

razz · 05/06/2023 19:04

Its a long one so I can try not to dripfeed. When my DH and I met I had a great job, good money, own (but mortgaged!!!) house and he earnt very little but was following a passion. We had our first child, I was still the main breadwinner but have always loved working (I am not really cut out to be a SAHM!) so have never minded that. Fast forward to DC2 DH had a much better job so I gave up work (happily) to look at DC2 and then DC3 when they arrived. Went back to work after 3 years working about 30 hours a week. Over the last 7 years I have retrained (whilst working full time) and got a great job with fab prospects. I have been approached by my boss about a promotion that will be even more challenging than my current role, more travel and lots more money (likely just below 100k). DH has a good job, decent money, still a bit of a passion but not as 'fun' as he once thought it was. So to cut a long story short...if I get the new job DH says he wants to give up work. DC are now late teens, DH does very little around the house (we have never had a cleaner), doesn't decorate, repair stuff or anything like that - I have always done 90% of everything. The issue is that I don't want him to. Mainly because I don't see why he should get to do what he wants all day (he wants to spend more time on his hobby....long days out in the country with his mates) and not contribute. I dont want to give up work so it isnt jealousy. I just know he won't keep up with the household choirs like I do so I will still need to do all that and the kids dont need full time care like they did when I wasn't working. I also accept that I am probably being mean. Am I? What would you do?

OP posts:
Maggie178 · 06/06/2023 17:45

If he's not going to contribute in a financial way he needs to in another way. If he quits the house work is his responsibility.

Doone21 · 06/06/2023 17:16

So it's OK for you to be a SAHM but not the other way round?
You say he won't do anything but he's never been in that position so it's just conjecture really.
TALK to him about what the job expectations are for his new role and make it clear that if he wants to skip the chores it's his responsibility to fund and find a cleaner.

Wanttobefree2 · 06/06/2023 14:34

I wouldn’t do it, just because you earn great money doesn’t mean he can’t still contribute. Unless he’s going to make your life a lot easier so you can focus on work I wouldn’t agree. I don’t think it’s mean at all.

CornishAdventures · 06/06/2023 14:20

I think if your role is going to become more intense and demanding then he could reduce his hours to part time however he would need to step up to become the parent to care for the teens, do the house work and all the life admin. If the majority is still falling to you there is no reason for him to not work unless he has saved substantial funds to afford his half of your life together from now through retirement

JustAnotherDayWorkingAtHome · 06/06/2023 14:15

Will his giving up work impact your ability to go on the holidays you want and have the lifestyle you want? Will it delay your plan for retirement?

It is a tricky one but I read that resentment is one of the key things that can lead to marriage breakdown so you need to be sure that isn't going to start creeping in.

Serena73 · 06/06/2023 14:15

It's only ok if he does most of the stuff at home. Otherwise it's totally unacceptable!

MadelineZott · 06/06/2023 14:12

SleeplessinScarbourough · 05/06/2023 19:59

Why can’t a DH be a SAHD? My uncle was for a long time. Teenagers still need parents around. It sounds like you won’t be short of money. I don’t get why DH are discouraged from giving up work in exchange for happiness and the mere suggestion labels them a CF cocklodger

Of course a man can be a SAHD; I doubt anyone has anything against that. But when OP was a SAHM, she did all the "wifework" including the housework, the kids and the life admin. Now she's working full time she still ends up doing this because he's a lazy arse. If OP's DH was going to do everything around the home so she could come home to a clean house, shopping done, meals prepared etc. then I'm sure she would be happy with the arrangement. But his track record suggests he will just mooch about all day or be out doing his hobby then expect her to come back from a work trip and still do all the domestic chores.

OP, you are not being mean. I say this as someone who IS funding my DH's early retirement, but I took early retirement myself and he does at least as much around the house as I do. Despite that, I sometimes feel a slight twinge of resentment and in your shoes the amount of resentment would be massive.

Congratulations on your promotion, by the way.

Changes17 · 06/06/2023 14:01

Would be fairer if you both carried on working and then both retired earlier than you might otherwise. Presumably your kids are still financially dependent?

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 06/06/2023 13:57

And I say this as someone planning to stop work at 50, with no children. But I've worked it out so my financial contribution to the household remains unchanged and my practical contribution will increase.

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 06/06/2023 13:56

Contribution to the household currently:

  • you >50% of the money, 90% of the work
  • him <50% of the money, 10% of the work

His proposal:

  • you 100% of the money, 90% of the work
  • him 0% of the money, 10% of the work (are you confident he'd even keep that up?)

Fuck that!

If you remove him from the equation:

  • you 100% of the money (but lower expenses, so more spare money), 90% of the work (get the teens to do at least 10%), and much less resentment and stress

And on top of that, you still have a mortgage, very little in savings and no pension?

No.

You need savings. You need a pension. I can't see any reason at all why you need him.

Riverlee · 06/06/2023 13:35

If you’re working full time, with a superb salary, and he’s not working at all, are you anyway better off. Does your new income exceed your previous combined income?

I’d be cheesed off if dh wanted to become a sahm partner, with teenagers. Wouldn’t we all like to be in permanent holiday at someone else’s expense! Does he expect you to do all the housework etc?

