Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Universal basic income and what it may look like

534 replies

porkpiesinthepark · 04/06/2023 09:54

I've been thinking for a while about the criticism of UBI and I think it's due to people not being able to imagine the government trying to 'match' peoples wages. In my opinion, it never will but there will be alternatives to what we have now, which will be able to offer something better.

So say the UBI is £1000 a month for a single person.
We could change the housing market to allow much more public housing with rents set at an affordable level, much more stability, no private landlords and the option to customise/ change your home. Let's face it, home ownership is out of reach for the majority at present. I don't find people are dying to own their own homes but desperate to be out of the instability of the private rental market, out of parents houses, out of house shares etc. If you could offer the next best thing to owning your own house, I think people would go for it.
There would be much more community linked to people having extra time due to not working or not working as many hours. Now, not having enough to do in the day is bad but most people have these huge dreams for retirement and this would just allow them to do some of these things now instead. Also more volunteering, looking after elderly relatives etc.
I don't think that private car ownership would be a thing. There would be a big system like Uber who you could call rides on. There would be a cheaper option, say if ten people wanted to go to the city centre at the same time, they would have to walk to a hub and then the van would pick everyone up, like public transport but based on demand. It would be a status symbol to be able to call a car out just for you.
I think a lot more people would wfh getting the cost of transport and childcare down. Schools might even go remote, as there wouldn't be both parents working and so in theory they could help facilitate the lessons. Then teachers would have small classes of Sen kids like mine, key workers and vulnerable children. Kids would interact with others through volunteering groups with parents, or just playing out as there would be less cars and more parents around to keep an eye on them.
People will either hate this vision as it's so different to what we have now. Or they will like some parts. But what we have now can't continue.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/06/2023 02:20

Ridiculous way to study the concept. If one was being cynical, one might conclude these were attempts to discredit the idea based on how incompetently designed the studies are

Or it’s an exercise to Pat the deluded on the head to pacify them while everyone else gets on with living.

AllllTheSmallThings · 06/06/2023 02:19

I disagree I think it could help because the poorer could afford to quit work to study, freelance or train their way into a better career or start a business.

Aargh. It won't be possible to pay for UNTIL there is no work for most people. That's the whole reason it is being seriously considered: because until then it couldn't possibly be funded, and until then it couldn't possibly be paid for either.

That's why studies in the current economic system are pointless because the same "rules" will not apply.

AllllTheSmallThings · 06/06/2023 02:17

Benidorm8Banter · 06/06/2023 02:05

There has been a trial in a Scandinavian country too

You may be thinking of Finland. Also not enough people to draw meaningful conclusions to extrapolate. But the results they did have showed that for those involved it increased wellbeing, but not employment market participation. Again a scewed group of participants, again too small a sample, and again not taking account of effects when everyone receives it which will be quite different to when only some do (in terms of inflation, incentives, etc). Also ignoring the very purpose of the idea to begin with and why it is being explored further in several countries.

Ridiculous way to study the concept. If one was being cynical, one might conclude these were attempts to discredit the idea based on how incompetently designed the studies are. Or, the studies are being done by silly people who haven't put all the jigsaw pieces together yet and are concentrating only on their own academic fields in isolation.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/06/2023 02:17

Alrighty… good luck to all of you that are gunning for this.

It will fail as miserably as it’s failed in the past. All of these ideas and theories always fail to take into consideration the most important component. The humans that are involved. Please think of the worst people that you can think of and fit them into this utopian mold.

The feckless, the cheaters, the cocklodgers, the CFs, the unreasonable, the driven, the gullible, the social climbers, the liars, the selfish, and the dreaded individual.

They will not fit into your utopia.

Benidorm8Banter · 06/06/2023 02:07

Instead of me working 12 hour shifts
Perhaps someone would like to pay me the £1600 a month instead ?

Benidorm8Banter · 06/06/2023 02:05

There has been a trial in a Scandinavian country too

AllllTheSmallThings · 06/06/2023 01:56

Benidorm8Banter · 06/06/2023 01:47

This is just stupid. How can you draw any meaningful conclusions from a sample of 30? And from two specific areas, so it can't possibly be "representative" as they claim. All they'll do is write up what happened with 30 people and shove it into statistically meaningless graphs and conclude "further research should happen to draw conclusions." Because no conclusions can possibly be drawn from it, so if you know that at the outset, why not do the research properly in the first place?!

Marmalayde · 06/06/2023 01:53

Florenz · 06/06/2023 01:42

It would kill social mobility stone dead. There would be a two tier society and the two tiers would be entirely separate.

I disagree I think it could help because the poorer could afford to quit work to study, freelance or train their way into a better career or start a business.

AllllTheSmallThings · 06/06/2023 01:50

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/06/2023 00:23

So I read this thread, those for this idea are still not answering a fundamental question.

What happens when people who don’t want to pay for this start to leave? It will first be the corporations, then (ironically) those with ties to other countries, then finally it will be those who say fuck it and go somewhere else.

Do the doors get locked? Other countries in this scenario haven’t signed up for this so people will be able to look around and notice that they don’t have to finance other people not working if they move.

Does everyone just say screw it I’m not working extra so someone else can sit on their ass and not contribute?

what about the people who get this UBI, do they suddenly feel like like are secure? Or do they look around and see that there are still ‘rich people’ who have more than them. Are they happy in there little state sponsored ghettos, where they can’t afford a car, can’t shop for their own groceries, etc?

Because it will be a ghetto, and they certainly won’t be living next door to someone who is working and can make choices… unless you take that choice away from someone who is working…which will incentivize them toe either move or stop working themselves…which reduces the money coming in to pay for those not working… which means you can’t afford to pay people not to work… which means you’ll have to make them work to get stuff done…

Honestly, this is communism which has NEVER worked because it goes against human nature and really only produces better capitalists but then punishes them for it.

The point of it is that it would be funded by taxes on capital. It's quite clear already no more can be squeezed out of higher rate income rax payers who are paying marginal rates of 85% to over 100% already on incomes from £50k upwards if they also have young children. The limit there has been reached.

The only way to fund UBI would be tax start taxing capital far more, not earnings. This can only happen to the extent needed it there are large productivity gains: the need for UBI and the means to fund it are linked. It will be because work will soon become very scarce, and simultaneously there will be very large productivity gains. But those accruing them need people to sell their products to who are not destitute, and also will not be able to operate in a jurisdiction at all unless they pay the taxes. It is a means of redistribution. It isn't about individuals upping sticks, that will make no difference. Systems will be changed so that if you sell products in a jurisdiction, you pay large taxes because you'll be making huge amounts of money, like in any other stage of a leap forward in technology, but this time on steroids.

That's if it's done properly, the adjustment of social structures to adapt. But I doubt it will be in time to avoid chaos because we are led by morons and based on the comments on this thread most people don't get what's about to happen in the next 10-20 years either. So many ridiculous comments based on how UBI would impact the status quo and not comprehending that this will soon cease to exist and the reason UBI is being considered is because it will be the only way to prevent total meltdown of society once work vanishes for 80%+ of people.

Benidorm8Banter · 06/06/2023 01:48

I was close it is £1600 per month

That is a decent amount

Florenz · 06/06/2023 01:42

It would kill social mobility stone dead. There would be a two tier society and the two tiers would be entirely separate.

Marmalayde · 06/06/2023 01:40

Perhaps offer everyone the option of 10 years ubi to be taken when chosen

Marmalayde · 06/06/2023 01:38

Also many would use ubi to take the time to move into more rewarding and high paying careers. It would help social mobility. It's rude to assume everyone would just choose to live off it and drop out of work. Many want fulfillment they can't pursue on low paid long hours

Marmalayde · 06/06/2023 01:35

Technology has taken away do many jobs. Tech is literally doing lots of jobs and earning money. Ai will increase this. This should mean more money and leisure time and money for all of us but instead the top keeps getting richer while the rest of us struggle. Take a look at how much richer the super rich have got in recent years because of this. A basic income is possible

Benidorm8Banter · 06/06/2023 01:20

I haven't read all the pages

In the news this week there is a 2 year trial
£1500 per month
No requirement to work, but you can work

AllllTheSmallThings · 06/06/2023 01:13

porkpiesinthepark · 05/06/2023 18:16

@SunnyEgg the problem is the difference between rents and house prices. So if you rent a family home worth £400k for £1,300 a month, you will hardly ever be able to save up the £40,000 plus to put the deposit down. But if you could then your mortgage would likely to be less than your rent. If you missed that golden time to buy then you're screwed, especially if you have children and then try to save for a deposit.

That's why people plan and establish careers first and buy a house before having children.

Florenz · 06/06/2023 01:12

I don't think UBI will ever happen so I don't think it is something worth worrying about. If it does ever come to be, I hope I am not around by then as I think it will be absolute hell on earth.

socialmedia23 · 06/06/2023 00:59

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/06/2023 00:23

So I read this thread, those for this idea are still not answering a fundamental question.

What happens when people who don’t want to pay for this start to leave? It will first be the corporations, then (ironically) those with ties to other countries, then finally it will be those who say fuck it and go somewhere else.

Do the doors get locked? Other countries in this scenario haven’t signed up for this so people will be able to look around and notice that they don’t have to finance other people not working if they move.

Does everyone just say screw it I’m not working extra so someone else can sit on their ass and not contribute?

what about the people who get this UBI, do they suddenly feel like like are secure? Or do they look around and see that there are still ‘rich people’ who have more than them. Are they happy in there little state sponsored ghettos, where they can’t afford a car, can’t shop for their own groceries, etc?

Because it will be a ghetto, and they certainly won’t be living next door to someone who is working and can make choices… unless you take that choice away from someone who is working…which will incentivize them toe either move or stop working themselves…which reduces the money coming in to pay for those not working… which means you can’t afford to pay people not to work… which means you’ll have to make them work to get stuff done…

Honestly, this is communism which has NEVER worked because it goes against human nature and really only produces better capitalists but then punishes them for it.

*stay on UBi meaning surviving solely on UBI in the long term

socialmedia23 · 06/06/2023 00:58

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/06/2023 00:23

So I read this thread, those for this idea are still not answering a fundamental question.

What happens when people who don’t want to pay for this start to leave? It will first be the corporations, then (ironically) those with ties to other countries, then finally it will be those who say fuck it and go somewhere else.

Do the doors get locked? Other countries in this scenario haven’t signed up for this so people will be able to look around and notice that they don’t have to finance other people not working if they move.

Does everyone just say screw it I’m not working extra so someone else can sit on their ass and not contribute?

what about the people who get this UBI, do they suddenly feel like like are secure? Or do they look around and see that there are still ‘rich people’ who have more than them. Are they happy in there little state sponsored ghettos, where they can’t afford a car, can’t shop for their own groceries, etc?

Because it will be a ghetto, and they certainly won’t be living next door to someone who is working and can make choices… unless you take that choice away from someone who is working…which will incentivize them toe either move or stop working themselves…which reduces the money coming in to pay for those not working… which means you can’t afford to pay people not to work… which means you’ll have to make them work to get stuff done…

Honestly, this is communism which has NEVER worked because it goes against human nature and really only produces better capitalists but then punishes them for it.

If everyone was so short sighted, no one would be living in London/SE and paying rent or a mortgage. Everyone would get a job paying £20-28k and live in a part of the UK where it costs £100k for a house. Maybe you can even work part time and top up with benefits..easier life.

But there are tons of people living in London /SE, in particular there are 9 million people living in London. And most people don't start out at 6 figures. This is because most people recognize that when you start working, you have a chance to increase your earnings and even if you don't become 'rich' you can still afford more luxuries and to buy the things you value. And if you stay on UBI, you would not be able to do that. Our combined income increased from £48k to £120k from 2016 to 2023 (my first job paid £18k which is around the same as UBI today). You can bet if i had received UBI instead of my first job, then i would still be on 18k maybe 19k and then i would be truly fucked. I am sure most people are smart enough to work out that if they choose to stay on UBI in the long term, that is just a recipe for disaster.

One benefit of UBI is that it would allow people to start a business or study without worrying too much about the bills. That would actually increase earning power in the long run.

Communism is when the state owns the means of production and decides how much of each product should be produced. UBI isn't advocating for that at all. It's just a different way of paying the poor and lower middle classes top up benefits so that they don't lose their pride and dignity (as i am guessing they don't want to accept that they are poor and possibly it may be detrimental to their mental health)..i expect that practically, higher rate taxpayers would be paying tax on their UBI..so it would be kinda like child benefit. On paper i am entitled to child benefit but as DH earns above the threshold, i have to pay it back.

GettingStuffed · 06/06/2023 00:31

Apparently it would be cheaper to do this as it's a lot less complicated than calculating benefits.
If work you'd get your pay on top of this. I also think it's good for working people as employees probably wouldn't have to work in crap jobs. Not necessarily pay more but make the working environment pleadsnt

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/06/2023 00:23

So I read this thread, those for this idea are still not answering a fundamental question.

What happens when people who don’t want to pay for this start to leave? It will first be the corporations, then (ironically) those with ties to other countries, then finally it will be those who say fuck it and go somewhere else.

Do the doors get locked? Other countries in this scenario haven’t signed up for this so people will be able to look around and notice that they don’t have to finance other people not working if they move.

Does everyone just say screw it I’m not working extra so someone else can sit on their ass and not contribute?

what about the people who get this UBI, do they suddenly feel like like are secure? Or do they look around and see that there are still ‘rich people’ who have more than them. Are they happy in there little state sponsored ghettos, where they can’t afford a car, can’t shop for their own groceries, etc?

Because it will be a ghetto, and they certainly won’t be living next door to someone who is working and can make choices… unless you take that choice away from someone who is working…which will incentivize them toe either move or stop working themselves…which reduces the money coming in to pay for those not working… which means you can’t afford to pay people not to work… which means you’ll have to make them work to get stuff done…

Honestly, this is communism which has NEVER worked because it goes against human nature and really only produces better capitalists but then punishes them for it.

DdraigGoch · 06/06/2023 00:23

@socialmedia23 a household income of £75k is not "poor". Particularly not outside of London. You really need to gain some perspective.

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 23:36

JuvenileEmu · 05/06/2023 23:26

You have my sympathy. Being a champagne socialist must be difficult. If only you could be given whatever you want for free, then you could be truly happy
Hmm

This is a country where healthcare is free at the point of access. Selling government property at cost price or at least 20% below market rate is far less controversial (at the same time as putting restrictions so that it doesn't end up in the hands of investors)

The reason why 'people who believe they are middle class' need to be given incentives is because as this thread amply shows, people don't want to accept they are poor. So we have to lie to them and tell them they aren't poor (and this subsidized housing is not the same as the housing for the 'poor' people) while making sure they don't completely bankrupt themselves trying to compete with the actual rich or investors to buy property. We are going to see lots of repossessions as families struggle to pay their mortgages. And a lot of them would be the 'middle class'.

I know of a Tory who is now voting labour as her mortgage went up £500 and that is a lot of money to her. Apparently she was not as middle class as she thought.

JuvenileEmu · 05/06/2023 23:26

socialmedia23 · 05/06/2023 23:10

I am actually contemplating buying ex social housing and it is my second stepper property i.e.. i had to overpay mortgage for 4 years by at least £1000 per month to get to this point.

The person selling it is definitely on at least £200k (it was her FTB flat).

It's a bit ridiculous that we are the ones paying private market prices for it though. And market is inflated due to housing being seen as an asset rather than a roof over one's head. There should be two markets- one for speculation and another for function. That's all i am trying to say. For medical care in the uk, there is functional healthcare (NHS) and luxury healthcare (private with all the bells and whistles). There should be such a distinction for housing.

You have my sympathy. Being a champagne socialist must be difficult. If only you could be given whatever you want for free, then you could be truly happy
Hmm

Swipe left for the next trending thread