Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the appeal of new build homes?

285 replies

GreenEyeGopher · 05/06/2023 12:09

I was looking at the proliferation of new build estates yesterday and wondering who buys homes there.

I don't think I've ever lived in a house that's much less than 100 years old.and would find it hard to imagine living in a new build. Or actually, I could imagine living in a new build home but not on a new estate - somehow they don't feel quite like 'real places' to me, everywhere I've lived has had a long time to get established!

So I'm just curious - if you live in a new build, or would like to - what is the appeal?

OP posts:
TheHandmaiden · 05/06/2023 13:52

@wildfirewonder - my point exactly! People often judge these places but literally it's NEW. I do think that they will, like any new development, get those softening elements with time.

ComtesseDeSpair · 05/06/2023 13:52

With the exception of converted churches, thatched country cottages with inglenooks, and former sixteenth century coaching inns, how many older homes nowadays actually have character or many original features anyway? We’ve been considering moving at some point fairly soon and idly browsing Rightmove and regardless of the age of the properties, new build, post-war or Victorian, there are virtually no differences to the interiors. You could stand inside and be anywhere. Virtually everyone favours the modern uniform of flooring of the hardwood parquet kind, either stark white or F&B emulsioned walls, plantation shutters, crittal shower enclosures with metro tiles and marble, and faux-mid century furniture. There’s no “character” to any of it. A few of the houses clearly owned by older residents and not updated in the last few years have escaped most of the above; but they aren’t quaint bastions of nineteenth century period charm and character, they have dusky pink carpets or pine floorboards, gas fires and UPVC windows.

I suppose if you like to spend a lot of time outside your house staring at it, the age of the building might matter. Personally, I do not do this very much.

Nordicrain · 05/06/2023 13:52

It's interesting that a thread like this has attracted all those building experts who can say with certainty that all new builds are terribly built and won't last half a decade. Who knew there were so many of them on MN.

SOBplus · 05/06/2023 13:51

UK: new build, spend 10 years fixing builder mistakes
US: new build, everything is new, fully functional so no headaches to deal with

wildfirewonder · 05/06/2023 13:50

RitaFires · 05/06/2023 13:40

I find it weird when people act like newbuilds are all the same and inferior to older properties.

In my area there are lots of tiny terraced older houses some of which are in poor condition whereas the newbuilds are very high spec, have plenty of parking and are designed to be convenient for modern life.

Yes same here - rows and rows of terraces with minimal foundations, excessively steep stairs and very small rooms, and lots of 1930s semis with single skin porches that always end up with interior mould in the hall.

We have some beautiful new homes, built to the highest environmental standards.

My friend's newer house is also so much better than my older property for wheelchair/zimmer/general access requirements.

Freshair1 · 05/06/2023 13:49

One thing I've noticed about mass produced new builds is that they're filled with minimal furniture. Decorated to the hilt and distracting so you don't realise that there's basically a small double and a wardrobe plus bedside tables in a "master bedroom." It also is outrageous that there is zero infrastructure so you're paying to live on an estate. Nearby, there are new builds without a single school, shop or chemist.

TakemedowntoPotatoCity · 05/06/2023 13:49

There aren't many sectors - fashion maybe - where second hand is considered better.

provided that the new build is built well, I like the idea that everything is new and untouched by others. No mould, built in dirt, egg and you can make your own mark on it. Just my thoughts.

GnomeDePlume · 05/06/2023 13:48

I grew up in a 1920s garden city semi. Lovely except it was cold and draughty, 'characterful' plumbing, generation's of dodgy 'improvements', old pre-building regs wiring, cold water tank in the loft rather than fresh water coming from the main.

As a student I lived in a single skin 1900s terrace. It was not warm

Now I live in a 17 year old house bought as a new build. Any early problems were dealt with by the developer. We have extended and made some internal changes as our needs have changed.

I would only now live in an older house if it was thoroughly modernised. Original features are only the decorative fashion of the time when they were put in. They don't have an inherent quality just because they are old.

wildfirewonder · 05/06/2023 13:47

Older properties come with gardens, trees and this softens how they look. They didn't when they were built.

New builds don't have this mostly. Yet.

Floralys2 · 05/06/2023 13:45

I've never heard anything positive said about new builds

They are well known for being built as fast as possible and being bodged to get the job done quick

TheHandmaiden · 05/06/2023 13:44

There is one thing about new builds which is that landscaping is awful. Older properties come with gardens, trees and this softens how they look.

New builds don't have this mostly. Though neither does large parts of suburban London where people rip out the front gardens. Row upon row of 1930s semis with paved front gardens.

MooMooSharoo · 05/06/2023 13:43

The only house I've ever lived in that was over 100 years old had so much damp it ended up being knocked down and replaced. Old doesn't = better

Plenty of reasons for people to buy new builds - location, availability, design, lack of initial maintenance allowing for more family time, etc.

DuchessOfSausage · 05/06/2023 13:42

@GreenEyeGopher , I mentioned it, but I meant in terms of everything is new. The carpets are new, the bath has never been usefd etc.

I know someone who when she and her DH moved house to a newly converted apartment, she insisted on having new everything including crockery and bedding. She kept her husband though.

