Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU VET BILL £5700

454 replies

bellewilson · 05/06/2023 19:00

Long story apologies- We own a beautiful Exotic cat she is one year old. Perfectly healthy took for one year vaccinations and she had a bad reaction temp and loss of appetite and started getting wobbly on back legs after 6 days. Obviously back and forth to local vet but when became wobbly local vet suggested she was better off being assessed in local veterinary hospital. Take her there (have insurance with £4k limit was supposed to be their top of range superior plus policy) vet hospital assessed her and said we need to admit her for tests and suspected neurological FIP (cat coronavirus) sedated her and did X-ray and scans and biopsies of fluid found in chest and abdomen and blood tests. Only had her in for 24hours and bill was £3150 took a week to finally get results as positive for FIP carrier with low probability of infection which means with her ongoing symptoms they think she has neurological FIP. So as now 7 days later our cat has got more poorly not eating or drinking having to syringe feed/drink. Re-admitted to hospital and they agree to only do minimal care to keep her comfortable whilst antivirals drugs kick in (drip and appetite stimulation) and would cost max £280 a night admitted for 3 days and everyday checked with vet the bill and costs and how much left on insurance. Collected today to be told owe £5700 so £1700 over insurance. Was expecting £600 max but £1100 more than I was told on the phone several times is a joke. Ask for bill breakdown and it’s CF at its best and laughable they can actually get away with it… from working it out the initial £3150 they have charged approx £1400 just for sedation to do the X-ray £450 and ultrasound £680 plus extra for biopsy and tests plus nursing care and £450 consultation. I made it completely clear to them we couldn’t afford a large bill and they agreed all along to do a direct claim with our insurance company and get pre authorised payments from them through a portal. Turns out didn’t do that either so if insurance doesn’t pay we have to. What can we do. I have Googled and average cost for Anastasia for a cat is £300/400 in Uk so how can they charge 4x the average cost. AIBU? Any advice please so stressed.

OP posts:
Chatillon · 06/06/2023 20:19

Vets' bills are terribly high. I took our poorly chicken to the local veterinary practice. He pulled out his stethoscope and listened to her abdomen. He shook his head sadly and said the hen is dead.

I implored him to do more tests. Sometimes hen's get cold-shock in the wind and will lay horizontal in a temporary state of torpor. He left the room and 10 mins later came in with a large Labrador. It sniffed all round my chicken, eventually gave up and left the room after shaking its head at the vet. Then he went out and brought a cat in. He lifted it onto the table and it also sniffed all round the hen before miaowing softly and shaking its head. The vet turned to us and said "I can now guarantee your hen is 100% dead".

We paid the small fee for her to be cremated and then at the reception desk his colleague presented us with a bill for £475. We were astonished. I said why such a large fee? The vet said it was £75 for the initial consultation, but an additional £150 for the Cat Scan and £250 for the Lab Report.

2023forme · 06/06/2023 20:07

adularia · 06/06/2023 18:50

You pay a lower rate if you have an emergency appointment, as I’ve had this before when I’ve been surprised at the low cost which included treatment.

Reading this I’m shocked at how little vets get paid, they deserve much more. We are lucky we have a lovely vets who don’t overcharge and sometimes don’t charge us at all for a quick check. It’s still expensive though. We have insurance and would never be without - we’ve had a few cats over the years and you never know when something will happen which will cost thousands. We’ve never had an issue with our insurance paying out. I wouldn’t have a cat without it (though premiums can get crazy when they get older). It’s saved us many thousands - it only takes them needing one simple op and it can cost a couple of thousand.

it was an emergency appointment!!!

Doris86 · 06/06/2023 19:50

hartof · 05/06/2023 19:07

Vet costs are insane. Our cat was recently in for 4nights as he'd eaten flip flop which caused a blockage. I got the itemised bill and they charge £86 for a bag of fluids!

Yes vet costs are normally expensive . However the ones quoted by the OP are on another level entirely.

EbonyRaven · 06/06/2023 19:47

Teateaandmoretea · 06/06/2023 19:19

It just frankly sums up modern life that any criticism/ discussion/ having a different opinion is bashing.

Being a vet is a shit job for sure these days which is sad but people are still allowed to question their philosophy and motives including the role of vulture capitalists.

Exactly this. ^ I am sick to death of hearing 'oooh I hate vet bashing!' It's a public chat forum, many MANY people have had bad experiences with rip-off vets, and yes, many of them DO take the piss. Like fuck am I not going to speak out because people go 'ooooh but vet bashing!' Hmm Some of them deserve it. Deal with it. Some are fine of course, and only charge what they need to, and do care about the animals AND the owners. Some do not.

eg.. This is just ONE example on this thread, and one of many in real life.

@RiderGirl · Today 16:38

When my mum's dog was very clearly dying of a failing liver (his abdomen was swollen with ascites which was drained once but soon swelled again), the fucking vets tried to guilt trip her into doing all sorts of interventional treatments on him, which at best would have bought him a few more weeks of life.

He was an old boy, she rang me in bits not knowing what to do but I think really she was seeking reassurance that PTS was the best thing for him. Of course I said put him down while he still had a bit of dignity left. I was disgusted really that the vets would even consider suggesting further treatment for a clearly dying dog, with an owner who was struggling to pay the bills as it was.

An example (of many!) of a vet trying to make multiple 1000s out of a vulnerable woman, like with the women in the post I made earlier with a pitbull cross who is paralysed from the waist down and shits herself in the house 3-4 times a day. Vet refuses to euthanize as the dog is not in pain, and prefers to take 1000s of ££££ off the woman in scans and x-rays and treatment for the dog, that is 90% of the way through its natural life anyway.

There are far too many posts on this thread now, from far too many posters, for there to be no truth in what is being said about SOME vets. Their prices are outlandish, and they do rip people off. Letting older pets live when they have multiple things wrong with them (or something serious/life affecting,) and taking multiple 1000s of £££ off their owners; (rather than putting them to sleep,) should actually be against the law.

AGAIN, I re-iterate, not ALL vets are rip-off merchants, but it's delusional and fanciful to say there are not SOME who are. Like with NHS workers, and surgeons, doctors, nurses, opticians, dentists etc; whilst some do a lot of good, and are often valuable to society, they should not be above criticism, and they should certainly be called into question when they cross the line/do wrong/try to rip people off.

Secretvet · 06/06/2023 19:35

@Teateaandmoretea it is a sore point with so many vets as we seem to be the focus of a lot of very unneeded and unfair criticism. It has been pointed out numerous times on this thread that vet wages are not high, and a lot less than doctors for instance. And yet we still get all the criticism for being money grabbers, only in it for the money etc. I’ve been at social functions, most recently a wedding, where someone asked what I did. As soon as I said I was a vet they instantly said “oh well you’re all just money grabbing chancers aren’t you?” I mean it was very rude and unnecessary. And as for the “if vets really loved animals they would do it for nothing” comment that also makes a regular appearance. So should mechanics do it for nothing as they love cars?

Just maybe all stop to think that vets are real people with real feelings. And have a suicide rate more than double that of other professions. Look up Not One More Vet. Yes there are greedy corporations behind many practices now. But there are also decent vets working for them who have no choice about the fees set. And some of us, like our practice, are proudly independent and do the very best we can for a mostly very grateful client base.

