Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU VET BILL £5700

454 replies

bellewilson · 05/06/2023 19:00

Long story apologies- We own a beautiful Exotic cat she is one year old. Perfectly healthy took for one year vaccinations and she had a bad reaction temp and loss of appetite and started getting wobbly on back legs after 6 days. Obviously back and forth to local vet but when became wobbly local vet suggested she was better off being assessed in local veterinary hospital. Take her there (have insurance with £4k limit was supposed to be their top of range superior plus policy) vet hospital assessed her and said we need to admit her for tests and suspected neurological FIP (cat coronavirus) sedated her and did X-ray and scans and biopsies of fluid found in chest and abdomen and blood tests. Only had her in for 24hours and bill was £3150 took a week to finally get results as positive for FIP carrier with low probability of infection which means with her ongoing symptoms they think she has neurological FIP. So as now 7 days later our cat has got more poorly not eating or drinking having to syringe feed/drink. Re-admitted to hospital and they agree to only do minimal care to keep her comfortable whilst antivirals drugs kick in (drip and appetite stimulation) and would cost max £280 a night admitted for 3 days and everyday checked with vet the bill and costs and how much left on insurance. Collected today to be told owe £5700 so £1700 over insurance. Was expecting £600 max but £1100 more than I was told on the phone several times is a joke. Ask for bill breakdown and it’s CF at its best and laughable they can actually get away with it… from working it out the initial £3150 they have charged approx £1400 just for sedation to do the X-ray £450 and ultrasound £680 plus extra for biopsy and tests plus nursing care and £450 consultation. I made it completely clear to them we couldn’t afford a large bill and they agreed all along to do a direct claim with our insurance company and get pre authorised payments from them through a portal. Turns out didn’t do that either so if insurance doesn’t pay we have to. What can we do. I have Googled and average cost for Anastasia for a cat is £300/400 in Uk so how can they charge 4x the average cost. AIBU? Any advice please so stressed.

OP posts:
LovePoppy · 05/06/2023 23:49

EbonyRaven · 05/06/2023 19:35

That is fucking outrageous and I have no idea how they have the bare faced cheek to charge these exorbitant prices. I am sure that someone will be along soon, to say 'well look at how much HUMANS cost for medical care lalalalala.' Save your breath. You can't compare pets to bloody humans. No WAY are any of these prices/breakdowns of the prices even remotely acceptable.

We had pets when I was a child (late 1970s and 1980s,) and always had a dog. No way was there EVER a bill that high for ANYthing. Not for anyone. It would never have been paid if there had, as no-one could have paid it as most people were brassick, didn't have access to credit, had very little savings, and would have surrendered the pet.

Someone will no doubt come along (also) and say 'but the treatments are sooo much more sophisticated now and pet vet-care has become so much more exquisite and intricate with fabulous new technology etc etc etc.' It's no more advanced now compared to the 1980s, than it was in the 1980s compared to the 1950s etc, So put that chestnut pack in its box!

I think some vets know that people have more access to money now, and better pay maybe, and that they will pay it. (Somehow.) Sure you can get pet insurance, but some conditions aren't covered, or even if they are it's only for a short spell, a year maybe, and also you struggle to get pet insurance for pets over 8 years old.

My cat's insurance TRIPLED when she hit 8, and I rang up the insurance company and said 'I am not paying that! Surely you can do cheaper!' She said 'that's it sorry.' I said 'well I will cancel it then.' She said 'sorry to see you go, have a nice day.'

Didn't give a shit that I cancelled. Didn't want an old pet registered that's all. I mean God forbid they may have to actually pay a decent amount out! Hmm

We have one cat left (aged 16.) When she has gone, we will never have any more pets. The vet fees are extortionate. And we have the preventative care (her yearly jabs/worming drops/flea drops,) and we have also had to pay multiple 100s (running into a couple of thousand) this past 2 years for dental work and things that were wrong with her ears.

