Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

“Men have to fight in wars and do the protecting and heavy lifting”

117 replies

DogEar · 05/06/2023 17:35

So says a male colleague as he monologues about female privilege.
I’m rather sick of it. I’ve moved offices over this but can still hear him droning on about women - the lazy entitled part of humanity.

I’ve argued - men fight in wars, do the protecting, do the heavy lifting, because this is the patriarchy - this is literally what has been created by men. He argues back harder, so I, and others in the office, have given up, yet he still drones on.

Apparently women can do nothing without men. Totally ignoring the many women who have had their inventions and discoveries stolen by men and not had any credit, including writers, composers, artists, scientists, astronomers, etc.

I recently read a convincing theory that Einstein’s work was largely carried out by his first wife, Mileva Einstein-Maric, who was his intellectual superior. I guess this is something we’ll never know, but at the very least she supported his work heavily, but very few know her name or her involvement in Einstein’s work.

If women need protecting it’s from men. If we go to war it’s men behind it (or a tiny number of women within a patriarchal society). Heavy lifting? If it’s so heavy I can’t lift it I can involve a friend, job sorted.

YABU - women owe men a debt of gratitude, we are so privileged (if you choose this option please explain why) and couldn’t manage without them.

YANBU - men fighting in wars, men protecting women (from men) are not female privileges.

OP posts:
Nothingisblackandwhite · 06/06/2023 10:39

The only thing most women may need protection from is men !

YukoandHiro · 06/06/2023 10:09

*no formal mechanism

YukoandHiro · 06/06/2023 10:09

Jellyx · 06/06/2023 09:51

I don't believe in the patriarchy.

We live in a good society - especially compared to history and other countries.. if that was all due to a male dominated society then let's thank men..

Anyway- they guys sounds like an idiot. Ask him if he's able to protect you and if he has a sixpack..

What do you mean by the first sentence?

Assuming you live in the UK, your parliament has only 35 per cent female representation and has formal mechanism for that minority of women to take maternity leave.

YukoandHiro · 06/06/2023 10:06

Tell him to look up the Kurdish resistance against Isis in Syria, large numbers of female led groups. I'd like to see how he'd fare in front line combat against the most brutal and medieval theocratic regime known in recent history.
Dickhead.

Catchasingmewithspiders · 06/06/2023 10:01

BeverlyHa · 06/06/2023 09:17

I am not going to war, neither doing heavy lifting, about protecting not sure how yall going to protect yourselves if there were only women on this planet.

Leave alone being able to procreate the biological normal way etc. One of these threads which will break many gentle women's hearts in seconds 😂

Who are we protecting ourselves from

No one is really serious about getting rid of men. We are just tired of men like the one the OP works with saying that we are privileged, lazy and entitled.

Do you feel privileged, lazy and entitled in your 'gentle woman heart'?

itsmylife7 · 06/06/2023 10:01

Does he have a female partner ?

Catchasingmewithspiders · 06/06/2023 09:57

Jellyx · 06/06/2023 09:51

I don't believe in the patriarchy.

We live in a good society - especially compared to history and other countries.. if that was all due to a male dominated society then let's thank men..

Anyway- they guys sounds like an idiot. Ask him if he's able to protect you and if he has a sixpack..

2 women a week being killed by men
97% of women sexually harrassed
20% of women sexually assaulted (that we know of)
35% of fathers not paying CM when they are obligated to do so

Yeah I'm going to hold off thanking men at the moment tbh

Jellyx · 06/06/2023 09:51

I don't believe in the patriarchy.

We live in a good society - especially compared to history and other countries.. if that was all due to a male dominated society then let's thank men..

Anyway- they guys sounds like an idiot. Ask him if he's able to protect you and if he has a sixpack..

Badbudgeter · 06/06/2023 09:40

BeverlyHa · 06/06/2023 09:17

I am not going to war, neither doing heavy lifting, about protecting not sure how yall going to protect yourselves if there were only women on this planet.

Leave alone being able to procreate the biological normal way etc. One of these threads which will break many gentle women's hearts in seconds 😂

Who are we protecting ourselves from if there aren't any men? Lions and tigers and bears? Oh my.

sashh · 06/06/2023 09:40

DogEar · 05/06/2023 18:53

A predator for example could only have been dealt with by sufficient strength and size. Hunting required sufficient stamina and strength.

Women hunted too, stopping when pregnancy, childbirth, injury or age stopped them. Even history is rewritten to exclude women’s roles.

I believe when it comes to stamina in extreme circumstances women trump men due to them having more brown fat.
I’m also sure I’ve read that much of the hunting that took place took stealth and cunning, rather than brute force and strength.

Women out perform men in ultra marathons.

Also hunting probably wasn't wild boar and hears, it's much more likely to have been rabbits, birds, squirrels, fish.

