Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Universal basic income and what it may look like

534 replies

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 09:54

I've been thinking for a while about the criticism of UBI and I think it's due to people not being able to imagine the government trying to 'match' peoples wages. In my opinion, it never will but there will be alternatives to what we have now, which will be able to offer something better.

So say the UBI is £1000 a month for a single person.
We could change the housing market to allow much more public housing with rents set at an affordable level, much more stability, no private landlords and the option to customise/ change your home. Let's face it, home ownership is out of reach for the majority at present. I don't find people are dying to own their own homes but desperate to be out of the instability of the private rental market, out of parents houses, out of house shares etc. If you could offer the next best thing to owning your own house, I think people would go for it.
There would be much more community linked to people having extra time due to not working or not working as many hours. Now, not having enough to do in the day is bad but most people have these huge dreams for retirement and this would just allow them to do some of these things now instead. Also more volunteering, looking after elderly relatives etc.
I don't think that private car ownership would be a thing. There would be a big system like Uber who you could call rides on. There would be a cheaper option, say if ten people wanted to go to the city centre at the same time, they would have to walk to a hub and then the van would pick everyone up, like public transport but based on demand. It would be a status symbol to be able to call a car out just for you.
I think a lot more people would wfh getting the cost of transport and childcare down. Schools might even go remote, as there wouldn't be both parents working and so in theory they could help facilitate the lessons. Then teachers would have small classes of Sen kids like mine, key workers and vulnerable children. Kids would interact with others through volunteering groups with parents, or just playing out as there would be less cars and more parents around to keep an eye on them.
People will either hate this vision as it's so different to what we have now. Or they will like some parts. But what we have now can't continue.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Florenz · 05/06/2023 23:14

Maybe children could learn in a virtual reality environment so it would like they'd be at school without there actually having to be a school.

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 23:12

Swrigh1234 · 05/06/2023 22:49

You think UBI is the answer to inequality?

Where have you been for the last 15 years while the level of free money being thrown around at the unproductive has grown while asset prices skyrocketed and the concentration of asset ownership consolidated at the top?

The mind boggles.

Actually there was a lot more free money being thrown at the rich due to low interest rates which meant asset prices skyrocketed.

The economy didn't grow which meant wages at the bottom and middle stagnated.

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 23:10

JuvenileEmu · 05/06/2023 23:01

FFS, having an after tax monthly income of £6500 is very far from poor, even in London. Get a grip. Obviously it's less than the super rich have.. everyone has less than someone. If you want social housing, I suggest you change your job to a minimum wage one, and who knows, your dream may come true Hmm.

I am actually contemplating buying ex social housing and it is my second stepper property i.e.. i had to overpay mortgage for 4 years by at least £1000 per month to get to this point.

The person selling it is definitely on at least £200k (it was her FTB flat).

It's a bit ridiculous that we are the ones paying private market prices for it though. And market is inflated due to housing being seen as an asset rather than a roof over one's head. There should be two markets- one for speculation and another for function. That's all i am trying to say. For medical care in the uk, there is functional healthcare (NHS) and luxury healthcare (private with all the bells and whistles). There should be such a distinction for housing.

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 23:01

DdraigGoch · 05/06/2023 22:29

Excuse me - I'm on a lot less than £150k (I'm low enough to be just below the 40p threshold). I'm not poor. Far from it. I'm very comfortable.

Are you suggesting that - under your proposal - if I was selling up and someone from London was downsizing for retirement that they wouldn't be allowed to buy it because they've got too much wealth?

I don't actually care about "profit" in housing. I do however care about having the freedom to live how I choose, in my small, pokey, 200 year old quaryman's cottage with a garden.

Well the £150k threshold is for London (as that is where i live). If your area is cheaper, threshold should probably be £75k household income...

And your home is private anyway, this is for the homes owned and built by the state. And the state should probably use this opportunity in the upcoming housing price crash to purchase more properties that can be repurposed for state housing. As many people would not be able to afford their mortgages.

