Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Schools responsibility to more able children

157 replies

Rainyrunway · 05/06/2023 13:06

I have twin DC aged 8. Both are working above the expected level across the board academically according to their teachers. What can I reasonably expect the school to do to accommodate this?
1 isn't too bothered, but the other absolutely hates school because they find it boring. Says the work is constantly repeated and they spend ages going over the same stuff.
This is absolutely not meant as a stealth brag, but I just want them to get back to enjoying school, without a fight for them to go in every day.
I always explain to DC that just because they find maths (for example) easy that doesn't mean everyone else does. In the same way as some kids are amazing at gymnastics while my DC can barely to a forward roll. They do understand this and don't show off as far as I can tell.
But I want them to enjoy school. I want to have a chat with the teacher but I don't want to be unreasonable, as I know she has a lot to deal with and kids with much bigger problems. So how can I address it? I know the school have additional work that can be done at home but this doesn't solve the issue really. It's while they're in the classroom that they're not being challenged at all.
I'm worried that not only are they not fulfilling their potential (either child) at least one is likely to completely switch off if the problem isn't addressed as they no longer enjoy going in at all. We have had school refusals and tummy aches and the like, and I think it's all related.

OP posts:
Ilovetea42 · 05/06/2023 22:13

I was always very good at English and reading etc and finished well before the rest of the class so my teacher would have given me extra worksheets to fill in or other small tasks to do to fill the time. She also got different books etc in for me to read in those spare moments so I didn't get bored and gave me responsibilities within the classroom when I'd finished early provided my work was okay. I now run an education centre for kids with widely ranging abilities ( most aren't in school for reasons that are nothing to do with academic abilities ) it's absolutely doable it just requires an individualised approach and some back up planning on the part of the teacher. I'd ask to chat with the teacher and see what you can come up with together. If it's compromising your child's willingness to attend school etc then it needs to be addressed.

Toxicityofourcity · 05/06/2023 22:07

My DC school had this when he was younger. He would fly through work and then be bored when waiting for others to finish, sometimes chatting and disrupting others while they tried to work, which is totally unacceptable and unfair to the others. This started when he was about 7 years old.

Met with his teacher when this started happening and we brainstormed, came up with the idea of a project table. There were 3 in the class that were academically ahead and once their work was done, it was agreed they would get up and go to the project table without disturbing the others. They worked on various projects that involved research, presentation making etc. and some additional work to do at home which DC loved. They also had a book club between the 3 of them which they loved! It made ALL the difference to everyone in the class. Could you suggest something like this?

Every teacher after this kept up the project table until he left the school last year. Still so glad these lovely teachers cared so much to find a solution for all the kids in class, honestly such an amazing school, I was irrationally sad when he finished!

Macaroni46 · 05/06/2023 22:03

Quinoawoman · 05/06/2023 14:06

The main problem is the curriculum and the way that schools are now required to teach it.

Believe it or not, what's in the curriculum is actually really difficult and not age-appropriate in any way for the majority of children. It is also quite knowledge-focussed for the foundation subjects. This, combined with mastery teaching (an emphasis on ensuring that ALL children get it and don't get left behind), means that teachers are essentially forced into a way of teaching that goes really slowly through the content so that all the children are picking it up and mastering it really well. There are ways to extend more able pupils within the same content but frankly, I often feel so exhaused by the constant, unreleting focus on special needs and the ones that aren't getting it that I sometimes don't have a lot left for those at the top. There is nothing wrong with focusing on the SEND kids by the way - it's just that kids seem to be becoming more and more needy and our class size are huge (35 in my school) so it can easily overwhelm.

Another factor is that a lot of the content is just really bloody boring. There are things I want to teach which are inspiring and which I know would fully engage the children but I'm not allowed because it's 'not in the curriculum' and we need all the time we've got to teach the stuff that is in there. Frankly, I am bored of teaching some of this shit and the kids are bored of hearing about it. I do a lot of 'cover teaching' now and I find that a lot of the lessons I'm given to cover are just very 'chalk and talk' - I tell them about something, they listen, and the task is to remember and regurgitate what I've said. We seem to have gone back to an 'empty vessels' model of teaching rather than the constrictivism I learned about at uni. Boring, boring, boring.

Anyway, I think the answer is probably to support teachers in calling for curriculum change. Meanwhile, I'm looking for a new job - outside teaching.

All of this, sadly. Really well put @Quinoawoman and this is why I'm leaving the profession after 30 years at the chalk face. I can no longer face teaching such an unsuitable, un-child friendly, knowledge heavy, prescriptive, irrelevant and quite frankly, pitched too high curriculum. No wonder behaviour is declining. Children are being set up to fail. Planning takes longer than ever with every lesson requiring a lengthy PowerPoint or similar and with fewer resources and TAs, and increasing numbers of children with SEND, the job has become untenable (well, for me, anyway).

Rainyrunway · 05/06/2023 21:26

@HollyBookBlue I'd love it if they had the more able kids together working on maybe slightly higher level or something. Up till year 2 they did sort of but it just randomly happened that the more able kids were clustered in 1 class out of the 3 in the year group. They mixed them up at the start of year 3 so that ability was spread evenly across the year.

OP posts:
HollyBookBlue · 05/06/2023 21:19

My DC's primary school had in-class extension work, for the more able kids... They called them "spicy challenges" 🤣. They still had to sit through the explanation at the start of the lesson (they complained it was often repetition and too slow) and do the regular work with everyone else, but then could move onto the more challenging task.

In maths specifically, they had a table for the more able kids or removed them from each class (4 form entry) to teach them separately. In year 4 and up they also had a lunch time maths club, oddly (against the stereotype at any rate) all the kids really wanted to be invited to go to it (they did have biscuits 🤣)

ThePlasticScouser · 05/06/2023 21:18

I think if you want them stretched, you have to do it yourself. I took mine to hobbies outside of school and I took my eldest to a maths centre one hour a week and it took him from an average maths child, to 9 at GCSE and performing really well at A level so far.

I learnt ages ago that you can’t rely on the schools, you have to add on to your DC’s education yourself with books, maths and hobbies.

ContinuousProcrastination · 05/06/2023 21:09

if a parent came in to complain their child felt bored at the top, I'd happily provide more extension tasks, but at the expense of less support for the lowest. I can't do it all.

Hypothetical question. If that shifted the balance of your attention from 80% less able/ 20% more, to 70/30, would that be unfair?

This is what parents of more able children find hard, their children almost continually get far less of the teacher's attention, throughout education.

ContinuousProcrastination · 05/06/2023 21:06

Muddygreenfingers

Op's kids deserve to have their needs met as much as any other child. They deserve an enjoyable, engaging education thar gives them the opportunity to achieve their potential. They are worth the teacher's time and energy as much as any other child.

ContinuousProcrastination · 05/06/2023 21:04

Believe it or not, what's in the curriculum is actually really difficult and not age-appropriate in any way for the majority of children. It is also quite knowledge-focussed for the foundation subjects. This, combined with mastery teaching (an emphasis on ensuring that ALL children get it and don't get left behind), means that teachers are essentially forced into a way of teaching that goes really slowly through the content so that all the children are picking it up and mastering it really well. There are ways to extend more able pupils within the same content but frankly, I often feel so exhaused by the constant, unreleting focus on special needs and the ones that aren't getting it that I sometimes don't have a lot left for those at the top.

This. It's quite hard to really extend able kids if they already quite frankly, know the content inside out and you are not allowed to go beyond it - my DC is suffering with this. He's miles ahead in maths & reading (not in other areas mind!!) and is bored and it honestly makes him lazy.

Add to this that the government wants levelling. They do not want the gap between higher & lower attainers to be as big as it is. In reality, as more able learners often progress faster/more easily than others, only way to reduce attainment gaps means holding them back to allow slower learners to not slip further behind.

Few state schools really do an excellent job of meeting the needs of the more able, the reality is these kids learn like sponges & do well regardless, as long as their parents do plenty at home to stimulate them/provide challenge.

Op - can you afford things like music lessons to challenge them? Play lots of board games at home, look for a chess club or language lessons, computer coding clubs are becoming really popular. This is what my parents did for me & kept me mentally stimulated. I'm doing the same with DS. The music lessons in particular really help.

Redlocks28 · 05/06/2023 21:00

I was thinking maybe he could read a book.whenhe's done the extra work

A reasonable request. What is your child saying they are doing once they’ve completed an activity?

Rainyrunway · 05/06/2023 20:55

@Muddygreenfingers that's a bit unfair really. At no point have I suggested I was going to go in and complain. And I also said all along I understand that teachers are prioritising the kids who are finding it hard to keep up. But actually it's not unreasonable to not want my kid to say they hate school because they're always bored. I was thinking maybe he could read a book.when he's done the extra work, not that she should have to create a second lot of work just for my child. I'm not sure why you're taking it so personally.

OP posts:
Muddygreenfingers · 05/06/2023 20:52

Oh and to add: a lot of our TA hours have been cut this year so I've even less support in the classroom, and I'm unable to provide interventions to support or extend, literally none at all in fact.

Muddygreenfingers · 05/06/2023 20:48

I feel a bit irritated reading this thread, being honest.

I teach (thankfully part time), a very large, mixed year group class and I have a wide range of abilities.
Planning one maths lesson takes well over an hour. I've got to combine two sets of objectives and try to teach the whole class something some kids can do easily, others can't do several steps below.

I try my best, I really do, but I can't always challenge the top end and support the lower end without almost killing myself in the process.

