Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Schools responsibility to more able children

157 replies

Rainyrunway · 05/06/2023 13:06

I have twin DC aged 8. Both are working above the expected level across the board academically according to their teachers. What can I reasonably expect the school to do to accommodate this?
1 isn't too bothered, but the other absolutely hates school because they find it boring. Says the work is constantly repeated and they spend ages going over the same stuff.
This is absolutely not meant as a stealth brag, but I just want them to get back to enjoying school, without a fight for them to go in every day.
I always explain to DC that just because they find maths (for example) easy that doesn't mean everyone else does. In the same way as some kids are amazing at gymnastics while my DC can barely to a forward roll. They do understand this and don't show off as far as I can tell.
But I want them to enjoy school. I want to have a chat with the teacher but I don't want to be unreasonable, as I know she has a lot to deal with and kids with much bigger problems. So how can I address it? I know the school have additional work that can be done at home but this doesn't solve the issue really. It's while they're in the classroom that they're not being challenged at all.
I'm worried that not only are they not fulfilling their potential (either child) at least one is likely to completely switch off if the problem isn't addressed as they no longer enjoy going in at all. We have had school refusals and tummy aches and the like, and I think it's all related.

OP posts:
OneTwoThreeFourFiveOnceI · 05/06/2023 19:10

Agree and want to reiterate the following points. It is ill informed and potentially offensive to state that kids are able for being academically talented. For a whole host of reasons, including that some children with SEN can have 'spiky profiles' and be very advanced in certain academic areas. Being very highly academically advanced due to a natural inclination in a subject does bring challenges for those kids and I disagree in principle that there are no specific legal obligations for them, but it needs to be seen in the context of kids with SEN currently not having their needs met, having a miserable time and their life chances severely impacted as is sadly often the case due to a lack of funding.

Scarlettpixie · 05/06/2023 18:38

My son’s school used to set harder work once the first lot of work had been completed but my son cba with doing something he found easy 40 times so he never got onto the harder stuff.

Soontobe60 · 05/06/2023 18:38

Rainyrunway · 05/06/2023 14:41

@Soontobe60 if this quote was meant to be about me I don't think it's fair
"I have, however, come across many children who say the work is boring and their parents think teachers don't challenge them - many of these children are average at best"
I love my DCs teacher. She is kind and caring and great with the children day to day. It's not her or teachers generally that I'm asking about. More about whether there is something in particular I could ask the school for that would be a reasonable request. Schools spend a lot of time (understandably) catering to the needs of the kids who are struggling because they are falling behind, is there anything that they can do to help out the ones who are finding the work unchallenging and boring? ALL children should have the chance to find school enjoyable.
I did expect some comments along the lines of this one though. It is AIBU after all.

Not about you specifically, but is my experience of children, including own DD.
she constantly said school was boring, especially maths. What she really meant was once she had completed the same work as the rest of the class she wanted to just play on a computer rather than complete any extension tasks. She actually thought being given extra tasks was unfair too.
She was worse at secondary school but fortunately did very well, got A*s in 3 different maths A levels and is now a highly paid corporate tax advisor. She still says she’s bored though 🤣

electriclight · 05/06/2023 18:27

YSWIM · 05/06/2023 18:13

We've dealt with this for the past 7 years since reception. Highly able DS, no extension work because they put emphasis on "mastery"🙄 I hear things are different in the private sector but not much luck in the state(at least in our case). Thankfully off to a super selective grammar so things should start to change for the better.

Mastery doesn't mean that you can't challenge pupils.

If your school are telling you that, they're wrong. It's about depth rather than extension but certainly challenging.

electriclight · 05/06/2023 18:25

I'm a teacher and always have a challenge activity for the early finishers in Maths. That's just good practice and expected.

In English, it is largely differentiated by outcome and expectation.

I think feel free to ask the teacher but be aware that I have had several parents approach me over the years and then slink away looking embarrassed once I show them all of the challenges and extensions provided, all of the lessons their child didn't reach the challenge, the work they got wrong on the day they said they were bored etc.

