Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the appeal of new build homes?

285 replies

GreenEyeGopher · 05/06/2023 12:09

I was looking at the proliferation of new build estates yesterday and wondering who buys homes there.

I don't think I've ever lived in a house that's much less than 100 years old.and would find it hard to imagine living in a new build. Or actually, I could imagine living in a new build home but not on a new estate - somehow they don't feel quite like 'real places' to me, everywhere I've lived has had a long time to get established!

So I'm just curious - if you live in a new build, or would like to - what is the appeal?

OP posts:
StatisticallyChallenged · 05/06/2023 15:05

driedgrassinavase · 05/06/2023 14:25

God it sounds awful wouldn’t you be happier in a Victorian terrace?

just kidding it sounds pretty ideal to me

I know, what were we thinking!!

Actually couple of others which mattered for us (and relates to question a PP asked about where are they cheaper)

  • no chain, so easy purchase
  • no offers over/bidding wars. I'm in Scotland so this is a big factor. We viewed an older bungalow just round the corner. About the same floor space, bigger plot, and about 10% cheaper. It actually sold for about 7% more and it needed at least 20% again spent - new windows everywhere, new boiler, new kitchen, take out at least one wall, new, bathrooms etc.

The offers over element is a biggy for people with limited cash/equity here. Our surveyor valuation matched purchase price, none of the neighbours had an issue. With an older property you might get say home report 500k, listed at o/o 450k, sells for 550k. Buyer needs to find required mortgage deposit on 500k(the official value) plus the 50k they went over to secure the property.

Curiosity101 · 05/06/2023 15:05

Sorry that shouldn't be bold and should read 3.65x4.32m and 3.65x3.2m

Lesson learnt - don't use * in place of x cause of the MN formatting 😁

Curiosity101 · 05/06/2023 15:02

@originalglazedsingle That's the main thing that surprised me on here. What you describe is similar to our local new build estates. You definitely pay a premium to buy a new build around here. And what reads wonderfully on paper is often not the case when you view it.

One of the ones we viewed was 3.654.32m for the master bedroom. Except that there was an ensuite built into the room so it was actually more like 3.653.2m with a corridor of just over 1m length into the room. It literally fit a king size bed with just enough room to scooch around it, built in wardrobes and two tiny side tables. Our box room in our current house is 2.9*3m...😑

We will still keep considering new builds though. There's a lovely slightly older estate nearby which I'd love to move to. I think it was probably built in the 70's and definitely has the feel of somewhere where the focus was building homes for people rather than cramming in as many houses as possible to maximise profits. It's incredibly rare that they come up for sale though and they get snapped up immediately.

Bluevelvetsofa · 05/06/2023 14:55

All those programmes where people want character properties. Then they’re shown them and don’t like the low ceiling height/ beams/ small kitchen/ whatever. Then there are the ‘character’ properties that have been made over with supposedly traditional looking kitchens and bathrooms, but are just a disguise for new. If you want an old house, buy an old house and bear in mind the costs for fuel, maintenance, insulation, wear and tear and upkeep. And don’t be snotty about people who like something different.

HowNowBrownElephant · 05/06/2023 14:32

Ours is 150 years old, lots of character…. but doesn’t have a single straight wall, a wonky kitchen window, 40-50 years of bodged / half arsed DIY jobs, and very, very antiquated plumbing. Sometimes I crave the flat walls and clean lines of a new build 😂

Crikeyalmighty · 05/06/2023 14:28

We have a beautiful 1898 rented 4 bed semi- extremely well modernised, lovely chunky radiators, nice bits of colour throughout , beautiful garden and in a lovely area- and as befits it costs a fair bit. but it was a real find-

most older houses we viewed had half done DIY , occasionally damp patches , needed a good decorate and to be honest most could have done with £20k spent on them- and these were advertised as fully renovated. A reasonable kitchen and a few nice shutters really isn't fully renovated. My friend who bought said the same, in the end she bought a doer upper for £85 k less than a 'done up one' but had the work done almost immediately I can see why people go for new , or newish, although I don't like big estates and I don't drive- so anywhere in middle of nowhere isn't good for me.

driedgrassinavase · 05/06/2023 14:28

originalglazedsingle · 05/06/2023 14:22

Where do people live that new build are cheaper to purchase?

I understand that it gets cheaper in maintenance charges, but I am South East, and all the new build come with an impressive premium. A new build with similar amount of rooms is a lot more expensive, a new build with the same square footage is on another level. I wouldn't live in a new build simply because I can't afford to buy one!

