Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I am probably being mean but......

233 replies

razz · 05/06/2023 19:04

Its a long one so I can try not to dripfeed. When my DH and I met I had a great job, good money, own (but mortgaged!!!) house and he earnt very little but was following a passion. We had our first child, I was still the main breadwinner but have always loved working (I am not really cut out to be a SAHM!) so have never minded that. Fast forward to DC2 DH had a much better job so I gave up work (happily) to look at DC2 and then DC3 when they arrived. Went back to work after 3 years working about 30 hours a week. Over the last 7 years I have retrained (whilst working full time) and got a great job with fab prospects. I have been approached by my boss about a promotion that will be even more challenging than my current role, more travel and lots more money (likely just below 100k). DH has a good job, decent money, still a bit of a passion but not as 'fun' as he once thought it was. So to cut a long story short...if I get the new job DH says he wants to give up work. DC are now late teens, DH does very little around the house (we have never had a cleaner), doesn't decorate, repair stuff or anything like that - I have always done 90% of everything. The issue is that I don't want him to. Mainly because I don't see why he should get to do what he wants all day (he wants to spend more time on his hobby....long days out in the country with his mates) and not contribute. I dont want to give up work so it isnt jealousy. I just know he won't keep up with the household choirs like I do so I will still need to do all that and the kids dont need full time care like they did when I wasn't working. I also accept that I am probably being mean. Am I? What would you do?

OP posts:
Needanewnamebeingwatched · 07/06/2023 12:06

If he gives up work then he takes on 100% of everything else.
Household chores, the mental load, the cooking, shopping, kids pick ups and drop offs etc etc

tattygrl · 07/06/2023 11:58

I mean, there's nothing unreasonable about not wanting such an imbalance in work status between you and your partner, but saying "I don't see why he should get to do what he wants all day", while also expressing that you work so much because you love it, is a bit telling. To me it wouldn't have anything to do with not wanting my partner to not do what he wants all day. If that was an option, I'd think that was great! It would only be a problem if other parts of the relationship weren't that healthy/functioning, and it sounds like that's the real crux of the problem; not the idea that he could do what he wants all day while you're working, because it sounds like your choice to work in the way you do is because it fulfils you.

CM1897 · 07/06/2023 11:40

Vitriolinsanity · 05/06/2023 19:13

We'll hang on @BuffyTheCat DH has financially funded the most in the past, and presumably OP was satisfied with the 90% or would've said so.

Compromise seems to be the way forward. OP takes the new job, DH asks his job for flexible working to say 3 days per week.

They get a cleaner.

dh financially funded because they had young children (who they made together) who needed looking after and the housework needed doing. He didn’t financially fund so OP could sit on her bum doing nothing all day. There’s a difference

Hankunamatata · 07/06/2023 10:08

I'd say to him that you both need to go to a financial advisor and look at retirement planning. It should become clear that he probably needs to work to afford retirement.

SkyandSurf · 07/06/2023 10:04

You love your job now OP.

What if your next manager is a bully? Or your company becomes insolvent or your position redundant? What if you injure your back or develop fatigue or just want to retire or reduce your hours yourself for some reason?

He'll be out of the workforce, possibly no longer employable, and will struggle with ageism even if he is willing to return to work.

All the pressure will be on you, because he's decided to live the good life.

Unless you are seriously wealthy, he should continue to work and contribute to build up your quality of life in retirement- for both of you!

ScribblingPixie · 07/06/2023 09:51

This is important, OP. He wants to retire whilst he’s young and you’re earning the money, so he can have fun with no financial restraints.

Then, when you retire too, there will be no money for you to have fun, and you’ll have to scrimp and go without, because there’s no savings in the pension pot and no income.

I completely agree. Look after your own future, OP.

N0ChildrenYet · 07/06/2023 09:49

I would say that given you had 3 years off work (albeit as a SAHM, I know it’s not exactly a holiday!) maybe you could compromise and give him a trial run of being a SAHD, so that he’s got some time off and it feels equal to him and that he feels like he’s got a ‘break’? I know that being a SAHM is NOT that, but you know what men are like… their perception of what women do just isn’t accurate 😂

Maybe he could have a trial run of being the ‘SAHD’, taking over teenager duties, running the house, doing all the chores you need him to do, cleaning, house maintenance, DIY, doing up the house where it’s needed to be done and just hasn’t been… and then when certain things have been done, he can let off some steam by going to do the things he wants to do?

i guess the real issues will be making sure that he does all of those things in ways that you are happy with - or at least in ways that are functional and clean and tidy. They might not be exactly to your liking but hopefully he will learn? You might have to let go and accept the new norm. So long as it’s not a tip! I think it’s something he will have to learn and feel good about doing in order to keep doing it (rather than do it wrong and then not want to do it again… like I child I guess!)

I think as long as he pulls his weight and uses his energy in productive ways and does things around the house that benefits both of you and not just himself, I think personally I would be fine with being the main breadwinner for a bit and letting him stay home and see what happens. In his mind, he is probably thinking ‘well, I let you do it’ and I KNOW it’s not the same. But to him, he’s probably not seeing it the same way. He just wants some time off.

I imagine if you try it and he doesn’t like it, he’ll find another job soon enough. Maybe at this point if he’s looking and you find that he did help around the house and with the kids, and he still wants to meet his friends, you could suggest a part time one and you might find that he’ll balance all those things.

in an ideal world haha…

MiniMileaway · 07/06/2023 09:32

It sounds like your DH believes you are moving into a time of less outgoings, responsibilities, etc (at least for him!) With teenagers, though, you are potentially moving towards quite an expensive time of parenthood - university fees and living costs are no joke.
He is not thinking ahead in those terms, not in terms of your mutual retirements - these things need discussing.
My feeling is, though, that he sees your success as his meal ticket to do the bare minimum. Yuck.

Frogmila · 07/06/2023 09:30

ODFODeary · 05/06/2023 19:15

Hmm I'm torn , you are doing what you want to do so I can see why he wants to do the same
I think it's unfair to put your standards of housekeeping on him though but you'd have to be strong to ignore it
I suppose you could give it a trial run or he could get a PT position

How is it equivalent in any way if he wants her to.fund the household/ him? It's not the same as being a SAHP of young children.

NoSquirrels · 07/06/2023 09:30

Also, late teenage years are expensive. Do your DC want to go to university or further training? Your new salary excludes them from much in the way of a student loan, so you’ll be expected to top up a lot of money. His salary could really help with that. If he retires he’s disadvantaging his DC as well as you.

NoSquirrels · 07/06/2023 09:25

I had envisaged another 10 years of both of us saving, paying off the mortgage and getting some kind of pension. We aren't rich, no real savings but of course the new salary is huge so would make a massive difference to achieving all these goals but not without him earning some kind of salary.

This is important, OP. He wants to retire whilst he’s young and you’re earning the money, so he can have fun with no financial restraints.

Then, when you retire too, there will be no money for you to have fun, and you’ll have to scrimp and go without, because there’s no savings in the pension pot and no income.

You’re not being mean. These 10 years are incredibly important. He needs to keep working.

SkyandSurf · 07/06/2023 09:22

Could you both work a four day week? Why should he have all the leisure time?

I wouldn't be on board with this at all.

I received a big promotion last year and my DH suggested that he resign and be a SAHD. I said absolutely fucking not.

He'd been a 'SAHD' for 4 months once before due to redundancy - we kept the nanny the whole time, he lived a life of leisure. Didn't do a single one of the list of jobs and tasks around the house we wrote together. Did less than half the housework. Eventually I told him that if he didn't get a job in the next week I'd give the nanny her notice and he could genuinely be a SAHD. Miraculously a job appeared and he was at work within a week.

It's hard to respect someone who doesn't contribute. Or someone who swans into the SAHP position once all the hardest child rearing years are done/the children are in school.

TheBerry · 07/06/2023 09:16

Sounds infuriating, he’s your partner not your sugar baby. He can’t sponge of you just because he’s earning well. At the very least if he wants to give up work he should keep the household in good order.

How are you even attracted to him.

user1492757084 · 07/06/2023 09:12

Maybe if he worked part time that would work out.
Also set aside your extra finances on an investment for the children, agreed upon, such as an extra property.

Work towards increasing your wealth while you can for the benefit of your children. Thus, the extra money you earn is not actually going in to the normal every day expense fund - not available to subsidise his hobby.

Catza · 07/06/2023 09:00

There is no one right way to run a family but there needs to be a discussion about responsibilities.
My partner and I both work (and both love our jobs) but we made an agreement that I only contribute towards a small portion of bills and some of the food. He takes care of the rest. In return I do “unpaid labour” at home - laundry, cleaning and 70% of all cooking (I work from home so it’s not a big deal). I also put a large portion of my earnings into a savings account should something happen and either of us is unable to work.
It works well for us BUT we discussed it at length and made an agreement that this is the best way forward for the family.
I would have a conversation with your husband that, if he wants to give up work, he needs to a”take 100% of household responsibilities. I would be leaning towards part-time employment until the mortgage is paid off and you can split household chores accordingly - 50/50 on the days you both work and 100/0 on the days only you work. If he is not able to uphold his end of the agreement, he needs to contribute either equally or proportionally financially.

Thoughtful2355 · 07/06/2023 08:24

@Doone21 Difference is she was a STAHM .... he will just be a stay at home person, he wont be doing anything...

They have older kids who will no doubt be growing up and moving out soon, she said he hardly does anything.. whereas she was a STAHM to young children..
He basically wants to be a leisurely kept for husband

Thoughtful2355 · 07/06/2023 08:22

No way, why should he be able to sit back and enjoy the money youve earnt? i think its different if you have kids that need parenting but not when theyre older -_-

He should ATLEAST work part time

Newnamenewname109870 · 07/06/2023 08:16

You never just gave up your job, you were a sahm to young children and did everything around the house. Would he be doing the same? Doesn’t sound like it at all.

loislovesstewie · 07/06/2023 08:10

Only if he does all the cleaning, repairs etc. Or he works part time and pays for people to do those jobs. He will end up sitting around the house doing nothing while you slog your guts out, and then moan that he is bored. (Speaking from experience).

billy1966 · 07/06/2023 07:25

BinturongsSmellOfPopcorn · 06/06/2023 13:56

Contribution to the household currently:

  • you >50% of the money, 90% of the work
  • him <50% of the money, 10% of the work

His proposal:

  • you 100% of the money, 90% of the work
  • him 0% of the money, 10% of the work (are you confident he'd even keep that up?)

Fuck that!

If you remove him from the equation:

  • you 100% of the money (but lower expenses, so more spare money), 90% of the work (get the teens to do at least 10%), and much less resentment and stress

And on top of that, you still have a mortgage, very little in savings and no pension?

No.

You need savings. You need a pension. I can't see any reason at all why you need him.

There you go OP.

A pension evaluation for the OP would be a deeply sobering experience.

She will likely find, as it stands, she has a a very frugal retirement ahead of her, despite having worked very hard.

overtherainbow1234 · 07/06/2023 07:20

Definitely not being mean!

when you stayed at home that was to care for your children. Let’s face it … SAHM do everything around the house. You didn’t use your day to do a hobby.

He now wants to sponge off your income to do a hobby. If you still had young children then yes why can’t he have that opportunity. Maybe reduce his house or something.

For anyone stating that the the poster got to stay at home whilst the husband had to work so it’s only fair he gets the opportunity … I bet the staying at home with the kids was harder work. Why should he get to lounge around care free with no young children whilst she no doubt has to do everything on top of a full time job.

converseandjeans · 06/06/2023 20:48

Nope. He wants to be a cocklodger, say no!

I agree with this. However if a woman of a similar age said her husband was forcing her to keep working the responses would be very different. It still seems to be ingrained that men have to work whilst it's ok for middle aged women to potter about claiming they have to do life admin and the food shop.

He needs to work part time at least & accept that work isn't all about having fun.

Murdoch1949 · 06/06/2023 19:14

Part-time would be a compromise with an agreed contract about what home responsibilities he will take full control of. Why should you work your butt off for him to indulge his hobbies, interests etc? He would need to take over all weeknight cooking, all laundry and cleaning, organisation of household repairs, decorating etc, gardening. It's a partnership, he needs to do his whack.

PaigeMatthews · 06/06/2023 19:10

Doone21 · 06/06/2023 17:16

So it's OK for you to be a SAHM but not the other way round?
You say he won't do anything but he's never been in that position so it's just conjecture really.
TALK to him about what the job expectations are for his new role and make it clear that if he wants to skip the chores it's his responsibility to fund and find a cleaner.

Yes he has been in that positions. They have teenagers. He has been an adult in a house for twenty years. In those twenty years he has barely lifted a finger.

He worked a passion for very little money rather than getting a decent paying job. He is now wanting to quit that job as it now pays a decent amount but is no longer fun.

this is not a man who is going to do the housework he clearly doesnt want to do.

Pubgardener · 06/06/2023 17:53

@Doone21 well as both the DH an OP work full time and she does 90% of the housework and life admin he is in the position to do it-he just doesn’t.