Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dream being shattered by husband, how to cope?

307 replies

WanderlustLost · 05/06/2023 09:13

I'm looking for advice on how to cope when you are being held back from your achievable dream.

I want to move out of the area we live in. We made a strategic move to an expensive area with a large mortgage for schools.

We planned (I thought) to only be here while our child attends school (5-7years) and then move out of the area.

We live in our home town and for as long as I remember I wanted to move, I don't like where we live although it's very popular, I want to live in the country.

He has now said he doesn't want to move.

This now means a huge mortgage over our heads until 68!

It also means being stuck in a house neither of us are particularly fond of.

It means I will never get out of this town.

He doesn't like moving, the packing, the paying the solicitor and the estate agent for their services and he doesn't want to be far from work even though moving would allow for him to retire early.

If I try and talk to him he just gets angry and then doesn't talk to me for days but I can't cope with the idea of living here forever.

What would you do, how would you manage the feeling of loss that losing an achievable dream brings?

I'm gutted and while I'm hiding my feelings from our children the older ones know what this means to me and are angry with their dad (he told me in front of them and I've spoken for years about the long term goal). It's their dream too.

Right now I want to curl up in bed and hide, I'm not obviously but I feel like what is the point. We will work out guts out till we die for what? A house we don't like in a place we hate.

OP posts:
CrazyHedgehogLover · 06/06/2023 18:52

You say he was “murmuring etc” I mean this in the kindest way OP, you sound like your pressuring him into this.

I agree with another poster that it really isn’t a good idea to sell up right now, I’d focus on the children, trying to get the marriage back stronger and then attempt to discuss it.. not where your saying “please tell me you agree” because in all honesty, he might just not want to move and people are allowed to change their mind. That’s where you’d need to make a decision on your happiness and compromise with him (if your planning to sell come up to a area your both happy with, if your not planning to sell decide if you want to stay or go)

it’s not fair to pressure someone into doing anything, If he doesn’t like change and moving etc.

I think it’s unfair for people to be saying how awful he is just because he’s apparently “promised you something and let you down” in a nutshell, if this was roles reversed everyone would be telling him that it’s not fair to put pressure on.. I’ve seen a couple of posts where someone has said “oh he’s agreed just tell him your doing it then as he’s already agreed”, how is that fair?

focus on your marriage first OP, get back stronger with him and try to compromise, if not only you can make the choice from there on..

whatausername · 06/06/2023 18:52

WanderlustLost · 05/06/2023 09:30

Yes, we've been together 22 years and this his reaction to every disagreement.

He can't cope with saying no so he says nothing until that thing starts to happen and then he freaks out.

He hates arguments so he'll get cross and then not talk.

Oh for Heaven's sake, life's too short, get rid of him and open a new chapter in your life!

Cherrysoup · 06/06/2023 18:48

Me and my DH have the same idea, move to the country when we retire, I bloody hope he doesn’t change his mind when it comes to it.

LadyLapsang · 06/06/2023 18:48

Two hour round trip.

LadyLapsang · 06/06/2023 18:47

I think you shouldn’t underestimate the identity many people gain from their work, especially men of the generation that had no paternity leave etc. If your husband has ASD it may be all the more difficult to adjust to retirement and losing some /all of the relationships he has with colleagues. If my maths is right he is still in his 50s anyway. However, if he does want to carry on working, surely it makes sense to live where you are, if you move he will have a two hour trip to the yard and then have to drive to his jobs. I wouldn’t want to do that in my mid sixties.

I would take the pressure off the move for now or you could look for a rental in the area to see how you both feel. I rather get the impression this is your dream and I’m not sure involving the children, even though they are young adults, is helpful.

Crumpleton · 06/06/2023 18:46

WilkinsonM · 05/06/2023 09:23

He gets angry and refuses to talk to you for days?
get a divorce, sell the house and buy a little place where you want to without him.
not even joking.

