Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it acceptable to judge a persons potential for a date based on their job ?

194 replies

AnyaMarx · 05/06/2023 03:12

I'm very curious to know what people actually think.

There is a thread here asking about whether to date someone based on their job .

Is that a thing ?

Would you date a bin man ?
Would you date a hairdresser?
Would you date a defence lawyer ?

Would it matter what a person does for a living or would you base any decisions on if they're nice and if you like them ?

Is it ever acceptable to base a decision on career choices?

If it is - is that the same as basing your decision on other things like skin colour or hair colour ?

Is it acceptable to say for instance "id never date a person with ginger hair ?

I'm curious as to where the line is .
It seems acceptable to say I wouldn't date a xxxx (met detective) for example

So is that the same as saying I wouldn't date a soldier?
A man with ginger hair ?
A hairdresser?
A man with glasses?

Is it ok to verbalise this if that's how you feel ?
It's made me very curious as to what's acceptable to say , or not to say but think ?

There is a thread on aibu asking whether to date a man based on his career and I wondered if this was substituted for a person of colour or a man with ginger hair or a social worker would it get the same response ?
Is it ok to say my stereotype dictates I shouldn't date a person who is xxxx
Or works as a xxxx
And whether that's ok to say even if you think it . ? Should we be able to say anything based on that ? Is any stereotyping ok if that's how we feel ? Whether that be based on career, colour , hair type , glasses , facial features, where does it end ?
Obviously anyone can say no to a date for ANY reason.....

OP posts:
StopFeckingFaffing · 05/06/2023 07:45

It is fine to follow whatever arbitrary rules you like when screening potential partners; it's possible you may rule out some very nice people by doing this but it is completely your own business and you know what you find attractive in a partner more than anyone else does.

I do think that when discussing your preferences (IRL and online) then it would be prudent to consider other peoples' feelings when declaring your preferences, so ok in a confidential chat with your bestie to admit you wouldn't date a ginger/man under 5'7"/binman or whatever but there is no need to express such things in a more public way as you are inevitably going to hurt someone's feelings.

Saschka · 05/06/2023 07:44

Of course it’s ok to not date somebody based on their job. Would you date an arms dealer? Drug dealer? People trafficker? Even if they were really nice?

You seem to be offended that people feel the same way about soldiers and police officers, when for them it is the exact same thing. They may have direct experiences which have led to this view - are you telling women to ignore their own judgement about their safety?

Workawayxx · 05/06/2023 07:41

Ok to do it but keep it to yourself otherwise people will just get offended (“but my second cousin is in the army and he’s amaaaaazing…” type of thing). Also you have to screen somehow otherwise you’d end up dating everyone just to give them a chance.

I wouldnt date someone in the forces as I knew I didn’t want to move (ds with local dad and I gave local family here) or be without my partner for significant chunks of time, both of which are likely with forces. I never encountered any met detectives so it wasn’t a decision that needed to be made!

it’s also not always about disparaging someone’s job or them as a person, it’s just making an assumption that you probably won’t have as much in common as someone else. Choosing a partner has to be done selfishly otherwise it’s not fair on either of you.

TheoTheopolis23 · 05/06/2023 07:39

*you're

Nordicrain · 05/06/2023 07:39

hattie43 · 05/06/2023 07:32

There would absolutely be some jobs I'd avoid .
Butcher
Abattoir worker
Game keeper
Meat processing factory worker
Fishmonger
Embalmer

Not status related but these give me the ick

Curious - are you vegan?

TheoTheopolis23 · 05/06/2023 07:38

Not sure why women are questioned for not being "equal opportunities" when men are not.

Try old and meeting a guy who decides your not his physical type on meeting, you'd be dumped faster than a doggy poo bag.

They don't date women for any number of reasons and they dont seem to ask each other questions like this about their justification.

Nordicrain · 05/06/2023 07:38

Well I would probably ifnd it difficult to date someone who was actively aiding a workplace I had serious moral objections to. E.g I probably wouldn't be rushing into bed with an arms dealer, or a BNP politician.