YSWIM · 05/06/2023 18:13

We've dealt with this for the past 7 years since reception. Highly able DS, no extension work because they put emphasis on "mastery"🙄 I hear things are different in the private sector but not much luck in the state(at least in our case). Thankfully off to a super selective grammar so things should start to change for the better.

SusiePevensie · 05/06/2023 18:02

And yeah, a lot of gifted kids are also autistic and/or adhd. Schools aren't built for them - it's often about giving them the tools to survive the boredom.

SusiePevensie · 05/06/2023 18:00

I'm going to assume, here, that your kids' school are ok with kids quietly getting on with other stuff once they've done their work.

If so. A) teach them chess. Usborne chess and Batsford book of chess for children are a good start. Then - ta da! - the whole world of chess puzzles and old chess matches opens up. Hours and hours and hours - a lifetime's worth, literally - of mathy fun.

B) puzzles, puzzles, puzzles. Print stuff off the nrich website, or Usborne (again) have a ton of good puzzle or activity books. Going sideways again, their Maps activity book is terrific for mathy kids. Nothing wrong with sudoku either.

Plasticplantpot · 05/06/2023 17:55

It’s really quite depressing to think that we cater to the lowest common denominator. Why not cater high, pull up standards and make parents accountable? I’d be mortified if mine had such basic skills as some in their classes - not able to use scissors or tie shoelaces or have a basic understanding of so many things by the end of primary (SEND not included in this statement, obviously). If teachers had a decent canvas to work with in the first place, maybe standards could increase. So many parents leave everything to school, when they need to educate their children themselves for a great part of life.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 05/06/2023 17:39

neverbeenskiing · 05/06/2023 16:08

Being academically able is not a form of SEN. A child has SEN if they have a learning difficulty or a disability which means they require a special provision. As I've already said, your kids deserve to be challenged and enjoy school, so I appreciate your predicament, but claiming that being clever is, in itself, a special educational need is tone deaf.

It's possible to have both.

The trouble is, a G&T child with, say, ADHD or Autism, has all the time in the world to think of ways to entertain themselves once they've done all the work, got fed up with helping everybody else, read three chapters ahead, done the end of unit test that's planned for July, drawn cartoons all over their exercise book and there's still over an hour to playtime.

Confrontayshunme · 05/06/2023 17:36

Most schools I know are drowning in SEN children who cannot get a diagnosis/specialist place, especially at EYFS/KS1 level. Unfortunately, that means that except for phonics/spelling and grammar, they just have to be a bit bored.

I tailor my lessons for higher ability children, but there are nearly 40% of the class below age related expectations, a gifted child will have to be bored a bit during the actual lessons but stretched in actual work.

Redlocks28 · 05/06/2023 17:35

Hungryfrogs23 · 05/06/2023 17:21

Contact your mp. Support teacher strikes. Use your vote. Sign the petition to overhaul ofsted.

Unfortunately primary schools are heavily judged on what they are doing for their lowest 20%. What they are doing to support those struggling, to catch up from covid, to put intervention in place for the lowest 20%.

Lots of the helpful suggestions listed above would have a school absolutely lambasted by ofsted. Differentiation is now not the done thing, it's mastery. "Chilli challenges, mild med spicy etc" are absolutely slated by ofsted. Setting by ability will have them come down on you like a tonne of bricks.

They/the gvmt belief is that all children should be exposed to the same content and progress through at the same rate. Higher ability should be challenged by applying their learning in different contexts, by being able to explain their thinking, by making links across their learning etc. Which often the children don't perceive as "harder work".
But the reality with chronic underfunding, nowhere near enough adults in classrooms, less specialist teachers and more Ta/HLTA cover, bigger class sizes, less SEN funding so more high needs children in main stream classrooms with no support etc all means that the bright, capable, well behaved ones are never going to get the time and attention and push that they deserve. Teachers are well aware of this being a problem, just absolute helpless to do anything about it.

I agree with this.