RitaFires · 05/06/2023 13:40

I find it weird when people act like newbuilds are all the same and inferior to older properties.

In my area there are lots of tiny terraced older houses some of which are in poor condition whereas the newbuilds are very high spec, have plenty of parking and are designed to be convenient for modern life.

Creditcrunch2243 · 05/06/2023 13:39

Our first house was a new build. We had an £8000 deposit and it was cheap to heat so we were able to save money. This was years ago, there’s absolutely no chance we would be able to buy for the first time these days without the new buyer schemes that come with new builds.

GreenEyeGopher · 05/06/2023 13:38

I find it quite interesting how many people have said that part of the appeal is that no-one else has lived there before (purely because I'm the opposite and part of the appeal of an older property is precisely that other people have lived there before - I like the idea that different families have come and gone over the years).

OP posts:
Porridgeislife · 05/06/2023 13:38

Don’t quite get the British obsession with Victorian housing stock. The Victorians were the original developers of identikit housing, you got a house absolutely identical to your neighbour and the surrounding streets.

To claim new builds have no character but Victorian homes do is baffling.

We have neither a new build not period home but I don’t miss our Victorian flat at all. The Victorians were as fond of a building shortcut as Barrett are today.

TheHandmaiden · 05/06/2023 13:37

It's mostly snobbery I think. Who really has time to think of people's houses in this way? Many people will struggle to buy their own home, anyone who manages it (short of Right to Buy) should be congratulated.

Also being invited to someone's home is privilege and even if it not your ideal taste or place then you should be complimentary and seek to find the positives. That's being a good guest.

fyn · 05/06/2023 13:37

@driedgrassinavase well on the estate we were housed on the majority were the same. When we were looking for houses they were absolutely prolific, three storeys to get the bedrooms in but reduce the footprint and cram more houses into the estate. We think they are so massively impractical for families.

https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/131318828#/?channel=RES_NEW

Check out this 3 bedroom semi-detached house for sale on Rightmove

3 bedroom semi-detached house for sale in Vickers Way, Warwick, CV34 for £450,000. Marketed by David Wilson Homes

https://www.rightmove.co.uk/properties/131318828#/?channel=RES_NEW

AffIt · 05/06/2023 13:36

As the proud but occasionally frustrated owner of a 'quirky' 150-year-old property (its biggest fault being that it suffers from an excess of personality sometimes) I can kind of see the appeal of NBs, a bit.

I would imagine that buying one saves you a considerable amount of time watching YouTube to learn random DIY techniques, for example.

I do think this from time to time (normally just after I've shelled out on yet another massive bill of some form or another), but then I think about it and realise that nah, actually I wouldn't give up all this light and space and character and mad bits, even if it did mean having plumb walls and underfloor heating.

The good outweighs the bad (and expensive).

Beaujolaisqueen · 05/06/2023 13:34

We also had loads of problems when moving with sellers changing their minds, long chains etc. if we didn’t find this 3 year old house our next option was to reserve a new build as we needed somewhere to live.

tattygrl · 05/06/2023 13:33

I'm definitely not middle or upper class, and I can't stand new builds. They're (to me) utterly soulless and make me feel like I'm in a show room on a retail park. I obviously appreciate everyone's taste is different, but I've always found it possible to find affordable places to live that aren't new builds. Not talking ancient stately homes or listed buildings, just pre-existing buildings with their own normal history - terraced houses on streets in towns etc. I can understand that people end up having to live places that wouldn't be their first choice, of course! But purely in matters of taste, as I feel this post asks about, I find them deadening.

Nordicrain · 05/06/2023 13:31

GreenEyeGopher · 05/06/2023 13:09

I think people buy out of convenience and not because they want a new build as such.

That's what I was wondering really - basically do people really fall in love with new builds and they just don't float my boat in the same way that we're not all attracted to the same kind of people. Or is it that people are buying what's practical and affordable and new builds happen to tick the most boxes?

It's both I'd say.

Our first house was a victorian terrace. It was what we could afford at the time where we were. That's much the same thing isn't it?

TheChosenTwo · 05/06/2023 13:31

My biggest bugbears with the ones that have sprung up round here is the lack of space and privacy, the ones I’ve been to when visiting friends are very small and overlooked from almost every window in every room.
The finished quality also leaves a lot to be desired, lack of attention to detail had caused a lot of frustration but only been discovered after living there for a couple of months.

GreenEyeGopher · 05/06/2023 13:30

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/06/2023 13:16

@GreenEyeGopher

Maybe I misunderstood you so and I wasn't having a pop. I guess I have always found the bias against new homes baffling, irrational and basically boiling down to classism so the comment made me wonder.

For some reason there's an association made with new builds and being working class whereas period homes are thought to have some vague and non-specific "charm" as a result of being old, poorly insulated and wonky. I've always thought it utterly daft and saying a lot more about the British class system than it does about the intrinsic value of the homes. There is no snobbery attached to living in new homes in other parts of the developed world. People are rightly happy to live in well-designed, well built homes and don't worry about what it says about their status in the world.

I'd not really thought about the class angle but it does make sense in that peculiarly British inverted snobbery way. It's bringing to mind that documentary series Grayson Perry did a few years ago about class (or something like that...wasn't it about British taste and class signifiers?)

OP posts: