Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the appeal of new build homes?

285 replies

GreenEyeGopher · 05/06/2023 12:09

I was looking at the proliferation of new build estates yesterday and wondering who buys homes there.

I don't think I've ever lived in a house that's much less than 100 years old.and would find it hard to imagine living in a new build. Or actually, I could imagine living in a new build home but not on a new estate - somehow they don't feel quite like 'real places' to me, everywhere I've lived has had a long time to get established!

So I'm just curious - if you live in a new build, or would like to - what is the appeal?

OP posts:
ChiaraRimini · 05/06/2023 13:30

There's a massive difference between a new build from a national house builder on a massive estate and a high quality new build. My new ish build house is on a small development built to a high spec.
I previously owned a Victorian terrace which had been modernised on the cheap, it was damp, plaster was crumbling and it had crappy fittings which would not have been economic to put right. Also no garage or off-street parking.

AmazingBouncingFerret · 05/06/2023 13:29

Because it was what I wanted.
Five bedrooms, utility room, two living rooms, and a dining room.
Also a garage and room for four cars on my driveway.
These things came above quirkiness in my criteria when looking.

Elevel · 05/06/2023 13:28

A lot of it will be personal taste. New builds aren't really for me, and you prefer your terraced house. For me, a terraced house would be hellish, whenever we've bought a house I've filtered terraces out as I won't even consider one. If it was a terrace or a detached new build, I'd be in that new build like a shot!
As others say, you can often buy them without a chain and no bidding war, which takes some of the stress out of the buying and conveyancing process.

Oblomov23 · 05/06/2023 13:27

I don't like them. Only because I've seen many and they are generally very poorly built. 3 of my friends bought bigger detached 4 bedroom new builds, but the snagging list went on forever and then there were drainage and foundation issues.

JennyJenny8675309 · 05/06/2023 13:27

New builds are out for me due to my preferences in home character, layout, fittings, privacy, etc. I prefer the character of cosy older homes rather than an open, modern layout.

When I was young and bought my first home I was thrilled to get a new build so I do understand why people choose them.

GasPanic · 05/06/2023 13:26

Old houses are ... old.

Old build. So much more prone to structural issues, damp. energy inefficient. Dodgy roofs.

Renovating listed can be a nightmare.

Soundproofing in old build is generally much worse.

Parking in older builds is much worse. The potential to have problems with deeds, rights of way, unregistered land any sort of legal issue is much higher with an old build.

New builds can be badly built, but also well built as well, a bit like any houses.

The thing I guess I like least about my new-ish build is that everything is "hidden" in the modern style - ie pipes behind walls etc. This means if something goes wrong, it can take a long time to discover (your ceiling gets wrecked before you discover the loose pipe joint) and you have to wreck the plasterboard to get to stuff to fix it.

I think people who say they "can't" live in new builds are a bit precious. Basically hundreds of thousands of people live in them perfectly happily. So the idea that they are "impossible" to live in is clearly idiocy.

bluebirdsongs · 05/06/2023 13:25

Not our first choice but....

We kept getting outbid and there's no a lot on the market in the area we want to live

No chain was an advantage to us as no risk of collapse

All bedrooms are generous sizes with no one in a box room

Other houses in our area we would have had to spend £££ to make them open plan or add a utility etc

It's well insulated so bills will be cheap

The garden is a blank space so we can plan it how we want it and it's large

It's a small development of only 5 houses in a central location, better location than other houses coming on the market in our area

We bought at the stage where we still have major input into fixtures, fittings and layout

We checked the builder & developers other properties and are satisfied the work is good

We're coming from a 100+ year old house and there was always something really odd with how it was built, the electrics, the gas, nothing was straightforward

Woofappreciationday · 05/06/2023 13:24

In my experience

More for money - ive got a 5 bed 2500sqft new build town house for the same money as a 3 bed 1920s style 1200sqft house.
Cheap to run -solar panels as standard, well insulated
Very little outlay - no boilers to replace, roof to replace etc in the first 10 years at least
Little decorating required in the first few years

And most of all location i am able to directly access the motorway in less than 2 minutes. I have a cinema complex in walking distance.

Yes my garden is small but im disabled anyway so the less the better.

My dad is even a builder himself and suggested a new build.... the shock. Because it made sense for me and my family.

Thats ultimately what it comes down to is personal choice.

Christmascracker0 · 05/06/2023 13:24

You know exactly how much it’s going to cost and how much cash is needed, as no offers involved.

Well insulated etc.

Don’t have to fix anyone else’s bodge jobs.

Usually 2 years of fixes free, then covered by NBHC for 10 years.

You can choose kitchens and bathrooms to be how you like.

No chain, usually you have a deadline to move by.

I personally would never choose and old house!

Zarataralara · 05/06/2023 13:23

planning to move to a new build from a 200 year old ‘ character ‘ property.
Light — bigger windows with no overhang that cuts light.
Better lay out.
modern insulation
better thought out storage. Design I’ve settled on has much better storage than the many pokey cupboards here.
Less maintenance.

Old properties that have a ‘history’ and ‘character’ are much overrated ime.

Ifyouarehappyandyouknowit123 · 05/06/2023 13:23

Life is so busy with kids, work, trying to survive that I think it just makes things a little easier when moving. You don't have to think about what 'hidden' issues there can be. (I do know that there can be many issues with new builds, just taking generally). I love the fact that it is a blank canvas and free to make it exactly as you want!

shieldmaiden7 · 05/06/2023 13:23

The first house I lived in after leaving my exdh was a new build, I lived there for 5 years and honestly it was the crappest workmanship. Everything broke, wobbled or creaked. I used to be friends with my neighbour and her house eas identical to mine which always felt like it had no character. Me and DH came in to money last year and bought a place ourselves. We looked at new builds but went with one built in 1880 and I love it! It has character, quirks and just feels solid.

Dibblydoodahdah · 05/06/2023 13:22

@fyn big generalisation there. I’ve got an eight seater table in my kitchen plus an island that seats four. I also have a ten seater table in a separate dining room. Yes, mine is on the bigger side of new builds but I actually find that smaller new builds are also better than the equivalent older properties with small galley kitchens.

Felicia00 · 05/06/2023 13:21

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/06/2023 13:16

@GreenEyeGopher

Maybe I misunderstood you so and I wasn't having a pop. I guess I have always found the bias against new homes baffling, irrational and basically boiling down to classism so the comment made me wonder.

For some reason there's an association made with new builds and being working class whereas period homes are thought to have some vague and non-specific "charm" as a result of being old, poorly insulated and wonky. I've always thought it utterly daft and saying a lot more about the British class system than it does about the intrinsic value of the homes. There is no snobbery attached to living in new homes in other parts of the developed world. People are rightly happy to live in well-designed, well built homes and don't worry about what it says about their status in the world.

It's just a snobbery thing which is a shame as many people in this country aren't particularly that well off. Instead of fussing over whether their house makes them look MC enough they could be spending the money on experiences for their DC. My SIL is all about the status , her DC never do anything days out, holidays because a lot of their income goes on heating and repairing their old house. Mention a new build and they go all sniffy. It's very sad.

driedgrassinavase · 05/06/2023 13:20

fyn · 05/06/2023 13:13

The layouts of new builds are just absolutely dreadful. We lived in one provided by my DH’s work and it was completely impractical. It was a townhouse style with a tiny ‘kitchen diner’ that barely fit a table in, we had to push it against the wall when we weren’t using it or the cupboards wouldn’t open and a living room that meant where ever you put your sofa it was in front of a radiator. All for the low, low price of £425,000 if you’d bought it new. Just cram as many into tiny foot prints as possible.

Now we are buying we have gone for an older house with loads of living space instead.

What every single new build is the same?

Somanycats · 05/06/2023 13:19

New build 30 years ago. Since then pretty much no maintenance. One boiler replacement and new windows, our choice. Accessible, easy to clean, low maintenance garden, sensible practical design, easy to heat, off street parking, a community as all original neighbours bought at the same time.
To me older house are high maintenance, inaccessible, often dirty as parts are out of reach due to odd design, hard to heart, have not enough parking and established communities that are hard to break into, or zero community. New build if possible every time for me if you plan a long-term home.

ooohoobigsummerblowout · 05/06/2023 13:18

GreenEyeGopher · 05/06/2023 12:26

Just because it's not what I'd personally choose doesn't mean it's not what other people would choose - hence the question!

I'm interested in whether people are buying them because they're looking at a new estate and thinking "oooh I'd love to live there!" or its because it's about finance etc (e.g help to buy, shared ownership etc) or some other practical considerations.