One of our Year 2 teachers started off the year with a class of 25-it was a great little class and it was possible to rotate herself around everyone throughout the week. The more able could be supported to move on, as much as the less able. In the last half term, she has had 7 new arrivals (and yes, this takes her over the allotted number, but we were directed to) and she is being pulled in too many directions. All 7 new children are working at the level of her existing SEN/lower attainer group, so this group is now two groups of 6. 4 of the new starters had virtually no English and the other 3 have SEN. No EHCPs, so there is no additional funding and the class has no TA. She simply cannot support those more able children the way she wants to or the way she used to. This is not her fault.

Plasticplantpot · 05/06/2023 17:35

Agree with @hettiethehare - we did all the Covid work, mine weren’t behind when they went back but the last couple of years has been spent catching up those who missed out. Mine are bored, not helped by being older children in their year groups. We got a tutor for extension activities and are moving schools this time round. One off to secondary so that helps. State schools should cater for everyone but in reality they cater to a low-set middle bar. If you’re beyond that already, you’ll never be able to fulfill your true potential.

Isitthathardtobekind · 05/06/2023 17:30

Hungryfrogs23 · 05/06/2023 17:21

Contact your mp. Support teacher strikes. Use your vote. Sign the petition to overhaul ofsted.

Unfortunately primary schools are heavily judged on what they are doing for their lowest 20%. What they are doing to support those struggling, to catch up from covid, to put intervention in place for the lowest 20%.

Lots of the helpful suggestions listed above would have a school absolutely lambasted by ofsted. Differentiation is now not the done thing, it's mastery. "Chilli challenges, mild med spicy etc" are absolutely slated by ofsted. Setting by ability will have them come down on you like a tonne of bricks.

They/the gvmt belief is that all children should be exposed to the same content and progress through at the same rate. Higher ability should be challenged by applying their learning in different contexts, by being able to explain their thinking, by making links across their learning etc. Which often the children don't perceive as "harder work".
But the reality with chronic underfunding, nowhere near enough adults in classrooms, less specialist teachers and more Ta/HLTA cover, bigger class sizes, less SEN funding so more high needs children in main stream classrooms with no support etc all means that the bright, capable, well behaved ones are never going to get the time and attention and push that they deserve. Teachers are well aware of this being a problem, just absolute helpless to do anything about it.

This is spot on regarding differentiation/ofsted focus on lowest 20%/overhaul of ofsted needed/chronic underfunding/the need to support teachers as they see what is wrong with the system and are trying to do something about it through strike action (definitely not just about pay as the media will have us all believe).

Justaflippertyjibbet · 05/06/2023 17:23

@IamAlso4eels

Just looked at Reciprocal Reading, omg, where to start. You have my sympathies with your job, you all need a medal for going in every day.

Hungryfrogs23 · 05/06/2023 17:21

Contact your mp. Support teacher strikes. Use your vote. Sign the petition to overhaul ofsted.

Unfortunately primary schools are heavily judged on what they are doing for their lowest 20%. What they are doing to support those struggling, to catch up from covid, to put intervention in place for the lowest 20%.

Lots of the helpful suggestions listed above would have a school absolutely lambasted by ofsted. Differentiation is now not the done thing, it's mastery. "Chilli challenges, mild med spicy etc" are absolutely slated by ofsted. Setting by ability will have them come down on you like a tonne of bricks.

They/the gvmt belief is that all children should be exposed to the same content and progress through at the same rate. Higher ability should be challenged by applying their learning in different contexts, by being able to explain their thinking, by making links across their learning etc. Which often the children don't perceive as "harder work".
But the reality with chronic underfunding, nowhere near enough adults in classrooms, less specialist teachers and more Ta/HLTA cover, bigger class sizes, less SEN funding so more high needs children in main stream classrooms with no support etc all means that the bright, capable, well behaved ones are never going to get the time and attention and push that they deserve. Teachers are well aware of this being a problem, just absolute helpless to do anything about it.

Isitthathardtobekind · 05/06/2023 17:16

Rainyrunway · 05/06/2023 16:34

Yes both of mine have been "free readers" for a while. I don't know whether that's normal or not though for their age.

Normal by key stage 2 and very possible during year 2. I would expect guidance around this though so that it’s not completely ‘free’ as it’s important that children have access to books at that age with appropriate themes- especially in years 2 and 3.

Justaflippertyjibbet · 05/06/2023 17:14

Racing ahead isn’t always the answer. When I was the Gifted and Talented coordinator we looked at ways to add breadth to the curriculum. We tried to find ways using alternative equipment, often IT, which the children in those days found to be a novelty, so a reward for their hard work. The problem was foreseeing where the pupil’s interest took them, let alone having that in your lesson plan. Thinking on the hoof very often. Helping others is a good way for able students to process their learning but not every day.
Peer support has been around for ever, but is not universally favoured by parents, It was my job to help Eric with reading seventy years ago.

DiscoStusMoonboots · 05/06/2023 17:13

@Isitthathardtobekind I completely agree with what you have said, and that is exactly how I plan. However, I'm aware that some schools do do differentiated/assigned learning to death and wasn't sure which camp the OP's school fell into.

Ideally, it would be as you suggested.

Isitthathardtobekind · 05/06/2023 17:11

Research from EEF shows that streaming and setting primary age children has no positive impact on the majority and actually negative impact in some cases.

Isitthathardtobekind · 05/06/2023 17:09

DiscoStusMoonboots · 05/06/2023 13:20

It's a tricky one, but the teacher should be planning for this one. Do they adapt the work or differentiate (create multiple different tasks for different abilities)? A challenge question/option to take a more independent approach to learning could benefit your two. At least, could they not use a school laptop to access the 'stretch' homework once they have finished the class work?

Teachers shouldn’t really be creating multiple different tasks for different abilities anymore (this puts a ceiling on the achievement of some), but agree that there should be challenges to move on to. It should be high expectations for all with scaffolds for those who need to enable all to reach the standard of expectation, with challenge to push further for those who can. For those who really need something different because they really can’t access it yet, then they should be planned for separately.

Greetingsfellows · 05/06/2023 17:02

I would talk to the teacher and explain your concerns (focusing on the positives you've already listed) and see what they say. The curriculum is very clear in terms of not moving children onto work from other year groups, etc, as others have said. The teacher may have other ideas once you've raised your concerns as they may not be aware of the issue in the same way that you are.

Predominantly though, understanding the perspective of the teacher may well help you to approach your DC and tackle their attitude from home. I'm not saying your DC have a bad attitude but you don't have the full context. I've taught 'bright' children who do not see the value of challenging work that they are set. Under the current curriculum, this view often stems from the fact that it is on the same topic so it feels repetitive when in actual fact it is rich in complexity.

If you understand what the teacher and school are trying to achieve with their higher attaining students, you (alongside the teacher) may well be able to support your DC to improve their approach to learning, which will benefit them now and in the long run. They will potentially become less bored by valuing different challenges more, if that makes sense?

Having said all of that, at a more basic level I do agree with the pp who said boredom is part of life and learning to deal with it is a life skill! I actually think we do our children a disservice building them up to expect everything in life to be thrilling.

Jenn3112 · 05/06/2023 16:59

DS (9, year 4) is very bored in maths as he gets maths concepts very quickly and finds the whole thing repetitive as he isn't allowed to skip ahead. Usually he does the hardest option, then the extension task, then 'helps' other children. However, while he pretty much always gets the right answer there is an ongoing argument with him about writing out his working and method, because over time things will get more complex and he will need to show working. Racing ahead and immediately knowing all the right answers isn't always helpful long term.

SchoolShenanigans · 05/06/2023 16:50

If it was me, I'd be speaking to the teacher about what they suggest. Do they tier the classes so those above and below expected can have a more tailored experience?

Can they sit with the class above for certain topics?

Can you afford to send them to private? Have you looked into scholarships based on academic ability?

Sadly though, mainstream schooling can't provide every pupil with the best experience. It just can't. I guess one saving grace for you is that your children don't seem to have any additional needs. It's very hard to accept how generic schooling is when your child is struggling and the support is minimal.

Thegoodandbadlife · 05/06/2023 16:45

Not that this is much help but when I was in this situation I was moved to a private school as fortunately a place came up half way through year 5. Until then my parents had been looking into tutors for me.