Ohhoho · 06/06/2023 19:31

The last time I took my dog to vets was for an unusual looking bleeding spot on her nose, the first vet saw me in the car park in the dark in the rain (during lockdown) she prescribed wide spectrum antibiotic injection told me she didn’t know and to come back in week if hadn’t cleared. and charged me £100.
I wanted to see a vet in consultation room so went to other vets who allowed that, he said he would have to admit her for a biopsy for £750 the next day, I rang up and cancelled it. The Spot had completely cleared in a week. It was as Google told me, and the other vet had covered, a bacterial infection from soil not an extremely rare nose cancer…
I think the spiral of expensive insurance over expensive treatments has got completely out of hand. I could give you more anecdotes of other vets I have tried and dumped because of mis-diagnosis, and expensive bad practice, it is such a shame. They should give you a choice of minimal cheap treatment and no holds barred expensive treatment and not just look at your insurance plan. Which are full of exclusions. I once took my puppy to vet because I was worried she hadn’t poo’d and perhaps she had eaten a chicken bone at the park… he assured me, told me to wait for few more days, gave me treatment, I paid the bill. I found out later from my insurers that she was no longer insured for any ailments due to digestion even though I had not claimed.
They play on peoples guilt and use emotional blackmail.
I feel very sorry for people who are struggling financially already. Thank goodness for the PDSA which I support and donate monthly because there for the grace of god go I, and all of us.
am very sorry to hear of your cats trials and your bill OP 😢

weirdoboelady · 06/06/2023 19:27

I haven't read every post, just most plus the OP's, so apologies if this has already been pointed out.

There are two different problems here. The first is the high charges made by the vet. There have been several posts by vets and others on here justifying these in general terms, and although this vet seems to have been on the higher end, this may not be a winnable argument.

The second problem is more serious - and winnable - IMHO. This is the fact that the OP was in regular contact with the surgery and trying to limit costs and stress that there was a budget maximum. This communication seems to have been totally ignored, and the surgery seems to have ignored the customer's wishes and simply incurred as much cost as it felt like. This argument should be totally winnable. Point out to them in writing that they disregarded clear instructions, misled you about how much cost had been incurred, and then presented you with a bill you cannot pay. Tell them that you are prepared to fight this legally. Pay the first £4000 (less whatever your insurance company refund) since you instructed them to limit treatment to £4000 (assuming I have understood your posts correctly).

You then have the choice of letting them sue you for the rest of the bill, which they will be silly to do if you have explained clearly that they ignored your instructions, or paying the rest of the bill and taking them to the small claims court for the additional money. (I'm a bit vague about the route 2 option, as is probably clear).

Teateaandmoretea · 06/06/2023 19:19

Ohgollymolly · 06/06/2023 19:14

… what did you expect?

I hate vet bashing. They’re highly skilled and have taken on lots of debt to train. Why shouldn’t they get paid for it?

We don’t bash Doctors and Nurses for wanting more money out of the poor NHS piss pot.

It just frankly sums up modern life that any criticism/ discussion/ having a different opinion is bashing.

Being a vet is a shit job for sure these days which is sad but people are still allowed to question their philosophy and motives including the role of vulture capitalists.

Lochjeda · 06/06/2023 19:16

Thats ridiculous, our dog was ill and was in the vets for three nights and the vet hospital with one to one care for 3 nights. She has loads of bloods, scans, xrays, meds done at both places multiple times and the bill was 2300. They are ripping the utter piss.

Teateaandmoretea · 06/06/2023 19:16

A lot of people expect their animals to be treated and managed with absolute gold standard care, whereas back in the day much less diagnostics would be done and therefore a lot more pets would die - but vet bills were cheaper!

No pets get out of this alive you know. There is a bizarre guilt tripping to your post with the drama about pets dying.

As you are a vet you clearly believe in all these modern treatments. Many people believe it was actually better when treatments for animals were simpler, however.

Mumm1993 · 06/06/2023 19:14

Stuff like this isn’t down to the vets themselves but the drug companies.
LEGALLY as vets we HAVE to prescribe veterinary licensed products if one exists. We can get in real trouble if we don’t. And we have no option but to charge what the drug companies charge us.

That being said I will often “strongly advise” some dog paracetamol but also casually mention it’s exactly the same stuff you can get from Tesco’s “and I can’t force you to buy it from me” blah blah. Then leave it to the owners to decline the treatment and go and buy it from tescos!

most vets really do try their best to make sure animals are not suffering and to ease the financial cost to the owners but often our hands are completely tied

Ohgollymolly · 06/06/2023 19:14

… what did you expect?

I hate vet bashing. They’re highly skilled and have taken on lots of debt to train. Why shouldn’t they get paid for it?

