Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it acceptable to judge a persons potential for a date based on their job ?

194 replies

AnyaMarx · 05/06/2023 03:12

I'm very curious to know what people actually think.

There is a thread here asking about whether to date someone based on their job .

Is that a thing ?

Would you date a bin man ?
Would you date a hairdresser?
Would you date a defence lawyer ?

Would it matter what a person does for a living or would you base any decisions on if they're nice and if you like them ?

Is it ever acceptable to base a decision on career choices?

If it is - is that the same as basing your decision on other things like skin colour or hair colour ?

Is it acceptable to say for instance "id never date a person with ginger hair ?

I'm curious as to where the line is .
It seems acceptable to say I wouldn't date a xxxx (met detective) for example

So is that the same as saying I wouldn't date a soldier?
A man with ginger hair ?
A hairdresser?
A man with glasses?

Is it ok to verbalise this if that's how you feel ?
It's made me very curious as to what's acceptable to say , or not to say but think ?

There is a thread on aibu asking whether to date a man based on his career and I wondered if this was substituted for a person of colour or a man with ginger hair or a social worker would it get the same response ?
Is it ok to say my stereotype dictates I shouldn't date a person who is xxxx
Or works as a xxxx
And whether that's ok to say even if you think it . ? Should we be able to say anything based on that ? Is any stereotyping ok if that's how we feel ? Whether that be based on career, colour , hair type , glasses , facial features, where does it end ?
Obviously anyone can say no to a date for ANY reason.....

OP posts:
LakieLady · 05/06/2023 21:35

Southoftheriver32 · 05/06/2023 06:43

I wouldn’t date a bin man no. That type of unskilled job shows how little motivation and self respect they have, not to mention money.

One of the cleverest and most talented men I've ever known worked as a bin man for a few years. It was relatively well paid in those days, and meant he got the afternoons free to do the school run and spend time on his music.

Someone else I used to know completed a PhD while working as a postman.

GimmeCoffee · 05/06/2023 21:20

I’d never date a Tory. Full stop - either a party member in any guise or a voter!

Other than that, no real rules: personality, morals and how a person acts etc is more important to me.

🤷‍♀️🤐🙃

Fairislefandango · 05/06/2023 20:49

Agree with this. The whole point of dating is to find out if someone is right for you and you're right for them.

Exactly. It's absolutely absurd to say that preferences for partners based on something as central and potentially highly personality-related as their choice of job are unacceptable, when people are quite happy to talk about preferences based on far, far more trivial things. Just read one of those 'What things do you find really attractive in a man?' threads. Suggesting it's unacceptable to choose or reject a partner based on their appearance is also daft.

dancinginthesky · 05/06/2023 20:35

Nrtft

Ofc its acceptable to decide based on someone's career you don't want to or do want to date them - if it goes anywhere then that becomes part of your life

Ofc somethings would be more important to weigh up than others - hairdresser Vs job that is shift work and risking life daily

Saschka · 05/06/2023 18:37

jannier · 05/06/2023 14:55

Do you give your female police friends a wide birth? They must be power crazy emotionally detached individuals too.

I have plenty of female friends I would never date! Don’t you? You can put up with differences between friends that would be absolute dealbreakers in a life partner.

jannier · 05/06/2023 14:55

AllllTheSmallThings · 05/06/2023 11:55

Hmmmm... well. I have a couple of (female) friends in the police and based on their reports, it is an incredibly toxic and misogynistic culture and does attract a certain type of man to it, although there are exceptions. It also involves very unsociable hours generally. It also has a huge psychological impact on people and they end up having to be quite emotionally detached to cope, and often end up with PTSD. And it is pretty poorly paid unless you become very senior. So while it's clearly ridiculous to say everyone in the police is X, if I was dating I'd definitely give anybody in that career I wide berth. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Do you give your female police friends a wide birth? They must be power crazy emotionally detached individuals too.

ChopSuey2 · 05/06/2023 14:41

I definitely consider a person's career choice when deciding about dating them because it can give an indication of whether our values and interests align. People who work in health and social care, forensics, law (some areas), and the death industries are likely to understand my work and share values (although I may find out I'm wrong after meeting them). People who work in finance or the armed forces are less likely to align with my values.

I consider field of work far more than likely salary, e.g. I'd rather date a support worker than a hedge fund manager.

EBearhug · 05/06/2023 13:37

I ended up not dating a chef, because we didn't have any mutually free time.

I want someone who shares my values and has enough intelligence and education to keep up with me. That's more likely (but not limited to) with certain professions, though a binman could be doing other things on the side. They're certainly essential, but there's a difference between dating someone and employing them. Can't say I'd be keen on the early starts...

Azurebird · 05/06/2023 13:21

I'm a nurse and I'd say no to dating other nurses. I have done in the past, getting stuck talking shop all the time, clashing/incompatible schedules etc would be big reasons.

I've dated guys from various walks of life, and bigger turn offs are, lack of respect for education I.e "school/college/uni are a waste of time" and self-deprecation I.e "why would YOU want to date me, when I'm only a bin-man".... I've walked away for both of these reasons in the past. They weren't big men one was a lorry driver and one a community support worker for adults with learning disabilities. I didn't care, it was nice to hear about some else's different day.

Swipe away any bloke that lists "university of life" on his profile, that's a red flag for the above behaviours

LolaSmiles · 05/06/2023 13:11

Why OP does "discriminating" specifically based on career strike you as an issue? I mean, surely people discriminate based on all sorts of criteria about a person, isn't that kind of the point of dating, to find out if someone is a match for you? With some things like whether they are physically attractive it may be obvious straight away of course but others like their personality it may take a bit of dating to find out. But in the end it is all about "discriminating" those compatible with you from those who are not? And I'd say someone's work will actually be a major factor in impacting a relationship more than many other considerations.
Agree with this. The whole point of dating is to find out if someone is right for you and you're right for them.

The alternative to discriminating (aka selecting people who share your values, work patterns, life aspirations, priorities) is demanding everyone you date accepts and adores you exactly as you are and sets aside their own priorities and values in life. That's a much more problematic approach to dating in my opinion.

AffIt · 05/06/2023 12:49

If my OH died tomorrow, I'd probably just get more cats, having heard too many nightmare stories of the hell that is dating over 40, but yes, I think (like most people) I do have some biases, conscious or unconscious.

I probably wouldn't date somebody who worked in Conservative head office, for example, or an abattoir, because I'm a left-leaning vegetarian and either of those choices would, for better or worse, feel like making life difficult for myself for no reason.

Now, perhaps I am completely unreasonable, they're lovely hypothetical people (I've decided to call them Giles and Pete in my head, btw), and I'm doing myself out of years of happiness because I can't past my own prejudices. But, you know, I'm only human.

The one 'occupation' I will never entertain ever again (having had too much of it in my younger days) is the starving artist type - the ones who bum through life as waiters / baristas / petrol station attendants (nothing wrong with any of those jobs in principle, btw) because they're waiting to make it big with their next single / novel / hand-thrown pot or whatever.

Nodinnernogift · 05/06/2023 12:34

The comparison with job and skin or hair colour is confusing to me; the former is a choice about how you spend your time and contribute to society and the latter simply appearance.

Anyway I wouldn't write someone off entirely based on their job but it contributes heavily to the overall picture for me. For instance, someone might be working casually with good reason as they need to be available for childcare or whatever.

If someone is work shy or spends his time moaning about work while not changing anything that is a massive turnoff for me.

I have one hard rule though - no barmen.

StormShadow · 05/06/2023 12:28

Saschka · 05/06/2023 10:45

Dating police officers (I haven't but work with many) , sure to shift work , not being able to clock out on time etc, however most people saying that it's their reason for not dating a Met detective probably wouldn't say the same about a hospital doctor....

I suspect many people don’t realise the reality until they are actually dating one - lots of us have experience of relationships and even marriages breaking down because the man can’t cope with a girlfriend/wife in a demanding role with shiftwork.

DH has openly said he would never date another doctor if we split, it just isn’t compatible with, well, me being a traditional wife and doing all the housework and childcare, basically. He is far from alone in this, plenty of men say they want an equal partner when what they actually mean is they want two equal incomes but still don’t appreciate having to do the school run themselves because you are on a long day.

I would!

But there's one big potential difference between a hospital doctor and police, which is that the former have higher average earnings, plus more of them end up on consultant salaries than the really good police salaries. So there's more chance of being able to throw money at the problem. I still wouldn't fancy it though.

YorkshirePuddingsGreatestFan · 05/06/2023 12:02

I didn't want to date a store cleaner. Not because he was a cleaner, but because of his attitude. He brags about doing the bare minimum work he can get away with at work and refuses to work a minute over the minimum hours required to claim top up benefits. It was that attitude which made him sound like he'd be a lazy man child and that was one of the things that put me off him.

AllllTheSmallThings · 05/06/2023 12:01

MovinGroovinBarbie · 05/06/2023 10:06

It's interesting that a man would be viewed poorly if he wanted to date a high earning woman so he could go part time. I feel like true equality would be this working both ways.

It depends what people want. Helena Morrissey is a very successful career woman with 9 children and a husband who is a SAHD. I have a friend who took two years out after her second child and then swapped with her husband, he is now a SAHD and she's been focusing on career. Then later they will both go part time again.

But many women now do not want to be financially dependent on a man, not do they want to be the sole earner, so they want an equal partner who will share earning and home responsibilities so they don't get dumped with having to do most of the stuff at home as well as working. This rules out people in certain jobs who would not be in a position to do that.

AllllTheSmallThings · 05/06/2023 11:55

jannier · 05/06/2023 11:47

It's a thread judging a character by a job choice and is reflective of what is seen in the media virtually saying everyone who chooses that career path is a mysogonistic potential rapist etc. Which is ridiculous. Any profession will have criminals, abusers etc. Your guard should be up for everyone you meet

Hmmmm... well. I have a couple of (female) friends in the police and based on their reports, it is an incredibly toxic and misogynistic culture and does attract a certain type of man to it, although there are exceptions. It also involves very unsociable hours generally. It also has a huge psychological impact on people and they end up having to be quite emotionally detached to cope, and often end up with PTSD. And it is pretty poorly paid unless you become very senior. So while it's clearly ridiculous to say everyone in the police is X, if I was dating I'd definitely give anybody in that career I wide berth. 🤷🏻‍♀️

AllllTheSmallThings · 05/06/2023 11:51

Another thing if you are planning children is flexibility, so that childcare responsibilities and drop offs, collections, sick days etc can be shared. Will there be options for the person to go part time as well?

Then there is the level of stress. Is work going to be all-consuming or unpredictable meaning things have to be cancelled at short notice? Is it likely to make them ill or burned out in the longer term? Or is it physically dangerous?

These are all important things that will impact a relationship. To some people some will matter, others to others, and to some people maybe none of it matters at all.

Why OP does "discriminating" specifically based on career strike you as an issue? I mean, surely people discriminate based on all sorts of criteria about a person, isn't that kind of the point of dating, to find out if someone is a match for you? With some things like whether they are physically attractive it may be obvious straight away of course but others like their personality it may take a bit of dating to find out. But in the end it is all about "discriminating" those compatible with you from those who are not? And I'd say someone's work will actually be a major factor in impacting a relationship more than many other considerations.

jannier · 05/06/2023 11:47

It's a thread judging a character by a job choice and is reflective of what is seen in the media virtually saying everyone who chooses that career path is a mysogonistic potential rapist etc. Which is ridiculous. Any profession will have criminals, abusers etc. Your guard should be up for everyone you meet

AllllTheSmallThings · 05/06/2023 11:41

Zanatdy · 05/06/2023 06:34

i probably wouldn’t choose to date men doing certain jobs now. In the past it didn’t bother me, and the guy I adored most was on the dole and working on the side! I am more choosy now, and I have been single for years through choice as my dating criteria is pretty strict. That said if someone told me they worked in an office and I fell in love and they later told me they were a bin man, would I dump them? No. Probably not

You should, for lying to you!

AllOfThemWitches · 05/06/2023 11:40

I'd rather date a bin man refuse collector than a lawyer.

AllllTheSmallThings · 05/06/2023 11:40

Wittsendhasarrived · 05/06/2023 06:26

It's a fair assumption that the majority of people on this site are heterosexual women right? And I'm wondering how many people would think this is okay the other way around? How many SAHMs are there compared with SAHDs? How many women are forced to not go back to work after children because childcare costs outstrip their salary? How many men does that therefore place an enormous (and very often underappreciated) burden of being the sole breadwinner for the family? And yet would anyone suggest to a man that it's acceptable to judge a potential date with a woman based on her job or earning power?

I would say exactly the same to a man, and will be to my son! When choosing a life partner people need to be practical, I wish I had been. A very expensive mistake and the impact on my children has been huge. I totally agree that I cannot imagine having a penis making it any more palatable to have an adult dependent or such an unequal relationship, having the burden of being the sole earner and getting less time with your children as a result. I think many men do not want this at all and try to weed out women who view them as an alternative to having a career of their own.

AllllTheSmallThings · 05/06/2023 11:35

My point on that thread was judge by the person not their job .

While this is true to an extent, the person chose the job so it does tell you something about what kind of person they are and what is important to them. And also the way it might practically impact the relationship if the dating was to be successful. There's not much point starting to date someone if you know you'd never progress it to something serious because of incompatibilities, unless you are just dating very casually for a bit of fun of course.

AllllTheSmallThings · 05/06/2023 11:32

AnyaMarx · 05/06/2023 03:27

That's my point Perry we can think anything- but what is acceptable to say ?

I might have an "I'd never date a short man " rule but if I asked here am I unreasonable to say I'd never date a man based on height ? I wonder what reaction I'd get .

To say to who, though? Do you mean if asked on a date to tell the person you are declining them because of X? That seems needlessly cruel or rude.

To discuss with your friends, I don't see why you can't be honest about your preferences.

Different people are looking for different things after all, in all kinds of ways.

Some jobs would make your life more difficult if you were looking for a partner to have children with because they would have a large impact on your quality of life, for example anybody working away a lot or doing shift work or weekend work.

Likewise some industries have a very toxic work culture, or are high stress. This is likely to impact on your relationship in one way or another. Other industries are very low paid so if looking for a relationship just for dates that would be ok, although if they couldn't really afford to go out for interesting dates it would be a bit of a non-starter! And it would be a problem if you wished to cohabit or marry as you'd end up carrying someone else financially and potentially losing half of your assets if you divorced! Some people don't mind that but others would, understandably. Some people are looking for a meal ticket so deliberately try to target those earning more than they are. Others might be wary of people with certain types of self-employment as it can be precarious.

Other people are only attracted to people with more intellect so would want someone with that kind of job, others might want to find someone very focused on career if they are themselves so that it doesn't cause friction in the relationship, or the very opposite and want to find someone who views work as just a job because they also do.

Surely this is ok because like with any other characteristic when it comes to dating it us about compatibility, so not an implication that there is anything "wrong" with the person, just that they are not right for you?

Mew2 · 05/06/2023 11:21

So I met my hubby- he worked in a supermarket. I outearn him massively about 4-5 times his salary.. guess what it makes no difference to us...
There were a few no go's for me when dating- but they were more ethical than anything else. Anything can change in a heartbeat- could have a stroke, a car accident etc tomorrow and where would you be in terms of a job and I see this regularly... I actually wanted someone who knew the power of saving something for a rainy day. For a just in case day and we both have savings of 2 months salary just in case...
Lots of men wouldn't date someone if the woman has more education and that also doesn't seem fair either

Mew2 · 05/06/2023 11:14

So what if a man didn't drive because he has a medical condition. Is that different to if he chooses not to drive?