Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that making craft shit for school at home is pointless?

114 replies

purplepencilcase · 04/06/2023 14:10

Can someone explain why spending almost a whole day on making a Viking Longboat for Year 3 homework is a good use of time?

I honestly can't believe it's enhancing education in ways that other activities couldn't do?

OP posts:
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 16:36

AngelinaFibres · 04/06/2023 16:31

This. Researching, designing and making are crucial skills for life and for many jobs. The making of mess and the clearing up of that mess are also crucial life skills and the lack of those skills are often moaned about on here.

I doubt a y3 can make a longboat without parental help. So they just get frustrated. It’s ‘teaching’ them nothing.

AngelinaFibres · 04/06/2023 16:31

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 14:28

Design skills
Figuring out the best materials to use skills
Building skills

The future designers, engineers and builders of future products have got to learn their skills somehow. This is how they start.

This. Researching, designing and making are crucial skills for life and for many jobs. The making of mess and the clearing up of that mess are also crucial life skills and the lack of those skills are often moaned about on here.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 16:29

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 14:28

Design skills
Figuring out the best materials to use skills
Building skills

The future designers, engineers and builders of future products have got to learn their skills somehow. This is how they start.

I spent 19 years as a designer and 25 years as a DT teacher up to A level.

This is not teaching a y3 design skills. The project to build a Viking long boat is way too difficult for y3. They need to know basic construction skills or the standard of attainment will be shite. And then they get upset because it’s not how they wanted it.

This used to do my head in about primary school. Giving impossible art/design projects. My dd once got told to make a musical instrument in y3. Cue child bringing in amazing saxophone covered in tin foil obviuosly made by parent.

I used to ask y7 what they’d done at school. ‘Draw Romans’ or ‘Made a Long boat’ were normal answers. When k asked them what skills they learnt they had no idea. ‘Draw Romans’ 🙄How about a bit of shade, tone, form before we try and draw complex people with no reference?’Make a Viking king boat’ How about teaching card construction or basic 3D modelling in paper before making a complex 3D shape with no basic skills

Used to do my head in. Homeworks way above level of age ability.

Magnoliainbloom · 04/06/2023 16:20

YANBU. I never got involved.

SirCharlesRainier · 04/06/2023 16:06

Just don't do them, we never have.

InSpainTheRain · 04/06/2023 16:01

YANBU. I had 2 DS and tried to do all the stuff with them because honestly the assignments set were well beyond what they could do and they always needed craft stuff to do it. They are early twenties now and I wish I'd told the school a big fat no!

Funny story - Once DS forgot he had to do make a calendar for advent until the night before when he was in bed (he was like 9 or something). I told him not to worry and I'd quickly cobble something together which he could take in. I did it - and he duly took it in and said "mum helped him". Then at the carol service the vicar came over to say well done because it had a lovely christian message. I am as atheist as they come, but googled some Xmas bible verses to put in t

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 04/06/2023 16:00

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 04/06/2023 15:57

Get your child to draw one and colour it in instead.

^ because all the cornflake/egg boxes and yoghurt pots went into the recycling Wink

pussycatinfluffyslippers · 04/06/2023 15:57

Get your child to draw one and colour it in instead.

daffodilandtulip · 04/06/2023 15:56

@nahwhale as in, we have to set homework to work alongside what they are learning here.

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 15:53

I think a big thing here is people talking about children "winning prizes" with crafts projects clearly made by an adult. That never happened at my daughters school. There were no prizes for a craft based homework.
It was just (actually not even compulsory) homework.
Why are children getting prizes for homework?

nahwhale · 04/06/2023 15:39

SweetSakura · 04/06/2023 15:17

Exactly.

Cutting the sellotape/buying materials/ being an extra pair of hands as they execute their designs etc...Fine.

Treating it as some opportunity to show off that you have a degree in art and design or whatever... Twatty. (And doesn't help your child anyway, they would learn a lot more if you let them take charge)

I agree with this assessment. It needs to be child led. If they go off bored and do something else then that's it - half finished homework gets handed in

nahwhale · 04/06/2023 15:37

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 15:00

@nahwhale so parents shouldn't help their children with maths, reading or sporting skills either? Just leave everything for the children to do by themselves?
If a parent says they never help their child with reading they get shot down in flames.
But god forbid they help with some crafting.

Helping them by listening to their ideas fine. Holding something in place while it sets - fine. Actually doing the crafting and sticking it all together coz the kid got bored, not fine.

Nevermind31 · 04/06/2023 15:35

I’m of the opinion that child needs to do their craft homework - and I will assist if they need help. But they need to come up with their own ideas.
my friend believes that as other parents make it, if her children ask her she will make it so they can be proud at school.
for winning prizes, it’s always the child made ones that win, not the elaborate parent models.
also, some of the parents in DC2s reception class are realising now that neither their children, nor they, like the 7 hour input their model requires, and that they don’t get any brownie points for it either

mastertomsmum · 04/06/2023 15:25

EasyLifer · 04/06/2023 15:10

Luckily these days are long gone for me, but it's not just the making of the damn thing that's a pain in the arse, it's then got to be transported into school! Not so easy to carry a homemade volcano, or similar shite when the school run is 15 mins walk in all elements!

I recall that our neighbours - whose kids have been inseparable since reception - opted to do a Yr9 science project together. I can still picture the giant relief model of the planets being manipulated into the back of an estate car by 2 mums and 2 kids. They must have had to bring it home too as it ended up in a skip when their neighbours were having a kitchen extension built the following year.

My son escaped having to do a science project because of Lockdown

deplorabelle · 04/06/2023 15:24

TheYearOfSmallThings · 04/06/2023 14:22

If all the Viking longships were set on fire after dark at the local pond and sent out across the water, it would be like a miniature Up Helly Aa, and who wouldn't like to see that?

I am so doing this when winter comes

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 15:22

@MereDintofPandiculation well parents don't have to do that. If they "take over" that's their choice.

mastertomsmum · 04/06/2023 15:18

PuttingDownRoots · 04/06/2023 14:33

I'd love to say it gets better at Secondary school...

But DD had to make a castle in Yr7.

Yup same in Yr 7 here. There was also an egg thing, bunting, a mask and volcano (not functioning, just labelled like the mot and bailey castle). I recall with the castle that the instructions used some other word than labelled and we ended up doing it last minute

SweetSakura · 04/06/2023 15:17

MereDintofPandiculation · 04/06/2023 15:13

There’s a big difference between “helping” and taking over completely the design and execution.

Exactly.

Cutting the sellotape/buying materials/ being an extra pair of hands as they execute their designs etc...Fine.

Treating it as some opportunity to show off that you have a degree in art and design or whatever... Twatty. (And doesn't help your child anyway, they would learn a lot more if you let them take charge)

PaigeMatthews · 04/06/2023 15:16

iatealltheminieggs · 04/06/2023 15:02

Currently helping my 7 year old make a bus so I feel your pain.

Haha spent lunch time making a Gaudi inspired building with a year 8.

MereDintofPandiculation · 04/06/2023 15:13

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 15:00

@nahwhale so parents shouldn't help their children with maths, reading or sporting skills either? Just leave everything for the children to do by themselves?
If a parent says they never help their child with reading they get shot down in flames.
But god forbid they help with some crafting.

There’s a big difference between “helping” and taking over completely the design and execution.

Sensibletrousers · 04/06/2023 15:11

I don’t mind craft homework as long as

a) I’m given plenty of notice
b) my child actually engages and doesn’t complain or wander off leaving me to do it

Sadly it’s rare both conditions are met!

EasyLifer · 04/06/2023 15:10

Luckily these days are long gone for me, but it's not just the making of the damn thing that's a pain in the arse, it's then got to be transported into school! Not so easy to carry a homemade volcano, or similar shite when the school run is 15 mins walk in all elements!

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 15:06

@iatealltheminieggs bus is easy. Empty cornflake box. Painted red (or the colour of your local buses). Draw window and door shapes on In each window either draw a person or cut out faces from an old magazine and stick them on. Cut out black cardboard circles for wheels and stick them on.
Done.

notsurewherenotsurewhy · 04/06/2023 15:04

Yabu, as homework goes I prefer this sort. We spend as little or as much time as we fancy / other plans permit. My DC always loved a bit of junk modelling whether in the classroom, set as homework, or spontaneously raiding the recycling at home. I'm not aware of it ever feeling competitive at school - suspect in our school there are low levels of parental over-involvement - as far as I can tell that's a very middle class mumsnet thing.

I'm a lone parent of two kids, and have a full time job. Have always been much happier to make time and fend off a toddler for this stuff rather than practising bloody spellings. Much easier to engage both the dyspraxic sensitive kid, and the one who generally finds everything easy, in Viking boats than worksheets.

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 15:02

@Mydusa how old was your daughter when she was "marked down" though?
Making a viking ship in Year 3 isn't the type of thing that would be "marked" or given a grade?

Swipe left for the next trending thread