Downsizing is an interesting question. In my home country, my dad wanted to buy government flats for my grandparents in cash and would have been allowed to because my grandfather only had a teacher's pension. It would have been a good investment for him and he was planning to purchase it in their names as well as that of myself and my sister so that we could own a home in our teens and always have a place to go back to. In hindsight it was probably a good thing it didn't work out (couldn't manage to find one in the area my dad wanted and also my grandparents deteriorated fairly quickly) as me owning a property overseas would have had implications on stamp duty relief when i finally bought in London years later. But it would have been a good option for them as it would have been more suitable for elderly living and nearer facilities. My point is that i think most elderly downsizers would probably be able to qualify as most pensions are usually less than PAYE pay.

The income threshold is meant to guard against landlords and investors buying state subsidized properties as that is where most of the RTB properties landed up.

You have the freedom to buy whatever property you wish. But at the same time, you have far less buying power than many people..this means that while you can safeguard your ownership rights for now, it is not guaranteed. There are people selling their homes to pay for healthcare treatment because NHS is underfunded. Right now..On an income of £40k can you afford £100k medical bills in your old age? Probably not. So if you sell your house to pay for medical bills and there is no subsidized government housing, where will you go? This is why we need to have a robust welfare state because in an unequal world, there are a myriad of ways poorer people can lose their assets. Healthcare, care costs, inflation, you don't need to be creative to imagine it..

We talk about welfare for the poor, but in this age, we need welfare for the ex middle classes as well..

JuvenileEmu · 05/06/2023 23:01

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 20:50

What is wrong with being poor? At least I know where I stand and I am also very motivated to improve our situation in life..being poor in London isn't the same as being poor in the third world- we are poor and own our 2 bed flat, we have overseas holidays, we eat out regularly. So we have a comfortable life (for now).

But what makes us 'poor' is that my DH and mine combined after tax earnings of £6500 per month- it is less than the interest on the savings accounts of multi millionaires. And even if our combined income was £200k, it would still be less..and there are more and more multi millionaires-globally they are a growing number.

And this makes us vulnerable because unless we increase our income steadily, our earning power would diminish every year. So we need to aggressively pursue that next promotion, that next pay raise with absolute single mindedness or will just get poorer and poorer.

I put the figure at £150k because HSBC premier banking criteria is £75k so double that (for husband and wife ) is £150k..I think that at that level you are at least fledging middle class so would probably be ok..I think we are on the cusp of ok to be honest but at the same time at 10% inflation...

FFS, having an after tax monthly income of £6500 is very far from poor, even in London. Get a grip. Obviously it's less than the super rich have.. everyone has less than someone. If you want social housing, I suggest you change your job to a minimum wage one, and who knows, your dream may come true Hmm.

Swrigh1234 · 05/06/2023 22:49

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 21:45

It doesn't need to be 'government allocated'. It can be government built and government subsidized but with caveats that you can only sell it on to people who are poor like you i.e..income of below £150k.. that's quite a large segment of the population so selling would probably not be an issue though of course it would not be as profitable. But Homes are for living in, not for profit.

The alternative is that your child will end up sharing a room with 8 other people because they only can get work on zero hours contract (AI meaning that the only people who can get jobs are those with the relevant skills/top 5% of the cohort) and because housing is so scarce (as the only properties that are built are for the children of rich people and there is a general shortage of housing).

UBI is a response to the extreme inequality that we would face in a decade or so, social researchers know this and so are already preparing for it.

You think UBI is the answer to inequality?

Where have you been for the last 15 years while the level of free money being thrown around at the unproductive has grown while asset prices skyrocketed and the concentration of asset ownership consolidated at the top?

The mind boggles.

Swrigh1234 · 05/06/2023 22:45

StarDolphins · 05/06/2023 21:38

Who would think children learning remotely is a good thing? Social skills & being with their peers are just as important as the academic side.

I would never ever be happy for my child to be at home all day.

The sheer idiocy of the idea is astounding. It’s like some people lack basic observation skills as well as comprehension. Maybe they just hibernated through lockdown and missed the colossal harm done to an entire generation of children as result of school closures and ‘home learning’.

DdraigGoch · 05/06/2023 22:29

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 21:45

It doesn't need to be 'government allocated'. It can be government built and government subsidized but with caveats that you can only sell it on to people who are poor like you i.e..income of below £150k.. that's quite a large segment of the population so selling would probably not be an issue though of course it would not be as profitable. But Homes are for living in, not for profit.

The alternative is that your child will end up sharing a room with 8 other people because they only can get work on zero hours contract (AI meaning that the only people who can get jobs are those with the relevant skills/top 5% of the cohort) and because housing is so scarce (as the only properties that are built are for the children of rich people and there is a general shortage of housing).

UBI is a response to the extreme inequality that we would face in a decade or so, social researchers know this and so are already preparing for it.

Excuse me - I'm on a lot less than £150k (I'm low enough to be just below the 40p threshold). I'm not poor. Far from it. I'm very comfortable.

Are you suggesting that - under your proposal - if I was selling up and someone from London was downsizing for retirement that they wouldn't be allowed to buy it because they've got too much wealth?

I don't actually care about "profit" in housing. I do however care about having the freedom to live how I choose, in my small, pokey, 200 year old quaryman's cottage with a garden.

SunnyEgg · 05/06/2023 22:20

StarDolphins · 05/06/2023 21:38

Who would think children learning remotely is a good thing? Social skills & being with their peers are just as important as the academic side.

I would never ever be happy for my child to be at home all day.

Yep. We already tried that, it was bad.

Probably some who liked it on here but no thanks

DdraigGoch · 05/06/2023 22:18

StarDolphins · 05/06/2023 21:38

Who would think children learning remotely is a good thing? Social skills & being with their peers are just as important as the academic side.

I would never ever be happy for my child to be at home all day.

The same people who think that cheese is an acceptable substitute for milk in coffee.

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 21:45

DdraigGoch · 05/06/2023 21:34

Or maybe that we want choice. I chose what house I bought. I can make what changes I like to it (within reason).

I don't want some miserable grey flat allocated to me, where some government official has decided that because I have no kids (yet) I have no need for more than a single room with no garden.

Just like I'm not accepting your dystopia where I can't walk into a shop, instead having to accept whatever has come in the weekly delivery - doubtless with some iffy substitutions if I even get any choice at all, not to mention that the only possible time it'll arrive will be when I'm in work.

Oh hang on, you want to abolish work too, so I'll be stuck staring at the walls in that government-allocated flat, eating my government-specified food rations (which I bet won't include bacon), no leisure activities left to enjoy, with all purpose in life sapped from me.

It doesn't need to be 'government allocated'. It can be government built and government subsidized but with caveats that you can only sell it on to people who are poor like you i.e..income of below £150k.. that's quite a large segment of the population so selling would probably not be an issue though of course it would not be as profitable. But Homes are for living in, not for profit.

The alternative is that your child will end up sharing a room with 8 other people because they only can get work on zero hours contract (AI meaning that the only people who can get jobs are those with the relevant skills/top 5% of the cohort) and because housing is so scarce (as the only properties that are built are for the children of rich people and there is a general shortage of housing).

UBI is a response to the extreme inequality that we would face in a decade or so, social researchers know this and so are already preparing for it.

StarDolphins · 05/06/2023 21:38

Who would think children learning remotely is a good thing? Social skills & being with their peers are just as important as the academic side.

I would never ever be happy for my child to be at home all day.

SunnyEgg · 05/06/2023 21:37

Based on knowing job and lifestyle, not doubling up on jobs. Holidays are often enough and it’s usually after school club not free childcare. I don’t know anyone that has that regularly.

DdraigGoch · 05/06/2023 21:34

porkpiesinthepark · 05/06/2023 17:27

I think we'd have to examine the reasons why people want to own a house. Is it the security? You arguably have more security in a council house as it would still be yours if you lose your job or ill health means you can't work. If your relationship turns abusive, you can kick your partner out and the likelihood that the council will look favourably on the abused/ main caregiver. Whilst a lot of women who live with men who are the main breadwinners find themselves unable to kick their spouse out.

Is it to leave something to your children? Well most of my elderly relatives have had to sell their houses to pay for care.

Is it to feel that you've 'made it'. Well my European relatives are much better off than I am and all rent. None of them begrudge paying rent and enjoy the freedom that they have to move around.

Or maybe that we want choice. I chose what house I bought. I can make what changes I like to it (within reason).

I don't want some miserable grey flat allocated to me, where some government official has decided that because I have no kids (yet) I have no need for more than a single room with no garden.

