Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that making craft shit for school at home is pointless?

114 replies

purplepencilcase · 04/06/2023 14:10

Can someone explain why spending almost a whole day on making a Viking Longboat for Year 3 homework is a good use of time?

I honestly can't believe it's enhancing education in ways that other activities couldn't do?

OP posts:
iatealltheminieggs · 04/06/2023 15:02

Currently helping my 7 year old make a bus so I feel your pain.

KnickerlessParsons · 04/06/2023 15:02

DH DD once made a brilliant WWI trench. Took him them bloody ages.

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 15:00

@nahwhale so parents shouldn't help their children with maths, reading or sporting skills either? Just leave everything for the children to do by themselves?
If a parent says they never help their child with reading they get shot down in flames.
But god forbid they help with some crafting.

TeaandHobnobs · 04/06/2023 14:58

Ugh, we had so many weekend craft homeworks when DS was in Y3/Y4 - drove us mental!
Thankfully they seemed to have stopped the practice now DD is in this part of the school… there’s an optional “grid” of activities to be completed over the half term, but we don’t bother - it’s hard enough getting her to do the actual homework 😬

Mydusa · 04/06/2023 14:58

DD did a PowerPoint for a project once and got marked down for it not being creative enough. We did papier mache etc after that, less actual work required.

Whowhatwherewhenwhy1 · 04/06/2023 14:58

Pointless because 9/10 times most of the making has been done by a parent and can easily be spotted when the little darlings bring them back to school. Waste of time and not really a learning experience and just a bloody annoyance to already overstretched parents. My daughters school had the sense to make them in school.

Teabab · 04/06/2023 14:58

We used to do all of this stuff at school in school time and with school resources, sadly there isn't the time or the money now so it gets sent to be done at home. Art and making stuff in general is very beneficial for children, the real crime is that it is undervalued in the curriculum.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 04/06/2023 14:58

SweetSakura · 04/06/2023 14:26

Yanbu. I realised most of the time the parents must have done most of the making. So I don't make mine do these projects.
Crap for them to try compare what they can make with something mainly made by someone 4x their age

Indeed. When DS1(now 18) was in Reception class, the homework was to make a model 'space rocket'.

He managed to cover a Pringle tube in tinfoil, put some stickers on it and tape a plastic ice-cream cone thing to the top. He was ever so pleased with himself.

Until he got to school and saw all the elaborate rockets clearly made by the competitive parents, that was. I've never forgotten seeing his little face crumple, and I never encouraged him to bother with these types of homework again..

nahwhale · 04/06/2023 14:57

daffodilandtulip · 04/06/2023 14:35

Ofsted. I'm a childminder and got marked down because the children (under 3) don't do enough home learning.

That's utterly ridiculous. Why is that your responsibility?

nahwhale · 04/06/2023 14:56

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 14:28

Design skills
Figuring out the best materials to use skills
Building skills

The future designers, engineers and builders of future products have got to learn their skills somehow. This is how they start.

What by getting their parents to do it? This sort of thing is fine until the parents get involved

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 14:54

@GaspingGekko I guess you have never met any toy designers - a big part of having an interest in a career like that is building toys out of cardboard as a kid.

Zoologydragon · 04/06/2023 14:54

I don't think it's too much of an issue once they get a tiny bit older. The projects my y1 dd5 has to complete on the other hand are pointless! In the 2nd term of reception: build a habitat. Not one child's was made by the actual child.

GaspingGekko · 04/06/2023 14:51

GaspingGekko · 04/06/2023 14:49

@Needmorelego My interest came from having very strong maths skills and an interest in physics and the area of engineering I went into.
In my various jobs I've analysed data, produced statistics, created computer simulations, worked on test rigs - mainly computer based.

Posted too soon. I appreciate that thwre are children who will absolutely love many aspects of these projects, and they can be fun for some, I'm just not convinced that sticking loo rolls together are really the thing that are going to spark a passion or assist the skills that you seem to think it will.

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 14:51

Does it matter if parents help or not. In the 7 years of my daughters primary school you had the children who built stuff by themselves, the children who had help and the models that were clearly built by an adult when the child gave up interest.
The teachers could tell the difference, so could the children, so could the parents...but no one cared. It was all fun.
My daughter was of the "gave up interest" group but I loved making models.
One of mine was displayed in the classroom all term. All the children knew I made it because the teacher told them and I gave a brief Show and Tell about it. It was known as "Xs Mum's Model of .....".

megletthesecond · 04/06/2023 14:51

Yanbu. We had many miserable trips to hobbycraft with me trying to organise what they needed for school while the dc's were off looking at the toys.

kingtamponthefurred · 04/06/2023 14:51

TheYearOfSmallThings · 04/06/2023 14:22

If all the Viking longships were set on fire after dark at the local pond and sent out across the water, it would be like a miniature Up Helly Aa, and who wouldn't like to see that?

I would travel to see that!

GaspingGekko · 04/06/2023 14:49

@Needmorelego My interest came from having very strong maths skills and an interest in physics and the area of engineering I went into.
In my various jobs I've analysed data, produced statistics, created computer simulations, worked on test rigs - mainly computer based.

lieselotte · 04/06/2023 14:47

Completely agree. Teachers must know the parents make these models but still set them for the children to supposedly do!

Itsanotherhreatday · 04/06/2023 14:45

Nobody’s mentioned the ideas and collaboration! All great skills- plus your child can teach you their knowledge and a lot of children learn through teaching.

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 14:42

@GaspingGekko what made you interested in becoming an engineer?
Something must have sparked an interest.
(I actually find "Working in enginering" one of those vague phrases like "working in the Civil Service" - in that I don't really know what someone does in their job if they tell me they are "an engineer")
The thing is building a cardboard ship covers many different skills and potential careers. Some children will love the actual physical design part of it (ie making it the correct boat shape that sails well), others the decorative side of the design, some the actual physical building side of it.

SweetSakura · 04/06/2023 14:41

I don't dispute the skills to be learned/the value. But when every time a section of parents do nearly all the work, I'm afraid I am just not pushing my children to take part.

We do crafts at home in our own time. No need for them to have their work compared to what a 40 year old sahm can produce

CheesyOnion · 04/06/2023 14:39

There are loads of skills to be learned from it for those who are interested.

But why all day? Why your time?

Give DC some materials and leave them to it. If they are happy with what they create in 30 mins, job done. If they want to spend all day on it, enjoy the quiet day.

hettiethehare · 04/06/2023 14:37

By DC3 I have completely stopped doing all types of craft homework that require more of my input than the DC's.

The world does not seem to have stopped.

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 14:36

@SchoolShenanigans do your children do any crafts at home? Do you consider those a waste of time too?

GaspingGekko · 04/06/2023 14:35

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 14:28

Design skills
Figuring out the best materials to use skills
Building skills

The future designers, engineers and builders of future products have got to learn their skills somehow. This is how they start.

As an engineer I can only say I absolutely hated all this craft stuff in school. Pretty sure none of it assisted me at any point in my career.