Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not think this is a big deal? DH disagrees

261 replies

awedding1one · 05/06/2023 12:32

A close friend of mine is getting married in a couple of months.

It's happened quite fast so she's pretty stressed and trying to pull everything together in time (the grooms mother is terminally ill and so they are wanting to do it sooner rather than later).

She is inviting children to the wedding and my daughter is close friends with her two along with some of the other children going of other mutual friends.

The issue is that my step children are not invited and my husband has taken issue with that and thinks it's unfair (they would be staying with DHs mum that evening although technically one is old enough to stay home alone too if they'd prefer). They are 15 and 12.

Husband thinks it's "mean" for me him and our DD to go out for the evening and leave DSC with grandparents (even though I imagine that's where they'd prefer to be).

I on the other hand can't see the issue at all and don't think it's mean whatsoever. It's the wedding of my friend who I honestly can't say has ever met DSC and who's child is good friends with our own DD hence her coming.

AIBU to think DH is being a bit OTT about this? He wants me to ask my friend to invite DSC as they are part of our family however I don't want to as I know she's already stressing about numbers and don't think it's fair to pressurise her into inviting who to her are two random teenagers who probably couldn't care less about being there.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Grrrrdarling · 13/06/2023 17:35

aSofaNearYou · 13/06/2023 17:27

@Grrrrdarling But the accommodation might well be possible, just an inconvenience in a variety of ways. So it's not a situation of saying no with zero guilt because it isn't possible, there would be guilt because it could be possible, she just doesn't want to do it.

I understand what you are saying but that is not my experience & not how myself & my friends are with each other.

We’ll just have to agree to disagree or this will literally go on forever.

Off to have a Gin in the courtyard after hard day blitzing house & I hope you have an equally relaxing evening ahead ❤

aSofaNearYou · 13/06/2023 17:27

@Grrrrdarling But the accommodation might well be possible, just an inconvenience in a variety of ways. So it's not a situation of saying no with zero guilt because it isn't possible, there would be guilt because it could be possible, she just doesn't want to do it.

Grrrrdarling · 13/06/2023 17:22

Yousee · 13/06/2023 17:13

I'm glad you understand what I'm saying. It might not be a big deal to you if you were asked but to a woman planning a small wedding in a hurry on account of a dying mother in law, it's very likely an added hassle she just doesn't need.
"Oh, friend isn't happy, this is terrible/I feel bad for not thinking of them/fuck me I don't know them, annoyed you even asked/have I put her in an awkward spot with her DH/I suppose I could but it would mean annoying XYZ as their kids were not invited/maybe great aunt Gladys wont be well enough to come and then there will be space? OMG can't believe I just allowed myself to think that/can I afford another £100 to feed these kids?/will she still be my friend if I say no? She says no pressure but obviously there is an issue or she would not have mentioned it"

Just some potential thoughts of the bride of the top of my head. I'd not be putting any friend of mine through it.

@Yousee I have, in the past, & I would cover any extra costs as they aren’t expected guests. That would be my expense, or should I say my DH’s, NOT the bride or grooms.

We’ll agree to disagree but again even with ALL that going on it would not bother me if I was asked if it was possible to accommodate a tricky situation one of my friends found themselves in.
The question being asked would add no pressure at all & my answer would come from a place of knowing if that accommodation was possible.
No second guessing, no wondering just a straight answer so the guest knows the answer to their question.

PosiePerkinPootleFlump · 13/06/2023 17:16

My kids are similar ages to your step kids.

  1. they would not want to go to a wedding of someone they didn't know
  2. I can't imagine them caring a jot if their dad and stepmum and stepmum's kids (no shared kids between dad and stepmum) were going to a wedding of someone they didn't know without them, even if they were due to be there that night.
Yousee · 13/06/2023 17:13

Grrrrdarling · 13/06/2023 16:52

@Yousee Not within my friends & family circle.
My opinion of the situation & how it would pan out from my experience is clearly just different & some can’t get their head round that.
I find it strange that people can’t ask close friends simple questions, I would feel bad if someone I knew didn’t feel they could ask me this sort of question, but I do understand what you are saying.

At the end of the day ‘No’ is a whole sentence & doesn’t need any explanation unless the person hearing ‘No’ doesn’t like what they have heard.

For me ‘No’ would be enough, I’d thank my friend for answering the question & i’d ask if there was anything she needed to help her de-stress or to help with the wedding prep.

I'm glad you understand what I'm saying. It might not be a big deal to you if you were asked but to a woman planning a small wedding in a hurry on account of a dying mother in law, it's very likely an added hassle she just doesn't need.
"Oh, friend isn't happy, this is terrible/I feel bad for not thinking of them/fuck me I don't know them, annoyed you even asked/have I put her in an awkward spot with her DH/I suppose I could but it would mean annoying XYZ as their kids were not invited/maybe great aunt Gladys wont be well enough to come and then there will be space? OMG can't believe I just allowed myself to think that/can I afford another £100 to feed these kids?/will she still be my friend if I say no? She says no pressure but obviously there is an issue or she would not have mentioned it"

Just some potential thoughts of the bride of the top of my head. I'd not be putting any friend of mine through it.

Grrrrdarling · 13/06/2023 17:04

aSofaNearYou · 13/06/2023 17:02

@Grrrrdarling I can ask my friends questions, I just wouldn't ask one I knew was cheeky. So, for example, I wouldn't ask them for £10k when I knew they weren't that well off. And I wouldn't ask them for two extra places at their wedding, even if I was going to stress that it would be ok to say no. It would still be cheeky to ask.

Guess we’ll agree to disagree then.
I would not have an issue if you asked me❤

aSofaNearYou · 13/06/2023 17:02

@Grrrrdarling I can ask my friends questions, I just wouldn't ask one I knew was cheeky. So, for example, I wouldn't ask them for £10k when I knew they weren't that well off. And I wouldn't ask them for two extra places at their wedding, even if I was going to stress that it would be ok to say no. It would still be cheeky to ask.

Grrrrdarling · 13/06/2023 16:52

Yousee · 13/06/2023 16:27

I guess one of my life mottos must be "read the room before opening mouth" and another is "don't place friends under additional pressure who are already having a really tough time".
Asking the question is placing them under pressure. It's communicating that the original offer was not enough for you. The wedding isn't about OP and her DSC experiencing a wedding as a family unit and it's crass to even highlight that there is an issue.

@Yousee Not within my friends & family circle.
My opinion of the situation & how it would pan out from my experience is clearly just different & some can’t get their head round that.
I find it strange that people can’t ask close friends simple questions, I would feel bad if someone I knew didn’t feel they could ask me this sort of question, but I do understand what you are saying.

At the end of the day ‘No’ is a whole sentence & doesn’t need any explanation unless the person hearing ‘No’ doesn’t like what they have heard.

For me ‘No’ would be enough, I’d thank my friend for answering the question & i’d ask if there was anything she needed to help her de-stress or to help with the wedding prep.

QueenofKattegat · 13/06/2023 16:52

johnnydeppsslipper · 05/06/2023 16:06

@awedding1one

Tell your dh it's not about how it looks regarding him and his dc it's actually about someone else's big day that's being organised quickly due to someone close being terminally I'll Hmm

Tell him to give his head a wobble.

Unfair is planning a quick wedding so said dying family member gets to see before they pass away. That's unfair Shock

Exactly this! I'd be mortified if my husband was trying to put himself front and centre in a situation like this.

The ridiculousness around step kids on MN is something to behold.

Grrrrdarling · 13/06/2023 16:39

@StopFeckingFaffing That is why I WOULD NOT EXPECT friend to say yes but I see no harm in asking the simple question to get a straight answer so I can give butt hurt DH an answer & we can make alternative arrangements for the DSC.

My point is that, FROM MY EXPERIENCE, no-one I know would have an issue if I asked & I would not have an issue if they asked me but asking does not mean that someone has to accommodate you.

The DH is out of order for expecting an invite, being upset DSC haven’t been invited & having a go at OP or the bride for not inviting DSC.
He can choose to stay home with DSC & not come to the wedding or after party if the brides answer is not good enough for him.

Yousee · 13/06/2023 16:27

Grrrrdarling · 13/06/2023 16:16

Not at all @Yousee

My life mottos…

If you don’t ask you don’t get…
If you don’t ask you’ll never learn…
If you don’t ask you’ll never know.

&… Having everything in life won’t make you happy but you can be happy with what you have.

In short I think OP’s DH is very wrong to blame her for the DSC not being invited & he is also out of order being annoyed at her friend.

From my experience NO-ONE I know would have an issue with me asking IF it was possible, no demanding, to bring 1/2 more to more to an event or after party, with the party being an understandably easier situation to accommodate extra numbers, so I would just ask & whatever the bride said would be an acceptable answer.

There is no pressure for the friend to say yes to extra guests just a simple adult conversation to see IF it is possible before I arranged other childcare for the DSC or rearranged contact for any other weekend.

It is strange to me that people can’t have these sort of simple conversations with people they consider close friends without everyone getting offended because I would feel bad if I found out someone close to me felt they couldn’t ask me something!

I guess one of my life mottos must be "read the room before opening mouth" and another is "don't place friends under additional pressure who are already having a really tough time".
Asking the question is placing them under pressure. It's communicating that the original offer was not enough for you. The wedding isn't about OP and her DSC experiencing a wedding as a family unit and it's crass to even highlight that there is an issue.

StopFeckingFaffing · 13/06/2023 16:25

It's not just a party though @Grrrrdarling , it's a wedding

If it was a BBQ or birthday party or something then is a completely different scenario

I don't know any couple getting married who hasn't struggled with the guest list to some degree making sure they have everyone they want there, while trying to avoid offending anyone and keeping control of costs. Being asked if you can add a couple of extra teenagers is no small ask. There are likely plenty of other parents invited who haven't had their DC included in the invite so it's not just about finding space for 2 extra bums it's the added politics/stress which I'm sure the bride could do without.

Grrrrdarling · 13/06/2023 16:16

Yousee · 07/06/2023 05:52

This is a horrible perspective.
How "me, me, me" can one post get?

Not at all @Yousee

My life mottos…

If you don’t ask you don’t get…
If you don’t ask you’ll never learn…
If you don’t ask you’ll never know.

&… Having everything in life won’t make you happy but you can be happy with what you have.

In short I think OP’s DH is very wrong to blame her for the DSC not being invited & he is also out of order being annoyed at her friend.

From my experience NO-ONE I know would have an issue with me asking IF it was possible, no demanding, to bring 1/2 more to more to an event or after party, with the party being an understandably easier situation to accommodate extra numbers, so I would just ask & whatever the bride said would be an acceptable answer.

There is no pressure for the friend to say yes to extra guests just a simple adult conversation to see IF it is possible before I arranged other childcare for the DSC or rearranged contact for any other weekend.

It is strange to me that people can’t have these sort of simple conversations with people they consider close friends without everyone getting offended because I would feel bad if I found out someone close to me felt they couldn’t ask me something!

Grrrrdarling · 13/06/2023 16:05

aSofaNearYou · 13/06/2023 11:20

@Grrrrdarling I get what you're saying but a lot of people would feel awkward saying no and that has to be considered.

Plus I would have decided in my own mind that, even if they would have said yes, asking for two extra strangers is too much to ask and I would not do it. Maybe one, at a push, but not two.

Apologies for waffling on. I don’t know how else to explain things & it seems as though people are completely misunderstanding what I mean despite me trying to explain what i mean from my experience of similar situations.

It seems to me that DSC are only strangers because they haven’t met OP’s close friend as that situation has possibly never arisen & OP doesn’t really talk about DSC with her friends. To be honest I find that more weird than OP asking if DSC could POSSIBLY be added to the invite but people deal with these things differently based on their family dynamics & childcare options.

My life mottos…

If you don’t ask you don’t get…
If you don’t ask you’ll never learn…
If you don’t ask you’ll never know.

Having everything in life won’t make you happy but you can be happy with what you have.

In short I think OP’s DH is very wrong to blame her for the DSC not being invited & he is also out of order being annoyed at her friend.
From my experience not many people, if any, would have an issue with you asking if you could bring 1 or 2 more to the event or the after party, party being easier to accommodate more numbers so I would just ask & whatever the bride said would be an acceptable answer.

Scalottia · 13/06/2023 11:27

happylittletree · 05/06/2023 12:34

It is mean. Not sure whether it's worth raising this with your friend, but your husband isn't wrong about that.

I'm baffled - how can you see this as mean?

aSofaNearYou · 13/06/2023 11:20

@Grrrrdarling I get what you're saying but a lot of people would feel awkward saying no and that has to be considered.

Plus I would have decided in my own mind that, even if they would have said yes, asking for two extra strangers is too much to ask and I would not do it. Maybe one, at a push, but not two.

Grrrrdarling · 13/06/2023 11:12

aSofaNearYou · 13/06/2023 09:51

@Grrrrdarling but even just asking puts her in an awkward position. She might not mind at all but she might feel obliged to say yes, or bad saying no, at a time she's already feeling bad.

And I would not want to be known to my friend as the person who would ask for not even one but two additional guests to their wedding.

@aSofaNearYou Apologies for the long reply. I have ADHD & it is hard to cover all bases in text form as you can’t convey feeling or sentiment easily this way & stuff often gets lost in translation.

I totally think OP’s husband is wrong to be upset & angry that his DSC haven’t been invited & to demand they should be at the wedding but I see no harm in OP asking the bride, who is OP’s very close friend, if there is any space to add them to OP’s invite.
They are part of OP’s family, they come as a package with her partner, so I can’t see a problem with running the situation past her close friend.

This is a situation myself & my friends have dealt with in the past & none of us would feel bad if we genuinely couldn’t accommodate extra guests or if the person we asked couldn’t accommodate extra guests.

My friends would also not have an issue with me asking this sort of question but they would be upset if I didn’t feel I could come to them with such a simple situational question.

It is not like OP or her DH are telling the DSC they can come then demanding the bride invite them because they are already excited about the day. That would be childish, rude, presumptuous & very bad form!
If anyone did that to me or my friends I would be seriously reconsidering their friendship because our friends group & people I know/associate with do not behave like that.

There could be lots of reason the DSC can’t be added to the guest list - Limited numbers due to small venue, budget, personal choice etc etc - but my friends would not feel bad at all if they had to say no. At the end of the day they can have whoever they want at their wedding & my situation is mine to deal with not theirs.

This is literally a…
‘Hi friend,
Your wedding clashes with the weekend we have DSC to stay.
We do have alternative childcare with grandma to fall back on & I know you have never met DSC but is there any chance you could you squeeze an extra 2 on the guest list JUST INCASE they would like to come.
Totally fine if you cannot accommodate them because 1) you don’t know them, 2)I know how quickly all this is being pulled together & how stressed you are about the whole thing right now & 3) it is your day so you can invite & not invite who you choose.
I haven’t told DSC they can come & do not expect you to say yes because the situation that has arisen is mine to deal with &, like I said, we do have alternative help if they can’t come.’
Then I’d ask if there is anything my close friend needs or anything she needs help with for the wedding.

If friend says no & OP’s DH is so upset he can stay home with his DSC, quality dad & kids time is priceless, while OP & the daughter go to the wedding. Problem solved.

aSofaNearYou · 13/06/2023 09:51

@Grrrrdarling but even just asking puts her in an awkward position. She might not mind at all but she might feel obliged to say yes, or bad saying no, at a time she's already feeling bad.

And I would not want to be known to my friend as the person who would ask for not even one but two additional guests to their wedding.

Grrrrdarling · 13/06/2023 01:22

DrMarciaFieldstone · 07/06/2023 07:17

Yes, can I ask them if they want to come?

Oh, you want them to come, okay.

No, I want to ask them if they want to come, they might decide not to.

Right….

People lose their heads whenever steps are involved.

@DrMarciaFieldstone I don’t know if you agree with what I said or what WunWun said.
I did waffle a bit in my original comment & reading it back it could be misconstrued if WunWun didn’t read past the 1st few lines.

I would never expect someone to invite anyone to their wedding but I would not be shy about having an adult conversation with a friend about a situation arising regarding the weekend of the wedding & running the idea past her of DSC being able to come along, IF it was ok with her.
She can say no because it is her wedding so she can invite & not invite who she wants to & as I am an adult I can take that answer & would then make alternative arrangements for the DSC for that day/night/weekend.

Grrrrdarling · 13/06/2023 01:15

WunWun · 07/06/2023 06:47

Explain that you would like to give the DSC the option to come to the wedding 😂 What on earth are you talking about? They haven't been invited, of course it's not okay with her. That is absolutely asking her to invite them to the wedding, dressed up in an extremely self involved, entitled way.

@WunWun I think I may not have explained very well, after reading my comment back, what I meant but it may also be that you haven’t read past 1st line or 2 & decided I said OP should just bring the DSC whether they were invited or not.

That is not what I meant or said at all.

OP should not be telling the bride she has to invite the DSC to the wedding at all but there is no harm in talking to her friend to see if it was a possibility.
OP also can’t invite the DSC or give them the option to come to the wedding if the bride isn’t ok with them coming. Her wedding her choice as to who comes no matter what DSC situation the decision could cause.
All the asking would involve is an adult conversation with the bride about the weekend of the wedding clashing with when OP & her husband have the DSC to stay & checking with the bride if it was ok to bring them along, if they wanted to come.
It is a simple as that.
No one is acting entitled or anything of the sort.
I would certainly not be telling OP to demand that the bride lets DSC come or doing that myself as that is just rude!

aSofaNearYou · 07/06/2023 10:32

Your DF knows you have step children, so could have invited them.

My friends know I have a SC but that doesn't mean it would ever occur to them to invite them anywhere. They also know I never really talk about him to them, and he's also never there when I see them - so I'm obviously fine doing things without him and primarily do.

They have no reason to take from this that it's necessary to invite him places when they invite me.

I know this comment wasn't against OP, but I just wanted to say this in defence of friends not inviting their friends SC. This simply isn't the dynamic for everyone.

Barney60 · 07/06/2023 09:44

Its not mean at all, your DH is being unreasonable to expect your friend to invite extra guests whom shes never met.

Dibbydoos · 07/06/2023 08:14

Your DF knows you have step children, so could have invited them. But she doesn't know them, so risk to her wedding is could they cause havoc. And weddings are expensive so why should she invite them when they present a potential risk?

It's not your wedding, it's not your or your DPs choice so he needs to suck it up.

Life isn't fair It isn't meant to be. Survival of the finest and all that...

jackstini · 07/06/2023 07:40

It's not a big deal - she doesn't know them! Who invites people they have never met to a small wedding?!

Turn it round for your DH - there are bound to be friends of dsc's Mum who they know and your dd doesn't. You would not expect your dd to be invited to their weddings

DrMarciaFieldstone · 07/06/2023 07:17

WunWun · 07/06/2023 06:47

Explain that you would like to give the DSC the option to come to the wedding 😂 What on earth are you talking about? They haven't been invited, of course it's not okay with her. That is absolutely asking her to invite them to the wedding, dressed up in an extremely self involved, entitled way.

Yes, can I ask them if they want to come?

Oh, you want them to come, okay.

No, I want to ask them if they want to come, they might decide not to.

Right….

People lose their heads whenever steps are involved.