Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU VET BILL £5700

454 replies

bellewilson · 05/06/2023 19:00

Long story apologies- We own a beautiful Exotic cat she is one year old. Perfectly healthy took for one year vaccinations and she had a bad reaction temp and loss of appetite and started getting wobbly on back legs after 6 days. Obviously back and forth to local vet but when became wobbly local vet suggested she was better off being assessed in local veterinary hospital. Take her there (have insurance with £4k limit was supposed to be their top of range superior plus policy) vet hospital assessed her and said we need to admit her for tests and suspected neurological FIP (cat coronavirus) sedated her and did X-ray and scans and biopsies of fluid found in chest and abdomen and blood tests. Only had her in for 24hours and bill was £3150 took a week to finally get results as positive for FIP carrier with low probability of infection which means with her ongoing symptoms they think she has neurological FIP. So as now 7 days later our cat has got more poorly not eating or drinking having to syringe feed/drink. Re-admitted to hospital and they agree to only do minimal care to keep her comfortable whilst antivirals drugs kick in (drip and appetite stimulation) and would cost max £280 a night admitted for 3 days and everyday checked with vet the bill and costs and how much left on insurance. Collected today to be told owe £5700 so £1700 over insurance. Was expecting £600 max but £1100 more than I was told on the phone several times is a joke. Ask for bill breakdown and it’s CF at its best and laughable they can actually get away with it… from working it out the initial £3150 they have charged approx £1400 just for sedation to do the X-ray £450 and ultrasound £680 plus extra for biopsy and tests plus nursing care and £450 consultation. I made it completely clear to them we couldn’t afford a large bill and they agreed all along to do a direct claim with our insurance company and get pre authorised payments from them through a portal. Turns out didn’t do that either so if insurance doesn’t pay we have to. What can we do. I have Googled and average cost for Anastasia for a cat is £300/400 in Uk so how can they charge 4x the average cost. AIBU? Any advice please so stressed.

OP posts:
MadisonAvenue · 05/06/2023 21:56

Our 11 year old dog is diabetic. When he was first diagnosed our vet was charging us £60 for four insulin cartridges, four week’s worth, and £55 for a box of 100 needles which screw onto the insulin pen.
Once I became more familiar with the condition I discovered that with a vet prescription I could buy the insulin online at a cost of £72 for ten cartridges (plus £13 for the prescription). The biggest rip off was the needles. I found that some meant for humans also fitted the insulin pen and a box of 100 was £4.20.

By law he has to have a health check every six months due to being on a controlled drug, that costs £220 due to having blood tests.

Last year he developed cataracts and we paid £5200 for surgery to remove those. He was at the specialist vet for 8am and we had a call at noon to say that the surgery had been successful but he was unsettled so could we go and sit with him. However, we weren’t allowed inside due to Covid restrictions so we spent 5 hours sitting on the grass outside the surgery with him (it was rural so not like we were sat at the side of a busy road) with a nurse coming out every hour to check on him. He didn’t get the proper post-op recuperation inside which we paid for though. Must say though that the vet there was very upfront with pricing as he initially needed a number of eye drops and all of those used were also human ones available from a pharmacy so we were advised to get them that way. One in particular was priced at £53 from the vet and £4 from a pharmacy.

KnittedCardi · 05/06/2023 21:55

My current (not for long) vet, recently built a state of the art animal practice. It is on a standard with the local private hospital. It has four! Receptionists. It has fancy lights, comfy sofas, fresh flowers. There prices have quadrupled and the last (and final) time U went they spent half an hour trying to upsell treatments for my perfectly healthy cat.

The original partner resigned, and has set up back where we all started, in a converted house down the road. Everyone has decamped back.

The super expensive flashy new vets are now struggling for customers. It's the care you want, not the bells and whistles.

Toomanycaketins · 05/06/2023 21:54

I don’t understand the outrage at veterinary costs… particularly dentistry.

If you only went to the dentist every 10-20 (dog) years, never brushed your teeth, hunted mice or chewed on sticks and bones, then turned up at a private dentist with bad breath or a swelling on the side of your face… they would be X-ray, filling and extracting the hell out of your mouth.

it would cost a fortune, and it would be very unlikely the dentist would squeeze you into a packed ops list and lose their lunch break, because they didn’t want you waiting in pain to get treatment (as vets frequently do)

dentistry is easily one of the most time consuming and technically difficult work vets do if done properly.

Maireas · 05/06/2023 21:53

cansu · 05/06/2023 21:53

tbh if my cat needed care that was expensive and beyond my insurance policy, I would have to have it put to sleep.

I think that's sensible.

cansu · 05/06/2023 21:53

tbh if my cat needed care that was expensive and beyond my insurance policy, I would have to have it put to sleep.

Maireas · 05/06/2023 21:52

Can you not communicate that to the vet, @EilonwyWithRedGoldHair , maybe say how much you're prepared to pay?.

EffortlessDesmond · 05/06/2023 21:52

Pets are a luxury, not a right, and vet bills should not be minimised because vets are animal lovers. Vets are professionals and should be recompensed properly. My (brilliant) vet who knows when to refer to an expert, and when not to, uses specialists who have stayed aloof from the commercialisation of veterinary medicine. But it's a tiny rural practice, and I am sure she turns out to deliver calves for her farmer DP on a regular basis too.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 05/06/2023 21:51

Maireas · 05/06/2023 20:00

This. People would be horrified if they knew the full costs of medical care. Just because it's an animal doesn't make it cheaper..

I get that. What I wonder about is the extreme lengths vets will sometimes go to and if it's always in the best interests of the animal.

In the past I'd be presented with options and the pros and cons of each would be discussed - so elderly cat with thyroid problems, we went with daily medication rather than the surgical option that might not have worked or a third option that would have involved him having to go elsewhere for treatment and being kept there for up to two weeks. Even if we'd had the money for the third option I think the stress would have killed him while he happily took the tablets everyday and they cost £30/mth.

Now when we go to the vet they seem to jump to the expensive option straightaway, and I need to push for alternatives and the discussion of pros and cons. I don't want to keep my cats alive at any cost, I want them to have a decent quality of life and to do what's best for them (within what is affordable to us).

Trixiefirecracker · 05/06/2023 21:50

Sadly pets are a luxury not a right. Everyone should be thinking very carefully about how much they might have to be prepared to spend on a poorly animal and research the costs well. If you can’t afford the extortionate insurance, don’t get the animal in the first place. The only thing I can suggest is asking the vet if they have a payment plan in place.

OnTheBoardwalk · 05/06/2023 21:50

PetPlan pay without quibble.

agree they don’t. My vet used to accept them and didn’t make you pay upfront but now they dont

i can see why vets don’t want to be a collection agency if insurance don’t pay out

randomfemthinker · 05/06/2023 21:48

Pets seem to be considered the "standard norm" in society but for me there's no way I could afford a pet and haven't really ever felt the main drive to do so, tbh. I like cats and enjoy bonding with other people's cats and I'd love to go to a cat cafe sometime but I am not in a position to have one of my own and like you say, OP, you just don't really know what the costs can end up being, even with pet insurance. I'm sorry you are having to deal with all this and over hard decisions.

Thesharkradar · 05/06/2023 21:38

People have the attitude where they think vets should be cheap because it’s helping animals and it’s some sort of charity!
I often have the impression that pet owners feel they are doing something heroic by having a pet, something akin to saving an endangered species.
It's a hobby though isnt it- something you do for your own entertainment & amusement.

GatoradeMeBitch · 05/06/2023 21:37

PetPlan pay without quibble.

Erm, no they don't! Before my cat was insured I took her to the vet because she had something stuck between two teeth and I couldn't get it. Since then I'd insured her. An annual check-up picked up that she needed two teeth extracted, and PetPlan refused to pay out because of her previous medical history. I asked how getting a piece of straw stuck in her gum could cause her to lose teeth elsewhere in her mouth, but apparently it could be a thing and they won't cover anything to do with her teeth or gums. Buggers.

Maireas · 05/06/2023 21:36

upanddownandupanddown · 05/06/2023 21:35

The most shocking figure on this thread is that a vet only gets paid £37.71 an hour! I’m a GP in humans and can charge £600 a day for locum work, and £100 an hour at the weekend. This is not a stealth boast, it’s just to illustrate that vets are very much not overpaid. (Or maybe GPs are overpaid?)

You're definitely not overpaid!
Sounds like most vets are underpaid..

upanddownandupanddown · 05/06/2023 21:35

Lonecatwithkitten · 05/06/2023 20:09

These prices are from the Royal Veterinary College a private business totally separate to the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons who provide no price details.
Plus if you check their website in detail they have not update their prices since December 2021.
This is the current rod to beat vets with.
Oh yes and I am 25 years qualified with various additional qualifications a snd skills the highest paid vet in my practice and I earn £37.71 per hour and I work a 45 hour week.

The most shocking figure on this thread is that a vet only gets paid £37.71 an hour! I’m a GP in humans and can charge £600 a day for locum work, and £100 an hour at the weekend. This is not a stealth boast, it’s just to illustrate that vets are very much not overpaid. (Or maybe GPs are overpaid?)

CiaoBellisima · 05/06/2023 21:33

Fruitjellies · 05/06/2023 19:14

Cue everyone saying how expensive vets are.. money grabbers etc. You only think this because you don't see your NHS bills!

It does sound a lot OP but your cat needed specialist care which I wouldn't be surprised is pricey. Equally I'd expect to be liable for the bill if insurance doesn't pay which you often don't find out until after treatment.

I was going to say similar. Healthcare is expensive. Don’t let the Tories finish off the NHS.

LizzieSiddal · 05/06/2023 21:33

If you repeatedly told them you couldn’t go I’ve the 4000 insurance limit then there’s no way you should pay them the extra money. Don’t pay them!

OnTheBoardwalk · 05/06/2023 21:32

@bellewilson The vets really should have told you when you were nearing your insurance limit. That’s the first thing my vet checks with you.

I had a £5k limit for my 17 year old cat because premiums were getting silly and I could pay a bit more if needed. they kept me informed of all costs and treatments above this limit

@Reluctantadult sorry I don’t think you'll get insurance for your dog. Most new policies only go up to 10 year max which is why I had to stay with my expensive insurance but cut the limit

mycoffeecup · 05/06/2023 21:31

Jagley · 05/06/2023 21:04

My dog managed to get hold of some grapes on a Sunday evening so out of hours. £400 to make her sick.

Out of interest what insurance companies do the vets/in the know on here recommend for solid policies? (Mine are dogs though not cats)

Op I really feel for you, when you've made it clear your limits they should be communicating with you when it gets to that point.

PetPlan pay without quibble.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 05/06/2023 21:29

EffortlessDesmond · 05/06/2023 21:23

Be grateful for the NHS. Good modern medical (and veterinary) care costs a lot. I'm old and hard of heart, and faced with a large bill for an elderly animal, my default would be to PTS. And I have an ageing but much loved dog who has had congenital musculo-skeletal issues since she was nine months old. Her middle name is Vet Bill. But now she's nearly 10, and technically geriatric in veterinary terms, if a serious new condition appeared, I would probably cut short the agony. The grief is going to be the same, whether sooner or later.

I think this is the right attitude to have. It has always come down to quality of life when I’ve had to make that decision, especially with older pets. Some cases I’ve chosen the expensive procedure with a high probability of a good quality of life. Other times I’ve declined the cheap procedure if there wasn’t a likelihood of a quality of life.

MyTruthIsOut · 05/06/2023 21:26

Wowzer!!!!

I hope you don’t end up having to pay that!

Last week my gerbil hurt the end of her tail and I was quoted £180 just to have her looked at, with a possible extra £150 for some antibiotics.

Thankfully the gerbil was fine as there was no way I would have £330 just for that.

EffortlessDesmond · 05/06/2023 21:23

Be grateful for the NHS. Good modern medical (and veterinary) care costs a lot. I'm old and hard of heart, and faced with a large bill for an elderly animal, my default would be to PTS. And I have an ageing but much loved dog who has had congenital musculo-skeletal issues since she was nine months old. Her middle name is Vet Bill. But now she's nearly 10, and technically geriatric in veterinary terms, if a serious new condition appeared, I would probably cut short the agony. The grief is going to be the same, whether sooner or later.

littleripper · 05/06/2023 21:22

I am a farmer. I vet came to my house, delivered 2 lambs, revived them (they were stuck a long time), gave them 2 injections each and heart massage. Got them latched on, came back that evening to check back, called again the next morning and have the ewe a dose of hormones to help her milk Total cost £46. Vets are truly amazing people. Small animal care has become a huge commercial business with money, not animal care at it's heart. Insurance has, unfortunately been the driver of these costs.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 05/06/2023 21:20

Applecoresweet · 05/06/2023 21:15

They probably gave your cat unnecessary tests because insurance pays. They may as well give the animals the whole works, test for everything under the sun. If you had have been uninsured they would only have conducted the necessary tests.

Insurance or not you the owner decides which tests to do.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 05/06/2023 21:16

OrwellianTimes · 05/06/2023 20:00

Every time I go to the vets I think exactly this.

if you think vets are taking the mick I suggest you spend half an hour googling the cost of medical treatment in America. I saw a video a couple days ago where a 7 year old boy was diagnosed with diabetes and needs
$3000 worth of medication a month. No insurance and the mum was trying to work out how to tell the kid.

Yup, thinks its about $6k for a standard birth?

As stated above, a lot of it is meds (separate debate on those costs of course). One guy in America was bitten by a rattlesnake and posted his invoice online - $150k for a week in hospital. Half of which was drugs.