Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To just let my 1 year old cry it out

192 replies

justwanttobe · 04/06/2023 20:11

My 13 month old is still waking a lot in the night and only a bottle gets him to finally settle down again.

It's usually twice a night. I'm just so fed up and exhausted.

He usually has no problem going down at bed time, but has now started to cry when I leave the room too. ( usually he was happy if he had a bottle, I could just walk out ).

During the day, it's really hard to get anything done too.
He's always clingy and wants to be held a lot.

I am really struggling with energy levels and can't take it anymore.

I want to have more rest in the quickest possible way. I don't want to prolong it. I hate leaving him to cry, it's stressful and not ideal, but I think it's yeh quickest way..

OP posts:
SparklingMarkling · 04/06/2023 22:36

@whattodo22222

Thank you 😊.

everybodytidy · 04/06/2023 22:35

Also for us, it made him sleep through for a while. But then every few weeks he goes back to not sleeping again. Then the cycle continues, he's almost 2 now and I wish I'd have done what I did with my first which was tend to him every time he cried, but eventually leaving it 3/4/5 minutes before I went in to see if he would go back to sleep on his own. If he didn't, I knew he really needed me. He's slept through from 1.5. It's so hard to make the right decisions when your brain isn't working from tiredness and stress though.

SparklingMarkling · 04/06/2023 22:35

@everybodytidy

It isn’t completely “fixed”. Try not to be too hard on yourself. We can only look forward. 🌸

whattodo22222 · 04/06/2023 22:34

SparklingMarkling · 04/06/2023 20:27

@justwanttobe

Because it’s cruel. I regret doing it, I was a young mum and didn’t really know the implications of doing so. It did work but he would have felt scared and lonely at an age where he wouldn’t have been able to understand why his mum didn’t come and make him feel safe 😢. It’s just not worth it.

He is a teen now, a great boy and I’m lucky to have him. I hope I’ve managed to make amends over the years and we do have a good relationship but if I could turn back time I absolutely wouldn’t let him cry it out.

@SparklingMarkling you sound like a wonderful mum. How refreshing that you can look back and say what you would've done differently rather than the usual "I did it and mine were fine"

OP I'm cosleeping with my 12 month old. She still wakes several times in the night, not for feeding but for comfort. In many cultures babies aren't expected to sleep alone. To get things done in the day I strap her to my back. It's normal for them to want us all the time. My DD is in nursery now so if we don't bedshare that would be 19 hours of the day we're separated for.

Peppadog · 04/06/2023 22:32

To be honest, if most babies would fall asleep after 10 minutes CIO, then I don't think there would be so much controversy about it.
Most babies will cry for a very long time if left, especially at age 1 when they can stand in a cot and bawl.
Controlled crying isn't much better and often just prolongs it from what I've been told.

everybodytidy · 04/06/2023 22:32

SparklingMarkling · 04/06/2023 20:22

Don’t do it. I did. BIG regret.

Me too. He's very very clingy now, we don't seem to have a good attachment and I blame that

SparklingMarkling · 04/06/2023 22:29

@SouthLondonMum22

There’s a line though isn’t there? From “sleep training technique” to neglect. I think overall mothers need to listen to their instincts first and foremost and I regret not doing that.

I lay there with my heart racing thinking I was doing the right thing by “training” when in actual fact I was neglecting my baby who was getting more distressed by the minute. I was very young, and didn’t have anyone around me to advise me that, actually, it might not be a good idea.

Thankfully I did listen to my instincts with subsequent babies and I would advise this first and foremost. The OP has already stated in the original post that contemplating this feels stressful.

OP, I hope you manage to resolve this in the best way possible for you and your baby. This will pass, even though it currently feels like a lifetime. Good luck. 💐

muffinmclay22 · 04/06/2023 22:27

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Namasti · 04/06/2023 22:24

People get very up in arms about this…we did nearly reach the point with my toddler as nothing helped her- she didn’t want to be held, or put down, or have a drink, or come in our bed, or have anything, she was just screaming because she was dog tired.

It sounds like he is seeking your comfort and connection and is prime age for separation anxiety.

We used Lucy Wolfe stay and support which I highly recommend. Once they know you will be there but cot time is sleep time it gets better.

Also introducing a cuddly toy- you can hear our daughter on the monitor singing to them sometimes!

scrantonelectriccity · 04/06/2023 22:23

I think YABU.

My 2 year old woke hourly (minimum 8 times a night) until 19 months and is also a super clingy girl in the day time. I was absolutely exhausted and really struggled in the day but the most important thing to me was that she felt safe and secure. I had the odd night where I just wanted to leave her to it cos I couldn't cope anymore but I knew it was wrong and just persevered.

She's 2 now and only wakes 1-2 times a night

Icouldbehappy · 04/06/2023 22:22

How would you feel if the person who is supposed to love you the most just ignored you when you are crying/upset?
Don’t do that to your baby.

SouthLondonMum22 · 04/06/2023 22:22

SparklingMarkling · 04/06/2023 21:45

@Kath85

10 minutes? That’s more like controlled crying.

CIO is when a baby cries for an extended period of time alone, often to the point of vomiting. The baby is feeling terror at this point and then passes out through sheer exhaustion.

That’s not quite the same as letting a baby cry for a couple of minutes to self soothe. I do think people struggle to know exactly what is meant by CIO.

CIO is simply a sleep training technique that doesn't involve going back to baby and attempting to soothe them which would be controlled crying.

It may only take 10 minutes with some babies but that wouldn't suit the agenda people who have likely never used the method push of these poor vomiting babies passing out out from exhaustion.

I think it's always worth trying controlled crying first but sometimes, CIO can actually involve less crying.

scrantonelectriccity · 04/06/2023 22:20

Op cry it out is no big deal for a 1 year old.

Ignoring your child when they're crying out for you, alone and scared in the dark until they eventually learn you're not coming is no big deal? Ok...

FlounderingFruitcake · 04/06/2023 22:19

justwanttobe · 04/06/2023 22:03

@Maztek he's got a brutal schedule.

I just don’t understand this as a justification at all. I can completely understand that it’s on you when he needs to be up early for work the next day, if he’s working a night shift or working away. I wouldn’t expect it to be 50:50 or even close if you’re a SAHP. But surely there are nights when he’s home and doesn’t have work the next day and why isn’t he giving you a break then?

tiaandduck · 04/06/2023 22:19

I have a 12 month old who is like this and it's horrendous.
I solo parent Monday to thurday as dh works away and I work five days a week. I know how hard it is and that horrible anxious feeling of bedtime approaching.

I can't bring myself to do cry it out. Dd doesn't have the personality for it...she would make herself sick and just cling to me during the day, I know that as her mother...it would not have a positive outcome other than a bit more sleep.
Dd has always been high needs, can't be left a minute type of baby but it will get better.
I've struggled to cope on a night and I know how awful it is so no judgment here. But I personally would avoid.

zurala · 04/06/2023 22:17

justwanttobe · 04/06/2023 20:31

@RosettaTheGardenFairy I think it's unrealistic that you can always be there for your child when they cry. It's impossible sometimes, even without cry it out.

Rubbish. I was always there for my children. They never cried alone.

I don't understand parents who abandon their children to cry in distress and don't comfort them. It's our entire job as parents to be there for our children.

SparklingMarkling · 04/06/2023 22:17

@Sometimeswinning

You are more than welcome to disagree.

I do believe that crying it out is a neglectful practice which therefore will not encourage a secure attachment. I’ve already said the whole concept isn’t black and white so I am not sure why that makes you so angry. If you are indeed a professional (which I doubt) maybe you should reflect on why you’re so angry.

Its common sense really and not one that requires any special sort of training.

gemloving · 04/06/2023 22:17

Why don't you do a gradual retreat as in 2 minutes and then work up to 5, go in every 5 minutes.

FTMFeb21 · 04/06/2023 22:16

I had the same issue when my DS was that old. I was leaning on cry it out but my DH wanted to see what’s wrong. We started giving him 2-3 bottles every night spaced between two-four hours and didn’t leave until he finished and handed it back. Maybe he’s just hungry. Once his appetite becomes better in terms of food during the day , his night time feeding will reduce.

It won’t last forever.

RedHelenB · 04/06/2023 22:12

I think babies get over tired. Crying is their way of showing that. I'd try leaving him, you being ridiculously tired helps no one.

RosettaTheGardenFairy · 04/06/2023 22:12

So you leave your 13 month old to cry because you don't want to leave your 3 year old? You need a fresh start with a brand new system in place, because that is not right.

Do you know what CIO is? Do you know why your son stops crying? It's not because he suddenly feels safe and happy and content. It's because he's exhausted and has given up. Given up on you. He has learned that no matter how hard he cries for mama and dada, they're not coming. You may think, well it's only 3 nights, but what your baby is learning in those 3 nights is shitty.

Peppadog · 04/06/2023 22:11

Sometimeswinning · 04/06/2023 21:53

Where have you got vomiting from? There is a huge difference between neglect and cio. Same as attachment is not linked with a few nights upset.

If my child had cried so much he had vomited cio would not have continued, it wouldnt have got to that point as my child was a fan of sucking on his hand so i was also pretty well trained on responding to gagging, sick etc.

You have completey changed your focus. You are talking about 2 separate things now. If you know anything about attachment you know a few nights is not even flagged as an issue! It's life changing, neglect, death, abandonment which are the issues through the early years.

There have definitely been links made between CIO and attachment. Some studies have said it affects attachment and others found no link. It isn't just a 'few nights'. CIO trains the baby to not cry when it is in distress at night, so the effects could be far longer lasting, noone really knows.

Sometimeswinning · 04/06/2023 22:08

SparklingMarkling · 04/06/2023 22:00

@Sometimeswinning

Of course it is all of those things, like I have already said it’s not black and white. CIO doesn’t encourage secure styles though and you will not convince me otherwise. I think you’re referring to controlled crying as CIO is overall a neglectful practice. It is well known the method can lead to a vomiting baby or a very distressed one. I’m not sure why you’re getting so defensive over that.

I'm disagreeing with you. I also find your link with attachment ridiculous.

I don't think you have the first clue what you are on about and yes that annoys me. Stick to what you know next time.

Maztek · 04/06/2023 22:07

Can you co sleep with both of them instead?

FlounderingFruitcake · 04/06/2023 22:05

Usually I’m all for sleep training but leaving a baby to scream so you can cosleep with a 3YO is absolutely not ok. It’s like he’s being punished so you can pander to her, which leaves a pretty sour taste in my mouth. If you’re going to change things then it should be with her because she’s old enough to understand. And why isn’t your partner helping?

Swipe left for the next trending thread