Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

White woman In a headscarf, would you stare?

555 replies

Tooshyshyhushhushidoi · 05/06/2023 12:12

And conservative/ ‘modest’ clothing. Would you stare? Would you look twice?

context to follow :)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Tooshyshyhushhushidoi · 06/06/2023 10:35

loislovesstewie · 06/06/2023 10:23

And, for me, the term is very judgemental. Calling it 'full cover' wouldn't offend me, as it's a description of what the clothes do, ie cover all of the body. Modest and immodest are judgements on the woman.

but some of the ‘modest’ clothes aren’t full cover though, Jewish ladies and Muslim ladies have different religious standards of modesty.

A Muslim lady’s garment should cover wrist to ankle but a Jewish lady (and the Jewish sisters who’ve commented, please correct me if I’m mistaken) she can wear a skirt below the knees and a 3/4 length sleeve but she can’t wear trousers (whereas the Muslim lady can). A Jewish lady can wear a wig but a Muslim lady cannot.

it doesn’t mean for a second that a Jewish lady thinks I’m immodest for wearing trousers or I think she is immodest for wearing a skirt to the knee.

for whatever reason modest is the term that has been appropriated by the fashion industry to describe a particular fashion choice or aesthetic. So I’ll use it to describe that aesthetic until the fashion industry changes their term for it. Maybe consider lobbying for that change as you feel so strongly about it. I do feel as a Muslim, we have to constantly change or adapt or diminish the things we believe in to be accepted, this feels like that.

OP posts:
loislovesstewie · 06/06/2023 10:23

And, for me, the term is very judgemental. Calling it 'full cover' wouldn't offend me, as it's a description of what the clothes do, ie cover all of the body. Modest and immodest are judgements on the woman.

Tooshyshyhushhushidoi · 06/06/2023 10:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I have a handful of good friends in the Muslim community, yes

OP posts:
Tenacioustattle · 06/06/2023 10:19

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Tooshyshyhushhushidoi · 06/06/2023 10:18

FierceBadIggi · 06/06/2023 10:06

Well, no, I assume that your choice of clothing means you view other women as dressing immodestly. Since wearing those clothes are your way of complying with guidance on being modest.
I don't see any way to argue against that, tbh. It's fine for you to feel that way too, but I don't see why you deny it.

That is your assumption on what I think, you’ve not asked me for my opinion? So how can you make such a judgment? I’m afraid that your prejudice

What I wear says nothing about you, nor is that the intention. I dress this way because I’m a Muslim woman and even though it’s tough at times, I’d like to be known as such. That is the first part of the ayah that talks about covering, that they may be known as believing women

and for your second comment, no the fashion industry didn’t invent the term modest but it has been applied to a specific aesthetic

OP posts:
FierceBadIggi · 06/06/2023 10:09

The fashion industry did not "make up" the concept of modesty through clothing, the use of that term goes way back in religions.

PurpleChrayne · 06/06/2023 10:08

I would stare but only to see if I knew them! I'm a modern orthodox Jewish woman and wear a headscarf.

FierceBadIggi · 06/06/2023 10:06

Well, no, I assume that your choice of clothing means you view other women as dressing immodestly. Since wearing those clothes are your way of complying with guidance on being modest.
I don't see any way to argue against that, tbh. It's fine for you to feel that way too, but I don't see why you deny it.

Tooshyshyhushhushidoi · 06/06/2023 10:02

No it doesn’t mean anything about any other clothing. Its just a name applied by the fashion industry to a particular aesthetic that doesn’t show much skin. There is no value judgment here.

do skinny jeans imply all other jeans those who wear them are fat? Or active wear imply all other clothing is lazy wear?

tbh these comments read as just projecting your feelings, judgments and insecurities onto other women who dress a certain way

OP posts:
loislovesstewie · 06/06/2023 09:26

I agree with @FierceBadIggi .It's also the labelling of clothes as modest that irritates me. I find it judgemental. If I wear t shirt and shorts am I immodest? I don't think so, but some will. I am speaking about all sorts of religion just to be clear.
Others will think I am judgemental because I believe that women are told what to do by men as part of a religion. And I clearly I don't get that.

FierceBadIggi · 06/06/2023 09:21

I can't go along with the use of "modest" to describe the kind of clothing the OP is linking to. It's one particular definition of the word and is linked to a religion rather than a general idea of modesty - it by default labels other clothing choices as immodest
Feminists should obviously not be harassing anyone in the street or staring at them, but they are entitled to form and hold opinions about the cultural regulation of female behaviour, in all its forms, and usually that's going to be a pretty negative opinion.

CharlottenBurger · 06/06/2023 06:43

Coolhwip · 05/06/2023 23:01

Who peed in your burger, Charlotte?

