Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I am probably being mean but......

233 replies

razz · 05/06/2023 19:04

Its a long one so I can try not to dripfeed. When my DH and I met I had a great job, good money, own (but mortgaged!!!) house and he earnt very little but was following a passion. We had our first child, I was still the main breadwinner but have always loved working (I am not really cut out to be a SAHM!) so have never minded that. Fast forward to DC2 DH had a much better job so I gave up work (happily) to look at DC2 and then DC3 when they arrived. Went back to work after 3 years working about 30 hours a week. Over the last 7 years I have retrained (whilst working full time) and got a great job with fab prospects. I have been approached by my boss about a promotion that will be even more challenging than my current role, more travel and lots more money (likely just below 100k). DH has a good job, decent money, still a bit of a passion but not as 'fun' as he once thought it was. So to cut a long story short...if I get the new job DH says he wants to give up work. DC are now late teens, DH does very little around the house (we have never had a cleaner), doesn't decorate, repair stuff or anything like that - I have always done 90% of everything. The issue is that I don't want him to. Mainly because I don't see why he should get to do what he wants all day (he wants to spend more time on his hobby....long days out in the country with his mates) and not contribute. I dont want to give up work so it isnt jealousy. I just know he won't keep up with the household choirs like I do so I will still need to do all that and the kids dont need full time care like they did when I wasn't working. I also accept that I am probably being mean. Am I? What would you do?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Singlespies · 10/06/2023 12:29

My, now ex husband, put me in this position. I was always exhausted. We are no longer married. I now have time and money and a clean home. I resented him.

YerArseInParsley · 10/06/2023 11:59

razz · 05/06/2023 19:04

Its a long one so I can try not to dripfeed. When my DH and I met I had a great job, good money, own (but mortgaged!!!) house and he earnt very little but was following a passion. We had our first child, I was still the main breadwinner but have always loved working (I am not really cut out to be a SAHM!) so have never minded that. Fast forward to DC2 DH had a much better job so I gave up work (happily) to look at DC2 and then DC3 when they arrived. Went back to work after 3 years working about 30 hours a week. Over the last 7 years I have retrained (whilst working full time) and got a great job with fab prospects. I have been approached by my boss about a promotion that will be even more challenging than my current role, more travel and lots more money (likely just below 100k). DH has a good job, decent money, still a bit of a passion but not as 'fun' as he once thought it was. So to cut a long story short...if I get the new job DH says he wants to give up work. DC are now late teens, DH does very little around the house (we have never had a cleaner), doesn't decorate, repair stuff or anything like that - I have always done 90% of everything. The issue is that I don't want him to. Mainly because I don't see why he should get to do what he wants all day (he wants to spend more time on his hobby....long days out in the country with his mates) and not contribute. I dont want to give up work so it isnt jealousy. I just know he won't keep up with the household choirs like I do so I will still need to do all that and the kids dont need full time care like they did when I wasn't working. I also accept that I am probably being mean. Am I? What would you do?

Sounds like he thinks because u had time off it's his turn, the difference is u took care of a home and young kids. Has he said what he intends to do with his time if he gives up work? Is he going to be a house husband or does he think you're going to work hard so he has a life of leisure?

I wouldn't be happy about it at all if I were u. Maybe agree to part time but he is responsible for the upkeep of the home.

cimena · 09/06/2023 22:16

AcrossthePond55 · 09/06/2023 14:57

I don't have a problem with EITHER partner/spouse being a SAH, even after the DC are gone. My older sister has never held a paying job in her life and the 'partnership' she has with her DH works for them, both when they had DC at home and now as 'empty nesters'. And that's the key, it works for them. As long as it's by mutual agreement AND the SAH takes over full/majority household duties.

My DH was off work due to an injury for close to 2 years before he was able to return to work. During that time he carried I'd say 95% of the 'domestic workload' which worked for both of us. In fact I loved it! I eventually asked him if he wanted to stay a SAHD and he said no way, it was too much work! Plus the financial dependence issue was a concern of his, too.

IF OP's DH could be depended upon to pull his weight as a SAHS (stay at home spouse), then fine. But it sounds to me as if she can't depend on him to do that so the idea is a non-starter, just for that reason alone.

This. I earn loads (not loads loads but loads) and we’re not spendy people. He works cos he likes it and it means he has his own money which is better for both of us mentally. If he wanted to stop, I’m fine with that BUT a) he needs to looks after ALL the house and b) if I can’t work or just want to quit he’ll have to go back. And same for me if it was reversed.

if it works for you it works for you. but if I was at home with nothing to do (small children wise) I’d expect to run the full house and so I’d expect the same in reverse, and I don’t think that’s unreasonable.

AcrossthePond55 · 09/06/2023 14:57

I don't have a problem with EITHER partner/spouse being a SAH, even after the DC are gone. My older sister has never held a paying job in her life and the 'partnership' she has with her DH works for them, both when they had DC at home and now as 'empty nesters'. And that's the key, it works for them. As long as it's by mutual agreement AND the SAH takes over full/majority household duties.

My DH was off work due to an injury for close to 2 years before he was able to return to work. During that time he carried I'd say 95% of the 'domestic workload' which worked for both of us. In fact I loved it! I eventually asked him if he wanted to stay a SAHD and he said no way, it was too much work! Plus the financial dependence issue was a concern of his, too.

IF OP's DH could be depended upon to pull his weight as a SAHS (stay at home spouse), then fine. But it sounds to me as if she can't depend on him to do that so the idea is a non-starter, just for that reason alone.

Coolmom81 · 09/06/2023 13:21

I have never understood this concept of the wife working part time whilst the husband goes out to work full time (except while children are small and require some form of childcare) My mum went part time after us kids had grown up and left home leaving my step dad to continue working full time. I just don’t understand it! Unless you are contributing in another way i.e. doing all the housework on your “days off” then you work full time unless you can both afford and want to work part time. An increase in your income should mean you can go on some nice holidays or splash out a bit on a new car, nice things not have nothing to show for it except a lazy partner who will be out spending your hard earned wages. It will only lead to resentment.

Lavellan · 09/06/2023 11:30

I think you should offer that you will be happy to support him in finding a new job, even if it pays a bit less, but makes him happier.

I would say you could suggest he does some retraining but since he's already voiced the idea of not working, I'd be leery to let him to drop out of life without a clear plan.

Beautiful3 · 09/06/2023 07:46

I'm a sahp but I have actual jobs to do e.g. school run, walk the dog, wash up, clean the house, change bed sheets, paying the bills, making dinner and lunches, food shop, guiding homework. What exactly is your partner going to be doing? When my youngest turns 12 I'm looking for a job again.

My neighbour's husband told his wife, he wanted a break from work after redundancy. They had teenage sons at the time. It's now been 6 years! She went to work for most of it, now she's lost her job and he's refusing to look for one. He started drinking everyday and became an alcoholic. All they do at night is argue about money. It's really sad to hear. Because they used to look happy and enjoy going out. Now they sit in and argue.

Whataretheodds · 08/06/2023 19:18

there are loads of women who are SAHM with teenager or adult kids who literally do nothing at home as they have cleaners and spend the whole days in cafes...they get pocket money. When they divorce...

The above isn't a situation OP has suggested or signed up for, so she's rightly unhappy about it. If it works for other people, good for them.

The fact so many of these stories involve divorce surely indicates both parties aren't happy and harmonious as a result of these arrangements.

Beautiful3 · 08/06/2023 19:10

Maybe he could reduce his hours and do the housework? Otherwise he is being lazy and you'd end up resenting him.

Brightandshining · 08/06/2023 14:06

YANBU when you weren't in paid employment you were still saving you both money by doing the childcare and housework for free.. so you were still massively contributing to the family throughout. How does he intend to contribute to the family if he leaves his job? The children won't need him at home.. he doesn't do DIY or the cleaning? I'd say he's having a complete laugh wanting to be a kept man.
I'd have a discussion with him about what he thinks he's actually going to bring to the table if he quits his job. It isn't fair for him to just sponge off you getting to do whatever he wants all day long.. that isn't a stay at home dad or househusband that's just someone dossing about. Make it clear to him what you actually did when you weren't working and what you actually do every day to keep the household running outside of paid work.

Lalalalala555 · 08/06/2023 13:53

So you husband effectively just wants to stop working and have you pay for everything for him?
Whilst you go out to work?
And he's not actively trying to reassure you he will lesson your load with chores. And you don't need childcare anymore.

Lol. Just no.

Why don't you suggest on the flip side.
How about you quit work. Stop doing household chores - he can pick up what you did.
And you just spend your time having fun.
I bet he gives that a no.

Its very different when you have small kids, that have to have childcare. That aren't old enough to go to school.

Someone has to look after them, or pay for them to be looked after. So looking after them as a parent saves a childcare cost.

With his proposal, what cost is he saving? And why is he not also taking on more of a load of housework.

It just sounds all wrong.
You can't blame the man for asking hey wife, will you pay for me to just stop working and go and have fun.

But that is literally why we all have jobs. Because we need to afford to live and eat. It's a luxury not to work.
By him quitting and not working, you will be working for longer before you can retire.
As a family unit you will have less, be able to afford less, less able to afford your family financially.

It sounds like he just wants to win the lottery, but can't do that so wants to use you.

Dont feel bad.
Its very different if you offer to pay for him vs he asks.

I wouldn't pay for my partner to not work. It's just unfair. I wouldn't ask him to pay for me so I could stop working and have fun.
I

Boredandbitter · 08/06/2023 11:46

Lazy bugger. Tell him no.

boomboom109283 · 08/06/2023 07:12

There is no way he should be reducing hours if he has no plan to contribute towards retirement and pay off the mortgage. The fact you have a new higher paying job means you can reach those goals collectively sooner not that he can just stop working.

Aishah231 · 08/06/2023 07:08

Don't do it OP. You know what will happen. Resentment will grow as any promises made about work around the house will be broken.

N0ChildrenYet · 08/06/2023 06:42

Anna79ishere · 07/06/2023 20:56

I would not do it as you do not seem in a super stable financial position (no savings) despite your high salary which you might one day lose. Also if you think he won’t do anything at home you will also need to pay for help, as with such job it would be crazy for you to do everything at home, while he does nothing all day. However if he had good savings and you could afford a lot of house help, I can’t see why you should be bothered he does nothing.

there are loads of women who are SAHM with teenager or adult kids who literally do nothing at home as they have cleaners and spend the whole days in cafes, at the gym, meeting friends and at beaty centres. they get pocket money regularly l. When they divorce they get houses and very geniuses alimony, allowing them to continue the lifestyle. No one seems shocked so many of the comments in which people seem to find the situation unacceptable just show an enormous gender bias, which is really shocking.

totally agree

N0ChildrenYet · 08/06/2023 06:41

N0ChildrenYet · 08/06/2023 06:38

Totally agree on this one. There is a lot of gender bias and male hatred on this thread!

This was in reply to someone but I can’t find the message now!

N0ChildrenYet · 08/06/2023 06:38

Totally agree on this one. There is a lot of gender bias and male hatred on this thread!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 07/06/2023 22:36

No, I don’t think it’s fair for him to just give up work.

I think adults should support themselves unless looking after young children:

Your kids are far too old to need a SAHP - what would he be contributing? He wouldn’t even be doing the housework by the sounds of it.

If he did everything about the house - kept it properly clean and tidy, cooked all meals and did washing etc, plus the life admin esp for the kids - it would be ok (as long as agreed). But it sounds like he just wants to piss about.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 07/06/2023 22:30

clarewithoutani · 07/06/2023 17:27

Sounds like me n my partner. It's infuriating and also not fair. I am losing the will where he is concerned. Have aid out for everything over the years, took a less demanding job with a big salary cut but still paid out childcare, etc. I don't have a pension because of this while he does and he buys coats and trainers all the frickin time.

Why do you tolerate this?

randomfemthinker · 07/06/2023 22:13

If I was earning 100k over a job I enjoyed I would be fine with my partner not working as a "wage slave" over less enjoyment over it but they'd need to fully contribute over "house husband" role, leaving you both free to enjoy time to be together. We live in a world that "glorifies" both partner's being "run ragged" over working the same hours over paid when if two people love another, I'd have thought one less person stressed over work would add to the relationship over taking away from it, really if it's valued over time together.

Dashel · 07/06/2023 21:28

For the record, I have said the same on threads where the SAHM refuses to go back to work ever again. I think adults need to pull their weight financially regardless of gender.

Dashel · 07/06/2023 21:26

razz · 05/06/2023 19:40

Yes I guess so, but part of it is that have worked hard to get this chance and I suppose I had envisaged another 10 years of both of us saving, paying off the mortgage and getting some kind of pension. We aren't rich, no real savings but of course the new salary is huge so would make a massive difference to achieving all these goals but not without him earning some kind of salary. Maybe I compromise with part time and he does the decorating and we get a cleaner then we both get more time lol!

No way would I leave DH to pay the mortgage and sort out proper pensions. Fuck that. What happens if you get sick or decide you don’t want to work?

You are going to work years longer than you need to, so he can retire early and play.

DH both want to retire early so have cleared the mortgage and are increasing pensions so we can do it together. No way would I leave him to solely sort out finances.

It isn’t remotely fair that he has even asked this, I would be fuming. You should be working towards common goals not you having to work to support a man child.

Anna79ishere · 07/06/2023 21:01

Yes but the SAHM Witt baby and toddler last a few year, then they keep on being SAHM doing really nothing (especially when they have help). So in a 45 year working career, the SAHM work keys say full time 5 years, part time 15 years and the the rest 25 years basically do nothing. This men in his 50 has worked 30 years and he will do nothing for 15 years. So actually he has worked more than a SAHM!

Anna79ishere · 07/06/2023 20:56

I would not do it as you do not seem in a super stable financial position (no savings) despite your high salary which you might one day lose. Also if you think he won’t do anything at home you will also need to pay for help, as with such job it would be crazy for you to do everything at home, while he does nothing all day. However if he had good savings and you could afford a lot of house help, I can’t see why you should be bothered he does nothing.

there are loads of women who are SAHM with teenager or adult kids who literally do nothing at home as they have cleaners and spend the whole days in cafes, at the gym, meeting friends and at beaty centres. they get pocket money regularly l. When they divorce they get houses and very geniuses alimony, allowing them to continue the lifestyle. No one seems shocked so many of the comments in which people seem to find the situation unacceptable just show an enormous gender bias, which is really shocking.

FinallyHere · 07/06/2023 18:37

Dacadactyl · 05/06/2023 19:15

Tbh if you like working and he doesn't, it wouldn't bother me. But, he'd need to do the housework.

I'd just tell him "I want to see how you get on first, so for a while I want you to take on all the housework and if you do it, then that's fine. But you can't just not have a job, nor do housework"

This

Not sure what to do if he doesn't step up, or steps up for a few weeks then relapses once he has given up work

How would you not resent him, if he didn't step up on the housework ?

Swipe left for the next trending thread