We don’t bash Doctors and Nurses for wanting more money out of the poor NHS piss pot.

Mumm1993 · 06/06/2023 19:07

As a vet myself all I can really see as the issue here is possibly a lack of communication from your vets rather than the costs themselves.
£5700 for diagnosis of FIP in a specialist centre, including a few vials of remdesivir (incredibly expensive and most practices will book this out with no/very little mark up) actually seems very average/reasonable.

A lot of people expect their animals to be treated and managed with absolute gold standard care, whereas back in the day much less diagnostics would be done and therefore a lot more pets would die - but vet bills were cheaper!

the sedation will not have cost £1400, there will be more to it than that. And unfortunately £4K of insurance is normally the minimum amount of cover offered for a lot of insurance companies. Most reputable insurance companies offer £12-15k as their premium policies.

I promise you that vets are not making as much money as you think - the overheads are HUGE and the amount of staff and equipment and expensive drugs used to diagnose and treat your cat with a disease that was until recently impossible to diagnose to treat will be a lot more than you could imagine!

eyestotheskies1 · 06/06/2023 19:06

OP I’m sorry you’re in this situation.

I learned my lesson regarding pet insurance after my 12 year old cat fell ill suddenly - I could tell he was extremely unwell and when I took him to the vets they said he would die if they didn’t do anything- 6 hours of tests later and he was PTS 😔 leaving me with a £2k bill I’m still paying off.

I wish they’d been honest about how ill he was, I felt unable to make a rational decision with my two young kids with me absolutely heartbroken.

Rosscameasdoody · 06/06/2023 19:06

Our cat was diagnosed with lymphoma and over 15 months of treatment at our local University’s small animal hospital, our insurance covered £16000 worth of treatment which involved monthly consultations and supplies of chemo tablets and antibiotics, and several overnight stays for more intensive treatment. Before the insurance company authorised direct billing from the hospital, I received itemised copies of each bill and they were horrendous. At the end, the bill for euthanasia was over £300.

I’d recommend everyone to shop around for pet insurance because some are a lot better than others, and generally if you pay a bit more you get better cover, but watch the small print. Most won’t pay for dental problems or pre-existing conditions, so be careful about swapping insurance companies if your pet has already been diagnosed with a condition of any kind. We have insurance for our little dog with the same provider, as they were great when our cat was ill. We’re with ManyPets and among some other really good benefits, they provide £15000 of cover each year, dental treatment in the case of illness or injury and 24/7 access to FirstVet service - video calling with a vet online.

Cerealkillerontheloose · 06/06/2023 19:02

bellewilson · 05/06/2023 20:20

I made it clear from outset when first admitted we couldn’t go over our limit on insurance and they said they would get treatment pre approved through insurance portal to make sure covered and not go over limit. Yes animal friends they had good reviews and took their top policy. Never had pet insurance and googled average cost of treatment for operations etc and £4k seemed good (stupid now but hindsight is a wonderful thing) I work in insurance industry and read policy but not knowing costs of vet specialists how are you supposed to know limits are low? Their first bill was £3150 and obviously when re admitted a week later every day I asked costs and total bill and what was left on insurance before I agreed for them to keep her in and on treatments. There was another bill for £600 for FIP antivirals I had paid a £300 deposit so when she had £550 left on insurance for her stay and we would cover the rest being told £250-£280 a day (so potentially only a few hundred worst case maybe £600 to pay) and them confirming all prices etc everyday…then to get a bill of £1700 over my limit from no where when it wasn’t agreed. That is what I am moaning about plus the initial bill seems excessive for 1hr of sedation at £1400 is way over the top. One injection of ATIPAM cost £616 (on top of sedation costs and other medications and vet costs etc) I have Googled how much this medicine costs and it’s £50 a bottle. X

At the end of the day the extra £1400 which you said is laughable is actually good value for money

mt cars £6700 yearly bill was 27 years ago!!! Today it’s over £13,000

dpesnt matter if you can’t afford it. That’s how much animals are…. They won’t stop care if you can’t afford it will they?

Lemieux3 · 06/06/2023 19:00

How would you prove that the vaccines caused FIP?

Cerealkillerontheloose · 06/06/2023 19:00

My cat was healthy and then suddenly developed bad breathing. After (many) tests it turned out his heart was too big

ge had a cardiologist appointment once a year and it was £6700. For one day. Every. Single. Year

we did however have cat insurance so he was already insured before that. His first years insurance was £10 a month

by the time he passed it was £150 a month.

people don’t realise how expensive vets are and you should really be putting aside £200 a month. I had a veteran horse and she was a good £1000 a month at the grand old age of 35. It happens.

minpin · 06/06/2023 18:59

It’s interesting that your cat was fine until it went in for vaccinations. Perhaps the vet should be compensating you for injuring your cat. I’m so sorry.

Inwiththenew · 06/06/2023 18:57

Did they make you aware that there were any risks involved with the jab? If you weren’t given informed consent you may have a case . You should be entitled to compensation from somewhere.

adularia · 06/06/2023 18:50

2023forme · 06/06/2023 15:55

@Newuser82 @Maireas yes it was NHS dentist - I was quite shocked myself as I’d expect to pay nearer to £35 for a filling. But this time only £16 for some reason.

You pay a lower rate if you have an emergency appointment, as I’ve had this before when I’ve been surprised at the low cost which included treatment.

Reading this I’m shocked at how little vets get paid, they deserve much more. We are lucky we have a lovely vets who don’t overcharge and sometimes don’t charge us at all for a quick check. It’s still expensive though. We have insurance and would never be without - we’ve had a few cats over the years and you never know when something will happen which will cost thousands. We’ve never had an issue with our insurance paying out. I wouldn’t have a cat without it (though premiums can get crazy when they get older). It’s saved us many thousands - it only takes them needing one simple op and it can cost a couple of thousand.

Username33141973 · 06/06/2023 18:49

Missingmyusername · 05/06/2023 19:25

It’s not vet bashing.

It’s greed. Pure and simple. I know a vet and she’s left the practice due to greedy partners, rising charges, tearful owners.

This - it’s not vet bashing I agree. I took my old cat to the vet this morning just for an injection (£178 please 🙄). Arrived dead on time. The vet strolled in 10 mins later then took another 10 mins doing who knows what before I was called in. No explanation, no apology. While I was waiting, I looked around at the place - absolutely gone to pot. Shelves that used to hold nice displays are empty, everywhere is FILTHY, noticeboards not updated (be aware of hedgehogs in your bonfire!) and there is a general air of neglect. And the prices keep rising - the cat’s other meds that very recently cost £47/month are now charged at well over £60. It’s money grabbing - that’s all. And don’t get me started on the fucking insurance companies - thieving bastards one and all!!

Gingernan · 06/06/2023 18:46

It is a lot, I'd have to do go fund me, though I know treatment for FIP is quite new and very intensive. I hope your cat recovers.
We've recently paid getting on for £2000 for our rabbit. Luckily we have had help from friends. We had to take her to a specialist rabbit vet.

Birkridge51 · 06/06/2023 18:44

My crazy dog had to have 2 major surgeries last week after breaking her elbow and leg. The vet at my local practice had to bring in a specialist to help as both surgeries were very complex.
The final bill was £9200, which we had to pay up front and we are now keeping our fingers crossed that the insurance pays out.
Luckily I'd taken out a good policy so have cover up to £10,000. We do however have to pay an excess of £80 and 20% of the final value. The vet explained that insurance policies haven't increased their cover in line with the increase in policy costs and £2000 of cover Will actually get you very little. It's only when the worst happens that you realise how much cover you actually need.
The figures do seem outrageous, but I can't thank my vets enough for their expertise, care and specialist knowledge that they obviously have in order to rebuild my dog's leg.

Ttpetals · 06/06/2023 18:43

Our cat was eventually diagnosed with FIP in March it took over £1,000 before they realised it was FIP. I currently pay £28.70 per tablet you need to have 84 tablets (12 weeks) of treatment. We have 13 days to go.

Swipe left for the next trending thread