Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If they "followed the science" and "got all the big calls right"

81 replies

verdantverdure · 04/06/2023 14:01

And protected the people of Britain, and our economy...

Then Boris Johnson, Rishi Sunak, Matt Hancock and all the Cabinet Ministers of the Conservative government since 2019 have nothing to hide

And can hand over any and all communications to the Covid Inquiry.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
StormShadow · 05/06/2023 16:26

GasPanic · 05/06/2023 16:19

Yes.

But I suspect if you asked people what they thought the current crop of politicians, be they Labour, Tories or Liberals not many people would think those candidates were up to much.

So there's the rub. Make being a politician a crap job with a crap quality of life.

Get crap people. Or at the very minimum get people with significant ulterior motives.

You can't possibly think reducing the level of scrutiny would do anything to prevent people with ulterior motives from wanting the job, though? And we'd have shitter mechanisms to identify when they acted on those motives.

GasPanic · 05/06/2023 16:19

StormShadow · 05/06/2023 15:35

Yet there's still no shortage of applicants.

Yes.

But I suspect if you asked people what they thought the current crop of politicians, be they Labour, Tories or Liberals not many people would think those candidates were up to much.

So there's the rub. Make being a politician a crap job with a crap quality of life.

Get crap people. Or at the very minimum get people with significant ulterior motives.

StormShadow · 05/06/2023 16:04

I think the conduct of those in government and whether lockdown was ultimately the best option are two different, albeit overlapping questions, and would benefit from separate enquiries.

Because the first lockdown at least was politically inevitable. And while we knew full well what a lot of the downsides would be in March 2020, despite lots of claims otherwise whenever this topic comes up, what we didn't know was whether they'd outweigh the benefits. Additionally, we actually aren't in a position to answer that question yet, and won't be for a long time. A lot of the longer term consequences, of restrictions in particular, haven't happened yet.

Whereas ministerial conduct is something we do need to be discussing now, while they're still in power. Things like corruption in procurement and the impact of Partygate should be hashed out asap, so people have as much of the information as possible before the next general election. And those things aren't actually affected by whether one thinks lockdown was the right policy or not.

KnittedCardi · 05/06/2023 15:51

Sceptic1234 · 05/06/2023 14:57

Where is this? I cant find anything but the one that came out early in 2022.

Sorry, slight misdirect. One of the authors of this is associated with John Hopkins. Here is the link: iea.org.uk/media/lockdowns-were-a-costly-failure-finds-new-iea-book/

verdantverdure · 05/06/2023 15:38

"Straining every sinew"

How could I forget that one?!

OP posts:
StormShadow · 05/06/2023 15:35

GasPanic · 05/06/2023 15:07

Not sure that it would actually be for anyone given how little they are paid and that at every point in time they are one utterance or text away from ending their career.

Yet there's still no shortage of applicants.

GasPanic · 05/06/2023 15:07

StormShadow · 05/06/2023 13:35

Not sure I would want to live my work life in a goldfish bowl where every decision I took, everything I did was scrutinised to the nth degree.

Being in government probably isn't for you then.

Not sure that it would actually be for anyone given how little they are paid and that at every point in time they are one utterance or text away from ending their career.

Sceptic1234 · 05/06/2023 14:57

KnittedCardi · 05/06/2023 14:07

Following the science is now under debate though. John Hopkins has just completed a meta analysis of the worldwide responses to COVID. The unfortunate truth is that lockdowns didn't work, didn't reduce deaths, and that the costs to the economy, our childrens education, mental wellbeing, and to general health outcomed, will last a generation. Fab.

Where is this? I cant find anything but the one that came out early in 2022.

verdantverdure · 05/06/2023 14:53

Everanewbie · 05/06/2023 14:40

I'd like to know what the plan was from May - November 2020. Apparently, a vaccine was way off, were they just hoping something would turn up?

My suspicion is that they knew a vaccine was likely ahead of where the admitted publicly, that would have been the only justification for restrictions in that period.

The Matt Hancock whatsapps seem to show that the government were more worried about being seen to be doing something than actually doing something.

The Nightingales were the ultimate in "being sen to be doing something"

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 05/06/2023 14:43

Jaxhog · 05/06/2023 14:29

BTW, I would be in favour of a COVID enquiry - if, and only if, it was to learn what we could do better next time - NOT if all it does is assign blame. Which, sadly, this enquiry will.

Responsibility

Accountability

Transparency

Not "blame".

OP posts:
Everanewbie · 05/06/2023 14:40

I'd like to know what the plan was from May - November 2020. Apparently, a vaccine was way off, were they just hoping something would turn up?

My suspicion is that they knew a vaccine was likely ahead of where the admitted publicly, that would have been the only justification for restrictions in that period.

The Matt Hancock whatsapps seem to show that the government were more worried about being seen to be doing something than actually doing something.