This.
As dramatic as this seems its to be considered if you really want to live the life you imagine and really want.

OP I don't know how old you are but the years go by so quickly.
I've seen many posts where it's always one half of the partnership, and to be fair mostly the man, dictating where they live and no discussion will be had once the decision has been made.
It does seem so wrong that no consideration is given for what the other sides feelings.

Life isn't a dress rehearsal and I expect many many people of a certain age, for want of a better phrase wish that looking back they'd have taken the plunge.

Pamalot · 06/06/2023 18:39

Find him somewhere with a mancave or cellar or some great outbuildings. Maybe if he can visualise himself somewhere it would help but forget about him retiring for now.

justasking111 · 06/06/2023 18:38

WanderlustLost · 05/06/2023 09:13

I'm looking for advice on how to cope when you are being held back from your achievable dream.

I want to move out of the area we live in. We made a strategic move to an expensive area with a large mortgage for schools.

We planned (I thought) to only be here while our child attends school (5-7years) and then move out of the area.

We live in our home town and for as long as I remember I wanted to move, I don't like where we live although it's very popular, I want to live in the country.

He has now said he doesn't want to move.

This now means a huge mortgage over our heads until 68!

It also means being stuck in a house neither of us are particularly fond of.

It means I will never get out of this town.

He doesn't like moving, the packing, the paying the solicitor and the estate agent for their services and he doesn't want to be far from work even though moving would allow for him to retire early.

If I try and talk to him he just gets angry and then doesn't talk to me for days but I can't cope with the idea of living here forever.

What would you do, how would you manage the feeling of loss that losing an achievable dream brings?

I'm gutted and while I'm hiding my feelings from our children the older ones know what this means to me and are angry with their dad (he told me in front of them and I've spoken for years about the long term goal). It's their dream too.

Right now I want to curl up in bed and hide, I'm not obviously but I feel like what is the point. We will work out guts out till we die for what? A house we don't like in a place we hate.

My tortoise 🐢 was just like this. I did everything, estate agents, solicitors, packing, removals. The only thing he did was pack up his shed. We actually moved from very rural to a village. Two had married, third child was 14.

Seven years on he still says he'd move back to his 2.5 acres, big house. After two torn rotor cuff injuries a knee that is kaput I just roll my eyes.

We had twenty wonderful years rurally but it can be very lonely, isolated. So we picked a more urban setting a big bungalow, near, shops, the river, there are buses!!!

Our rural home energy bills 3.5k eight years ago. Now abou £1200 per annum. That is a bonus.

We never lost our friends, social circle, didn't have to change schools. @WanderlustLost there's a lot to think about.

Lullab · 06/06/2023 18:33

Start looking at properties you could move to and find some you think he would like. Send him the links and see if he is interested. Sometimes it just takes a nudge in the right direction especially if the payments would be much cheaper!

CantFindMyMarbles · 06/06/2023 18:30

This is one of those situations where you’re both invalidating each others thoughts and feelings.
your desire to move isn’t more superior than his desire to stay.

revisit the topic in a couple of years and see how he feels then. There may well be more to his side of things than you’re aware of or letting on.

Kilofoxtrot99 · 06/06/2023 18:29

OP- you could be reporting my own exact situation. It’s painful on many levels. We have had the exact same experience and I have not ever wanted to be someone who forces their other half into a decision about moving. But after 10 years of agreeing that when oldest child was certain age, we would sell our house and make the move, it all came crashing down. I won’t lie, it has completely changed our marriage and the way I view my husband. Our children are of an age where they can leave home to start their own lives now and they are both planning the move that we had talked about all their lives. I love my husband but feel completely betrayed by the lie that he was agreeing to all these years in letting me believe that this move was ever going to happen.

Pamalot · 06/06/2023 18:26

Apologies if I am repeating what someone else has said as I have only read OP’s account. Before you mentioned your daughter has ASD I was thinking maybe that is the issue with your husband. For him you have given him two major issues moving house and giving up work. If he struggles with change these will both be extremely difficult for him. Perhaps work on the move first and dont mention leaving his job.

Densol57 · 06/06/2023 17:58

OP - Id get divorced, split the assets and live where you want.
You can get a no fault divorce.
Id never live the rest of my life unhappy in a house for any man like this

Densol57 · 06/06/2023 17:56

Ffsmakeitstop · 05/06/2023 09:32

We are currently having the opposite issue. DH is 68, hasn't worked for 14 years due to ill health. I am 65 and work full time and need to work till 70 to pay our mortgage. I will also get my pension.
I paid all our outgoings until he got his pension last year because he wasn't entitled to any benefits, which meant I've had to extend the mortgage to still have a home. To say it was stressful is an understatement.
We are now in a reasonable position where we can afford days out on a weekend, nothing extravagant just a drive and lunch out. BUT because he's bored and rarely sees people he wants to sell up and live in a caravan. He cannot see why I don't want to. I fee! I have worked too hard to end up living with no space and not much privacy.
His reasoning is partly that the garden is a bit big to manage, I think we could pay someone to do it and we have adult kids who would help. I also wouldn't need to work as I get my pension next year. But to me it just feels like I will go back to just managing and I can't do that again.
He is currently not speaking to me. He has said if I don't agree we will split up. Fine if he can do that after 40 years so easily crack on.
Sorry for the rant. I don't have an answer.

Have a look at the holiday park / residential park action groups on Facebook
They are huge horror stories of people loosing thousands and thousands buying these statics. Not a good investment at all.

Ifinkyourefreaky · 06/06/2023 17:48

WanderlustLost · 05/06/2023 09:13

I'm looking for advice on how to cope when you are being held back from your achievable dream.

I want to move out of the area we live in. We made a strategic move to an expensive area with a large mortgage for schools.

We planned (I thought) to only be here while our child attends school (5-7years) and then move out of the area.

We live in our home town and for as long as I remember I wanted to move, I don't like where we live although it's very popular, I want to live in the country.

He has now said he doesn't want to move.

This now means a huge mortgage over our heads until 68!

It also means being stuck in a house neither of us are particularly fond of.

It means I will never get out of this town.

He doesn't like moving, the packing, the paying the solicitor and the estate agent for their services and he doesn't want to be far from work even though moving would allow for him to retire early.

If I try and talk to him he just gets angry and then doesn't talk to me for days but I can't cope with the idea of living here forever.

What would you do, how would you manage the feeling of loss that losing an achievable dream brings?

I'm gutted and while I'm hiding my feelings from our children the older ones know what this means to me and are angry with their dad (he told me in front of them and I've spoken for years about the long term goal). It's their dream too.

Right now I want to curl up in bed and hide, I'm not obviously but I feel like what is the point. We will work out guts out till we die for what? A house we don't like in a place we hate.

'What would you do, how would you manage the feeling of loss that losing an achievable dream brings?'

Don't suffer the loss, you shouldn't have to. There's always a way, it won't be easy but you do whatever you have to do to stick to the original plan

Mediocrates · 06/06/2023 17:48

WilkinsonM · 05/06/2023 09:23

He gets angry and refuses to talk to you for days?
get a divorce, sell the house and buy a little place where you want to without him.
not even joking.

Another vote for this ^

kamillertime · 06/06/2023 17:46

WOW..you support him for 14 years and he pulls this? Dump him now. Seriously.

Doone21 · 06/06/2023 17:22

I'd leave. Rather than live in misery. My 1st husband did that pretty much, accompanied by the phrase you've made your bed now you have to lie in it...it was to be near his parents we were even in Essex, in a house I bought as he didn't work.
Left him moved back to the sticks, never been happier

DontTouchMyMug · 06/06/2023 15:55

*I am a bit puzzled by the whole 'dream' thing. If I were to move an hour's drive away from where I am now, it wouldn't really be a big change - even if I were in a much more rural environment. I'd be able to hold onto the same circle of friends, even if more driving/public transport was involved. I'd be pretty much in the same region. It would be known territory - a 'safe' move, rather than a big risk.

To me a more radical step - one that involved a lot more envisioning - would involve, at the very least, moving to the other end of the UK or crossing the border (Scotland, Wales). Or to another English speaking country. Perhaps becoming proficient in another language, so that I could move to mainland Europe. Doing a completely different kind of work - and maybe training for that - could also be part of the dream.

This one seems a relatively timid dream, and the whole situation sounds quite sad*

Strong disagree with all of this. An hour away would make a huge difference where I live.

In all honesty I only want to move 20 minutes away from where we are but it would be a different school, nursery, neighbours, further from family (currently a few streets away and same school). Different social circle. We are currently on the train line and in my dream location we wouldn't be so the commute would be totally different (ie always driving instead of a few drinks after work). A lot of our normal day to day interactions, routines, familiar things would all be different.

Not sure why you feel the need to downplay the OPs dream anyway. Even if it's not bold enough for you, it's her dream 🤷🏻‍♀️

RedRiverSun · 06/06/2023 10:32

I'd wager the OPs husband is ASD. They have a 'spiky' behaviour pattern. There will be some properly atrocious behaviour that in an ND man would be unforgivable because it would indicate a controlling arse. But especially around conflict and communication there can be a lot of 'can't' rather than 'won't'. Intent matters quite a bit and none of us can tell sitting from here but OP has been clear he is a good man whom she loves very much and doesn't wish to divorce.

LaGiaconda · 06/06/2023 10:06

No, I'm on the edge of a large urban area and an hour's drive could take me to somewhere more rural. But if you have access to a car, that distance means you have a safety net. Nights out/visits/meetings with old friends are relatively easy - at the point where you are still trying to build up new connections after moving.

I think the main thing about rural living is simply having to drive a lot more. Oddly, one can be a lot more 'green' in the city - where pretty much everything is a walk or a bus ride away.

RampantIvy · 06/06/2023 10:00

@LaGiaconda I think you underestimate how different somewhere an hour away can be. I live an hour away from York (on a low traffic day), yet York is so very different in many ways from my village on the edge of the Pennines.

LaGiaconda · 06/06/2023 08:43

I am a bit puzzled by the whole 'dream' thing. If I were to move an hour's drive away from where I am now, it wouldn't really be a big change - even if I were in a much more rural environment. I'd be able to hold onto the same circle of friends, even if more driving/public transport was involved. I'd be pretty much in the same region. It would be known territory - a 'safe' move, rather than a big risk.

To me a more radical step - one that involved a lot more envisioning - would involve, at the very least, moving to the other end of the UK or crossing the border (Scotland, Wales). Or to another English speaking country. Perhaps becoming proficient in another language, so that I could move to mainland Europe. Doing a completely different kind of work - and maybe training for that - could also be part of the dream.

This one seems a relatively timid dream, and the whole situation sounds quite sad.

BusyMum47 · 06/06/2023 06:55

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 05/06/2023 09:16

It doesnt matter what the issue...refusing to speak about it and then getting angry and then punishing you by giving you the silent treatment is unacceptable. Refusing to at least attempt a compromise is unacceptable...especially as his issues (like not liking packing) are surmountable. Do you want to stay with him?

100% this! ⬆️ He's being selfish & childish.

His only reason for not moving is that he just can't be arsed with the hassle?!

I second the question: Do you want to stay with him? In a house you dislike. In a town you hate. Especially after the kids have left.

LudicrouslyCapaciousBag · 06/06/2023 06:49

Benidorm8Banter · 05/06/2023 23:26

If your dream was to leave the area, why didn't you move before you were married & before you had children ?

If you want to move that badly, make it happen
But you can't force your DH to move too

They moved to the current area for their child’s schooling.