Kiwano · 06/06/2023 13:32

Tell him that before you even think about this you need say 6 months of him demonstrating that he can fully pull his weight with the housework - and that means that over that period your roles are reversed and you do 10% of it and he does 90% of it, as you have been doing for years. If he can demonstrate that everything runs well with him taking responsibility, then great, there's a way forward with him packing in work. If not, you aren't going to carry on doing all the housework plus a full time heavy-duty job whilst he plays with his hobbies.

38andtrying · 06/06/2023 13:27

so basically he wants to retire early and you are his retirement fund, wtf!! sounds like a bum

Eatstootsandleaves · 06/06/2023 13:25

I know it's dull and boring, but what about his pension? He'll need to have worked/ paid NI for 35 years to get the full state pension. That's only £10,600-ish this year. It doesn't go far. Does he have any other pension provision?

The decisions he makes now will have consequences over the next 30+ years. If you're going to work on and build a great pension and savings (if there are any savings once you're solely responsible for house maintenance, new boilers, roof repairs, replacement cars, holidays, a cleaner, garden maintenance) and he retires now, you'll be paying for him for the rest of your lives. Are you going to be comfortable paying a massive amount for his dental treatment, or paying for a holiday for him to pursue his hobby?

You share three DC who'll need money to get through university or training and will then perhaps need help with house deposits. Has he thought about any of this, or is he just the kind of person who just jogs along and doesn't plan for the future?

bussteward · 06/06/2023 13:17

When you were a SAHM it was with small children who need more hands-on round the clock care, and you only did it for three years. Then retrained and got so good you’ll earn £100k! Whereas his version of SAHD is to do it with kids in school, do it forever, and not attempt to train, earn or do anything but have fun. One is not like the other and it’s not mean to ask 50% of the partnership to pull 50% of the weight. He doesn’t have to earn £100k, but he does have to earn NI, pay into pensions and savings, no do his share of life admin/mental load/etc.

KingOfThieves · 06/06/2023 13:15

He is funny. You could consider part time once the mortgage is paid off? I’d expect him to be working around the house plenty too! What about his pension? Or is he wanting you to be financially responsible for the both of you forever?

goldentoes · 06/06/2023 13:13

@Usernamenotavailab women do it all the time but it's not seen as acceptable?!

Usernamenotavailab · 06/06/2023 13:13

NameChangePoP · 06/06/2023 12:58

OP please don't do this.

This happened to a friend of mine. She was the higher earner, so her husband (cleverly) began reducing his work under the guise of keeping the house and childcare until eventually he stopped working. After a couple of years he proceeded to have an affair and divorced her.
As he was the SAHP he got to stay in the house with the children, she had to give him half her pension, and he got the bigger equity share.
My friend had to start over with little money and without her children around her.

Both parties need to be contributing to the household or it has the potential to get very messy.

Women do this all the time and it’s seen as completely normal and acceptable. And then bitch about the nrp “starting over with very little money” not paying as much maintenance as they want. Disney parenting and living the good life not having the daily drudge of kids.

are these women being “clever” reducing their work hours to be sahm?

double standards.

Whataretheodds · 06/06/2023 13:11

SleeplessinScarbourough · 05/06/2023 19:59

Why can’t a DH be a SAHD? My uncle was for a long time. Teenagers still need parents around. It sounds like you won’t be short of money. I don’t get why DH are discouraged from giving up work in exchange for happiness and the mere suggestion labels them a CF cocklodger

Because OP has already stated that she does 90% of housework and family admin

So unless he makes a massive stepchange he wouldn't be a househusband, he'd be a cocklodger.

goldentoes · 06/06/2023 13:11

I don't think you're being mean. You're being sensible. You've had good news and all he's heard is yippee I can finally get out of my job. That's most likely put a massive downer on your prospective promotion.

Partners should only give up work when it's agreed by both parties.
Perhaps you can say you're uncomfortable with being the breadwinner when you can't see what your whole family will gain from it given he doesn't like helping enough around the house. A compromise for me would be to pay for hired help for jobs he currently does so he can 'only' do his work and not then have much less to do at home.

If it were my own dh I would say go pt but he already does as much as possible around the home and picks up when I need it as well.

Applesonthelawn · 06/06/2023 13:10

Absolutely he should not be allowed to give up work unless he has history to demonstrate that your life would be a lot easier if he did. That history has not been demonstrated, so no. You’d end up doing everything and resenting him. It would be the beginning of the end.

ScribblingPixie · 06/06/2023 13:08

What? You're not being mean in the slightest. He obviously needs to at least pay his own way even if he can't find himself a career he loves. And he also needs to pull his weight at home. Don't be a mug, OP.

ireallycantthinkofaname · 06/06/2023 13:07

Even if he can't no way would I let him give up work. That's just bloody lazy!

ireallycantthinkofaname · 06/06/2023 13:06

Can he get another part time job in his hobby? (Depends what it is I guess)

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/06/2023 13:06

DH and I had this conversation very early on. He’s in a ‘retire young’ profession so will be ~54 when he’s eligible to retire with his full pension. He was wistfully thinking of his leisure time one day and I told him that while he may be retired he’ll still be working somewhere, I didn’t (and still don’t) care what he did, but it would paid employment. He didn’t argue since the man has worked 2 jobs simultaneously since he was a teenager by necessity then and choice now.

People need to work and contribute to the household, they need to be part of a larger world. (Obviously this is my opinion and I’m sure others will disagree).

I think the biggest factor is your savings situation. IMO, you both should be working full time and saving as much as possible for retirement. The good news is that it should be a lot easier with your new job!

Swipe left for the next trending thread