Never again. As I said, vet fees were NEVER this expensive. It's scandalous! Nothing anyone says will change my mind. If people don't want 'vet-bashing,' as someone said earlier, then get them to drop the bloody prices! Hmm Utterly disgraceful what some of them charge.

and people wonder why vets have such a high rate of suicide with clients like this

Lonecatwithkitten · 05/06/2023 23:14

"What I wonder about is the extreme lengths vets will sometimes go to and if it's always in the best interests of the animal." Often you only hear one side of the story, many clients think there are cures for the more common forms of death I proud up hold the oath I took to protect the animals in my care and advocate for them when euthanasia is the best options.
As my mother in law lies dying of starvation as she has lost her swallow reflex with Alzheimer's disease I have said more than once we wouldn't allow a dog suffer like this. I wish someone was able to protect her welfare as what's going on now sure as hell doesn't.
There are areas where human medicine and veterinary medicine run in parallel and others where they diverge. There will always be people who wish the two always ran in parallel for different reasons.

Fanlover1122 · 05/06/2023 23:14

Sorry - have not read the whole thread.

depends what the terms of the contract are. Generally should be advised of approx cost and then if goes over advised as to what the bill is.

if you were not advised, you can rely on the simple law of reliance.

I work in a law firm and if we go over the bill estimate and don’t tell the client - on a strict legal basis they don’t have to pay, we get advised this in induction training!

JaceLancs · 05/06/2023 23:05

I’ve just lost 2 beloved Dcat one to old age and one suddenly quite young due to kidney blockage - when he was younger they thought he had joint problems needing surgery which would be 3-4k I had no insurance and would have had to take out a loan but would have done so because he was very young and much adored
when I get next Dcat I will research properly re insurance as it’s a minefield
however do agree we are cushioned by NHS etc - a colleague who is married to a non U.K. citizen had recently had to find £27k for surgery for MIL in country of origin - then when op did not go according to plan got billed another £23k for additional surgery and as MIL still in hospital bills are still mounting

Puddinglovespie · 05/06/2023 23:04

@bellewilson we’ve recently treated our cat for FIP (he’s alive and back to his annoying self!) the costs were astronomical! We maxed out our insurance very quickly and then had to use savings to pay for his treatment. I didn’t so much mind paying for his care because the vets were wonderful and kept him alive. The mark up on medications was what annoyed me most!
Bova (the company that makes the GS medicine) have reduced their prices in the last couple of months. They’re much much more reasonable now - we paid £600 for 10 tablets.
I’d be going back to the vets and pushing for them to reduce their prices on the meds as neuro needs a higher dose. There are support groups that can help you with FIP treatments that can tell you prices to expect and they’re very good at getting you to fight your corner at the vets. Just shout if you want some help with it

pillsthrillsandbellyache · 05/06/2023 22:58

And sorry to hear about your cat OP 💐

pillsthrillsandbellyache · 05/06/2023 22:58

I havent read full thread but for anyone struggling to pay for medication, get the prescription from the vet and buy the medication online cheaper. I felt rude doing this until my vet tried charging me £29 for a pack of antibacterial wipes. They obviously don't like you doing it but tough shit. I pay them enough for a monthly package that covers fucking nothing.

ArdeteiMasazxu · 05/06/2023 22:53

If all this was triggered by a vaccine reaction then the primary recourse should be the vaccine manufacturer, not just your personal insurance policy and certainly not your personal funds.

Our cat had a bad vaccine reaction and we didn't end up paying a penny, not even the excess on our insurance policy. I think the insurance covered some of the costs but the vaccine company covered everything that insurance didn't.

Toomanycaketins · 05/06/2023 22:52

I don’t know any vets on more than £30/hour. Maybe clinical directors/practice lead vets

JemimaTiggywinkles · 05/06/2023 22:49

Because I charge £50p/h for 1:1 tuition for gcse maths students, and I have only trained for 4 years, and am not responsible for the life of anyone's pet if I get it wrong!

I charge the same for tutoring, but that’s not most tutors’ main employment - the majority are teachers. Teachers get paid around £20-£25 per hour for normal work. Self-employed charge out rates are usually more per hour because there’s no sick pay, mat leave, paid holiday, etc. It isn’t reasonable to compare a contracted wage with a self-employed charge out rate.

A vet being paid £35 per hour works out at nearly £70k per year - a good salary considering national average is around £33k.

HappyNannie · 05/06/2023 22:45

Vets charges are Totally outrageous!!
We pay because we love our animals.
Must admit it terrifies me at the thought of the NHS getting systematically dismantled and outrageous medical bills for a family member
It's well known people have had to sell their homes and declare bankruptcy in America to pay medical bills.
I hope there is someone who can help point you in the right direction of a veterinary ombudsman who can scrutinise your bill.
Hope you're kitty 🐈‍⬛ is feeling better soon xx

Toomanycaketins · 05/06/2023 22:45

BotterMon · 05/06/2023 22:30

Sorry your cat is so sick OP.