There's not point killing a bear if you don't have refrigeration or a huge number of people to feed.

A while ago I read, Letters of a Woman Homesteader, it is literally letters from a widow with a young child to her former employer.

She thinks noting of taking her toddler on a horse for a few days camping in the wild. We don't think of women 100 years ago having the independence to do that.

Badbudgeter · 06/06/2023 09:34

Maybe men could stop starting wars? Maybe they could stop being aggressive to other men and women.

Pretty sure I can manage my own heavy lifting 👍

Its almost like men create a society which enables them to be valuable. Crazy I know.

MissCrowley · 06/06/2023 09:24

Tell him during 1000BC we were a Goddess worshipping society and there was no conflicts or wars.. so he can stick that in his pipe and smoke it! War is a massive Willy waving activity and it pisses me off.

BeverlyHa · 06/06/2023 09:17

I am not going to war, neither doing heavy lifting, about protecting not sure how yall going to protect yourselves if there were only women on this planet.

Leave alone being able to procreate the biological normal way etc. One of these threads which will break many gentle women's hearts in seconds 😂

Catchasingmewithspiders · 06/06/2023 09:13

RightOldMe · 06/06/2023 08:17

Hmm either men are biologically stronger so they shouldn't be allowed to compete in women's sports or men and women are equal and women can lift men and fight just as well as men. We have to decide where we stand. The goal post can't be moving depending on what a man is saying/doing.

Lots of men are biologically stronger than lots of women

But that doesn't mean Bob in accounts who hasn't done any sports since he left school 20 years ago and thinks it's hard work mowing the lawn is going to be stronger than Emily Campbell

In the same way, no matter how hard Emily Campbell works she's probably never going to be as strong as Hafthor Bjornsson

So no we shouldn't have male athletes who have actually trained competing in the women's section, but that doesn't mean every man is faster and stronger than every woman.

And regardless this was to do with women hunters I think? They did exist there is proof. Perhaps they weren't as fast and strong as the men but that doesn't mean they didn't exist.

JazbayGrapes · 06/06/2023 09:00

Tell him to go to war then

ErrolTheDragon · 06/06/2023 08:53

RightOldMe · 06/06/2023 08:17

Hmm either men are biologically stronger so they shouldn't be allowed to compete in women's sports or men and women are equal and women can lift men and fight just as well as men. We have to decide where we stand. The goal post can't be moving depending on what a man is saying/doing.

Of course men are on average stronger than women, and the upper ends of the male and female distributions are different which is why most sports need to be divided by sex.
But in most people's everyday lives this doesn't matter much, less and less with increasing mechanical aids. There's nothing in most people's jobs nowadays which needs much muscle strength, more that requires manual dexterity... and mental abilities including working well with a team which this bloke clearly hasn't mastered.

Ihatepickingausername3 · 06/06/2023 08:52

Indeed

HadalyEve · 06/06/2023 08:47

EBearhug · 06/06/2023 08:37

Women did work in mines until after the 1842 Mines Act, which banned them until 1985 (by which point there were very few mines left.) Women weren't allowed in parliament until the 20th century, so let's guess which sex banned them by passing the act...

And which class.

EBearhug · 06/06/2023 08:37

Women did work in mines until after the 1842 Mines Act, which banned them until 1985 (by which point there were very few mines left.) Women weren't allowed in parliament until the 20th century, so let's guess which sex banned them by passing the act...

LadyGardenersQuestionTime · 06/06/2023 08:35

Sex is a protected characteristic; his comments constitute bullying and harassment; this is unlawful. Your management are tacitly condoning him.

What does he have that’s so special they don’t pick him up on it? Are you secure enough in your role to challenge management? Absolutely no point talking to him.

Lidlpopdrinker · 06/06/2023 08:20

Offer him some advice. You know men love a bit of unsolicited advice.

  1. Tell his fellow men to stop starting wars, so they won’t have to fight and die in them.
  2. Tell his fellow men to stop raping and attacking women, then we won’t need protecting.
  3. Fake a bad back if he doesn’t want to lift things.
RightOldMe · 06/06/2023 08:17

Hmm either men are biologically stronger so they shouldn't be allowed to compete in women's sports or men and women are equal and women can lift men and fight just as well as men. We have to decide where we stand. The goal post can't be moving depending on what a man is saying/doing.

hennybeans · 06/06/2023 08:17

I read this the other day:
Man: if there were no men, who would protect you?
Woman: protect me from what?

Evaka · 06/06/2023 08:05

I'm not going to dignify this non-debate with a view and nor should you. I would wear ear buds and make an exaggerated "I can't hear you" gesture every time he speaks. Encourage others to do same. Cut off his oxygen.

Swipe left for the next trending thread