Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being told who your baby looks like

110 replies

Emfrancesca · 05/06/2023 04:01

Is it just me or does anyone else feel annoyed when someone from your other half's family says that your baby looks like their dad or someone from that side of the family?!
It's like I grew this baby for 9 months and for what? 🤣

OP posts:
FloofCloud · 05/06/2023 06:50

... posted too soon ... MiL piped up that my DDs eyes seemed to be remaining that beautiful blue colour and she takes after uncle Alister ... which really annoyed me because it was the one thing she took after my family as we all have blue eyes (in laws all brown eyed except this one uncle). I said no that's my family genes abs the cheeky cow said oh no Floof these are a beautiful blue colour, not like yours, definitely from my side of the family 😳

Emfrancesca · 05/06/2023 06:50

Interesting responses!
I personally feel like she is a complete mix of us both and doesn't look like either of us specifically.
Obviously babies change all the time and she is only 8 weeks so got a lot of growing to do yet!

OP posts:
FloofCloud · 05/06/2023 06:46

When my eldest was young my MIL piped

LudicrouslyCapaciousBag · 05/06/2023 06:24

It used to be considered a great compliment to tell parents that their child looked like the father. It was a sort of early paternity test. There is even one such conversation in the opening scene of Much Ado About Nothing.

It is really not a big deal. Sometimes family resemblances are really striking and tbh I find the science of it absolutely fascinating.

I have a friend whose three children look absolutely nothing like her, and so very like their father’s family that their paternal aunt is regularly mistaken for their mum when they are all together. That really pisses her off and I can understand why.

sawnotseen · 05/06/2023 06:23

Sorry that those comments make you feel bad.
I had this as my first born, a girl, has always been the image of her grandma, her dad's mum.
I was having a very similar conversation with my close friend the other day, as her neice (sisters daughter) looks very like her but her own daughter doesn't (she looks just like her dad).
My daughter is, and always has been, the absolute spitting of her dad and my beloved late MIL, she looks nothing like me at all - I've always loved that, as MiL never had a daughter and the physical resemblance to her is so clear and she really loved that. They were very close.
My son looked a lot like me when he was very young, lots of people commented. He's a young adult now and has somehow morphed into looking like his dad! Im a bit gutted about that.
I am apparently the image of my late maternal grandfathers sister! She sadly died young so I never met her. The photos are uncanny though. Build too - im tiny (very short and size 6) as was this woman, my great aunt - but my mum, sister, daughter, neice and aunt are all pretty average, about 5'4" and dress size 12. She didn't have any children so no one to compare to now but it is a bit spooky when I see photos as I do really look like her! It's like looking at me dressed up for a 1940s event.
I find it fascinating. Try not to jet the comments get to you....I'm sure they're from a loving place. I think that they are just delighted to have your baby in their family and are trying to make connections.

MyPurpleHeart · 05/06/2023 06:21

It only irks me when someone says my 2 week old looks like some distant family member and not even me or DH 😂

WandaWonder · 05/06/2023 06:21

I hardly ever see anyone in a baby unless it is very obvious but if it's there it's there not sure why I would be annoyed if it was my baby

LittleBumblebee3 · 05/06/2023 06:19

I think (in my case at least) it comes down to how you feel about the commenter generally.
100% agree with you on this one @CurtainsForBea

A few minutes after I gave birth to DS1, the midwife turned round to DH and said “Well I don’t think anyone can question who the dad is! He’s your double!” 🤔🤣 I was like “ehhhh….who was questioning it?!” 🤔

My best friend (who I’ve known literally since she was born) wasn’t raised by her biological dad. Her stepdad has been in her life since her mum was pregnant, raised her as his own, and very very few people know that he isn’t her biological dad. Her and I used to have such a giggle growing up when people said she was her “dads” double 🤣 they literally couldn’t look more different! She’s now got 2 boys of her own and people comment on how much they look like “grandpa” 🤣

MrsLiam · 05/06/2023 06:14

Don't read too much into it; it's just conversation. My friend is continually told how much her baby looks like its dad - which is a bit odd as baby was conceived with donor sperm (only a handful of close friends and immediate family know this).

NowZeusHasLainWithLeda · 05/06/2023 06:13

Babies look pretty generic until interesting things start happening. I bet if they lined 10 newborns all the same skintone/hair side by side you'd not be able to pick yours out.

And yes, agree with above. Other people's babies aren't nearly as interesting to the rest of the world. We're programmed for our own to be centre of the universe and we don't get it when they're not the centre of everyone's. Everyone knows that so we try and be polite and think of something to say. Who does he look like? Is he sleeping? Does he feed well? Etc. We don't even actually care. It's just a social convention.

loislovesstewie · 05/06/2023 06:12

I shouldn't worry; all babies look like Winston Churchill. But seriously , people often look at the baby and think they see a resemblance to one parent. My oldest looks like his dad, my youngest looks like me. They always have done. Genetics are weird , the way features are handed down is just random. Each baby will have a resemblance to some relative.

TeenDivided · 05/06/2023 06:09

I think it's partly a bonding thing, finding someone on their side who the baby resembles.

That said I had people saying my DDs were like me, and they are adopted which always made us smile internally.

CurtainsForBea · 05/06/2023 05:51

I think (in my case at least) it comes down to how you feel about the commenter generally.

I have maternal extended family (aunts etc) who like to say knowingly and authoritatively that this child or that child looks exactly like some random far off distant family member. But I am not particularly fond of this side of the family and find them unpleasant and toxic. So anything they say is going to piss me right off. Not least because they hold fast to this strange belief that 'family is everything' despite being absuive and aggressive and 'family' only means blood and anyone who marries in is not 'family'.

So them commenting irritates me.

DH's side? Well, there was a huge and excited discussion beforehand about who the Dcs would take after in terms of things like skin colour and tone and if various very common physical traits would be passed on. I did not mind that at all because I love them.

Florin · 05/06/2023 05:48

I don’t see the problem some kids do resemble one parent more than the other. I showed a picture to my own mother who completely refused to believe a photo was of my husband not of our son. They look identical at the same age.

SkyandSurf · 05/06/2023 05:41

Lord, people who complain about things like this are probably people who would also complain if someone wasn't showing enough interest in their baby.

Other people's babies are boring. There is only so much you can say/ask.

Just be glad they tried to make conversation with you and lighten up.

Did you have a baby with the goal of cloning yourself? That's quite narcissistic.

FeigningConcern · 05/06/2023 05:41

I find this stuff interesting so always comment on who seems to have got what from where. I've said it about my DS his whole life. In fact only the other day I told him he's looking more and more like his dad everyday!

Upanddownthemerrygoround · 05/06/2023 05:34

It’s something people say. Annoying but you’ve just got to let it wash over you.

my (male) friend was told repeatedly when they were born how much his kids look like him. Hardly anyone knew they’d been donor-sperm conceived….

marblemad · 05/06/2023 05:28

I think you're being abit dramatic, if they see a resemblance they see a resemblance. You can't ALWAYS control the narrative OP

anormalperson · 05/06/2023 05:15

I don't mind at all when people say DC are like DH but DH's family like to say how much my DC look like random relatives I've never met from their side that happen to have the same colouring as me as if it makes much more sense for them to look like these people...

Funkyblues101 · 05/06/2023 05:03

Rtmhwales · 05/06/2023 04:30

Everybody tells me DS is the spit of DH. DH adopted DS (he's biologically mine). He looks more like DH than my two DSS.

I like this 😁

Remaker · 05/06/2023 05:00

My kids look exactly like my husband, although DD is a tiny bit more like me as she’s got older. But DS is just the double of DH.

I have an elderly aunt who will always find some feature in my kids from my side of the family. She’s imagining it haha. It doesn’t worry me one bit who they look like, I know they’re mine.

Violasaremyfavourite · 05/06/2023 04:41

My sons look exactly like my husband and one is so dissimilar to me, somebody thought he was adopted. I did end up looking like my mother but I was an enormously fat sumo baby and my mother heard the matron, who in those days visited the new mothers, telling the nurse that she, my mother, couldn't possibly be the mother of baby Viola. I was very fat, had hair that grew in a strange peak, and had a prominent birth mark on my face and my parents told me that they thought I was so beautiful.

Fedupwife28 · 05/06/2023 04:40

It doesn’t bother me personally but perhaps that’s because my 5 month old is the image of her dad, so there’s no denying it. I haven’t met one single person who’s said she looks like me, family or otherwise, so I just say things like “I know! Who knew DH would look so beautiful as a girl!”. She does seem to look more like me as she gets older though. Don’t take it personally, people aren’t trying to hurt your feelings.

NurseEssie · 05/06/2023 04:36

And I do get a bit uncomfortable for some reason when people comment how much DS looks like me. I've had someone even say 'is your DH a even the dad? Nothing of him in your DC!' Which I found very rude

NurseEssie · 05/06/2023 04:35

Completely the opposite here.
Everyone says the son is the image of me (he is) and I would have loved for him to be the image of his dad Grin
I'm now trying to convince everyone that he started to look like his dad.

Swipe left for the next trending thread