StormShadow · 05/06/2023 14:30

Jaxhog · 05/06/2023 14:25

The trouble is that most people have no idea how hard it is to run a country! Politicians are humans and humans make mistakes. Sadly, in our social media-biased world, anything can be taken out of context, blown up, and presented as 'the truth'. No wonder they want to keep some of their conversations private.

Again though, people who feel like this aren't suited to being in government. We have legal requirements about scrutiny, openness and disclosure. Which despite some of the dafter arguments otherwise, are a good thing. They're not optional. It's fucking ludicrous to argue that people are right to ignore their legal obligations after the fact because they've decided the rules shouldn't apply to them.

Jaxhog · 05/06/2023 14:29

BTW, I would be in favour of a COVID enquiry - if, and only if, it was to learn what we could do better next time - NOT if all it does is assign blame. Which, sadly, this enquiry will.

Jaxhog · 05/06/2023 14:25

The trouble is that most people have no idea how hard it is to run a country! Politicians are humans and humans make mistakes. Sadly, in our social media-biased world, anything can be taken out of context, blown up, and presented as 'the truth'. No wonder they want to keep some of their conversations private.

Swrigh1234 · 05/06/2023 14:19

KnittedCardi · 05/06/2023 14:07

Following the science is now under debate though. John Hopkins has just completed a meta analysis of the worldwide responses to COVID. The unfortunate truth is that lockdowns didn't work, didn't reduce deaths, and that the costs to the economy, our childrens education, mental wellbeing, and to general health outcomed, will last a generation. Fab.

Yet anyone who questioned the efficacy of lockdowns back then or even until recently was labelled a conspiracy theorist.

Because the science was wrong. Or misused. Perhaps people should remember that on the next topic where they are told to follow the science.

KnittedCardi · 05/06/2023 14:07

Following the science is now under debate though. John Hopkins has just completed a meta analysis of the worldwide responses to COVID. The unfortunate truth is that lockdowns didn't work, didn't reduce deaths, and that the costs to the economy, our childrens education, mental wellbeing, and to general health outcomed, will last a generation. Fab.

Thesharkradar · 05/06/2023 13:45

StormShadow · 05/06/2023 13:35

Not sure I would want to live my work life in a goldfish bowl where every decision I took, everything I did was scrutinised to the nth degree.

Being in government probably isn't for you then.

I agree!
Power corrupts, people who seek it and people who have it are extremely prone to behaving corruptly and therefore need to be scrutinized constantly.
We should take it as a given that those who have wealth and power will do whatever they can get away with to hold on to and further that wealth and power- therefore they need to be constantly under the spotlight 🔦

StormShadow · 05/06/2023 13:35

Not sure I would want to live my work life in a goldfish bowl where every decision I took, everything I did was scrutinised to the nth degree.

Being in government probably isn't for you then.

GasPanic · 05/06/2023 13:33

Not sure I would want to live my work life in a goldfish bowl where every decision I took, everything I did was scrutinised to the nth degree.

But this seems to be the kind of society we are moving to.

What it will do is hamper peoples ability to operate, to the point that their output is far lower, because they will spend 90% of the time thinking about how stuff they say in private might actually be used against them, and 10% of the time actually dealing with the problem at hand.

So basically, if we want politicians to be more self serving, more grey, more constant arse covering, more unwilling to take any sort of position other than a completely neutral one, this is exactly the way to go about doing it.

EmmaEmerald · 05/06/2023 13:25

These are the ONS Covid death figures for the summer period

https://www.ons.gov.uk/aboutus/transparencyandgovernance/freedomofinformationfoi/covid19deathsresultingfromtheeatouttohelpoutscheme

Swrigh1234 · 05/06/2023 13:23

When someone says ‘follow the science’, just check what other science they are into. Usually these same patronizing, condescending proponents of ‘the science’ are the ones who also believe that women can have a penis.

StormShadow · 05/06/2023 13:16

Are they still using the phrase 'followed the science' now? That alone is reason for them all to lose their seats at the next GE, frankly. There was never one unified 'the science' when it came to covid, couldn't possibly be, because pandemic management inherently involves value judgements about who and what to prioritise.

Either way though you're obviously right about the messages OP. The bit about privacy concerns is particularly pathetic. If politicians are worried about that, they shouldn't conduct government business on their personal What's Apps.

verdantverdure · 05/06/2023 13:15

I'd be surprised if anybody was in favour of bypassing established providers to give inflated contracts for testing and PPE to mates of the government in return for substandard goods and services.

I think almost everyone would agree on that.

Profiteering in a pandemic is never a good look, but the fact that it materially affected the country's pandemic response, and caused more lives to be lost is a whole extra layer of wrongness.

All but the most partisan supporters of the government must agree, surely?

OP posts:
verdantverdure · 05/06/2023 13:09

@TooBigForMyBoots GrinGrin

OP posts: