Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If they "followed the science" and "got all the big calls right"

81 replies

verdantverdure · 04/06/2023 14:01

And protected the people of Britain, and our economy...

Then Boris Johnson, Rishi Sunak, Matt Hancock and all the Cabinet Ministers of the Conservative government since 2019 have nothing to hide

And can hand over any and all communications to the Covid Inquiry.

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 05/06/2023 10:49

verdantverdure · 05/06/2023 10:19

"Party of fiscal responsibility"

My arse!

LlynTegid · 05/06/2023 10:29

There was one instance where the science (and medical view) was followed, the order of vaccinations and who went first for their vaccine.

I'd say 99% of the big calls they either got wrong or decided too late to have the maximum impact.

I'd be OK with not handing over all phones and information yet, whilst the criminal trials that should take place happen. Corporate manslaughter, corruption, misconduct in a public office, health and safety breaches, for example.

verdantverdure · 05/06/2023 10:19

MrTiddlesTheCat · 04/06/2023 23:07

Yep, £11 billion it cost us.

www.bbc.com/news/business-61754394

"Party of fiscal responsibility"

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 05/06/2023 10:19

If the Covid Inquiry can't achieve anything because it was all unknown then there's even less reason for the British government to refuse to comply with British law and hand over the evidence to the Inquiry they set up.

OP posts:
Sceptic1234 · 05/06/2023 08:49

sleepwouldbenice · 04/06/2023 23:40

Exactly this

I am no fan of the government and really want the enquiry to dig deep and expose the issues

But even on here you can easily see the opposite opinions, united in their hatred of the government but totally opposite views as to what should have happened instead.....

And this is why I think the enquiry will ultimately achieve nothing. As I said above...there was a strand of opinion that the whole deal was overplayed, that chris whitty et al were bumbling left wing technocrats who didnt know there job. There was another strand of opinion that government wasn't doing enough....nobody should be allowed out of the house to meet anyone etc etc etc.

In these days of social media the two camps basically retreated to their own echo chambers.

If you look back on AIDS in the early 80s, many of the same things emerged. HIV denialism was pretty big. The Daily Telegraph opposed the idea that HIV caused AIDS for years. The South African government refused to accept the idea and so refused all aid based on anti retroviral drugs. As far as they were concerned it was all just a conspiracy driven by Western capitalists. That view cost at least 300000 lives. Toby Young's right wing online publication Quillette ran at least one article in 2020 which restated HIV denialism, and maintained that the current epidemic was just another left wing plot.

The obvious difference is that aids occured before social media!

sleepwouldbenice · 04/06/2023 23:40

mauveiscurious · 04/06/2023 21:16

I think the main issue I'm here is we are reflecting on a difficult event in history. At the time there was conflicts of information science snd opinion

Exactly this

I am no fan of the government and really want the enquiry to dig deep and expose the issues

But even on here you can easily see the opposite opinions, united in their hatred of the government but totally opposite views as to what should have happened instead.....

Swrigh1234 · 04/06/2023 23:16

Rishi Sunak is the guy that enabled Johnson to truly tank the economy. The fact that he is now PM shows that lunatics are well and truly in charge of the asylum. The guy is everything you don’t want in a leader - incompetent, technocratic, a puppet on a string. How far the standard of leadership has sunk in this country in 30 years.

MrTiddlesTheCat · 04/06/2023 23:07

Yep, £11 billion it cost us.

www.bbc.com/news/business-61754394

MrTiddlesTheCat · 04/06/2023 23:03

Endlesssummer2022 · 04/06/2023 22:27

This. How anyone can say he was even a decent chancellor is unbelievable. He was criminally incompetent. Let’s not forget he was installed by Dominic Cummings as he was more willing to be a puppet than Savid Jarvid. Rishi was a dreadful chancellor who lost the country more money than Truss/Kwarteng.

Was it Sunak that forgot to pay some insurance bill that cost us millions/billions? I have vague memories of something like that.

Endlesssummer2022 · 04/06/2023 22:27

Kazzyhoward · 04/06/2023 19:38

I expect there's a few smoking guns re Rishi's covid support schemes and the 3 million self employed/freelancers he excluded, then lied about them in Parliament! Then the bounce back loan frauds. Eat out to help out is only the tip of the iceberg with the other Treasury failings during Covid.

This. How anyone can say he was even a decent chancellor is unbelievable. He was criminally incompetent. Let’s not forget he was installed by Dominic Cummings as he was more willing to be a puppet than Savid Jarvid. Rishi was a dreadful chancellor who lost the country more money than Truss/Kwarteng.

Teabab · 04/06/2023 21:50

We know the gov didn't follow the science as the leaked messages from MH said as much. Chris Whitty was thrown under the bus when in reality he said its unreasonable for people to not see their partners etc and to be more balanced, MH said no we can't as people will know we were wrong.

Thesharkradar · 04/06/2023 21:48

Jourdain11 · 04/06/2023 21:22

Too right. And doing 10 tests a day - "why not, they're free?" Hardly free - we're going to all be paying for them for the next decade 😔

AND all the fraudulently claimed money that they cant be bothered to chase, WE have to pay for that😡😡😡
of course they cant be bothered to go after it, it's OUR money that they wasted, we the people at the bottom who do the actual work that keeps the wheels turning and keeps those greedy fuckers at the top of the pyramid.
Not me, not any more I'm a 'late 50's no longer willing to work to generate tax for those cunts' person now

WakeMeUpWhenGoodOmensIsBack · 04/06/2023 21:45

thecatsthecats · 04/06/2023 17:20

Well, to play devil's advocate, I suppose there is how a decision was arrived at, and the discussions that surround it. Say, they did make all the right calls (not saying they did!) but had to have some pretty cold and calculating discussions to reach that point.

E.g. "We can do x which will kill 65% of the over 80s, or we can do y which results in a lower death rate overall but with significantly more long term sick."

There's no nice way to have that debate.

If I were minister, even in a hypothetical government who'd uncannily made all the right decisions entirely unburdened by personal failings, then yes I'd be really worried about having those inevitability brutal cost benefit calculations made public.

But there's no doubt at all that they should be within the scope of the enquiry.

What would be a more legitimate concern would be if a relevant WhatsApp message between cabinet colleagues was followed up by "My God Colleague X is getting on my tits on these committees. Do you think his affair with Colleague Y is going badly and that's why he's such a PITA at the moment?" Or even "I'm sorry I appeared brusque today and was late for the committee start - I think I should tell you that my teenager has just been admitted to an in-patient anorexia facility - it's been a hellish few days."

Dymaxion · 04/06/2023 21:35

They were a bit like the control zones which are in use for bird flu, I presume there is some science involved with those too.

Jourdain11 · 04/06/2023 21:22

Swrigh1234 · 04/06/2023 19:41

This government is corrupt.

It’s not sleaze, nudge nudge, wink wink. It’s pure out and out corruption.

Covid was a gravy train where those in the know made billions. Test and trace, PPE, furlough. All paid for by a trillion pounds of borrowed and printed money.

That said, hysterical stupid people, even on this forum no less, wanted more Covid restrictions. They wanted more lockdowns, more spending, more draconian measures against a virus which for the majority was not even harmful, let alone fatal. Well, you got what you wanted. Now enjoy paying it back, with double digit inflation and sky high taxation.

Too right. And doing 10 tests a day - "why not, they're free?" Hardly free - we're going to all be paying for them for the next decade 😔

mauveiscurious · 04/06/2023 21:16

I think the main issue I'm here is we are reflecting on a difficult event in history. At the time there was conflicts of information science snd opinion

munchbunch12 · 04/06/2023 20:54

@Sceptic1234 they were 'tiers' which had many people in tears! I was in a tier where everythnig was closed, but within walking distance of one where pubs, cafes and 'non essential' shops were still open.

Dymaxion · 04/06/2023 20:46

The Cabinet Office refused to disclose some of the material by arguing it was not relevant to the inquiry, it would compromise ministers' right to privacy, and would set a precedent that could prevent ministers discussing policy matters in future.

Interesting paragraph from the news, how would it compromise ministers rights to privacy ? Are they asking for work phone messages or personal phone messages ?

Sceptic1234 · 04/06/2023 20:45

BogRollBOGOF · 04/06/2023 20:35

There were vast quantities of damaging illogical rules and guidence that defied the known science of the time, particularly by autumn 2020 onwards where there was a fair amount known about the virus, who was vulnerable and how it spread. Stupid rules like two households exceeding 6 not being able to meet outside, even though it was considerably safer than 6 people meeting in a pub. Children spending vast tracts of a year being unable to meet with children beyond their household, and often prohibited from going to school. Now we see the consequences in delayed development and difficult behaviours, and there's no support to mitigate it.

Aside from corruption, profiteering and respect for the consequences of their decisions on the population, so, so many decisions were never about science and managing viral spread.

And the bizarre grading system....cant remember what they were called. Different rules in different regions....no body knew what they were supposed to be doing. I was pretty confused anyway. I could actually cycle to a location where pubs were open....

thebellagio · 04/06/2023 20:41

What irritates me beyond belief is that of all people, Rishi Sunak knows who recieved fradulant billions of pounds of taxpayer cash. He signed the fucking cheques. Yet they don’t seem to be doing anything to recover that lost money. Money which could have paid for the pay rises needed by schools and hospitals across the uk.

as someone who has part of the excluded freelancers, I will NEVER EVER forget being told by this government that I wasn’t deserving of any financial support despite being newly self employed and ten days away from filing a tax return.

BogRollBOGOF · 04/06/2023 20:35

There were vast quantities of damaging illogical rules and guidence that defied the known science of the time, particularly by autumn 2020 onwards where there was a fair amount known about the virus, who was vulnerable and how it spread. Stupid rules like two households exceeding 6 not being able to meet outside, even though it was considerably safer than 6 people meeting in a pub. Children spending vast tracts of a year being unable to meet with children beyond their household, and often prohibited from going to school. Now we see the consequences in delayed development and difficult behaviours, and there's no support to mitigate it.

Aside from corruption, profiteering and respect for the consequences of their decisions on the population, so, so many decisions were never about science and managing viral spread.

cakeorwine · 04/06/2023 20:29

I think they are using the Human Rights Act as part of the right to privacy to fight this.

Which is so ironic

verdantverdure · 04/06/2023 20:26

Imagine messages from Whitty saying this is absolute madness and will lead to thousands of deaths and Sunak dismissing him as it's a price he's willing to let others pay, then Johnson piping up to hilariously point out it'd sort out the social care crisis.

I can imagine something like that all too well

OP posts:
TheThinkingGoblin · 04/06/2023 20:19

Swrigh1234 · 04/06/2023 19:41

This government is corrupt.

It’s not sleaze, nudge nudge, wink wink. It’s pure out and out corruption.

Covid was a gravy train where those in the know made billions. Test and trace, PPE, furlough. All paid for by a trillion pounds of borrowed and printed money.

That said, hysterical stupid people, even on this forum no less, wanted more Covid restrictions. They wanted more lockdowns, more spending, more draconian measures against a virus which for the majority was not even harmful, let alone fatal. Well, you got what you wanted. Now enjoy paying it back, with double digit inflation and sky high taxation.

Covid was indeed a "gravy grain" due to instutionalised UK corruption.

But that does not change the realities on the ground as it pertains to the epidemiological impacts (mortality and morbidity) on the UK population due to covid-19.

The "two" are not the same thing.

We have a corrupt Govt in the UK, but we still have world class objective scientists in the aggregate sense. They were absolutely correct in their views about the pandemic situation.

sleepwouldbenice · 04/06/2023 20:10

Swrigh1234 · 04/06/2023 19:41

This government is corrupt.

It’s not sleaze, nudge nudge, wink wink. It’s pure out and out corruption.

Covid was a gravy train where those in the know made billions. Test and trace, PPE, furlough. All paid for by a trillion pounds of borrowed and printed money.

That said, hysterical stupid people, even on this forum no less, wanted more Covid restrictions. They wanted more lockdowns, more spending, more draconian measures against a virus which for the majority was not even harmful, let alone fatal. Well, you got what you wanted. Now enjoy paying it back, with double digit inflation and sky high taxation.

Yawn