Just like I'm not accepting your dystopia where I can't walk into a shop, instead having to accept whatever has come in the weekly delivery - doubtless with some iffy substitutions if I even get any choice at all, not to mention that the only possible time it'll arrive will be when I'm in work.

Oh hang on, you want to abolish work too, so I'll be stuck staring at the walls in that government-allocated flat, eating my government-specified food rations (which I bet won't include bacon), no leisure activities left to enjoy, with all purpose in life sapped from me.

DojaPhat · 05/06/2023 21:33

A lot those deemed 'managing just fine' are just about staying afloat, some working more than one job, some having to cajole friends and relatives for childcare. If someone on £100k is squeezed as posted above, their concerns are far deeper than whether to spend the summer in the Maldives or Antigua then you can just imagine what it's like for people on a fraction of that. Remember it's more expensive to be poor despite what some would have you believe about big screen TVs and the like.

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 20:55

jenandberrys · 05/06/2023 20:21

What are you on about? Everyone on less than 150K household income in London isn't 'poor', most people are on less than that and living perfectly happy and comfortable lives and many of them owning their own homes. Comparing a nation of almost 70 million people with a city state of 5 million is ridiculous, they are in no way comparable. I feel very sorry for you that you appear to have chosen to relegate yourself to some 'poor relation' category for no discernible reason.

Rent for a 2 bed flat is £1600, childcare is £2000. I mean I remember a while back we were on £110k and I posted on Mumsnet asking whether I could pay my mortgage and childcare on that and the consensus was it can be done but a bit tight. That's just for one child and I was lucky to pay down a mortgage for five years on a mortgage rate at 2%... Someone renting would need far more money...

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 20:50

jenandberrys · 05/06/2023 20:21

What are you on about? Everyone on less than 150K household income in London isn't 'poor', most people are on less than that and living perfectly happy and comfortable lives and many of them owning their own homes. Comparing a nation of almost 70 million people with a city state of 5 million is ridiculous, they are in no way comparable. I feel very sorry for you that you appear to have chosen to relegate yourself to some 'poor relation' category for no discernible reason.

What is wrong with being poor? At least I know where I stand and I am also very motivated to improve our situation in life..being poor in London isn't the same as being poor in the third world- we are poor and own our 2 bed flat, we have overseas holidays, we eat out regularly. So we have a comfortable life (for now).

But what makes us 'poor' is that my DH and mine combined after tax earnings of £6500 per month- it is less than the interest on the savings accounts of multi millionaires. And even if our combined income was £200k, it would still be less..and there are more and more multi millionaires-globally they are a growing number.

And this makes us vulnerable because unless we increase our income steadily, our earning power would diminish every year. So we need to aggressively pursue that next promotion, that next pay raise with absolute single mindedness or will just get poorer and poorer.

I put the figure at £150k because HSBC premier banking criteria is £75k so double that (for husband and wife ) is £150k..I think that at that level you are at least fledging middle class so would probably be ok..I think we are on the cusp of ok to be honest but at the same time at 10% inflation...

SunnyEgg · 05/06/2023 20:47

jenandberrys · 05/06/2023 20:21

What are you on about? Everyone on less than 150K household income in London isn't 'poor', most people are on less than that and living perfectly happy and comfortable lives and many of them owning their own homes. Comparing a nation of almost 70 million people with a city state of 5 million is ridiculous, they are in no way comparable. I feel very sorry for you that you appear to have chosen to relegate yourself to some 'poor relation' category for no discernible reason.

People probably get skewed by their sector, if in finance etc

I know loads of people in London in other professions not on that but they are fine

DdraigGoch · 05/06/2023 20:45

despite the fact that automated car wash is not very sophisticated technology (and has existed even when I was a kid in the 1990s), there are still lots of car wash businesses where their modus operandi is still 'man with rag and pail'. This presumably is because labour is cheap.

More likely it's because humans usually do a better job - they can get into all of the nooks and crannies and are less likely to damage the paint job.

porkpiesinthepark · 05/06/2023 20:44

There aren't many 'true' council estates in my city. Most are a mixture of ex local authority houses which are now privately owned, and council. Some of the ex LA ones go for 400K. Imagine spending all that money to live in the middle of an inner city council estate!
Still I think the middle classes thinks it's 'urban' and cool. If you offered them the chance to live in a gated community with other rich white people, they wouldn't.

OP posts:
jenandberrys · 05/06/2023 20:21

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 20:16

The reason why it's like that is because council housing is associated with the poor. However in the new world, anyone on below £150k combined income in London /(in today's salaries)or £75k in the north is 'poor', I include me and DH in this equation, we earn combined £120k but hopefully we can elevate ourselves in the next year.

This is because of huge concentration of wealth at the top I have a colleague who has so much savings that the interest on his savings pay the £800 mortgage..he isn't from a rich family, just someone with a good professional career and shrewd investments.this is the new middle class. And they would be the ones who can afford home ownership in 20 years time as well as their childre. The majority have to massively downgrade their expectations and the government should be preparing for this new world where 95% of the population would be poor and therefore unable to aspire to things like home ownership. And for the unlucky bottom half, I think food would be a problem

What are you on about? Everyone on less than 150K household income in London isn't 'poor', most people are on less than that and living perfectly happy and comfortable lives and many of them owning their own homes. Comparing a nation of almost 70 million people with a city state of 5 million is ridiculous, they are in no way comparable. I feel very sorry for you that you appear to have chosen to relegate yourself to some 'poor relation' category for no discernible reason.

DojaPhat · 05/06/2023 20:20

@HandBall I'm impressed that means you keep up with lyrics. Usually people listening to music pick up on beat and parts of syntax - if your focus is on lyrics that means you'd do much better in an afternoon of distant sounding Taylor Swift, followed by 50 cent and Metallica than you would with just one song from Sezen Aksu who sings melodic Turkish music. That's remarkable! I'm also ND and would really struggle with an afternoon in my first example!

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 20:16

HandBall · 05/06/2023 17:57

A council housing is like public transport compared to home and car ownership, having experience of them all.

it's not all detached houses with big gardens, it's often groups of high rise flats with shared stairs and lifts that scare you at every opening/corner, never mind the loud multicultural music so you have the extra pressure on your brain that it can't make out where the music is coming from or what's being said, it's all added stress in life.

The reason why it's like that is because council housing is associated with the poor. However in the new world, anyone on below £150k combined income in London /(in today's salaries)or £75k in the north is 'poor', I include me and DH in this equation, we earn combined £120k but hopefully we can elevate ourselves in the next year.

This is because of huge concentration of wealth at the top I have a colleague who has so much savings that the interest on his savings pay the £800 mortgage..he isn't from a rich family, just someone with a good professional career and shrewd investments.this is the new middle class. And they would be the ones who can afford home ownership in 20 years time as well as their childre. The majority have to massively downgrade their expectations and the government should be preparing for this new world where 95% of the population would be poor and therefore unable to aspire to things like home ownership. And for the unlucky bottom half, I think food would be a problem

HandBall · 05/06/2023 20:07

porkpiesinthepark · 05/06/2023 18:05

@HandBall not multicultural music??!

I struggle with neurodivergence sensory issues. To have music sounds coming from a direction you can't locate is not easy to cope with. When singing is in English it's easier to cope with even if a genre of music that's not my preference, it's very taxing on the brain to hear someone singing very loudly in a language you don't understand your brain is constantly trying to make sense of it yet can't, I used to find it hard to cope in social housing in a tower block it was the worst time ever.

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 20:07

HandBall · 05/06/2023 17:57

A council housing is like public transport compared to home and car ownership, having experience of them all.

it's not all detached houses with big gardens, it's often groups of high rise flats with shared stairs and lifts that scare you at every opening/corner, never mind the loud multicultural music so you have the extra pressure on your brain that it can't make out where the music is coming from or what's being said, it's all added stress in life.

I rented an ex council flat in Camden in my student days, we paid £2080 for a 2 bed in 2012 as it was near UCL. Most of the neighbours were council tenants. I can't say it was bad, it was high rise but the location was great.. the neighbours friendly. We now own a private flat (1930s build) but DH really wants to buy this ex council 3 bed flat in Highgate which would cost around £550k.

If we could live in it without paying the market rate, we would be happy.