As an aside, I find it interesting you list a defense lawyer as one of your examples of jobs people would surely hate to date. You know that defense lawyers (and the right to representation) is a corner stone of our justice system and that they will represent many many innocent people, as well as guilty ones. But even guilty people deserve representation to ensure that justice prevails. In the UK there are also lots of rules to what the lawyers can and can't do (it's not like the US shows) and they cannot lie to the courty if they know their client is guilty (they might suspect, but if they know they have a duty to the court no to lie and the defense will be focused on disproving the prosecution's evidence). They are still officers of the court.

Stressfordays · 05/06/2023 07:35

We all have preferences and thats ok. Its ok to discuss preferences with friends etc. But what its not ok to do is blatantly turn someone down and say something like 'I don't date gingers' and be deliberately cruel when you can politely turn them down with a 'sorry, I'm not dating right now/sorry I'm seeing someone'.

For what its worth, I wouldn't date someone unemployed but have been asked out a lot by unemployed men. I just politely turn them down. I'm never mean to someone.

logicisall · 05/06/2023 07:34

There is nothing wrong in deciding a person's potential for a date based on their job/looks/personality because that decision is based on your own personal preferences. Last time I looked that wasn't morally wrong, harmful to others or illegal.

fyn · 05/06/2023 07:34

There very regular threads about how dreadful the armed forces are because they never just ‘the lifestyle wouldn’t work for me’ it’s always what dreadful, wife beating psychopaths they are. It’s sad to hear because I see first hand what sacrifices people make to keep others in this country safe.

DH is in the armed forces, before that he spent his 20s working for NGOs developing projects in developing countries to get girls into school and fund businesses for women in patriarchal societies. I’d hazard a guess he’s done a lot more good than those berating the armed forces.

AnImaginaryCat · 05/06/2023 07:33

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 05/06/2023 07:27

To add, it depends on how old you/they are. In their 20s, so much can still change, it could be a stop gap. In their 50s, (like I am now), probably not.

Although in Australia the truck does all the work, there are no bin men who actually touch the bins, so a little bit different?

My DB is a builder, and it's hard work. And his body is knackered from it. When our DNephews (not his DC, my DSister's) did work experience with him he deliberately found the hardest jobs he could legally make them do (like cleaning all the tools) started the day at 5.30 am, etc. He did this deliberately to give them the incentive to knuckle down and go to uni.... they both did engineering so it worked.

I'm encouraging my DSs to make the most of themselves, and they both look like they're heading to uni. If they weren't going to be uni bound I'd help them find a good apprenticeship with great future potential. If I want the best for them, why wouldn't I want the best for me? Why is the first admirable, but the second shallow?

On a tangent but how can the truck do all the work? How do the bins get to the truck?

Simianwalk · 05/06/2023 07:33

Personally I need a partner who has similar values to me. As a pacifist I wouldn't date someone in the military. As an environmentalist I would date someone who worked int he petroleum industry. I would struggle with someone who's job was purely about making them rich rather than improving our world.
I also wouldn't vote someone who voted Tory (particularly at the moment), who voted Brexit, who were anti abortion, where racist, homophobic, xenophobic or sexist. Anyone that had been in prison for violence, hurting a child, or sexual inappropriateness. Was heavily into porn, was a gambler, heavy drinker or drug user. Refused to travel, try new experiences, or had to eat the same food every week. I would also avoid someone not solvent, who wanted children (no more for me), didn't like children.
They could look like anything, dress anyway which way, have any accent, they would have to loved dogs and most importantly be easy going.
Luckily I'm married to a man who ticks all these boxes. TBF he definitely wasn't solvent when we met but I didn't care then. And he wanted kids but so did I 25 years ago.

hattie43 · 05/06/2023 07:32

There would absolutely be some jobs I'd avoid .
Butcher
Abattoir worker
Game keeper
Meat processing factory worker
Fishmonger
Embalmer

Not status related but these give me the ick

Sugaristheenemy · 05/06/2023 07:31

Is it ok to verbalise this if that's how you feel ?
Might be a bad idea IRL. Depends on your audience I guess.

It's made me very curious as to what's acceptable to say , or not to say but think ?
you can’t police peoples thoughts.
and you don’t have to date someone because it’s “not acceptable” to refuse to. That’s silly.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 05/06/2023 07:30

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 05/06/2023 07:25

As others have said, it

Shit, erased most of my post by accident!

Anyway, as others have said, it's fine to apply whatever criteria you like with regard to whom you date. You might end up narrowing the field unnecessarily and restricting your options, but that will only really affect you so it isn't really a problem.

It isn't necessary or acceptable in my view to give voice to all of the criteria that you might apply though. Some things are best kept private!

Teabab · 05/06/2023 07:29

The only way in which it would matter to me is if it was a lifestyle/shifts that didn't suit what I wanted rather than the job itself. My first serious relationship was with someone in the military for example and I wouldn't date someone in forces again just because for me I found it hard with them being away so much.

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 05/06/2023 07:27

To add, it depends on how old you/they are. In their 20s, so much can still change, it could be a stop gap. In their 50s, (like I am now), probably not.

Although in Australia the truck does all the work, there are no bin men who actually touch the bins, so a little bit different?

My DB is a builder, and it's hard work. And his body is knackered from it. When our DNephews (not his DC, my DSister's) did work experience with him he deliberately found the hardest jobs he could legally make them do (like cleaning all the tools) started the day at 5.30 am, etc. He did this deliberately to give them the incentive to knuckle down and go to uni.... they both did engineering so it worked.

I'm encouraging my DSs to make the most of themselves, and they both look like they're heading to uni. If they weren't going to be uni bound I'd help them find a good apprenticeship with great future potential. If I want the best for them, why wouldn't I want the best for me? Why is the first admirable, but the second shallow?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 05/06/2023 07:25

As others have said, it

ThePorchSwingCrowd · 05/06/2023 07:22

It's all very well saying 'I wouldn't date a bin man' on here, but in reality if you met a gorgeous man on a night out, who made you laugh a lot and was kind and considerate, then turned out to be a bin man ... you probably would date him. Wouldn't you? I would anyway. If you click, you click.

I wouldn’t. Each to their own.

I find it very strange that OP is so bothered about this. Multiple posts on the other thread and now a new one. Just accept that not everyone will want to date you but lots of people will based on many, many reasons.

PuttingDownRoots · 05/06/2023 07:20

As for binmen... ourlives would be pretty shit if no one did it . Its a hard graft which deserves some respect really. I don't think you can call someone who is at work at 6am working out in the elements all day shifting heavy objects lazy.

PuttingDownRoots · 05/06/2023 07:17

Past the first few dates, a relationship is only likely to develop if you are physically attracted to each other and one the same morally and outlook. Since your job could reflect your morals and outlook, then there's a strong chance the relationship won't develop if you don't like aspects of someone's job.. even something like shifts etc

ChopperC110P · 05/06/2023 07:15

Southoftheriver32 · 05/06/2023 06:43

I wouldn’t date a bin man no. That type of unskilled job shows how little motivation and self respect they have, not to mention money.

Yes because that is what determines whether you are working class or not- motivation and self-respect.

ThePorchSwingCrowd · 05/06/2023 07:10

From your examples, I wouldn’t date a bin man, a met detective, a soldier.

I wouldn’t go around announcing this randomly, but this is a discussion forum do people discuss things. In terms of the police force, with some concerning findings of investigations, no wonder it’s a talking point.

IWonderWhereThatDishDidGo · 05/06/2023 07:07

You don't owe anyone a date. Go out with who you find attractive. If that excludes people with red hair and bin men then that's your preference. I'm sure there are plenty of things men would rule you out over too if it makes you feel any better

MRex · 05/06/2023 07:07

Hi @AnyaMarx , when did AI start putting typos into forum posts, and did anyone suggest it to you?