Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dream being shattered by husband, how to cope?

307 replies

WanderlustLost · 05/06/2023 09:13

I'm looking for advice on how to cope when you are being held back from your achievable dream.

I want to move out of the area we live in. We made a strategic move to an expensive area with a large mortgage for schools.

We planned (I thought) to only be here while our child attends school (5-7years) and then move out of the area.

We live in our home town and for as long as I remember I wanted to move, I don't like where we live although it's very popular, I want to live in the country.

He has now said he doesn't want to move.

This now means a huge mortgage over our heads until 68!

It also means being stuck in a house neither of us are particularly fond of.

It means I will never get out of this town.

He doesn't like moving, the packing, the paying the solicitor and the estate agent for their services and he doesn't want to be far from work even though moving would allow for him to retire early.

If I try and talk to him he just gets angry and then doesn't talk to me for days but I can't cope with the idea of living here forever.

What would you do, how would you manage the feeling of loss that losing an achievable dream brings?

I'm gutted and while I'm hiding my feelings from our children the older ones know what this means to me and are angry with their dad (he told me in front of them and I've spoken for years about the long term goal). It's their dream too.

Right now I want to curl up in bed and hide, I'm not obviously but I feel like what is the point. We will work out guts out till we die for what? A house we don't like in a place we hate.

OP posts:
Bintle · 05/06/2023 09:57

FlatWhiteExtraHot · 05/06/2023 09:55

There is no compromise in a situation like this though. For either one to get what they want, the other has to give in. That’s not compromising.

Although as is usual on MN, he is totally in the wrong and the OP is entitled to everything she wants or she should leave him, which I don’t think was quite what she was looking for!

Without knowing wjere the OP wants to move then it's perfectly possible that there could be compromise.

BelindaBears · 05/06/2023 09:57

You’re not wrong to be disappointed but I don’t believe for a second it’s your children’s dream. It’s what you want, which is enough reason without having to embellish it!

You have options, even if your plan doesn’t end up being how you expected.

FlatWhiteExtraHot · 05/06/2023 09:55

Shoxfordian · 05/06/2023 09:21

Divorce and move without him; a relationship where you can’t talk and compromise isn’t working

There is no compromise in a situation like this though. For either one to get what they want, the other has to give in. That’s not compromising.

Although as is usual on MN, he is totally in the wrong and the OP is entitled to everything she wants or she should leave him, which I don’t think was quite what she was looking for!

Seeingadistance · 05/06/2023 09:55

Shoxfordian · 05/06/2023 09:21

Divorce and move without him; a relationship where you can’t talk and compromise isn’t working

This.

toomuchlaundry · 05/06/2023 09:54

What will happen to your DC who wants to live with you forever when you are not around?

Can you compromise slightly on area and you do all the organising etc.

WanderlustLost · 05/06/2023 09:53

gamerchick · 05/06/2023 09:27

You dont have to stay. You can leave, force the sale of the house and buy where you want. I'm assuming your job can be done anywhere since you want to leave so bad.

What's stopping you?

Yes, my job can be done anywhere but I won't be divorcing him.

We've been together 22 years, he's a good person most of the time. He just doesn't like arguements or change.

OP posts:
Bintle · 05/06/2023 09:53

WanderlustLost · 05/06/2023 09:43

The eldest are at uni and driving. One plans on living with us forever (autistic).

In the nicest possible way OP, and obviously I don't know your exact circumstances, living very rurally (as I do) isn't always amazing. You actually need to lean on your partner more if anything as life in the winter is difficult. Do you have an actual place in mind?

Anonymouseposter · 05/06/2023 09:53

I have found that, if you are in a marriage and there is a difference of opinion like this, the person who doesn’t want to act and wants to maintain the status quo tends to get their way because it’s difficult to act unilaterally. If you are really serious about moving would you be prepared to move on your own? He may choose to come with you if he sees that the marriage will be over, but he may not. If you don’t want to separate you might need to accept the situation as it is and make the best of it. You can’t force him to move.

WanderlustLost · 05/06/2023 09:51

LaGiaconda · 05/06/2023 09:47

I am suspicious of the word dream. If for example you'd said 'Norfolk'. You told me that you'd had regular holidays there, and knew a particular village where there was a post office and a shop, a thriving community and a nearby RSPB place that appealed to you because you were a keen birdwatcher, then it would seem like you'd been proceeding with a plan that worked for you and were - understandably - frustrated if 'buy in' had been suddenly withdrawn, after years when your partner had seemed to go along with it.

I don't think it is unreasonable for a partner to want to remain in a place that obviously has got good facilities, where there are established networks, and it is easy to travel to work.

But I don't know how you resolve these differences.

I have the specifics I just don't want to share them in this because it would be very identifiable.

The location, our knowledge of the area etc it's all there.

OP posts:
trytopullyoursocksup · 05/06/2023 09:51

ltb. Seriously.
Or at least tell him you will, and mean it. you can say: you can join me in a life where I can be happy, or you can work with me on redesigning it with a negotiated plan on a life that can make us both happy. Or you can refuse to do anything, which you are doing now, and I will leave you and be happy on my own.
Mean it. See what happens.

Wavescrashingonthebeach · 05/06/2023 09:50

Wow he sounds EXACTLY like my Dad. My Mum left him in the end by the way and made her dream home. Its just a shame it took so long.

Toujoursla896 · 05/06/2023 09:50

A couple of things.

Not all men, but many, are reluctant to change, or renovate or move. They like the familiar and they dislike hassle. They are understandably wary of costs etc. But once persuaded to move, upgrade or renovate, they are fine about it. It’s pretty infuriating tbh!

Why does your dh’s decision- making hold more weight than yours? Is he the main earner? Do you work? Does the move involve a change of job for him which could potentially lower his earnings, status or negatively impact on his career path? You don’t need his permission but if you are moving forward as a family unit then it’s important to take in to account how much you both earn, your commutes, your ability to earn from a rural destination etc.

However, the more worrying aspect of this is his shutting down and not speaking for several days when you need to talk about it.

In order to get him to open up, and to properly discuss all facets of this, you need to take all emotion and talk of blame and guilt out of the discussion. Take him out to lunch and discuss it factually. What is he worried about? Show some understanding of his perspective, not just yours. Prepare a list of pros and cons. Be as objective as you can.

I say all this as someone who would shrivel up and wither away if I had to live in a busy town. I just don’t feel mentally or physically healthy in an urban environment so I understand where you are coming from op.

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 05/06/2023 09:50

It's tricky. I've had situations with my husband where we agreed a plan and then down the line it's not happened. He says "he's allowed to change his mind".
I guess it's true.
Now it's happened the opposite way we bought a house for the short term and I actually really like living here. He wants to move. I said I'm allowed to change my mind ;)

I think you have a few issues. The not talking is emotionally abusive. Telling you Infront of the kids was done to end the discussion - not good either.

Can you start a conversation about how you both have this problem so let's work together to come up with a compromise. If he disagrees again then he looks the twat because he isn't even willing to work to make both your lives happy. In this scenario I would divorce. Sounds like your kids are up for the move too so crack on without him and he will soon realise he can't keep the house he wants if you split up.

WanderlustLost · 05/06/2023 09:49

sandyhappypeople · 05/06/2023 09:42

he hasn't given a firm commitment until last week when I said to him we can make this happen if we really want it, are you in? And he said yes

do you mean he said no? Or am I misunderstanding something?

No last week we were talking and he had been making some vague murmurs that maybe we weren't going to be moving. So I said to him, please can I get a firm yes to this, that we will move when youngest finishes like we planned.

He said yes.

Then Saturday got annoyed and hasn't spoken to me.

OP posts:
Stephisaur · 05/06/2023 09:48

@WanderlustLost "just old" did make me giggle 😂

Ok then, I can definitely sympathise with the fixer upper. My husband cried our first night in the new house because he hated it so much.

So I think what you may need to do is just double down on the renovations. I see you mentioned new windows etc and I would personally get the ones you love, even though they're more expensive. Once your husband is in the middle of a building site, he may reconsider staying anyway ;) but at the very least, posh windows are something that a future estate agent can really push when it comes to reselling (if you get to that point).

I would also suggest offering to take on all the jobs he hates. I dealt with the estate agents, viewings for our house, mortgage applications, movers, etc etc. All he had to do was pack, which was fine as he wouldn't let anyone touch his things anyway 😂

But of course, it might be that once all the work is done then you feel differently. Have you seen love it or list it on C4? A lot of people change their minds once the house is "fixed" for them xx

LaGiaconda · 05/06/2023 09:47

I am suspicious of the word dream. If for example you'd said 'Norfolk'. You told me that you'd had regular holidays there, and knew a particular village where there was a post office and a shop, a thriving community and a nearby RSPB place that appealed to you because you were a keen birdwatcher, then it would seem like you'd been proceeding with a plan that worked for you and were - understandably - frustrated if 'buy in' had been suddenly withdrawn, after years when your partner had seemed to go along with it.

I don't think it is unreasonable for a partner to want to remain in a place that obviously has got good facilities, where there are established networks, and it is easy to travel to work.

But I don't know how you resolve these differences.

bonzaitree · 05/06/2023 09:47

I don’t know how people can be in relationships like this.

Your husband should firstly listen to you and treat your opinion as and equal. Secondly he should want to make you happy above (almost) everything else. Thirdly he should be happy to compromise!

OP, YOU can live in the countryside. That might be on your own. Maybe time to make him aware of that!

think about what’s more important to you. Being with him or being in the countryside

Fleebags · 05/06/2023 09:46

Ffsmakeitstop · 05/06/2023 09:32

We are currently having the opposite issue. DH is 68, hasn't worked for 14 years due to ill health. I am 65 and work full time and need to work till 70 to pay our mortgage. I will also get my pension.
I paid all our outgoings until he got his pension last year because he wasn't entitled to any benefits, which meant I've had to extend the mortgage to still have a home. To say it was stressful is an understatement.
We are now in a reasonable position where we can afford days out on a weekend, nothing extravagant just a drive and lunch out. BUT because he's bored and rarely sees people he wants to sell up and live in a caravan. He cannot see why I don't want to. I fee! I have worked too hard to end up living with no space and not much privacy.
His reasoning is partly that the garden is a bit big to manage, I think we could pay someone to do it and we have adult kids who would help. I also wouldn't need to work as I get my pension next year. But to me it just feels like I will go back to just managing and I can't do that again.
He is currently not speaking to me. He has said if I don't agree we will split up. Fine if he can do that after 40 years so easily crack on.
Sorry for the rant. I don't have an answer.

How awful. You did not work so hard to end up living in a caravan. What if you did, and then you ended up splitting up anyway because the lack of personal space would drive you crazy..

IneedanewTV · 05/06/2023 09:46

You love him but are you actually in love with him? You are an adult who is also allowed to have plans and ideas. If he doesn’t want to move and you really do then leave. Could you cope without his income? Are you working full time? It’s tough knowing you are working to fund an expensive lifestyle - perhaps he is scared about his job and finances. But whatever it’s your life too. Tomorrow has already gone. Start making plans to downsize and buying two houses.

Weenurse · 05/06/2023 09:45

My DH did not want to leave our last house.
I told him the DC and I were moving, he could stay or come with us, up to him.
It took me nearly a year to find our current house. He got used to me looking most weekends.
I did not show him anything until I found this one as nothing else worked for our family.
Once I asked him to come and look, he could see the potential and where his space would be (we have man land with his office and gaming gear in it), he was willing to think about a move.
I think I slowly got him to realise I was serious and was not staying in the old house.
Good luck

TheCreamTeaWasFromMe · 05/06/2023 09:44

It sounds like you have reached a crunch point in your marriage, where you need to think about what you want.

Is it important to keep your marriage, in which case you may need to give up your dream of moving?

Or is it important that you get to move and live the life you've wanted for a long time, and you realise that if your H isn't prepared to get on board now then it's time for you to separate because you want different things?

billy1966 · 05/06/2023 09:44

I think you need to stop focusing on a not very kind man.

Start looking at a future without him.

Your children will move off and live their own lives, particularly if their father isn't that nice.

They probably see him very clearly.

You sound like a very down trodden emotional abused woman.

Invest in some counselling.

Do not tie up your money in this house.

Give yourself options to get out.

WanderlustLost · 05/06/2023 09:43

Bintle · 05/06/2023 09:23

How is it your older children's dream if they will have finished school? They'll be off at uni by then won't they? Better make sure they can drive if they want to move to the countryside otherwise they'll have no social life unless you are a taxi (bitter experience!)

The eldest are at uni and driving. One plans on living with us forever (autistic).

OP posts:
Mirabai · 05/06/2023 09:43

I mean I would just say: I’m moving and you can either come with me or we can split.

However much he dislikes the upheaval of moving, he will dislike the upheaval of divorce more and he would have to move as well.

HouseInTheMiddle · 05/06/2023 09:43

YANBU

For him to make a decision that affects everyone is not fair.

I would stick to the plan and keep talking about renovating to be able to move on, looking at properties rurally, rope in the kids too seeing as they are wanting to move as well.

We're currently living a happy compromise, small house in the country that I desperately wanted and plan to retire to, a place in London where Dh works and is thinking we could retire to, we both live in another house in the middle of the two, its a bit bonkers but suits us atm.