Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I am probably being mean but......

233 replies

razz · 05/06/2023 19:04

Its a long one so I can try not to dripfeed. When my DH and I met I had a great job, good money, own (but mortgaged!!!) house and he earnt very little but was following a passion. We had our first child, I was still the main breadwinner but have always loved working (I am not really cut out to be a SAHM!) so have never minded that. Fast forward to DC2 DH had a much better job so I gave up work (happily) to look at DC2 and then DC3 when they arrived. Went back to work after 3 years working about 30 hours a week. Over the last 7 years I have retrained (whilst working full time) and got a great job with fab prospects. I have been approached by my boss about a promotion that will be even more challenging than my current role, more travel and lots more money (likely just below 100k). DH has a good job, decent money, still a bit of a passion but not as 'fun' as he once thought it was. So to cut a long story short...if I get the new job DH says he wants to give up work. DC are now late teens, DH does very little around the house (we have never had a cleaner), doesn't decorate, repair stuff or anything like that - I have always done 90% of everything. The issue is that I don't want him to. Mainly because I don't see why he should get to do what he wants all day (he wants to spend more time on his hobby....long days out in the country with his mates) and not contribute. I dont want to give up work so it isnt jealousy. I just know he won't keep up with the household choirs like I do so I will still need to do all that and the kids dont need full time care like they did when I wasn't working. I also accept that I am probably being mean. Am I? What would you do?

OP posts:
ferntwist · 07/06/2023 14:43

LocalHobo · 07/06/2023 14:37

Why can’t a DH be a SAHD? My uncle was for a long time. Teenagers still need parents around. It sounds like you won’t be short of money
He is entitled to the 3 years you had at the very least.

No way is not working and not doing chores when your kids are late teens remotely comparable to being a SAHM with a baby or a toddler. Don’t make me laugh!

PoppyPP · 07/06/2023 14:41

You didn’t give up work though… you gave up one paid job to do a different unpaid job to look after small kids. I did the same for 3 years when my DC were little.

Like hell is it appropriate for your DH to give up paid work now to do jack shit. He should be working towards building his pension. Teenagers don’t get cheaper.

ferntwist · 07/06/2023 14:41

You’re not being mean in the slightest. Hard no!

LocalHobo · 07/06/2023 14:37

Why can’t a DH be a SAHD? My uncle was for a long time. Teenagers still need parents around. It sounds like you won’t be short of money
He is entitled to the 3 years you had at the very least.

meuroticjishmum · 07/06/2023 14:30

I would say why not both continue as you are and use the extra money to overpay the mortgage? Once mortgage reduced, he could then go part time? If you don't have health problems and dc are no longer small, surely no functioning adult should be an adult dependant in a relationship. No one knows what the future holds - you could be made redundant - just making a point, I'm sure you won't! - and then his part time salary and a reduced mortgage would be a blessing....

AcrossthePond55 · 07/06/2023 14:28

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/06/2023 13:06

DH and I had this conversation very early on. He’s in a ‘retire young’ profession so will be ~54 when he’s eligible to retire with his full pension. He was wistfully thinking of his leisure time one day and I told him that while he may be retired he’ll still be working somewhere, I didn’t (and still don’t) care what he did, but it would paid employment. He didn’t argue since the man has worked 2 jobs simultaneously since he was a teenager by necessity then and choice now.

People need to work and contribute to the household, they need to be part of a larger world. (Obviously this is my opinion and I’m sure others will disagree).

I think the biggest factor is your savings situation. IMO, you both should be working full time and saving as much as possible for retirement. The good news is that it should be a lot easier with your new job!

Seriously, what? So no one is allowed to fully retire?

As long as a person's retirement income is enough to maintain their share of the expenses, why on earth should they continue to work?

I retired in my mid-50s with a pension that meant our lifestyle did not change, DH did the same. If anything, we're a teeny bit better off due to savings on fuel and work expenses. If one of us had told the other that they had to continue working we'd have told them to get stuffed. Retirement is wonderful and as I told a friend "I worked all my life for this!!".

Keep working 'to be a part of the larger world, my eye! We have more time to be involved in the larger world now that we're retired than we ever had when we were working. Travel, volunteering, socializing...all so much easier when you're retired.

If you want to stay working until they find you dead at your desk, so be it. But assuming his pension is sufficient let the man retire when it's his time, FGS. After working 2 jobs his entire life, he certainly deserves it.

MsRosley · 07/06/2023 14:23

Unless he was going to spend his time completely overhauling and redecorating the house and earning his keep that way, it would be a hard no from me. How convenient he wants to be a stay at home dad when the hard work phase is pretty much over.

SiobhanSharpe · 07/06/2023 14:22

There is no upside in this for you, it's all for him; you know that you will still be doing everything.
Is he normally so selfish?

BoogieBoogieWoogie · 07/06/2023 14:22

People are giving your DH a hard time. He made a proposal, that is all. If you dont support it then have the conversation and say so.
No need for any of the crap being slung at him on this thread based upon the info you have supplied

SkyandSurf · 07/06/2023 14:16

Being a SAHP to a baby, toddler, preschooler saves a family thousands in childcare fees. It is a financial contribution in and of itself.

The same cannot be said for staying home with teenagers.

Mirabai · 07/06/2023 14:02

No is there short answer.

If you have no savings then you both need to keep working. You both need to contribute to your pensions. 10 years of both working will make a big difference to your retirement fund.

kingtamponthefurred · 07/06/2023 13:58

It would not be at all mean to tell him HELL NO. It's not just about the money, it's about the principle. And if he suddenly gets marriage-minded, be very suspicious.

Theunamedcat · 07/06/2023 13:54

Usernamenotavailab · 07/06/2023 13:25

Many women continue to sah with teens though. It’s quite often discussed on here, saying teens need someone at home through the stressful gcse and a level years.

if it’s ok for a woman to sah with teens then why not a man.

as long as he picks up all that wifework as well.

Many women take care of the house too they have chores not "hobbies"

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 07/06/2023 13:40

Hankunamatata · 07/06/2023 10:08

I'd say to him that you both need to go to a financial advisor and look at retirement planning. It should become clear that he probably needs to work to afford retirement.

This is the best way.
From experience they will listen to "experts"
You'll be supporting him up to retirement age (68?) that's up to 17 years. Then he'll go on state pension and you'll be supporting him with your company pension.

You gave up work for 3 years to care for preschool and primary school children.
He's giving up to effectively retire in his early 50s and live off your wages for the next 17 years and then off your pension
This is taking money from your children. It will impact any savings you might otherwise be able to build, help with uni fees, or emergency medical that might not be NHS. Orthodontics etc.

Don't let him do a Trial period... at over 50 it will be really hard to get back into the world of work after giving up for three years.
You will still be doing 90 per cent of the work and paying for it too.

Usernamenotavailab · 07/06/2023 13:25

Theunamedcat · 07/06/2023 13:01

You dont NEED to stay at home with teenagers they don't legally require childcare for a reason

Many women continue to sah with teens though. It’s quite often discussed on here, saying teens need someone at home through the stressful gcse and a level years.

if it’s ok for a woman to sah with teens then why not a man.

as long as he picks up all that wifework as well.

Riverlee · 07/06/2023 13:23

@N0ChildrenYet

Its a bit different to taking ‘three years off’ to look after under fives, compared to teens, who can (hopefully) get dressed themselves, wash, get themselves to school, feed themselves, help to wash up, put bins out, make their beds, put clothes in the wash etc.

TillyBilly29 · 07/06/2023 13:22

BuffyTheCat · 05/06/2023 19:09

So he has never really pulled his weight, and now he just wants to sponge off you? Unless he’s ill or something, I can’t see why this would be acceptable.

This sums it up well

Theunamedcat · 07/06/2023 13:01

Doone21 · 06/06/2023 17:16

So it's OK for you to be a SAHM but not the other way round?
You say he won't do anything but he's never been in that position so it's just conjecture really.
TALK to him about what the job expectations are for his new role and make it clear that if he wants to skip the chores it's his responsibility to fund and find a cleaner.

You dont NEED to stay at home with teenagers they don't legally require childcare for a reason

1offnamechange · 07/06/2023 12:58

I'd say part time and he has to commit to doing set chores as the best way to avoid arguments.

Even if he worked 2.5 days then spent 1 (designated) day a week doing housework he would still have 1.5 days completely free plus weekends which is more than most people in their fifities!
surely it's just fair
You're a partnership
You will be bringing In more money but will have less time
He wants to work less so will be contributing less money so should make up by doing more household stuff
Exactly as you did when he worked full time and you stayed at home
You're not asking him to do anything you didn't or wouldn't do yourself
Otherwise I don't see how it wouldn't lead to resentment and lack of respect if you are doing everything and him nothing

RedToothBrush · 07/06/2023 12:53

Big thing here to me is the fact it doesn't sound like you've paid off the mortgage yet. This means neither of you can effectively afford to retire at this point.

So even being generous about this, he stays in work til then. One of the things about not working is the amount of money he's likely to be spending in his free time. He won't just be sat at home not spending. So not only will that mean that it will take longer to pay off the mortgage but you'll also have greater outgoing from him not working.

If he wants to take early retirement, then you need to BOTH make a financial plan for that - that means looking at early mortgage repayment (with him still working) and what your pensions look like.

It sounds like he hasn't given any thought whatsoever to this.

This affects YOUR retirement plans significantly. He's effectively asking you to work for years longer in order to enable his earlier retirement without you rather than thinking about how you BOTH can retire earlier and spend time together.

Yu aren't saying he can't give up work early - IT IS NOT REMOTELY MEAN TO BE ASKING TO WORK OUT A JOINT FINANCIAL PLAN FOR THE REST OF YOUR LIVES - THIS IS PRUDENT AND WHAT SHOULD BE THE DEFAULT IN ALL RELATIONSHIPS. You need to keep laser focused on this point.

The compromise could be that you AGREE for him to go part time at some point on the provision that he maintains the house - that might include him funding and managing any decorating / cleaning that needs doing (which could be hiring help with that). But you must be happy with that agreement and he can't take the piss. You don't want to be the one arranging the decorators/cleaners cos he can't be arse with the admin of that. But you need to have that explicit conversation. He doesn't get to dictate that.

If he doesn't want to discuss this like an adult OR he has a sulk / tantrum over you pulling him up on this and saying 'no' in any part thats the Red Flag that he's taking the piss. If he does that, you need to have a long hard think about where thats going to leave you long term. Do you want to carry him and potentially miss out on YOUR retirement and financial security? What happens if you fall ill unexpectedly before the mortgage is paid off? Whats you retirement plan - when do YOU want to retire? Is that possible if he isn't working for years?

littlehoops · 07/06/2023 12:43

I don't think you're being mean at all. There's no problem with him giving up paid employment (if you can afford that) but he would then need to contribute to the household by becoming a SAHD and doing the work you did when you were a SAHM. Doesn't sound like he's up to that though, in which case it would be a firm no!

SkyandSurf · 07/06/2023 12:33

Needanewnamebeingwatched · 07/06/2023 12:06

If he gives up work then he takes on 100% of everything else.
Household chores, the mental load, the cooking, shopping, kids pick ups and drop offs etc etc

How do you make sure this is what actually happens though?

My husband became a SAHD for a time- and he just didn't do even the basics. It was incredibly frustrating and strained our marriage.

If someone doesn't take on the mental load- you can't make them. You can't make someone clean the bathroom or meal prep or organise a cupboard.

OP's DH doesn't sound like he's going to suddenly step up around the home. He'll have long resigned before it's clear he's not pulling it weight- and then what recourse does she have?

Thinkingofmovingtosea · 07/06/2023 12:32

honestly it sounds to me like he does not put "value" or "cost" on staying at home minding kids and running a household - like several men. When you give up work you don't give up work you are also working just a different type of work .. So if he is not even going to do this type of work and spend the time following his passion then he is taking you for granted totally.... Also the kids are older now so there is less to do maybe? ( not in all cases obvs) so more focus on cleaning/ running house and house admin etc.... ) so less childcare unless he is taxi - ing them around which happens with teens... He needs a wake up call I think.. if you really love eachother maybe a counsellor could help to talk this through... otherwise it may lead to resentment on both sides..

IFIWASAFISH · 07/06/2023 12:28

I think part time would be a great compromise to be honest.
He works less but still contributes and can also help with the house but has time for hobbies also.
You cannot just decide you want to retire without either completely independent financial back up or agreement from your partner, suppose you became ill or lost your job or such.

I understand he supported you somewhat when you stayed at home but you were providing care for small children not teens who he can clearly leave to do what they want while he goes out.

Museya15 · 07/06/2023 12:21

JMSA · 05/06/2023 19:14

YANBU. He sounds like a lazy bastard.

🤣🤣

Swipe left for the next trending thread