It sounds a bit like, again, it's the apparent shock of someone thinking they'd actually love to live in a new house that's confusing! Because obviously the only other reason could be financial. I think the thread shows the wealth of appealing factors.

I have bought and lived in two new builds, with many of the benefits already noted important to me (good size / layout, big garden, efficiency, good town planning, close to where I need to be, views, total choice and costs clear).

I love making my own history in my bespoke home, built just for me and my family, instead of living in someone else's history.

Not to mention dirt - I hear you PP about new toilets and showers! 🤣 - nor the decoration / fixtures / fittings I'd have to spend time and money removing, when everything was as I wanted it on the day I moved in.

Family live in Victorian properties with different joys and costs, that's not right for me and a new build isn't right for them. Old and new properties are comparable in terms of desirability - but there are some interesting views finances or perceived prestige!

Prettypaisleyslippers · 05/06/2023 13:18

My new build house is 4 bedrooms, 3 storey with a bathroom on each floor, nice enclosed garden, amazing views and location. Ample parking. Super low cost to run, I pay about £120 for both gas and electric (even in winter). Well sound proofed, next door had a full on party and I didn’t realise until I went outside for something

Felicia00 · 05/06/2023 13:16

New builds do have more practical layouts utility room , extra toilets, bathrooms ,parking and a double garage are a must for me. A lot of older properties don't have practical layouts.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/06/2023 13:16

@GreenEyeGopher

Maybe I misunderstood you so and I wasn't having a pop. I guess I have always found the bias against new homes baffling, irrational and basically boiling down to classism so the comment made me wonder.

For some reason there's an association made with new builds and being working class whereas period homes are thought to have some vague and non-specific "charm" as a result of being old, poorly insulated and wonky. I've always thought it utterly daft and saying a lot more about the British class system than it does about the intrinsic value of the homes. There is no snobbery attached to living in new homes in other parts of the developed world. People are rightly happy to live in well-designed, well built homes and don't worry about what it says about their status in the world.

Beaujolaisqueen · 05/06/2023 13:15

You sound like a bit of a snob tbh. I’ve owned a 150 year old house and now live in a 3 year old house. I purposely did not want an old house, yes in some ways it was more aesthetically pleasing but it was also cold, draughty and damp. DIY was a nightmare as everything was wonky or had been botched 3 times before or needed a specialist to help. I was constantly worried about unexpected maintenance costs. My newer house is cheaper to run, warmer, more
comfortable and looks nice too. My parents actually chose a new build for retirement having owned a Victorian property as they were fed up of being cold and doing constant maintenance.

But then I’ve never been someone who has thought falling in love with a house = I should buy it, because I know practicalities of an old house, even if I prefer their character, will eventually make me fall out of love with it!

GeraltsBathtub · 05/06/2023 13:13

GreenEyeGopher · 05/06/2023 13:09

I think people buy out of convenience and not because they want a new build as such.

That's what I was wondering really - basically do people really fall in love with new builds and they just don't float my boat in the same way that we're not all attracted to the same kind of people. Or is it that people are buying what's practical and affordable and new builds happen to tick the most boxes?

Isn’t that what people do when buying a house whatever the type of house it is? I didn’t buy my Victorian house because of the character wonkiness, I bought it because it was in the right location for transport, had the right number of rooms and was within budget. We actually offered on a modern house as well which had the benefit of an upstairs bathroom but it was further from the station and we were outbid on that one.

User63847484848 · 05/06/2023 13:13

Low running costs
shiny and new
maybe the only options in budget in areas with low housing stock
layouts these days seem good and geared to modern living eg kitchen diner, ensuite.
thankfully the phase of having excessive numbers of bathrooms seems to have passed but one ensuite is useful for a family

Crikeyalmighty · 05/06/2023 13:13

Two of the best houses we have rented were less than 12 years old , not exactly new builds but newish- but neither were on estates.

Dandruffpandruff · 05/06/2023 13:13

GreenEyeGopher · 05/06/2023 13:09

I think people buy out of convenience and not because they want a new build as such.

That's what I was wondering really - basically do people really fall in love with new builds and they just don't float my boat in the same way that we're not all attracted to the same kind of people. Or is it that people are buying what's practical and affordable and new builds happen to tick the most boxes?

It's a little unhealthy to be this obsessed about people's house buying choices...