Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Universal basic income and what it may look like

534 replies

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 09:54

I've been thinking for a while about the criticism of UBI and I think it's due to people not being able to imagine the government trying to 'match' peoples wages. In my opinion, it never will but there will be alternatives to what we have now, which will be able to offer something better.

So say the UBI is £1000 a month for a single person.
We could change the housing market to allow much more public housing with rents set at an affordable level, much more stability, no private landlords and the option to customise/ change your home. Let's face it, home ownership is out of reach for the majority at present. I don't find people are dying to own their own homes but desperate to be out of the instability of the private rental market, out of parents houses, out of house shares etc. If you could offer the next best thing to owning your own house, I think people would go for it.
There would be much more community linked to people having extra time due to not working or not working as many hours. Now, not having enough to do in the day is bad but most people have these huge dreams for retirement and this would just allow them to do some of these things now instead. Also more volunteering, looking after elderly relatives etc.
I don't think that private car ownership would be a thing. There would be a big system like Uber who you could call rides on. There would be a cheaper option, say if ten people wanted to go to the city centre at the same time, they would have to walk to a hub and then the van would pick everyone up, like public transport but based on demand. It would be a status symbol to be able to call a car out just for you.
I think a lot more people would wfh getting the cost of transport and childcare down. Schools might even go remote, as there wouldn't be both parents working and so in theory they could help facilitate the lessons. Then teachers would have small classes of Sen kids like mine, key workers and vulnerable children. Kids would interact with others through volunteering groups with parents, or just playing out as there would be less cars and more parents around to keep an eye on them.
People will either hate this vision as it's so different to what we have now. Or they will like some parts. But what we have now can't continue.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
PhoenixArisen · 05/06/2023 13:43

@Swrigh1234
This is my total nightmare.
Dumbed down society. Nothing but reality tv on tv. All libraries shut and only rewritten ebooks available. Escape into the meta verse from your poxy box room.
The trajectory is there but surely it won't ever happen 😬

Swrigh1234 · 05/06/2023 13:30

PhoenixArisen · 05/06/2023 13:27

No they wouldn't, they would cut them. Why pay higher wages when the government is providing enough to live on? Just like tax credits encouraged employers to pay poverty wages

What would be the point of anyone getting an education, training and work?

There wouldn’t. That’s the thing. It’s another way to dumb down society and have the plebs known their place. Living in their small worlds, in virtual isolation, relying on handouts, never aspiring to anything, never questioning anything.

When you make people dependent on handouts to survive, they stop asking questions. You take their agency away from them.

PhoenixArisen · 05/06/2023 13:27

No they wouldn't, they would cut them. Why pay higher wages when the government is providing enough to live on? Just like tax credits encouraged employers to pay poverty wages

What would be the point of anyone getting an education, training and work?

Swrigh1234 · 05/06/2023 13:14

If UBI is so great, why did Finland scrap it?

Rasputina · 05/06/2023 12:19

They’re going to be discussing this on Today’s Politics Live shortly.

DdraigGoch · 05/06/2023 10:59

porkpiesinthepark · 05/06/2023 08:07

Just for reference I earn £1,450 as a full time mental health worker so they would have to raise wages if UBI was set at 1,600

No they wouldn't, they would cut them. Why pay higher wages when the government is providing enough to live on? Just like tax credits encouraged employers to pay poverty wages.

DdraigGoch · 05/06/2023 10:56

Kazzyhoward · 05/06/2023 07:58

I agree, along with scrapping of NICs.

Probably end up with a flat rate of income tax. Say 50% of everything earned beyond the UBI?

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 10:30

Freshfoods · 05/06/2023 09:39

I hadn't realized it was only 30 people. That's not nearly enough to gather useful data. I thought it was everyone in those areas. The article says that no-one should have to choose between heating and eating, but it looks like very many people will have to continue doing just that.
How disappointing. Naively, I thought it might be the beginning of a fairer society!

that would be really fun if it was everyone in east finchley! there is a house down my road (5 bedrooms admittedly) which is now listed at £1.9 million!

Not to mention the people who live in bishops avenue (its mostly empty but i think some of the apartments and houses are occupied). There are also some adjacent roads with higher occupancy rates, and the houses are all in the millions. Its a diverse area but I love living there as i feel like everyone gets along regardless.

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 10:28

I live in East Finchley (the other area where they are trialling UBI) and my mortgage is £1020 for a 2 bed flat. It costs around £1700 to rent my flat privately.

I think it would be really interesting to see the results.

I support UBI but think it needs to be pegged to local costs.

As for the OP's suggestion that there should be more public housing, we could fund it by having a state building company who would sell garden maisonettes and apartments to middle income earners (as well as having a set proportion set aside for lower income earners). The middle income earners would pay 25% below market rate but then they can only sell onto other middle income earners for the next 70 years. There would be income thresholds based on local wages i.e. £120k and below in London, £50k and below in the north.

Freshfoods · 05/06/2023 09:39

I hadn't realized it was only 30 people. That's not nearly enough to gather useful data. I thought it was everyone in those areas. The article says that no-one should have to choose between heating and eating, but it looks like very many people will have to continue doing just that.
How disappointing. Naively, I thought it might be the beginning of a fairer society!

HighlandCowbag · 05/06/2023 08:21

Ive literally just done an exam on this! As well as private vs state education, it's like MN knows my course.

I started the UBI topic think what a load of bollocks, get a load of 'Lazy Joes' who won't work while the rest of us graft to pay for them. However, the main benefit I can see is that companies will be forced to improve labour conditions in order to recruit staff. Which can never be a bad thing. As well as that, if we worry about reciprocity (ie people who don't work but benefit from society chipping in), then we should also worry about other free loaders who benefit from unpaid labour. This includes men who have domestic work done for them by women, people who benefit from volunteering but never volunteer themselves, the millions of ours of unpaid care that happens that saves society money and the 'cheap' labour like domiciliary care society benefits enormously from.

OneFrenchEgg · 05/06/2023 08:21

I'm guessing the pilot is with people not working and replaced other benefits? I couldn't tell when I read it yesterday.

Write2023 · 05/06/2023 08:20

Hyperinflation will make money redundant in a few hundred years resources will be the bartering tool of the future.

SunnyEgg · 05/06/2023 08:18

I’m not sure what the trial is testing for but if it’s temporary it’ll be more a boost to current lifestyle than showing long term change

Would cheaper towns be where people live if they prefer not to work, how does that pan out with social behaviour - good or bad?

Would people quit work

Beezknees · 05/06/2023 08:17

BarbaraofSeville · 05/06/2023 08:02

£1600 pm would provide a comfortable standard of living to many people, eg if it's per person and they're a two adult household unless they have multiple DC, or even for a single homeowner with no mortgage. It's more than many pensioners have. It's also more than NMW for full time work.

That pilot talks about studying the effect on mental health. I can see lots of potential positives if people use the time to study, undertake modestly priced hobbies or activities, or start a business without the pressure to bring in an income.

The main downside I can see is if people want to spend time undertaking expensive leisure activities/shopping, and find that the money doesn't go far if you are of a 'champagne tastes on a lemonade budget' mindset.

It would be terrible for single parents with more than one child though and could mean a lot of women forced to stay in abusive relationships.

IncomingTraffic · 05/06/2023 08:15

£1600 for a single person in jarrow is definitely going to be comfortable. Jarrow is an extremely cheap place to live.

Although if everyone got £1600 as a starting point (which would cost something approaching half of the current uk GDP in itself), then it certainly would not be extremely cheap to live anywhere in the country.

Unless you decide to do away with capitalism and go with the planned economy thing instead. Because there are no national examples where that hasn’t turned out to be utopia.

porkpiesinthepark · 05/06/2023 08:14

@110APiccadilly I don't think it will become good enough, no, I think we won't have a choice

OP posts:
110APiccadilly · 05/06/2023 08:13

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 10:23

@Theunamedcat you would have to get your shopping delivered, there would be no option to go into an actual grocery shop.

And when the shopping delivery AI had done a completely unsuitable substitution, say, follow on milk instead of formula, and you can't get into a shop to get any formula, and the AI at the customer service centre says, "This item was replaced from our acceptable list of substitutes. To repeat your order, press 1," what do you do then?

I'm sure you'll say that the AI will be good enough that this will never happen, but frankly I don't believe that.

porkpiesinthepark · 05/06/2023 08:07

Just for reference I earn £1,450 as a full time mental health worker so they would have to raise wages if UBI was set at 1,600

OP posts:
porkpiesinthepark · 05/06/2023 08:05

Ok so the plus side could be that £1600 in Jarrow will get you way more than it would in the SE so people won't have to move out of their hometowns unless they want to. More wealth distribution. More people living outside of the main areas of industry starting businesses and studying thanks to UBI.
The downside would be a lack of incentive to work, as mentioned by PP. I'm a firm believer that people want to work generally but if something doesn't happen to make childcare more available / cheaper then will people won't.
I also have a fear that UBI is the preparation for mass unemployment and that women will be expected to be the ones to give up their jobs, stay home and get UBI to leave more jobs out there for the men.

OP posts:
ZZpop · 05/06/2023 08:04

Those who cannot work will be worse off under UBI with severely disabled people ie the most vulnerable coming off the worst.

BarbaraofSeville · 05/06/2023 08:02

IncomingTraffic · 05/06/2023 07:53

£1600 a month. 30 people. A £1.15million budget for paying them for 2 years. 30 people.

Of course the people of central Jarrow thought that sounded like something they’d love to get involved in when they knocked on doors and asked people on Jobseeker’s Allowance if they’d rather get £1600 a months for 2 years. Jobseekers plus LHA is nowhere near that in jarrow.

£1600 pm would provide a comfortable standard of living to many people, eg if it's per person and they're a two adult household unless they have multiple DC, or even for a single homeowner with no mortgage. It's more than many pensioners have. It's also more than NMW for full time work.

That pilot talks about studying the effect on mental health. I can see lots of potential positives if people use the time to study, undertake modestly priced hobbies or activities, or start a business without the pressure to bring in an income.

The main downside I can see is if people want to spend time undertaking expensive leisure activities/shopping, and find that the money doesn't go far if you are of a 'champagne tastes on a lemonade budget' mindset.

ClaireandTed · 05/06/2023 07:59

Write2023 · 05/06/2023 07:56

I think they have this in a Middle East oil rich country for their native born. The model only works because they have slave wages and conditions for immigrants.

I believe the World’s resources will greatly diminish over the next couple of hundred years and society as we know it will be no longer.

I was thinking about this yesterday, I'm sure I saw a documentary about it but couldn't remember which country?

But yes they basically 'imported' workers from other countries to do all the jobs they didn't want to.

Kazzyhoward · 05/06/2023 07:58

EffortlessDesmond · 04/06/2023 20:35

Apologies if this has been said before, but any UBI must come hand-in-hand with the removal of ALL tax credits and a much flatter income tax regime.

I agree, along with scrapping of NICs.

Write2023 · 05/06/2023 07:56

I think they have this in a Middle East oil rich country for their native born. The model only works because they have slave wages and conditions for immigrants.

I believe the World’s resources will greatly diminish over the next couple of hundred years and society as we know it will be no longer.

Swipe left for the next trending thread