Well, you, it seems.

tunainatin · 05/06/2023 23:18

I'm white and wear a headscarf. I have done for a long time. I don't notice people staring anymore, but I suppose they still do sometimes. I have questioned whether I stood out more when I myself felt more self conscious. In those first few months/years I struggled to wear it in a way which felt natural to me, whereas now I'm very at home in what I wear and I think that comes across iyswim. Just keep on doing what you are doing, and know in your heart why you are doing it. Also remember that the stares may be interest or curiosity rather than anything religious.

SureJanSure · 05/06/2023 23:18

'Imma' is US slang for 'I'm going to'.

I'm going to -> I'm gonna -> I'm 'onna

-> I'm 'a or imma

Tooshyshyhushhushidoi · 05/06/2023 23:10

CharlottenBurger · 05/06/2023 22:51

Is spam allowed on here? What language is 'imma'?

well darling it’s not spam, one poster simply couldn’t fathom a long sleeve dress that wasn’t an abaya. Hopefully I’ve helped her.

and now to help you… imma is sort of a colloquial contraction of ‘I’m going to’. Any other slag that you need help with, feel free to PM me ;)

OP posts:
Coolhwip · 05/06/2023 23:01

CharlottenBurger · 05/06/2023 22:51

Is spam allowed on here? What language is 'imma'?

Who peed in your burger, Charlotte?

CharlottenBurger · 05/06/2023 22:51

Tooshyshyhushhushidoi · 05/06/2023 20:38

In fact imma leave the link here, now don’t get me wrong, not all work but many many do

please feel to peruse at your own leisure

https://www.asos.com/search/?q=long%20sleeve%20maxi%20dress&scrollTo=product-203825909&page=2

Is spam allowed on here? What language is 'imma'?

Darkmoad · 05/06/2023 22:20

Coolhwip · 05/06/2023 20:32

Oh dear, you've said the 'M' word. You'll now have to write a thesis on what you mean by modest clothing Wink

😂😂

Tooshyshyhushhushidoi · 05/06/2023 20:38

In fact imma leave the link here, now don’t get me wrong, not all work but many many do

please feel to peruse at your own leisure

https://www.asos.com/search/?q=long%20sleeve%20maxi%20dress&scrollTo=product-203825909&page=2

OP posts:
Tooshyshyhushhushidoi · 05/06/2023 20:34

@Tenacioustattle just in case modanisa didn’t convince of a dress like that’s existence, here’s some from asos. Now some I wouldn’t wear because I don’t like patterns but they fit the abaya adjacent criteria

https://www.asos.com/asos-design/asos-design-high-neck-big-sleeve-jacquard-maxi-dress-in-butterfly-floral-print/prd/202935397?clr=butterfly-floral&colourWayId=202935398&SearchQuery=long+sleeve+maxi+dress

https://www.asos.com/asos-design/asos-design-maxi-smock-dress-with-cutwork-in-natural/prd/204196953?clr=natural&colourWayId=204196954&SearchQuery=long+sleeve+maxi+dress. - scarf here would cover up the cut outs and keyholes, alternatively a chest cover piece (you can get them in Muslim shops) would work

https://www.asos.com/trendyol/trendyol-long-sleeve-side-wrap-maxi-dress-in-khaki-satin/prd/204424154?clr=khaki&colourWayId=204424155&SearchQuery=long+sleeve+maxi+dress

one more for luck

https://www.asos.com/asos-design/asos-design-long-sleeve-maxi-t-shirt-dress-in-black/prd/204624612?clr=black&colourWayId=204624613&SearchQuery=long+sleeve+maxi+dress. - I like this one… in fact I may purchase it

ASOS DESIGN high neck big sleeve jacquard maxi dress in butterfly floral print | ASOS

ASOS DESIGN high neck big sleeve jacquard maxi dress in butterfly floral print at ASOS. Shop this season’s must haves with multiple delivery and return options (Ts&Cs apply).

https://www.asos.com/asos-design/asos-design-high-neck-big-sleeve-jacquard-maxi-dress-in-butterfly-floral-print/prd/202935397?clr=butterfly-floral&colourWayId=202935398&SearchQuery=long+sleeve+maxi+dress

OP posts:
Coolhwip · 05/06/2023 20:32

Spendonsend · 05/06/2023 20:30

I live near a convent and a plymouth brethren meeting place. I see a lot of white women in modest clothing.
Although its different in style.

Oh dear, you've said the 'M' word. You'll now have to write a thesis on what you mean by modest clothing Wink

Coolhwip · 05/06/2023 20:31

Tooshyshyhushhushidoi · 05/06/2023 20:22

Ps there’s 371 pages of those type of dresses. Enjoy

Grin
Spendonsend · 05/06/2023 20:30

I live near a convent and a plymouth brethren meeting place. I see a lot of white women in modest clothing.
Although its different in style.

LivingDeadGirlUK · 05/06/2023 20:28

I have met several fair skinned ladies who wear the headscarf so I wouldn't stare or do a double take, but I have always lived in very diverse cities.

Tooshyshyhushhushidoi · 05/06/2023 20:22

Ps there’s 371 pages of those type of dresses. Enjoy

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread