Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it acceptable to judge a persons potential for a date based on their job ?

194 replies

AnyaMarx · 05/06/2023 03:12

I'm very curious to know what people actually think.

There is a thread here asking about whether to date someone based on their job .

Is that a thing ?

Would you date a bin man ?
Would you date a hairdresser?
Would you date a defence lawyer ?

Would it matter what a person does for a living or would you base any decisions on if they're nice and if you like them ?

Is it ever acceptable to base a decision on career choices?

If it is - is that the same as basing your decision on other things like skin colour or hair colour ?

Is it acceptable to say for instance "id never date a person with ginger hair ?

I'm curious as to where the line is .
It seems acceptable to say I wouldn't date a xxxx (met detective) for example

So is that the same as saying I wouldn't date a soldier?
A man with ginger hair ?
A hairdresser?
A man with glasses?

Is it ok to verbalise this if that's how you feel ?
It's made me very curious as to what's acceptable to say , or not to say but think ?

There is a thread on aibu asking whether to date a man based on his career and I wondered if this was substituted for a person of colour or a man with ginger hair or a social worker would it get the same response ?
Is it ok to say my stereotype dictates I shouldn't date a person who is xxxx
Or works as a xxxx
And whether that's ok to say even if you think it . ? Should we be able to say anything based on that ? Is any stereotyping ok if that's how we feel ? Whether that be based on career, colour , hair type , glasses , facial features, where does it end ?
Obviously anyone can say no to a date for ANY reason.....

OP posts:
continentallentil · 05/06/2023 08:13

You can date who you like - if you don’t fancy people with ginger hair / don’t want to deal with a surgeon’s hours / wouldn’t be happy with a binman’s salary, then don’t.

On the whole I wouldn’t say it because why do you need to? You would want to explain your reasons in order not to potentially upset people, so it’s easier not to go there.

burnoutbabe · 05/06/2023 08:11

OrderOfTheKookaburra · 05/06/2023 07:27

To add, it depends on how old you/they are. In their 20s, so much can still change, it could be a stop gap. In their 50s, (like I am now), probably not.

Although in Australia the truck does all the work, there are no bin men who actually touch the bins, so a little bit different?

My DB is a builder, and it's hard work. And his body is knackered from it. When our DNephews (not his DC, my DSister's) did work experience with him he deliberately found the hardest jobs he could legally make them do (like cleaning all the tools) started the day at 5.30 am, etc. He did this deliberately to give them the incentive to knuckle down and go to uni.... they both did engineering so it worked.

I'm encouraging my DSs to make the most of themselves, and they both look like they're heading to uni. If they weren't going to be uni bound I'd help them find a good apprenticeship with great future potential. If I want the best for them, why wouldn't I want the best for me? Why is the first admirable, but the second shallow?

In married at first sight, most of the blokes on that are "trades" it seems

I'd generally only date an office type worker. It's what I am. Snog a gorgeous bin man in a nightclub sure but I can't see that working long term. But I am a well paid professional woman so I can't see many manual workers particularly wanting to date me either, just too different.

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 05/06/2023 08:09

Bin man-yes
Hairdresser- would need to be optimistic!
Defence lawyer- no

RagingWoke · 05/06/2023 08:07

I've been ditched for having the wrong shaped arse, being 'too smart' and having curly hair. Those guys didn't feel any need to hold back.

I feel no guilt for being clear on who I wouldn't date- outside the obvious 'oats' I wouldn't date anyone who works long hours/is in an intense career that dominates their life, it's just not compatible with me. Also wouldn't date anyone obsessed with football because I detest it, anyone significantly shorter than me because I feel self conscious about my height (I've been 5' 10" since early teens and constantly mocked for it) or anyone boring (subjective of course but if I saw a man holding a fish on OLD that's a no, someone who says mrs browns boys is the height of comedy etc).

It's not anything bad, we all have preferences and compatibility is important.

Coffeeandcards · 05/06/2023 08:06

I think you have to make fairly quick judgements on people when deciding whether or not to date them, without knowing them on anything more than a superficial level.

For me there’s got to be physical chemistry and a matched intellect, that’s my hard line. Some people’s jobs, political leanings, hobbies etc give me a glimpse as to whether we’re more or less likely to he compatible. Their hair colour, eye prescription, race is not relevant to that to me.

What I wouldn’t do is wildly generalise, either in real life or on here with threads like “Would you date an xyz”. Because it’s just rude and likely to hurt people and I don’t want to do that.

SparklingMarkling · 05/06/2023 08:04

@jay55

I agree. I fancied my husband that much and was just exceptionally keen to get him into bed first and foremost 😂. I didn’t actually think about his job lol.

Anyway being a bin man is quite hazardous, particularly with impatient cars speeding past etc. One bin man died in my locality not too long ago as unfortunately he ended up in the actual truck. I think that was a freak accident though mind, but it was awful as it happened not too far away 😔.

MakesMeFeelSad · 05/06/2023 08:04

I can't think of any job that would mean I'd rule a person out.

samestyle · 05/06/2023 08:02

It's acceptable for me to choose whatever reason I don't want to date someone, job being one of them and I have far more other trivial reasons I won't date someone. I am not employing them so no equal rights needed.

susie25 · 05/06/2023 08:01

ChopperC110P · 05/06/2023 07:58

So that’s the standard? To be as good as men? How depressing.

Yes. Seems to work for them doesn’t it? Considering they hold most positions of power/control. I find it depressing you think men are fine to carry on doing this but women should “be kind”. Why is that double standard ok?

How depressing and typical.

FigTreeInEurope · 05/06/2023 08:01

My mate used to tell women in night clubs that he was a producer in the pop industry. He worked on the packing line at Coca-Cola.

Starseeking · 05/06/2023 07:59

I work at a senior level in my job.

What I find is that many men tend to judge high-earning women negatively, and my EXDP actively resented my career.

I wouldn't actively pursue a relationship with someone who earned a tenth of what I do, as would be the case with e.g. a bin man, as it would severely restrict my lifestyle.

I already have DC so I'm not looking to build a family, just to spend time with someone who enjoys being with me.

ChopperC110P · 05/06/2023 07:58

susie25 · 05/06/2023 07:54

Not sure why women are questioned for not being "equal opportunities" when men are not

Try old and meeting a guy who decides your not his physical type on meeting, you'd be dumped faster than a doggy poo bag

They don't date women for any number of reasons and they dont seem to ask each other questions like this about their justification

Absolutely this. I’m not going to be shamed into having dating preferences when men do it all the damn time. As for the “they are held accountable” for that- BS. By whom? Never in my life have I heard a man tell another man he should give a woman he doesn’t find attractive a chance because “she has a great personality”! What a load of utter garbage

So that’s the standard? To be as good as men? How depressing.

jay55 · 05/06/2023 07:58

A lot of things go out the window when you have chemistry.
It's much easier to overlook the height of someone if they make you laugh and share an interest.

Online dating skews the wishlist, and so people are rejected on jobs/height/picture with a python as not being right on paper (which is fine it's a minefield).

tiddlyipom · 05/06/2023 07:57

To answer the question, I wouldn't,date anyone whose,values and lifestyle did not align with mine, so no sexists, racists , different political views, different ideas about raising children etc -actual job wouldn't bother me at all.

ChopperC110P · 05/06/2023 07:57

I think it’s ok to rule out jobs based on practical incompatibilities.

It becomes prejudice when the reason a certain job is ruled out is because you believe everyone in that job is a racist, misogynist, domestic abuser, war-monger, psychopath, narcissist, corrupt, no self-respect, no ambition, no drive, unskilled, (as we’ve seen listed in this thread) that it becomes morally questionable and often can be distinctly classist in tone.

susie25 · 05/06/2023 07:54

Not sure why women are questioned for not being "equal opportunities" when men are not

Try old and meeting a guy who decides your not his physical type on meeting, you'd be dumped faster than a doggy poo bag

They don't date women for any number of reasons and they dont seem to ask each other questions like this about their justification

Absolutely this. I’m not going to be shamed into having dating preferences when men do it all the damn time. As for the “they are held accountable” for that- BS. By whom? Never in my life have I heard a man tell another man he should give a woman he doesn’t find attractive a chance because “she has a great personality”! What a load of utter garbage

MrsRachelDanvers · 05/06/2023 07:53

I’d never date a bald man or a fat man-but would happily be friends with them. Sexual attraction is an area where you go with your feelings. You’re not interviewing someone for a job or provide a service-so date who you like.

tiddlyipom · 05/06/2023 07:52

@AnImaginaryCat you just line your bins up on the kerb and the trucks have an arm that lifts them up, over the bin and tips them into the truck.

Is it acceptable to judge a persons potential for a date based on their job ?
Nordicrain · 05/06/2023 07:52

Nordicrain · 05/06/2023 07:45

Surely i's perfectly acceptable to say you wouldn't be in a long term relationship with someone who would require you to move constantly, or be apart from you for long periods. Regardless of what you think of the military.

I am/was pretty opposed to the army in many ways - not the people personally, but the idea of armed conflict, and the way as an insitution it is run - and went on a course with lots of military people. It did change my perception of people in the military and I feel there is a lot being done to change the way the forces are run for the better, but hearing about the reality of the life style definitely confirmed I would not want to live that life.

Just to add, I would probably feel similarly about a relationship with someone in a job that meant that they were never around at home. E.g. a city corporate lawyer. I assume you think that's ok though? because city lawyers aren't risking their lives for their country.

fyn · 05/06/2023 07:51

@Nordicrain sorry, of course it’s fine to say you couldn’t live the lifestyle. That’s never what people say on these threads though, it always ‘I couldn’t date a soldier because they are all psychopaths with PTSD and beat their wives’. People like me rightly feel defensive because we know it isn't true and how hard the armed forces work and how much they sacrifice.

IHeartGeneHunt · 05/06/2023 07:48

I really wouldn't mind what someone did as long as it was legal and they were a good person and I found them attractive. My ex worked fixing railway tracks.
I'm a cleaner so I daresay that would put a lot of people off me though!

ChopperC110P · 05/06/2023 07:46

TheoTheopolis23 · 05/06/2023 07:38

Not sure why women are questioned for not being "equal opportunities" when men are not.

Try old and meeting a guy who decides your not his physical type on meeting, you'd be dumped faster than a doggy poo bag.

They don't date women for any number of reasons and they dont seem to ask each other questions like this about their justification.

Men have similar discussions.

  • would you date a sex worker?
  • would you date a woman who makes more money than you?
  • would you date a fat woman?
  • would you date a “high maintenance” woman?
  • would you date a famous woman?
  • would you date a much older woman?
  • would you date a woman from a different race or religion?
  • would you date an immigrant?

And they’re questioned just as much by society on their preferences.

bluemoonswoon · 05/06/2023 07:46

I find ambition really attractive. So - if they were a bin man so they could spend the afternoon wiring a book they want to publish then I would find that attractive. But if they are a bin man with nothing else to do, I don't think I'd go for that.
Btw - I'm also very ambitious so it just wouldn't work if I was in a relationship with someone who had no drive.

Nordicrain · 05/06/2023 07:45

fyn · 05/06/2023 07:34

There very regular threads about how dreadful the armed forces are because they never just ‘the lifestyle wouldn’t work for me’ it’s always what dreadful, wife beating psychopaths they are. It’s sad to hear because I see first hand what sacrifices people make to keep others in this country safe.

DH is in the armed forces, before that he spent his 20s working for NGOs developing projects in developing countries to get girls into school and fund businesses for women in patriarchal societies. I’d hazard a guess he’s done a lot more good than those berating the armed forces.

Surely i's perfectly acceptable to say you wouldn't be in a long term relationship with someone who would require you to move constantly, or be apart from you for long periods. Regardless of what you think of the military.

I am/was pretty opposed to the army in many ways - not the people personally, but the idea of armed conflict, and the way as an insitution it is run - and went on a course with lots of military people. It did change my perception of people in the military and I feel there is a lot being done to change the way the forces are run for the better, but hearing about the reality of the life style definitely confirmed I would not want to live that life.

SparklingMarkling · 05/06/2023 07:45

My husband has a low status job but we met when we were kids and I fancied him that much his job didn’t even come into the equation. He was funny, popular and a bit of a Jack the lad who ticked my boxes at the time. He looked good on my arm 😂. At the time, I also had a low status job.

As it turns out we have grown together. We are older now with three kids/teens. I qualified as a clin psych whilst he remained in his job that he’s always been happy enough in. He’s a wonderful father, who is never stressed, and has plenty of time for his family. Also, he’s never been jealous of me having a higher status job, and it’s never threatened him.

I have a few colleagues who’s husbands can’t really cope with them having a high status job despite them also having a fairly good job. They sound like dicks to be honest and just make me all the more grateful for my husband and family dynamic. I think if we both had high stress roles our family life would look very different.

When I was a kid my mum always used to ask me and my sister would we date a bin man purely for entertainment purposes and never to judge. I always said yes and my sister always said no 😂. She married someone with a lot of money/status but for various reasons I know I’m the happiest one deep down 😜.