Some are hideous: built in the wrong area (floodplains, contaminated lands.. how do they get permit is anyone's guess), they are tiny, no storage and the show room has specially designed furniture extra small to give the illusion of space. Even these are more expensive, and the better designed new houses are just luxury.

You are lucky if you can purchase a cheaper home, it's not the case at all where I am, and it's not just a small premium because it's brand new.

It’s certainly cheaper if you buy off plan but then you sort of have to take the builders word what you’ll end up with. I’m in the south east too (Kent) and the new build vs older houses was pretty much the same cost. Depends on the builder too - the local builder was more willing to do a deal than the national chain

driedgrassinavase · 05/06/2023 14:25

StatisticallyChallenged · 05/06/2023 14:02

Size - larger than most of the older properties around here
Overall better layout - good sized bedrooms, good downstairs, quite big rooms, big windows/doors.
No immediate work needed bar decorating
Being able to get issues fixed on the builder's dime for a few years (every older place we've lived in has had hidden issues)
Nice sized gardens
Quiet dead end on a nice, quite open and spacious new street
Lots of families for kids to make friends with
Brand new school
Off road parking
On a good bus route
Cheap to run - very well insulated

We moved from a charming period property and were looking for another originally but this ticked far more boxes

God it sounds awful wouldn’t you be happier in a Victorian terrace?

just kidding it sounds pretty ideal to me

originalglazedsingle · 05/06/2023 14:22

Where do people live that new build are cheaper to purchase?

I understand that it gets cheaper in maintenance charges, but I am South East, and all the new build come with an impressive premium. A new build with similar amount of rooms is a lot more expensive, a new build with the same square footage is on another level. I wouldn't live in a new build simply because I can't afford to buy one!

Some are hideous: built in the wrong area (floodplains, contaminated lands.. how do they get permit is anyone's guess), they are tiny, no storage and the show room has specially designed furniture extra small to give the illusion of space. Even these are more expensive, and the better designed new houses are just luxury.

You are lucky if you can purchase a cheaper home, it's not the case at all where I am, and it's not just a small premium because it's brand new.

Hollyppp · 05/06/2023 14:14

GreenEyeGopher · 05/06/2023 12:09

I was looking at the proliferation of new build estates yesterday and wondering who buys homes there.

I don't think I've ever lived in a house that's much less than 100 years old.and would find it hard to imagine living in a new build. Or actually, I could imagine living in a new build home but not on a new estate - somehow they don't feel quite like 'real places' to me, everywhere I've lived has had a long time to get established!

So I'm just curious - if you live in a new build, or would like to - what is the appeal?

We live in a new build, it’s a close of 6 houses so not quite an estate. I don’t know if that changes your judgment or not?

We like living here because it was ready made, all high spec (not a starter home new build), it’s 5 beds. We had a baby a year or two later and didn’t want to spend weekends on a doer upper.
we could entertain from the first few weekends and not spend time on the house.

Have lived here 5 years and plan to for another 5

hermioneee · 05/06/2023 14:13

The Victorians were notorious for knocking up cheap housing as quickly as possible. Be careful what you wish for with your characterful terrace.

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/06/2023 14:11

Well, you'd be mistaken. Forget all the people who live in new(ish) builds and what they say about them, because the owners of the charmingly unique victorian semis say that they are all built of cardboard, ready to fall down and have no facilities.

Absolutely, I must be imagining my pretty solid, well insulated, easy to clean and maintain house with straight walls, flat floors not to mention all the easily accessible local amenities. I have extended family in old sandstone buildings, absolutely beautiful to look at but every one of them have sunk £10,000s into them I’ve the years. And the heating bills…

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 05/06/2023 14:10

wildfirewonder · 05/06/2023 13:47

Older properties come with gardens, trees and this softens how they look. They didn't when they were built.

New builds don't have this mostly. Yet.

Exactly! Now ours are 10 years old there are some enormous trees in the front gardens, big healthy established hedges and mature shrubs.

TallulahBetty · 05/06/2023 14:08

YOUR preference of house sounds like a nightmare to me, and I'm sure many others.

Withnailandeye · 05/06/2023 14:05

I just find it so depressing how small the gardens are in all the new builds around here, tiny little postage stamp gardens, utterly miserable.

Lostmum2407 · 05/06/2023 14:04

GreenEyeGopher · 05/06/2023 12:09

I was looking at the proliferation of new build estates yesterday and wondering who buys homes there.

I don't think I've ever lived in a house that's much less than 100 years old.and would find it hard to imagine living in a new build. Or actually, I could imagine living in a new build home but not on a new estate - somehow they don't feel quite like 'real places' to me, everywhere I've lived has had a long time to get established!

So I'm just curious - if you live in a new build, or would like to - what is the appeal?