Referral vets are always expensive due to their expertise and equipment.

Try and use independent vets not those who have been bought up by Private Equity firms who are just in it for the money. CVS Group being one of the worst.

If the first question your vet asks is "Is your pet insured?" run a mile.

I think this is a little unfair.

finding out if a pet is insured helps broach the issue of referral costs and whether this is even an option for this client. Because clients love their animals it can be a very delicate conversation to feel a way through with them, what are they prepared to do, how much are they able to spend, without making it all about money or the client feeling that they are letting their animal down if they can’t afford gold standard medicine, almost everyone has a financial limit.

You do also occasionally meet people who don’t understand that all the money and super vets in the world can’t save their pet or turn the clock back on ageing. There are also people who want everything done, declare money is no object, with absolutely no intention of paying a penny, running up debt in every practice in town. medicine is definitely an art with a side order of psychology.

the vet is trying to work out they have the means that allows the vet to do gold standard medicine, get a firm diagnosis, prescribe the best treatment, or make an informed guess at what they think is going on, based on the information in front of them, interpreted through their own experience. Sometimes the conversation may go that they could do x y or z tests but the treatment for all the likely conditions would be the same, however having a diagnosis would inform on the likely success of this treatment and future prognosis.

a lot of clients do seem to think that vets have a crystal ball… often you only know if a test was necessary once you get the results back, many things involve a process of elimination. Unfortunately you can’t just plug them into one of those machines that they have at the car dealership and see which error code comes up.

TheThinkingGoblin · 05/06/2023 22:43

Toomanycaketins · 05/06/2023 21:54

I don’t understand the outrage at veterinary costs… particularly dentistry.

If you only went to the dentist every 10-20 (dog) years, never brushed your teeth, hunted mice or chewed on sticks and bones, then turned up at a private dentist with bad breath or a swelling on the side of your face… they would be X-ray, filling and extracting the hell out of your mouth.

it would cost a fortune, and it would be very unlikely the dentist would squeeze you into a packed ops list and lose their lunch break, because they didn’t want you waiting in pain to get treatment (as vets frequently do)

dentistry is easily one of the most time consuming and technically difficult work vets do if done properly.

My cat had serious FCGS (FCV positive as he was a reacue) and required a full mouth extraction, with 3 days post-op care (at the Hospital), plus 1 month of medication (4 meds). This was a complex surgery that used a specialist dental vet surgeon (as you need specialist xrays to make sure all the tooth remnants are gone).

This was in the South in 2019.

I paid £3,500 all in with my insurer eventually covering it all (policy was £10k max).

What OP posted is absolutely ridiculous for a cat. Prices are way inflated and it definitely looks like they padded the bill.

rowbotham · 05/06/2023 22:34

MathsRocksMathsRocks · 05/06/2023 19:55

@GCalltheway I hope you're joking that you think £35 p/h is a reasonable hourly rare for a vet? Is this assuming they get no cut of treatment fees? Because I charge £50p/h for 1:1 tuition for gcse maths students, and I have only trained for 4 years, and am not responsible for the life of anyone's pet if I get it wrong!

We have pets. We have excellent insurance. Our vets are amazing (and charge very fairly from experience - 2 of our pets have lifelong conditions with daily meds all covered every year bar the excess, and routine checks also charged fairly) Definitely worth more than £35p/h!

I wish !
Self employed
£32 per hour
No holiday, sick pay etc
And I pay my own professional subscription and indemnity insurance
Might take up tutoring instead Grin

Fingeronthebutton · 05/06/2023 22:34

I know this won’t help, but, 7 private equity companies own all the vet surgeries in the uk. Their investors want their pound of flesh 😡

BotterMon · 05/06/2023 22:30

Sorry your cat is so sick OP.

Referral vets are always expensive due to their expertise and equipment.

Try and use independent vets not those who have been bought up by Private Equity firms who are just in it for the money. CVS Group being one of the worst.

If the first question your vet asks is "Is your pet insured?" run a mile.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 05/06/2023 22:30

Maireas · 05/06/2023 21:52

Can you not communicate that to the vet, @EilonwyWithRedGoldHair , maybe say how much you're prepared to pay?.

It was more about the range of options used to be presented. Now to get that I have to push for it. Outside of emergency situations, there should be time to discuss possible treatments and for the best to explain why they recommend one over another.

Jacopo · 05/06/2023 22:26

People have much higher expectations of their pets nowadays, and the treatments available have become commensurately sophisticated and therefore more expensive. In the past people did love their pets but there was no talk of “fur babies” and the dog’s name was not included on Christmas cards etc they way they are now. So animals just got pts rather going through weeks or months of treatment which they frankly cannot comprehend and which in some cases prolongs their suffering.
Sorry but some of these pet owners need to get real.

DisquietintheRanks · 05/06/2023 22:24

adriftinadenofvipers · 05/06/2023 20:47

I sincerely hope you don't have any pets.

Why? You can love and care for an animal without pissing away all your money on it when it's sick. Animals die, that's nature. Our job as owners is not to let them suffer

bonfirebash · 05/06/2023 22:19

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/06/2023 21:58

The worst thing that happened to animal care was pet insurance - it gave a green light to many vets to put their prices through the roof.

This is why animals don't receive the care they need a lot of the time now - and even euthanasia is phenomenally expensive (9 years ago had to have a cat euthanised - it was £95! God knows what it is now. This is why many people dump sick animals, or keep them alive even though they are in obvious distress..

£240 for my cat a week ago, including getting his ashes back but there was other options cheaper
I didn't pay, some kind friends did who said I shouldn't have to feel like I was paying to end his life and cleared his whole vet bill for me

Retsof · 05/06/2023 22:11

Tell them to listen to their call recordings and honor their previous statements.

EffortlessDesmond · 05/06/2023 22:08

Veterinary paracetamol is exactly the same as human paracetamol, but you obviously need to alter/reduce the dose for body weight. And the same is true of human medication: I had a post surgical infection over a long weekend, so while being turned away from A&E, I borrowed a dose of co-amoxiclav from the dog. When I saw the on call doctor, once he stopped laughing, he prescribed the exact same dose of the exact same drug but with an easier to swallow film coating.

trulyunruly01 · 05/06/2023 22:04

My little dog has something going on and my vet would like a CT scan, which their practice cannot do. She has referred us to a specialist centre in the next county for the CT.
It's £477 to get through the door. That doesn't include the scan. I don't really get why we need the consultation - why not just the scan and the results sent to my own vet?
If my GP refers me to the hospital for X-rays or scans, I don't see anyone beforehand. The report is sent back to my own GP and he delivers the result. If he then thinks I ought to see a hospital consultant he refers.
Vets are losing the trust of pet-owners. At weekends now we are referred over to some weird contracted out service and have to phone a call centre 350 miles away, then get charged £200 to see a random vet who is working out of our own surgery.
Vets are clearly reluctant to give out prescription for pet owners to fulfil online, much cheaper. Our practice is now charging £15 for a printed prescription.
And it will be our companion animals that suffer in the end, as people no longer insure, rely on OTC medications and crossed fingers.

Emotionalsupportviper · 05/06/2023 21:58

The worst thing that happened to animal care was pet insurance - it gave a green light to many vets to put their prices through the roof.

This is why animals don't receive the care they need a lot of the time now - and even euthanasia is phenomenally expensive (9 years ago had to have a cat euthanised - it was £95! God knows what it is now. This is why many people dump sick animals, or keep them alive even though they are in obvious distress..

JemimaTiggywinkles · 05/06/2023 21:58

Insurance or not you the owner decides which tests to do.

The advice you get changes dramatically when you tell a vet you don’t have insurance though. With cat 2 I was told she needed a huge array of tests (including sedation and overnight stay) but when I asked about costs and said I don’t have insurance the vet switched immediately to “the tests are just in case, overwhelming likelihood is that there’s nothing wrong”. It was quite shocking to see the complete pivot.

And vets are (ime) really not at all clear with you regarding the chances of your pet surviving to live a happy life. With cat 1 he had a heart condition that (on reflection) was always going to kill him within a couple of miserable months. I didn’t know that when I took him to the surgery, and I took the vets at their word when they said the tests and treatment were necessary. I’m not an expert and the vet is - they must have known the chances of survival were slim and didn’t bother telling me that. When I’m feeling charitable I think the obfuscation over chances of survival is because many pet owners would rather spend fortunes on a pet that was always going to die soon than wonder “what if”. When I’m feeling less charitable I think it is because it’s pretty easy to offer hope in return for cash.

Swipe left for the next trending thread