It's very very hard work and if a parent came in to complain their child felt bored at the top, I'd happily provide more extension tasks, but at the expense of less support for the lowest. I can't do it all.

Valeriekat · 05/06/2023 20:40

Homeschool them?

Offensiveapprently · 05/06/2023 20:32

It really isn't a special educational need in any way at all. But I do agree that more academically able children need to be challenged.

YSWIM · 05/06/2023 20:29

@electriclight I don't know, he sat primary maths challenge in Y4 and got a gold (24/25) in the bonus round. Questions in PMC would be delving deep down what's taught in primary but he was already at that stage when he was 8. School still talked about mastery in Y6.

Noodledoodledoo · 05/06/2023 20:18

Jenn3112 · 05/06/2023 16:59

DS (9, year 4) is very bored in maths as he gets maths concepts very quickly and finds the whole thing repetitive as he isn't allowed to skip ahead. Usually he does the hardest option, then the extension task, then 'helps' other children. However, while he pretty much always gets the right answer there is an ongoing argument with him about writing out his working and method, because over time things will get more complex and he will need to show working. Racing ahead and immediately knowing all the right answers isn't always helpful long term.

I spend my day having this argument with bright students at secondary - unsurprisingly my higher achieving Yr 11's due to get a 9 in the next few months, do this. My bright but unwilling to write anything down are not achieving as well long term. In 14 years of teaching I think I have known a handful of students who could get full marks with just writing down the final answer.

I encourage them to do it to form a habit now so it makes it easier, my tutee insists on doing everything in his head - and it slows him down so much.

mayflowergardens · 05/06/2023 20:06

bigbabycooker · 05/06/2023 19:49

Oh @mayflowergardens thank you. I get it - I think in primary school I got given lots of "wordy" extension tasks from older, harder maths books that didn't use any new concepts really, but did use them in much harder ways. "If the train is travelling at x miles per hour" type puzzles that really only rely on you to be able to multiply/divide/subtract etc, but require you to work out which one is appropriate etc. Is that mastery? Or is it just doing harder versions of one concept?

I can see that the former could extent able kids pretty well, whereas the latter could still end up with boredom from the more able kids.

As another poster wrote, mastery is more complicated than that (as is everything nowadays in education but that's another story!)

Yes, as I understand it, mastery means you have understand the concept and can apply it. Eg being taught what a simile is and then writing a descriptive piece with similes in it and even being able to extend them.

This is not going to be boring for the more able kids, mine love going onto the harder tasks as they challenge them. That's not to say I don't challenge the other kids, they may have similar type questions which are just a bit easier.

And yes, as other people have written, in state schools we do our best to cater for everyone but if you want more, either tutor and/or do extra at home or go private!

bigbabycooker · 05/06/2023 19:49

Oh @mayflowergardens thank you. I get it - I think in primary school I got given lots of "wordy" extension tasks from older, harder maths books that didn't use any new concepts really, but did use them in much harder ways. "If the train is travelling at x miles per hour" type puzzles that really only rely on you to be able to multiply/divide/subtract etc, but require you to work out which one is appropriate etc. Is that mastery? Or is it just doing harder versions of one concept?

I can see that the former could extent able kids pretty well, whereas the latter could still end up with boredom from the more able kids.

DancedByTheLightOfTheMoon · 05/06/2023 19:43

My son was moved up a year throughout primary school, He was still bored, He repeated work he'd already done in year 7 at secondary school and was so bored he started suffering with anxiety. Many intelligent students are inflicted by this, it seems to go hand in hand. He is now home schooled and this suits him much better as he can go at his own pace, as well as learn about subjects he's interested in. He has just sat first year of A levels.

mayflowergardens · 05/06/2023 19:33

bigbabycooker · 05/06/2023 19:20

@electriclight

Can I ask for an example of mastery? I'm really interested in what that means in practice.

Mastery is where the children can put what they've learnt into a greater understanding.

Eg if they are learning column addition in maths, they would have some reasoning questions on the board, often with more than one step, where they have to work out the answer using the taught skill and show logically how they reached their conclusion.

So being able to apply what they have learnt.

bigbabycooker · 05/06/2023 19:33

@electriclight

Thank you!

electriclight · 05/06/2023 19:31

bigbabycooker · 05/06/2023 19:20

@electriclight

Can I ask for an example of mastery? I'm really interested in what that means in practice.

It's too big for me to explain but NCETM website explains it well imo.

bigbabycooker · 05/06/2023 19:23

(When I was at school I basically just worked through a text book in year six for maths with little input (answers were in the back), which I wouldn't say was ideal. I do have a low boredom threshold though and would have been really bored just doin maths when I had already got the idea - in the early years at secondary school, I used to listen to the radio when I had to do maths homework because it was repetitive and easy).

bigbabycooker · 05/06/2023 19:20

@electriclight

Can I ask for an example of mastery? I'm really interested in what that means in practice.