I’m buying a new build because I’m recently divorced. I have £200 000 and don’t want a mortgage as my job is temporary. I’d like to buy a house outright. For £200 000 I could buy a new build with a new kitchen, bathroom, paved driveway etc or I could buy a house for £160 000 which seems to be the cheapest where everything needs doing, I’m talking avocado bathrooms and beige dated kitchens here. £40 000 doesn’t stretch far. I don’t do DIY either so I’d have to pay for ten work to be done. Therefore a new build is the best option.

StatisticallyChallenged · 05/06/2023 14:02

Size - larger than most of the older properties around here
Overall better layout - good sized bedrooms, good downstairs, quite big rooms, big windows/doors.
No immediate work needed bar decorating
Being able to get issues fixed on the builder's dime for a few years (every older place we've lived in has had hidden issues)
Nice sized gardens
Quiet dead end on a nice, quite open and spacious new street
Lots of families for kids to make friends with
Brand new school
Off road parking
On a good bus route
Cheap to run - very well insulated

We moved from a charming period property and were looking for another originally but this ticked far more boxes

Toddlerteaplease · 05/06/2023 14:01

My parents are buying one because they can have the upgrades they a
Want, and it won't need anything doing.

TheHandmaiden · 05/06/2023 13:58

Tbh old houses are often money pits. Particularly Victorian terraces with their dump, crumbling walls! They can also be a right pig to heat

Postbox87 · 05/06/2023 13:57

I've lived in my new build for 2 years and love it. Never had any issues with the house, it's always lovely and warm, no chain when buying it, comes with double driveway so no parking issues, everyone in the cul de sac looks after their house/garden, low maintenance, house was a blank canvas so could decorate as pleased, easy to clean/tidy.

I always thought I wanted a older house, I had to quickly buy this due to a relationship breakdown. I would never go back now :)

Corknut · 05/06/2023 13:55

We come from the generation of perpetual renting and the impossibility of saving for a deposit. We got on the property ladder very late. This has meant our options have been limited and unlike a lot of our peers (think help from family or a bit older than us) we only managed to buy a small flat in an old tenement building in 2018 despite living together for nearly 15 years. We loved it but started bursting out of it almost immediately. We needed to move to a bigger place but didn’t have the cash to really do it. We ended up part-exchanging for a biggish new build just before covid. Do I love it? No. Is it what I wanted? No. But it’s our house and we have a garden and room for our cats and crap. One day I might get my dream old house that has a leaky roof but sometimes it just feels we missed the property ladder boat when we were too young (and poor) to invest. I hope that clears up some preconceptions about a nouveau riche, white walled grey carpeted box. Although we do still have a lot of white walls…

GreenEyeGopher · 05/06/2023 13:55

Porridgeislife · 05/06/2023 13:38

Don’t quite get the British obsession with Victorian housing stock. The Victorians were the original developers of identikit housing, you got a house absolutely identical to your neighbour and the surrounding streets.

To claim new builds have no character but Victorian homes do is baffling.

We have neither a new build not period home but I don’t miss our Victorian flat at all. The Victorians were as fond of a building shortcut as Barrett are today.

Yes I guess I could just have easily framed the question the other way round!

It is kind of weird that in almost all other purchases "new" is seen as preferrable to "old" or "second hand" - but there's a sizable chunk of the population who prefer old when it comes to homes.

OP posts:
BounceyB · 05/06/2023 13:55

I loved my "new" build (15 years old when I bought it) for the first month. Then slowly I realised all the problems. Everything that broke - which was frequently- would cost a lot of money to repair. I can't talk about the problems I had because it would be really outing but in a nutshell the problems ended up costing me £50k to sort out over 5 years. The service charge was also extortionate. I moved because of it in the end. Been in 90 year house a couple of months now. I hated it initially but not a single problem yet except for the stuff I knew about. I'm feeling optimistic.

Nordicrain · 05/06/2023 13:55

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/06/2023 13:53

My home was newly built when I bought it 20+ years ago. We have a good sized garden, no one overlooking us and have adapted the house as our needs have changed. We have two primary schools next door, a GP surgery, dentist, local shops and a pub within walking distance.

Well, you'd be mistaken. Forget all the people who live in new(ish) builds and what they say about them, because the owners of the charmingly unique victorian semis say that they are all built of cardboard, ready to fall down and have no facilities.

Jellycatspyjamas · 05/06/2023 13:53

My home was newly built when I bought it 20+ years ago. We have a good sized garden, no one overlooking us and have adapted the house as our needs have changed. We have two primary schools next door, a GP surgery, dentist, local shops and a pub within walking distance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread