Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU that making craft shit for school at home is pointless?

114 replies

purplepencilcase · 04/06/2023 14:10

Can someone explain why spending almost a whole day on making a Viking Longboat for Year 3 homework is a good use of time?

I honestly can't believe it's enhancing education in ways that other activities couldn't do?

OP posts:
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 18:01

Teabab · 04/06/2023 17:55

A balance is probably more sensible. Yes technology is the future, but developing other non digital skills is really valuable- and dare I say to many...enjoyable! I do think as tech takes over the creative industries there'll be a resurgence of fine arts and other things that can only be thought up and made by humans.

So do l! It will be great!

JustGeorgie · 04/06/2023 17:56

I agree

Waste of time and resources!

Remotecontrolatmyside · 04/06/2023 17:55

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 17:52

But we live in the digital age. It’s the future. Better to learn to live with it than see it as an enemy. This is Luddism.

I'm not saying never to use it but many kids use technology far too much and it's detrimental to physical and mental health. We can agree to disagree on this.

Teabab · 04/06/2023 17:55

A balance is probably more sensible. Yes technology is the future, but developing other non digital skills is really valuable- and dare I say to many...enjoyable! I do think as tech takes over the creative industries there'll be a resurgence of fine arts and other things that can only be thought up and made by humans.

Twattergy · 04/06/2023 17:54

I refuse to do homework that is homework for me, not DS. I have a full time job and sorry, its not my homework.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 17:52

But we live in the digital age. It’s the future. Better to learn to live with it than see it as an enemy. This is Luddism.

Remotecontrolatmyside · 04/06/2023 17:51

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 17:48

Why?

My Dd taught herself to draw and paint from YouTube. No drawing bloody Romans on there.
Gaming improves hand/eye co ordination.
Most people use computers instead of handwriting.
My Dd uses her iPad as a drawing tablet.

Texhnology moves forward not back.

Technology is also hugely damaging.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 17:48

Remotecontrolatmyside · 04/06/2023 17:38

Gets them off iPads.
Gets them away from gaming.
Gets them away from YouTube/Netflix/phones
Gets them talking to their family
Gets them using fine motor skills which improves things like handwriting
They might learn a few things about the topic

Yeah complete waste of time 🤔

Why?

My Dd taught herself to draw and paint from YouTube. No drawing bloody Romans on there.
Gaming improves hand/eye co ordination.
Most people use computers instead of handwriting.
My Dd uses her iPad as a drawing tablet.

Texhnology moves forward not back.

Remotecontrolatmyside · 04/06/2023 17:38

Gets them off iPads.
Gets them away from gaming.
Gets them away from YouTube/Netflix/phones
Gets them talking to their family
Gets them using fine motor skills which improves things like handwriting
They might learn a few things about the topic

Yeah complete waste of time 🤔

Wishawisha · 04/06/2023 17:23

We’ve really enjoyed some of the projects but there are too many. It means the projects barely get displayed at school and there is little praise - I know my DC really enjoy it when the projects are included in the school newsletter, the children spend time looking at each other’s work and the teachers make a fuss.. but then when we’ve spent hours and hours doing paper mache and no one really cares because it’s the second at home project in the last 6 weeks it’s totally demoralising.. for them and me..

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 17:22

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow
I think you do have a point. They should have done some similar creative projects in school (at my daughters school they did) so would know some basic skills.
Unfortunatly some parents see crafts as time wasting or "busy work" in school and complain if they do too much. It's sad.

Guizez · 04/06/2023 17:21

My Son’s school has NO homework as a policy. I LOVE it. 😂

DelphiniumBlue · 04/06/2023 17:19

KR2023 · 04/06/2023 14:12

YANBU

complete waste of time. Goes in the recycling at the end of the week term. If it is that important it should be done IN the lesson

Hard for one teacher to supervise and help 30 7 year olds doing this. If it takes you all day to do it with one child, how long would it take for one teacher with 30 children, even if they were happy to use glue gun, scissors, staples etc without adult assistance?
Some children really like doing this sort of activity with their families, and gain a lot from it. Most schools make this sort of holiday project optional, which I think is the way to go.

nahwhale · 04/06/2023 17:19

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 17:15

I wouldn’t expect a fully functioning model. It’s about making it accessible. A longboat is a really difficult shape. Above the level of a y3. So they are never going to be able to do it.

Would a child be given a sheet of random number and letters and be told to make a complex formulae?

Design and art have building blocks and steps just like any other subject. But teachers say ‘just make’. This is why British design graduates all go abroad, and why engineers are highly paid. Because it’s easy innit? Just stick bits together, anyone can do it.

I mean some of the spelling and grammar materials I've seen certainly feel like they might has well have just thrown a quadratic equation at a Y4.

nahwhale · 04/06/2023 17:18

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 17:17

Engineers aren’t highly paid!

Depends what you engineer

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 17:17

Engineers aren’t highly paid!

Choconutty · 04/06/2023 17:15

I facilitate homework, I don't do it.

Teacher/student gets as much as they put into it.

Having said that, I quite enjoy a viking long-boat :) so in this case my kids would probably be beating me away so they could do it themselves :D

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 17:15

I wouldn’t expect a fully functioning model. It’s about making it accessible. A longboat is a really difficult shape. Above the level of a y3. So they are never going to be able to do it.

Would a child be given a sheet of random number and letters and be told to make a complex formulae?

Design and art have building blocks and steps just like any other subject. But teachers say ‘just make’. This is why British design graduates all go abroad, and why engineers are highly paid. Because it’s easy innit? Just stick bits together, anyone can do it.

Needmorelego · 04/06/2023 17:08

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow you must have had an interest in crafty stuff at some point as a child if you went down the designer and then DT teacher path. I can't imagine you just woke up at gcse age and said "I want to be a designer".
How are children meant to develop an interest in something if they don't first experience it at primary school.
A Year 3 teacher will be expecting something vaguely looking like a boat made out of cardboard - not a fully functioning model.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 16:59

CheesyOnion · 04/06/2023 16:54

That's fine though. They learn to add two and two before multiplication, that doesn't mean they're not learning numeracy.

Adding two and two is a building block though. Comes before multiplication.

Teaching construction skills and shape cones before making a king boat.

I would have taught (in school, so they learn the proper skills) a helmet using papier-mâché, with instruction on how to make the horns correctly, a headband, or a shield with relief pattern All doable. My A level classes would have struggled with a longboat.

CheesyOnion · 04/06/2023 16:54

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 16:49

But it wouldn’t look like a Viking long boat. It would look like boxes stuck together. And not the same shape.

So it’s taught them how to stick boxes together. But nothing about shape. And shape is a building block of design. Cardboard boxes aren’t.

That's fine though. They learn to add two and two before multiplication, that doesn't mean they're not learning numeracy.

QueefQueen80s · 04/06/2023 16:53

Our school stopped this just before my first started, thank god! They saw how pointless it was, parents did most of it, so they just set reading every night as homework.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 16:49

CheesyOnion · 04/06/2023 16:46

A 7/8 yo can stick boxes together to make something boatlike and decorate it on their own.

But it wouldn’t look like a Viking long boat. It would look like boxes stuck together. And not the same shape.

So it’s taught them how to stick boxes together. But nothing about shape. And shape is a building block of design. Cardboard boxes aren’t.

CheesyOnion · 04/06/2023 16:46

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 16:36

I doubt a y3 can make a longboat without parental help. So they just get frustrated. It’s ‘teaching’ them nothing.

A 7/8 yo can stick boxes together to make something boatlike and decorate it on their own.

nahwhale · 04/06/2023 16:39

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 04/06/2023 16:29

I spent 19 years as a designer and 25 years as a DT teacher up to A level.

This is not teaching a y3 design skills. The project to build a Viking long boat is way too difficult for y3. They need to know basic construction skills or the standard of attainment will be shite. And then they get upset because it’s not how they wanted it.

This used to do my head in about primary school. Giving impossible art/design projects. My dd once got told to make a musical instrument in y3. Cue child bringing in amazing saxophone covered in tin foil obviuosly made by parent.

I used to ask y7 what they’d done at school. ‘Draw Romans’ or ‘Made a Long boat’ were normal answers. When k asked them what skills they learnt they had no idea. ‘Draw Romans’ 🙄How about a bit of shade, tone, form before we try and draw complex people with no reference?’Make a Viking king boat’ How about teaching card construction or basic 3D modelling in paper before making a complex 3D shape with no basic skills

Used to do my head in. Homeworks way above level of age ability.

Yes! It has to be achievable